lsd on exige S
Author
Discussion

edoardo

Original Poster:

229 posts

256 months

Sunday 13th August 2006
quotequote all
Is it worth paying for the lisited slip differential on the exige S ?
I searched the forums but came to no conclusion.

simonk

908 posts

256 months

Sunday 13th August 2006
quotequote all
I would think so for track yes.

Mine is just a standard exige but on a tight corner i wish i had an lsd. The S has considerably more torque so i would think need it a lot more.

HTH

Simon

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
There are probably many better things you can invest £1k in than a device that will save you 1 second on one corner on some tracks (there are not a lot of 2nd gear corners around). Infact sending excess power to the driven wheel will compromise many peoples driving style (but great for drifting) especially if you have a long gear and are trying to keep the revs up.

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
And to fully qualify my answer, I have driven the folowing 2nd gear corners; Bedford turn 1, Brands Druids, Cadwell Hairpin, Castle Combe Bobbies (maybe), Croft Tower, Donington None, Mallory Shaws, Rockingham Turn 9, Silverstone Club #1 (maybe), Snetterton - None

Edited by hbaumhardt on Monday 14th August 08:47

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
From my limited understanding, you would have to be a driving god to exploit the benefits and negate the negatives with an LSD in an exige.

edoardo

Original Poster:

229 posts

256 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
gooby said:
From my limited understanding, you would have to be a driving god to exploit the benefits and negate the negatives with an LSD in an exige.

thanks this really helped. I can hardly overtake grandmas ...

bruh_la

319 posts

285 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
At hockenheim there are two 2nd gear hairpins. In both corners i can get fully on the throttle from the apex in my Exige S with LSD.

I have not noticed any negative effects in other corners. I was concerned it may promote understeer on corner entry. I agonized over the choice for weeks when i ordered my car, having talked to Russell at Lotus Motorsport and reading some replies from people with 240r and cup cars i decided to go for it.

The Exige with its lightweight (compared to porsches, M3s etc)can make up ground on heavier more powerful cars out of slow corners, it seems a shame to handicap it by it not being able to put its power down.

Check out the footage of stig in the white Exige S doing the timed lap, and look how often the inside wheel is smoking. I understand he claimed it would have quicker with an LSD.

I would deffo get it.

ballistic

968 posts

291 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
What are the negatives?

I'm thinking of changing to an Exige S and the lsd is an option I would consider.

Car would be used mainly for fast road use with the very occasional track-day.

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
If your not going to notice £1,000 then nail it on !

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
ballistic said:
What are the negatives?

I'm thinking of changing to an Exige S and the lsd is an option I would consider.

Car would be used mainly for fast road use with the very occasional track-day.


I witnessed a conversation between an experienced racer and a race mechanic who were very knowledgable but spoke a completly different language. The bottom line was there are pros and cons and you have to be very VERY good to exploit the benifits.

IIRC, the negatives include a propensity for the back end to be a little more willing to break grip in the wet. But I suppose in the S you have the TC....

bruh_la

319 posts

285 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
Whilst cornering, when the inside rear wheel of a Non LSD car starts to spin in the wet, the rear of the car will slide.

With the LSD you will need to break traction on both wheels at the same time to get them spinning which will need a corresponding increase in power.

I admit that once both the rear wheels are spinning the resulting rear end slide will be difficult to catch. Which is probably why Lotus insist on Traction control with the LSD. But in theory you can give more throttle before you reach this point.

I can remember how my S1 elise would accelerate in the wet, it could break traction in a straight line in the wet in 2nd gear. My Exige S can take full throttle second gear in a straight line in the wet without spinning the wheels (admittedly the A048 are also playing a role)

I can only reiterate how good the car feels as it exits sharp hairpin bends, both on track and in the mountains. The car just sits down, digs in and goes! I have experienced no negatives......yet;-)

edoardo

Original Poster:

229 posts

256 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
bruh_la said:

I can remember how my S1 elise would accelerate in the wet, it could break traction in a straight line in the wet in 2nd gear.


I spun my now-dead Elise S2 111s while accelerating in a straight line on changing from 1st to 2nd gear.
It may well be that what you described is what happened to me.
Ended with wheels on a high kerb and chassis was damaged. Still a nightmare haunting me.
Would love to think a future Exige S (with TSC & LSD) is safer in that respect!

bing

1,946 posts

269 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
edoardo said:

I spun my now-dead Elise S2 111s while accelerating in a straight line on changing from 1st to 2nd gear.
It may well be that what you described is what happened to me.
Ended with wheels on a high kerb and chassis was damaged. Still a nightmare haunting me.
Would love to think a future Exige S (with TSC & LSD) is safer in that respect!


How the hell did you manage that mate!!! Was it wet or dry at the time??? I drove mine in the wet the other day and accelerating in a straight line was fine....did you hit some standing water/oil etc etc???

bruh_la

319 posts

285 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
I presume it was wet, which was what i was talking about.........

Lotusnick S2

251 posts

261 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
edoardo said:
bruh_la said:

I can remember how my S1 elise would accelerate in the wet, it could break traction in a straight line in the wet in 2nd gear.


I spun my now-dead Elise S2 111s while accelerating in a straight line on changing from 1st to 2nd gear.
It may well be that what you described is what happened to me.
Ended with wheels on a high kerb and chassis was damaged. Still a nightmare haunting me.
Would love to think a future Exige S (with TSC & LSD) is safer in that respect!

Sorry to hear about your accident.

No offence, but unless you hit some oil or kept your foot on the accelator after it started losing traction, I cant see how you managed to do that.
The Elise has A LOT of traction and grip in the rain.
If you had trouble with the 111s I suggest you steer clear of the Exige S as with its torque and A048's it will mean more issues in the wet.

Yesterday we did a run with Seloc under really bad conditions.
There was loads of rain and standing water in really bad b-roads.
Yet cars with twice the power and torque of the 111s (SC Honda Elises) were going very fast without any issues

edoardo

Original Poster:

229 posts

256 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
bing said:

How the hell did you manage that mate!!! Was it wet or dry at the time??? I drove mine in the wet the other day and accelerating in a straight line was fine....did you hit some standing water/oil etc etc???


wet, wet! no standing water that I remember, *maybe* the surface wasn't that great (4-lane,2-way main city road France).
It really shattered my trust in the Elise and my driving.




Edited by edoardo on Monday 14th August 16:15

edoardo

Original Poster:

229 posts

256 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
Lotusnick S2 said:
[
No offence, but unless you hit some oil or kept your foot on the accelator after it started losing traction, I cant see how you managed to do that.

I didn't kept my foot on the throttle!
I avoided going towards the cars coming in the opposite direction(!), and I hit the kerb instaed.

So can I think TSC+LSD would have helped? Or that in general they would help avoiding a disaster if you make mistakes?

yan97

45 posts

249 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
Hi,

I have my Exige S with the LSD installed, if you are ordering the car with pre-factory LSD installed, then go for it. Else afterward any Lotus dealer will charge you the double price for the after-sale installation fee (as least in Switzerland!).
OK if you don't use the car on track that often, it does not make too much sense... but if you do, then GO for it!