Does my Elise S2 need a CAMBELT Service at 48,000 miles?
Does my Elise S2 need a CAMBELT Service at 48,000 miles?
Author
Discussion

philiphunter

Original Poster:

159 posts

243 months

Friday 18th August 2006
quotequote all
I have just bought a 2002 Lotus Elise with 48,000 miles (At least 20,000 are motorway miles) on the clock.

It has a full service history but instead of its 'C' service it had an 'A' service.

The next service is not due until May 2007.

The Lotus Garage suggested a 'C' service ASAP, and want £660 for it.

I'd like your opinions regarding the neccesity of this service.

Can anyone recommend somewhere in the North East where I can get the 'C' service carried out without having to shell out so much, and at the same time keep the service book up to date.

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Friday 18th August 2006
quotequote all
I wouldnt sweat a C service, just do it on the next schedule (its just spark plugs, air filter and coolant change).

I would sweat the cambelt though (and may as well do aux belt as well. These are SEPERATE to a C service and and should be changed every 4 years or 36k miles. Question is on the condition fo the cambelt, if its looking at all perished then get it changed.

PS a reputable Lotus specialist will do a full C service and change the belts, and refresh the brake flud for around £500.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Friday 18th August 2006
quotequote all
I'd get that cambelt sorted pronto. The cambelt should be changed every 4 yrs regardless of mileage.
With regards the 'C' service. In your shoes I'd get it done. Keeps the servicing schedule up to date. A future buyer may feel that if you've skimped here then the car ain't that well cared for.

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Friday 18th August 2006
quotequote all
Holdon Tipper, lets not go overboard here in a knoee-jerk reaction.

The original Lotus service schedule was to chnage the cambelts every 6 years (along with the C service) and this was reduced to 4 as a precaution a couple of years ago, engines dint instantly self destruct and this blokes cambelt is not about to give in or expire. The level of risk really depends, as I said below, on its ** CONDITION **.


jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Friday 18th August 2006
quotequote all
I think it is indeed true that all manufacturers play extremely safe when recommending periods for things like oil changes, belts etc.

There are no gaurantees of course, which is why they use very short periods. It is not the actual mileage only which does the belt, it is changes in temperature, cold starts etc.

A car, any car, cruising all day at 100 mph is putting far less stress on the belts and indeed the engine than at start up.

If I were you I'd enjoy what is left of the warm weather, then consider the belt change late in the winter, or before next season start if you intend to put it away.

You will still be well within the worry period, but all you will hear in your head now is ' Lotus recommend cambelt change...it may snap....' and it does get hard to relax!

djroadboy

1,183 posts

267 months

Friday 18th August 2006
quotequote all
I've seen belts go within 3 years and before 25k so I would recommend getting it changed if it hasn't been done. £170 including VAT just to do the cambelt so is it really worth the risk? Just done a rebuild after the cambelt lost 12 teeth. That cost in excess of 700 quid. I know which bill I'd rather pay.

That said, if it is documented in the service history that its been changed within the last 4 years then don't worry.

HTH

Dan@JPS

www.judeperformance.co.uk

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Friday 18th August 2006
quotequote all
You've mentioned it, you'll only be kicking yourself if it goes. Piece of mind is worth a lot of money if you ask me.

philiphunter

Original Poster:

159 posts

243 months

Friday 18th August 2006
quotequote all
What exactly does a 'C' service include?

Will I ba able to get a cambelt change without the service?

paul_c

245 posts

268 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
philiphunter said:
What exactly does a 'C' service include?

Will I ba able to get a cambelt change without the service?


A = oil + oil filter + general safety/condition checks
B = A + air filter + spark plugs
C = B + cambelt + fuel filter


and yes

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
I heard of a cambelt that failed within a week of driving out of the showroom, so based on that lets all change out cambelts every YEAR regardless of the condition then, just to be sure. FFS, madness.

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
On a K series S2 like what philiphunter has, a Lotus service schedule C service does NOT *include* a Cambelt change.

A = change oil
B = A + air filter, plugs
C = B+ transmission oil, fuel filter

Seperatley Lotus currently recommend a schedule of
Brake & Clutch Fluid = Annualy
Coolant = 2 Years
Cambelt 4 years or 45K miles

/reads manual

djroadboy

1,183 posts

267 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
And the car is now 4 years old so its due. rolleyes

I've quoted prices above. I never recommend work that I don't honestly believe is necessary. I never try to rip anybody off and have many happy customers on here so the advice I give is, in my opinion, sound and well reasoned.

At the end of the day its up to you if you want to take the chance.

Call me if you need any more advice. 0191 414 7900

HTH

Dan@JPS

mako111

98 posts

243 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
If you are in the North East then I can vouch for Dan @ JPS - top bloke, I even drive from Leeds to let him stamp my service book.

Dan (not @ JPS)

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
£170 inc VAT for a cambelt change!!

Dan can you come down to the Plymouth area and open a branch??!!

Final thoughts on Phils new car. I've no axe to grind Phil but Lotus do recommend a cambelt change every four years regardless of mileage. The cambelt deteriorates with age. The part of the cambelt you can see may well conceal internal deterioration and you'd only know about that when it goes.
Seen it happen often enough on yachts where the rope you see looks fine, but that's only the sleeve. The bit taking the strain is internal and you don't see the wear - Had a rope like that go bang on me when I was up the top of a mast (attached by said rope). Fortunately I had a secondary 'safety' attached (but your car only has one cambelt).

david@mediacopy

173 posts

252 months

Wednesday 23rd August 2006
quotequote all
My cars in a similar situation.

I didn't realise the cam belt change had been moved forward when I had the 36k service done, but I've decided to leave it till the next service at 45k. Belts really should last till then. That said the front breaks never made it as far as the 18k service, the heater has packed up and I still can't get anything but Radio 1 on the factory fit radio !

I did wonder if the reason that Lotus moved the Cam Belt change forward was because people were buying Elises and not using them, keeping them tucked up in the garage as Sunday cars, resulting in a lot of 'Low milage' cars suffering belt fails due to belts 'going off' due to lack of use?