111s v's 111r
Author
Discussion

ALE 111s

Original Poster:

218 posts

245 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
I'm sure I've seen something on this before but can't remember the outcome. I currently drive an 02 plate 111s with 16k miles on the clock, I'm looking at updating and the 111r seems the obvious choice....road use only. Should I stick with what I've got ????

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=286283&f=15&h=0

Read through this - has been done pretty much to death. Some prefer the 111r, others the 111s. Drive both and choose.

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
oh god, not again....

Which leg do you prefer - left or right?

ALE 111s

Original Poster:

218 posts

245 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
right !

grinzzz

566 posts

248 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
gooby said:
oh god, not again....

Which leg do you prefer - left or right?


Mrs Grinzzz says she prefers the middle one ......or is that tmi?

ALE 111s

Original Poster:

218 posts

245 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
Sorry guys I see you've discussed this before, wish I hadn't brought it up now.I'll try an R and make my own mind up.

Thanks

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
grinzzz said:
gooby said:
oh god, not again....

Which leg do you prefer - left or right?


Mrs Grinzzz says she prefers the middle one ......or is that tmi?


I never took him for a tripod...

Bleugh... shudder

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
Have a 111S, have an R on loan whilst mine's being repaired (accident damage - not me!)

Day-to-day, no difference, apart from needing to rev the R more. Feels slightly more comfortable on long motorway trips but then I have a noisy car and the R has Probax. Gearbox is better but still nowhere near as good as a conventional mechanical linkage (which, incidentally the Europa has and on that car it feels great)

Overall? Not worth the money to change. If you want to go the stock route, why not wait a year and try an Exige S or 240 Cup?

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
Or why not consider getting a Honda or Audi engine conversion for similar money to change? The K20 Honda engine is (IMvHO), a better package than the 'yota lump and offers a much more flexible spread of usable NA power as the 2nd cam comes in at 4200rpm and it revs round to the limiter at about 8500 IIRC.

With a 1 year warranty it's not something that you should pass over without considering if you want a seriously quick option.

philz

107 posts

274 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
From what I've witnessed the 111R vs 111S argument usually something like this.

111S owner says that their car is better cos it's lighter.
111R owner says that their car is better cos it's more powerful.
ex 111S owner that now owns a 111R says that the 111R is better cos they've owned both.


Personally I got the 111R cos I prefer it, I just love that 2nd cam. In my opinion it's the better car but obviously that's just my opinion which I'm sure isn't shared by the numerous S owners on here.

Lotusnick S2

251 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
philz said:
ex 111S owner that now owns a 111R says that the 111R is better cos they have to justify the extra money they spent.


zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Behave guys, both the 111s and the 111r are great cars. The original thread makes it pretty clear it's all about personal taste.

Zebra

PB9

175 posts

253 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
I think it goes like this,

1. If you dont have any elise, and you have the extra cash, 111R is the car to pick.
2. If you have a 111S, then the difference is not worth the 6k+ swap cost, unless you have the money to burn...
3. If you have a 111S and money to burn, then Honda conversion is probably better than a 111R upgrade.
4. If you have a 111R, then you probably would not swap back to an older version.

When I was on track in my 111S with a friend in a 111R at about the same skill level as me. The difference on track was not much if any on the corners. But on a long run the 111R would pull away because of the extra power, but not my a lot but a visable distance.

I assume a normal honda conversion in a 111S would be just a bit quicker than a 111R and the SC honda would be lots quicker...

GTRene

22,798 posts

255 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
PB9 said:
I think it goes like this,

1. If you dont have any elise, and you have the extra cash, 111R is the car to pick.
2. If you have a 111S, then the difference is not worth the 6k+ swap cost, unless you have the money to burn...
3. If you have a 111S and money to burn, then Honda conversion is probably better than a 111R upgrade.
4. If you have a 111R, then you probably would not swap back to an older version.

When I was on track in my 111S with a friend in a 111R at about the same skill level as me. The difference on track was not much if any on the corners. But on a long run the 111R would pull away because of the extra power, but not my a lot but a visable distance.

I assume a normal honda conversion in a 111S would be just a bit quicker than a 111R and the SC honda would be lots quicker...

Totaly agree with your vision I thought the same...I testdrove several elise's though stil not the honda converted one... what I do when I sell my M coupe and things go wel is something like this, I buy a 2002 or 2003 good example of the S2 Elise then do a Honda conversion and try to instal the Rotrex charger that gives 360hp that would be a monster 360hp in a light Elise here I gooooooooooooooooooooooo
GTRene

Edited by GTRene on Tuesday 8th August 11:33

cheekymonkey

1,139 posts

255 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
PB9 said:
When I was on track in my 111S with a friend in a 111R at about the same skill level as me. The difference on track was not much if any on the corners. But on a long run the 111R would pull away because of the extra power, but not my a lot but a visable distance


that's what i found at combe, had some excellent sessions chasing a 111R. he got away ever so slightly on the straight (maybe 4 car lengths gained) but i tended to get it back in the twisties. So very little in it.

Get either and you should be happy as a pig in sh*t

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
PB9 said:
I assume a normal honda conversion in a 111S would be just a bit quicker than a 111R and the SC honda would be lots quicker...


NA Honda is much quicker than an R (~3 car lengths ahead @ ~80mph in a recent, very unscientific drag @ N Weald). An SC Honda is otherworldly quicker.

philz

107 posts

274 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Lotusnick S2 said:
philz said:
ex 111S owner that now owns a 111R says that the 111R is better cos they have to justify the extra money they spent.




How many S owners went out and bought an R without test driving it? I doubt there are any S owners who went to Lotus when the R was released, drove it, thought it was crap then handed over £30k for one.

The previous owner of my car bought a brand new S in early 2004. Then a few months into ownership Lotus released the R which he then drove, loved it and traded up, losing a shed load of money in the process but he said that the R was so much better that it didn't really matter.

buggs

113 posts

250 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Some people need the more powerful 111r to make up for there driving ability. I am happy with the 111s

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
I bought a 111s from new, had it for 18 months and covered over 20,000 miles that were trouble free (apart from 10mph roundabout accident) and there wasn't one occasion where I didn't enjoy driving the car. I used it everyday come rain, sun or ice (hence 10mph accident on roundabout) as an everyday car; going to work, shopping, socialising as well as jaunts onto excellent quality b roads. When it came to replacement time the 111s was no longer available so I got the 111r. I'll keep it for about the same length of time and cover the same distance doing the same things.

Although there are differences in the cars both are superb and if forced to have one or the other I wouldn't be bothered which one it was(although I might hanker after an exige s), probably only wishing that 111r didn't have ALB and electric windows.

Get what ever you want, with an elise you will not be disappointed.

Zebra

Edited by zebra on Tuesday 8th August 13:36

NDT

1,767 posts

294 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
zebra said:
I wouldn't be bothered which one it was(although I might hanker after an exige s), probably only wishing that 111r didn't have ALB and electric windows.
Edited by zebra on Tuesday 8th August 13:36


what's ALB?