Advice required regarding dispute with dealer
Advice required regarding dispute with dealer
Author
Discussion

tom_allen

Original Poster:

119 posts

262 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
I took my Elise in for a "C" service today. Whilst trying to undo one of the bleed nipples on the brake calipers the "mechanic" snapped the nipple clean off leaving the threaded bit in the caliper. Admittedly it was quite badly corroded, but they are telling me I now need a new caliper as they can't remove whats left of the nipple. I only have basic engineering knowledge but I know my dad has tools for removing snapped bolts. Surely they can't have tried very hard to remove it. They have quoted me £265 for the caliper but said they wouldn't charge for the labour. How good of them!! Now what I need to know is should I have to pay for this, their mechanic broke the thing and I'm having to cough up big time for their mistake. If I could drive the car I would bring it home and tell them where to go but as the brakes are probably now screwed I won't be able to. Anybody got any ideas as to where I stand on this? Can I tell them they should either try harder to repair the old caliper that was working great until i took it there or pay for the new one?

I won't be taking my car there again thats for sure, only used a dealer to get the stamp in the book!! Another thing they told me was the steering rack wants replacing and they wanted nearl £400 for that. When they wrecked the caliper they phoned to say, we're going to leave the rack for now unless you want us to do it. I thought if it was that bad it needed changing how come it can now wait? Strange, is this a case of greedy dealers, I feel I might report them to the House of Horrors vloke to get them named and shamed.

Any advice greatly appreciated!!

Mrs Trackside

9,299 posts

264 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
tom_allen said:
I took my Elise in for a "C" service today. Whilst trying to undo one of the bleed nipples on the brake calipers the "mechanic" snapped the nipple clean off leaving the threaded bit in the caliper. Admittedly it was quite badly corroded, but they are telling me I now need a new caliper as they can't remove whats left of the nipple.


Am I missing something here? You've said yourself the nipple was badly corroded, so how can you blame the mechanic for breaking it? Maybe the nipple is embedded deep inside the caliper so they can't get a tool around it to get it out. My logic says you would need to replace the whole part if that were the case.

As for the steering rack. It may need replacing like they said, but maybe these guys have figured you've got enough to pay out already and that maybe you would rather wait until, I dunno, maybe next month when you've got some more cash before it is replaced.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
There should be a very easy and very, very cheap compromise here.

Admittedly, the Elise may have a different set-up and not enough meat left, but it is usually easy to drill out the hole and fit a new oversized bolt.

Have done so on motorcycle brakes loads of times.

You may have a dealer here who will refuse to do so on 'safety' grounds ( as the fix costs a tenner at the most it is a lot less money for them ) but if done properly, it is perfectly solid. They may not feel they have the expertise to do it - and I'm amazed they did not suggest it ( unless, as said, there is no scope to do this on the Elise calliper ).

I'd put this to them, or get in touch with an engineer who has experience - try www.motorcylenews.com for advice on the best. ( This process is often called Helicoil )

crackthatoff

3,314 posts

244 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
Snooker ball, sock!!! say no more

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
Mrs Trackside said:
tom_allen said:
I took my Elise in for a "C" service today. Whilst trying to undo one of the bleed nipples on the brake calipers the "mechanic" snapped the nipple clean off leaving the threaded bit in the caliper. Admittedly it was quite badly corroded, but they are telling me I now need a new caliper as they can't remove whats left of the nipple.


Am I missing something here? You've said yourself the nipple was badly corroded, so how can you blame the mechanic for breaking it? Maybe the nipple is embedded deep inside the caliper so they can't get a tool around it to get it out. My logic says you would need to replace the whole part if that were the case.

As for the steering rack. It may need replacing like they said, but maybe these guys have figured you've got enough to pay out already and that maybe you would rather wait until, I dunno, maybe next month when you've got some more cash before it is replaced.



If you are that worried as the to remove the caliper and you get it drilled out. They can then refit it for you or supply your own second hand caliper rather than a new one (ebay etc).

I'm failing to see the issue here as where ever you took it (or if you did it yourself) you would have had exactly the same problem.

Edited by Paul RN on Monday 21st August 22:05

GTRene

22,798 posts

255 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
not always true...some machanics put to much force on such easy to brake screw...
sometimes with some wd40 and time and little ticks of hammering on such release screw can make them go loose again without braking! just like exhaust manifold srews can do or other rusty srews...so it will not always brake!! only when you stupidly go on with using force on such delicate release srew...ok sometimes they can brake maybe even when you do the thing as advised above...but a lot is in the hands of a proper mechanic!
GTRene

MJK 24

5,679 posts

267 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
I think the issue here is not that the nipple is broken, that was going to happen anyway. The issue is that the dealer only employs monkeys who don't know how to repair cars. All they know how to do is service them.

I snapped the nipple in a caliper (A Peugeot one, not that it makes the slightest odds) and it took my dad about 15 minutes to get the old bit out and clean up the thread for the new nipple which cost me a huge £3.

Next time, use a respected specialist who will have the brains and decent spannermen who will be able to sort such an issue without drama.

GTRene

22,798 posts

255 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
agree...sh*t happens...sometimes twice a day but it don't have to be a mess...
GTRene

Lotusnick S2

251 posts

261 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
MJK 24 said:
I think the issue here is not that the nipple is broken, that was going to happen anyway. The issue is that the dealer only employs monkeys who don't know how to repair cars. All they know how to do is service them.

I snapped the nipple in a caliper (A Peugeot one, not that it makes the slightest odds) and it took my dad about 15 minutes to get the old bit out and clean up the thread for the new nipple which cost me a huge £3.

Next time, use a respected specialist who will have the brains and decent spannermen who will be able to sort such an issue without drama.


Problem is that even some so called Respected specialists employ monkeys that can fook up your car. (Mark you know the very serious problems I had with a said specialist)

Tell him to remove the caliper, and then fix however you can and give it back for him to re-fit.
Tell him to give you a discount and never go there again.

Nikos

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
MJK 24 said:
I think the issue here is not that the nipple is broken, that was going to happen anyway.


As GTRene has already said, this is not necessarily the case. If you can see that a bleed nipple is corroded and likely to cause problems, you don't just stick a spanner on it and hope of the best unless you are a complete neanderthal who could care less what happens. After all, it's not as though said neanderthal is going to have to pay for his actions is it?

Very often (but admittedly not always) you can remove such bolt/bleed nipples without shearing them given paitience and a little skill.

Now it's happened, remove the caliper and get the remains of the bleed nipple removed by someone competent.

MJK 24

5,679 posts

267 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
Lotusnick S2 said:
MJK 24 said:
I think the issue here is not that the nipple is broken, that was going to happen anyway. The issue is that the dealer only employs monkeys who don't know how to repair cars. All they know how to do is service them.

I snapped the nipple in a caliper (A Peugeot one, not that it makes the slightest odds) and it took my dad about 15 minutes to get the old bit out and clean up the thread for the new nipple which cost me a huge £3.

Next time, use a respected specialist who will have the brains and decent spannermen who will be able to sort such an issue without drama.


Problem is that even some so called Respected specialists employ monkeys that can fook up your car. (Mark you know the very serious problems I had with a said specialist)


This is truw. However, I do think there's a better standard of mechanic at a specialist anbd generally, there's someone who will hold there hands up when there's a problem. With a dealer, you may as well talk to the wall.

tom_allen

Original Poster:

119 posts

262 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
you see I'm glad there are some people here who have some common sense and agree that it is possible to fix these things!! As for the others I can't believe you think its alright to throw away a perfectly good part that can be fixed.

I will be getting it changed but I'm going to make sure I get the one they've taken off. So I can fix it and have a spare.

ferrisbueller

30,343 posts

258 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
I'd say you'd be able to get someone to drill that out for you no worries.

Steering racks wear out pretty quickly. Mine did. New one cost £350 inc fitting and is a quicker upgraded rack.

as400

161 posts

243 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
The majority of dealers have a policy of replace and not repair in my experience.