pleeeeeeease help me !!!!!!!!
pleeeeeeease help me !!!!!!!!
Author
Discussion

crackthatoff

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

244 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
Could you help me please, The dilema is s1 or s2 ?????
I really really really really really lurve the styling of the s2 elise but as Im going to buy second hand is it worth forking out the extra wonga for the s2?
I recently got taken out in an s1 and loved every minute.. to be honest I really couldn't fault it and for around the 10k mark (give or take a few)seems a real steal.

The s1 owner said its more of a drivers car than the s2 !?
Or do I really scare the finances into an 18k s2 submission (and that is really pushing it !!!) ??
Bearing in mind I have a seperate stash for insurance and a road angel what do I do? Lazer blue just looks so fine !
Any advice would be very much appreciated

cheers Noel

tuscan_thunder

1,763 posts

277 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
you can get an S2 for £12k.

sneakypete

173 posts

260 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
S2 everyday of the week. Slightly more sorted (roof etc) and looks better in my opinion. Although the S1 is certainly the 'classic'. Both are the best car you will ever have and will cost you a reasonable amount of money to run.

Get one in Ardent Red and be careful in the wet.

GTRene

22,798 posts

255 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
I would take a S2...
Color dark!! not yellow or red(sorry guys) dark blue and black or dark grey..get a hardtop to inclu a good price and you have a more man colour car(because the car is already little=sweet/cuit?) and stays a bit better in price or can be easyer sold afterwards...but thats my opignion
Also when the S2 engine goes bust? honda conversion linking to you
GTRene

Edited by GTRene on Wednesday 16th August 14:41

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
looks wise - depends...S1 handles better IMO (less understeer and more predictable oversteer) but the roof is a complete arse..however it is a very good design which (if you fit it properly) does not leak.

the S1 is quite raw but I prefer it because that means the car is faster than the S2 for the same power/torque. if you like leccy windows, air con and carpets etc get an S2 as I doubt you'd notice the drop off in performance

I drive my S1 every day to work but then again people regard me as a nutter mostly

my ideal Elise would be a 111R so it's not like I don't like the S2, far from it..to be fair though, if I had 35k for a 190bhp Elise i'd buy a 9k S1 and a 20k lHD F348 and use the money left over to insure the two

crackthatoff

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

244 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
Thanx guys keep it coming as I have decided to let You lot choose...
I have no mechanical knowlege and this is gonna be 'my baby' so who better to guide me than other elise owners...ps is it worth going to a main dealers for the warranty ?
cheers for your time
noel

Edited by crackthatoff on Wednesday 16th August 15:39

cej

961 posts

253 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
S1 obviously

Looks better, is lighter and in general just a more cool car

It's not that I don't like the S2, I just think the S1 is better. More raw and pure.

I love my S1 and wish I could drive it everyday,but the prices on cars here and the mileage I drive every year (30k) makes that impossible

Get an S1

crackthatoff

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

244 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
tuscan_thunder said:
you can get an S2 for £12k.


Yeah i've seen such but I want a minter because if its gonna be a molested elise I want to be the one that does it !!!
lol thanx

dave_s2_111s

246 posts

259 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
Definately s2.
You will get a mint 111s for £18, 05 plate.

Not as much to worry about reliability wise

Go on do it!

wacattack

576 posts

256 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
It depends why you are buying the car. If you are buying it for what it stands for i.e. a raw driving car then there is no arguement, S1 any day!

But, if you are wanting more looks from Joe public then the S2 is styled in a way that stands out more in a crowd. S2 is also easier to live with.

In my opinion and completely unbiased (hmmmmmm) I would go for the S1. Much better to drive, I prefer the looks, and they are cheaper.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
crackthatoff said:
Thanx guys keep it coming as I have decided to let You lot choose...
I have no mechanical knowlege and this is gonna be 'my baby'



I'm going to help you out:

S2!

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
wacattack said:
But, if you are wanting more looks from Joe public then the S2 is styled in a way that stands out more in a crowd



really?

i've found up here in t'frozen (where admittedly these cars are really rare) that my S1 garners equally as much attention as an S2, and I would honestly say that they are both equally outrageously styled (mine does have bright yellow viper stripes though ).

/2p

jaykaybi

3,494 posts

252 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
minimax, those stripes of yours are presumably an aftermarket addition - are they painted or vinyl? Just wondered if you could pass on a recommendation as I'm considering some white ones for my black s1!

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
jaykaybi said:
minimax, those stripes of yours are presumably an aftermarket addition - are they painted or vinyl? Just wondered if you could pass on a recommendation as I'm considering some white ones for my black s1!




to be honest, I don't know where they came from but I know the last owner had them done. they're vinyl not painted and I can give the previous owner a ring and report back to you if you like


Edit: the last owner had absolutely everything done to the car by Formula One - the Lotus dealer up here in Newcastle (website clicky here) so it's likely they'll be able to point you in the right direction

Edited by minimax on Wednesday 16th August 16:28

stsly

71 posts

246 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
I was in a similar place a few months ago and went for the S1...

I love the S1 looks and that it's not cluttered with things you don't really need. I thought no central locking and elec windows etc would be missed but they aren't.

Also wanted to keep some money aside for some mods and incase anything went wrong which I wouldn't have been able to do if I went for an S2.

The only thing against the S1 is the roof, but even that I love for it's quirkiness.. well ok sometimes I dont!

If I had the money a S2 111R would be on my drive but for me I would sooner have a late S1 than an early S2.

Happy hunting and let us know what you get.

Edited by stsly on Wednesday 16th August 16:24

D4V KC

644 posts

270 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
Let me give you a hand! I did a little DIY sticker work for Le Mans this year but i think you know what you need to do now......




Now go find yourself a S2 111s in Aubergine Metallic!



GTRene

22,798 posts

255 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
I have copyd this from another thread;
already seen some 111R cars under 18K...they come close, nice for potentional buyers but some worrie for owners??
GTRene
4x under 18k by the same dealer all 2004 cars

www.pistonheads.com/sales/list.asp


GTRene

stsly

71 posts

246 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
That is mental!! Maybe next year

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
If you want to spend around 13-15k I'd go for an S2 with the Sport 135 engine. If you want to spend more then, around 16k will get you into 135R or 111S territory.

If you'd prefer to spend less, I'd go for an S1 111S and spend around 11k to get a really good one.

Drive both, buy whichever you prefer, and above all get whatever you choose checked out by a recommended Lotus specialist NOT the AA or RAC. You cannot, and should not, purchase on looks alone.

turnamere

315 posts

266 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
Little chance that you will get an unbiased opinion here, so, S1

Set your budget and then try plenty of cars within your budget, a cherished S1 that has been properly maintained will have had all the bugs ironed out and a few choice mods fitted and will put the biggest smile on your face everytime you drive it. Don't let the roof put you off, most S1 owners get pretty quick with practice; if security isn't a problem get a shower cape, my car lives outside for weeks on end without the roof at this time of year. If you can find a good 111S in budget they are a cracking proposition - quicker than standard, few nice styling tweaks and a little bit easier around town than a 160; which is still THE best S1 if it's a weekend toy.