Elise S2 or Cerbera?
Author
Discussion

philiphunter

Original Poster:

159 posts

243 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
I need some help in deciding which car to buy next.

I currently drive a boring Escort estate as I have been at University for the past 3 years.

I have come into some money and decided to spend upto £13,000 on a 'less-boring' car.

I really love the TVR Cerbera as it is basically a Supercar that I could afford to buy, but I also find the S2 Lotus Elise appealing.

If I bought the TVR I would keep it in the garage until a fine day arose, then I would take it for a spin around the countryside. Whereas if I bought the Elise S2 I would use it daily to travel to and from University.

The thing that puts me off the TVR are all the horror stories of breakdowns, and £8000 engine rebuilds.
There again, there are some Elises out there that seem to blow their core's too.

At this price I can afford to run a daily drive and have the TVR or just buy the elise.

One of my main objectives is to lose as little of my initial spend as possible (i.e. If I spend £10,000 on a car I'd like to have a good idea that I would get most of that back if I sold it in a few years time).

Can anyone give some sound advise about these two (very different) cars, and perhaps offer any thoughts that aren't obvious to me?

Cheers.

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
Drive both but if I were you I would have the Elise.

Cheaper to run and a lot more fun. You can spank the arse off it and it wont cost £80 to refill it with petrol.

Its also more likely to work and not get you banned as quickly.

They are chalk and cheese but you should look at having a 'fighting fund' of a few grand at least if you go for the Cerb.

philiphunter

Original Poster:

159 posts

243 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
Is there anything I should watch out for with the S2 Elise?

What about colour? Do certain coloured cars sell easier than others?

I don't want to be stuck with one in a couple of years time.

What about engines (the 120bhp version), do they take a good kicking and live to tell the tale?

There seem to be a lot of low mileage elises out there; Is that because they are designed for low mileage or just that most people don't use them for commuting?

rfoster

1,482 posts

285 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
Hi.
Obviously being on the Lotus forum we're going to be a little biased. Best advice I can give is have a decent drive in both and see what floats your boat. TVR's can be expensive -significantly more so than Elises (there's so little to an Elise there's not actually that much to go wrong, worst case scenario is that the head gasket goes and that's somewhere aruond £600 from a specialist. Specialist servicing is actually pretty cheap, for the kind of car you're considering it's just a Rover engine so easy to work on.) Look for a car that's been owned by an enthusiast, PH and Seloc classifieds are a great starting point here. You'll generally pay less for a privately owned car. Buy based on condition and not mileage - you'll find that a 60,000 mile car that's been properly looked after may well be a better car than the 5,000 that's spent most of its life sitting around. These cars are meant to be driven.

I'm on my fifth Lotus now so you don't need to know my opinion, have a chat with the chaps on the TVR gassing page as well.

Whatever you decide, you'll find a minefield of info and fellow petrolheads here who are happy to share experiences and help out with any problems you may have.

Hope you enjoy choosing!
Richard.

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
philiphunter said:
I don't want to be stuck with one in a couple of years time.


'Stuck with one'?!

Perhaps the Elise isn't the car for you......

philiphunter

Original Poster:

159 posts

243 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
I didn't mean 'stuck'.

I meant when I graduate and upgrade I'd like to get what the car is worth and not have someone trying to rip me off just because of an unpopular colour or some other dodgy reason.

Unfortunately, a lot of buyers won't be enthusiasts and won't know the main reason to own one.

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
philiphunter said:

One of my main objectives is to lose as little of my initial spend as possible (i.e. If I spend £10,000 on a car I'd like to have a good idea that I would get most of that back if I sold it in a few years time)


13k your looking at an old S2 with some depreciation left to go if its a base model which it probably would be for that cash. Your budget is more decent S1 money, especially if you have 10k plus the rest for insurance etc.

Check the buyer guide sticky at the top of this forum. Plus get along to one of the runs to check out a few cars and chat with the owners.

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
Dont be too put off by the thoughts of reliability of the tvr. My dad bought his new cerbera in 1996. He still has it now. Its been the most reliable car he has ever owned! he's had Jags, porsche, volvo, so find a good one and it should be alright. it will cost more to run and service though and if something does break, then it is going to cost a bit whereas the elise is cheap to run and fix..... drive them. the tvr is good but you will have more fun in the elise.....

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
Q: how do you make a small amount of money running a Cerbera
A: start with a large amount of money

I watched several chums do this, unless you have significant funding I would suggest not.

as400

161 posts

243 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
As an ex Cerbera owner...you will need a bigger budget, it WILL go wrong, you WILL be taking it back to the garage, it is (the salesman told me) like a tempting mistress - it needs money spending on her.

I'd be surprised if you can get a good one for under £20,000, for £13K?...no way.


I'd say get an S1 for £10,000 plenty to choose from.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
Can't give you any direct TVR experience save to say that a good pal of mine ran two and both were money pits. He gave up in the end and bought a TT.
What I can tell you is that I bought my 99 S1 as a second car last December and she rapidly became my preferred daily driver. I've now done over 10k in her and the only money spent is on petrol. (She hasn't used a drop of oil).
There' a guy on Seloc who has now recorded over 180k miles and 100k milers are becoming more regular. At the end of the day the Elise is a simple car with a rover engine. Cheap to run and cheap to service/fix.

jago

247 posts

250 months

Wednesday 9th August 2006
quotequote all
if budget was a little higher, i could see the tvr being appealing, especially as they seem to have come down a lot very recently. If you've got spare cash to deal with anything unexpected and the 13k is simply all you're willing to spend on a car at present, fair enough. (Being here, goes without saying i'd take an elise under any circumstances).

Edited by jago on Wednesday 9th August 23:44

enjybenjy

928 posts

284 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
I'm in the lucky situation where I can regularly drive these cars back to back. I have an S2 111S and my colleague has a Cerbie 4.5 Lightweight.
In fact, I did this yesterday. They are chalk and cheese, yes. Both produce huge smiles. The 111S will keep with the Cerb up to about 80/90 then the TVR is just in another league. It's awesomely fast. The Lotus is much more nimble and the handling wins hands down. One thing I really notice when swapping back is how much more of the road you can see in the Elise. The TVR is cossetting to a point where it may be daunting for some.
If I were you, get the Lotus, maybe a 111S if you can run to it. At road legal speeds the two cars are pretty well matched and the cornering ability and fact that the Lotus feels like you're 'wearing it' win it for me. It would be a cheaper car to run as well, although the TVR has been very well behaved and is used regularly. I'd rather have to pay for the Lotus going wrong than for the TVR...
Hope this helps.

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
Well I know my dad wants to sell his. Its a P reg 1996 4.2 AJP V8 engine. Colour is similar to the blue M3 colour, maybe slightly lighter. Full cream leather, 1 owner from new, never crashed, its been on a track once, only got 24,000 miles on the clock. It doesnt leak at all ! and has never broken down ! I've emailed you some pictures. He's open to offers. Based near Telford.

rosso rebel

303 posts

285 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
We have a Chimaera which we've had for 5 years now, and friends with Cerbie's, and I know they cost more to run than our Chim. I'm also interested in buying a S2 and test drove a 111S this week (I'm thinking of swapping it for my mini cooper s) and my advice, for what it's worth, would be the Lotus in the first instance, then look at a TVR when you have more budget, and to be honest experience in driving a performance car.

I still remember the day we picked our Chim up and the responsibility of driving a car with the awesome raw power that TVR's produce should not be taken lightly !! However, I do have to stick up for my Chim (Even on the Elise forum!!) and say that for me, in the fun factor stakes the Chim wins hands down.......

The Elise is fun, fast and in a difference league to a TVR, and would cost a lot less to drive every day!

What ever your choice, go and have a few test drive's and it should make the decision a lot easier

whatever

2,174 posts

301 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
I've had a cerb for the last 5 years (bought used) and can tell you that a) they are likely to be relatively expensive to run; b) they tend to be better behaved if used more regularly, rather than kept for a "sunny day"

Get a good 'un and it's an astonishing experience. (Actually, if you get a bad 'un that's an astonishing experience too, but for different reasons...)

Can't say much about the elise, as I've not driven one (though hope to soon).

Pied Piper

1,388 posts

278 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
rosso rebel said:


However, I do have to stick up for my Chim (Even on the Elise forum!!) and say that for me, in the fun factor stakes the Chim wins hands down.......

The Elise is fun, fast and in a difference league to a TVR, and would cost a lot less to drive every day!


Did I not drive fast enough down Newick Lane for you?


I have owned a Cerbera as well as other TVR's in the past and you are going to need a big pot of money, maintaining TVR's is expensive, servicing even with the indies is not cheap.

I purchased my first Lotus at the beginning of the year and I love it. It's great fun around the lanes, but will never compete with the awesome power of the Cerbera.

As Rosso Rebel said try both if you go for a Cerbera get a bullet proof warranty and put some money aside just in case.

I used to work for a TVR/Lotus main dealer and have seen both sides of ownership if you want to have a chat feel free to Email.

philiphunter

Original Poster:

159 posts

243 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
It seems to me that at this point in my life it will be an Elise that is my next purchase.

Does anyone have any tips on buying?

I have started contacting sellers but to be honest I will have to travel to buy and this means I will see very few and not really have a chance to compare.

I live in the Durham area and apart from the Lotus garage in Newcastle where I found I could actually contort myself into one, I have never driven one.

Are there any trait sounds, knocks, or anything else I should be aware of?

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
piooly said:
Dont be too put off by the thoughts of reliability of the tvr. My dad bought his new cerbera in 1996. He still has it now. Its been the most reliable car he has ever owned! he's had Jags, porsche, volvo, so find a good one and it should be alright. it will cost more to run and service though and if something does break, then it is going to cost a bit whereas the elise is cheap to run and fix..... drive them. the tvr is good but you will have more fun in the elise.....


TVR Ownership is a lot like discussing smoking,

Someone always comes up with a tale about some old uncle who smoked 100 a day for 90 years and it never did him any harm

The problem is if something does go wrong with a Cerb it will be 3X the price to fix than an Elise

rosso rebel

303 posts

285 months

Friday 11th August 2006
quotequote all
Pied Piper - the drive down Newick Lane was definately fast enough thank you!! (As always)

Davey S2 - Are you saying I'm like your old 90 year old uncle as I have a reliable TVR ??!! (Touch Wood!!)