Exige vs Exige S (sacking off the honda elise idea)
Discussion
Firstly nothing wrong with the honda elise however i am not one for playing about with cars and simpley feel my money needs to be spent on the exige or exige S as 10K for the same car i just cant justify!
Guys Can you all let me know the good points of the exige and also bad points, I feel that i will be really happy with it without having to stretch to the S as financially that will mean me borrowing another 10K where as an 05 exige will leave me one happy debt free chappy!!!!
Comparisons and yout thoughts please!
Guys Can you all let me know the good points of the exige and also bad points, I feel that i will be really happy with it without having to stretch to the S as financially that will mean me borrowing another 10K where as an 05 exige will leave me one happy debt free chappy!!!!
Comparisons and yout thoughts please!
They are the same car really, only difference is the engine.
An 05 exige will be missing out on the 06 model year improvements but to be honest these arent that much. Probax seats probably the biggest thing plus the availability of traction control.
I think it really depends on whether you think the standard car is quick enough below 6000rpm. If you feel the need to always be over that to get the real power/acceleration then i think it would be a pretty frustrating drive on the road and youd be better off in the s. However, if you do find it quick enough then extra power on the 2nd cam is pretty thrilling when you do use it.
On any of the tracks ive been to so far its very easy to keep it over 6000 and i dont think there is much difference in acceleration between the two cars then. Any acceleration the standard car is missing should be more than made up for by feeling so much quicker than it does at lower rpm.
HTH
Simon
An 05 exige will be missing out on the 06 model year improvements but to be honest these arent that much. Probax seats probably the biggest thing plus the availability of traction control.
I think it really depends on whether you think the standard car is quick enough below 6000rpm. If you feel the need to always be over that to get the real power/acceleration then i think it would be a pretty frustrating drive on the road and youd be better off in the s. However, if you do find it quick enough then extra power on the 2nd cam is pretty thrilling when you do use it.
On any of the tracks ive been to so far its very easy to keep it over 6000 and i dont think there is much difference in acceleration between the two cars then. Any acceleration the standard car is missing should be more than made up for by feeling so much quicker than it does at lower rpm.
HTH
Simon
I've got a MY05 Exige and am very happy about not having the probax seats. I'm not that big of a person, so the Probax seats are definately too wide for my liking. I also don't like the drive-by-wire of the new 2006 models (I prefer as little as electronics as possible, in addition to a bit better throttle response). One other thing; Be aware that besides the 30bhp more power the Exige-S brings, it also is around 60kg heavier given both have the same options.
Cheers Phil
Cheers Phil
As I said on the previous thread. Drive both, buy the one you like best. Having driven both the main choice you are making is to do with what's in the engine bay, and how the power is delivered.
If you like the Exige and don't want to shell out for the S, there are some very good value cars around at the moment in the classifieds. Get one that's specced up with all the toys, has aircon and I'm sure you'll love it to bits.
If you like the Exige and don't want to shell out for the S, there are some very good value cars around at the moment in the classifieds. Get one that's specced up with all the toys, has aircon and I'm sure you'll love it to bits.
If you are looking new it's a no brainer. The extra for the S is only £3k so it has got to be done. New S vs used "normal" Exige is a much tougher call. As has been said in terms of ultimate speed on a track there is probably not that much in it, but on the road the extra torque of the S makes it much faster most of the time, as it can be quite difficult to keep a standard Exige on the boil in real world conditions. When you get caught below the cam changover point the standard car can actually feel a bit slow. Plus for me the whine of the supercharger in the S makes every journey a real event, and the sense of occassion is a big bit of what Exiges are all about really.
Chris
(traded up from normal Exige to S a few months back)
Chris
(traded up from normal Exige to S a few months back)
L888DER said:
it is definatley 2 year old exige against 3 month old exige S.... and i wont really be using this a a track car, just a weekend/sunny evening toy!
*cough*
www.wilson-group.co.uk/kcom/ucl/response.asp?querytype=7&vscoid=01&magic=500555
Test dove this last weekend along with the whiote one with red wheels they currently have. I told them i was allready redundanct but the money doesnt hit my account till 29th sep. However my 51 plate S2 elise with 31K miles was only offered at part ex for 12,000 and with the stage 2, armourfend and airfilter they want mine plus 15.5 ??????
I was in a similar decision a year ago, when I had to decide on either getting one of the very last 2005 Exiges, a 2006 Exige or perhaps even go for a limited 240R.
2005 Exige...
had the advantage of being a bit cheaper, being a bit lighter and more raw than the newer model. The response is better since it is not drive by wire and the seats were much more for my liking since they are not as wide as the new probax seats. I also didn't like the new LED rear-lights, though that's purely subjective.
2006 Exige...
What I do like over the 2005 Exige was that with the drive-by-wire, the pedals are definately more geared towards a heel&toeing. It's possible in my 2005 Exige, but it's taking me a bit of time to get used to. I also like the new non-linear rev counter...
Exige-S
Basically a 2006 Exige with the supercharger, but at a hefty price.
If I were you and you find the performance figures between a standard Exige and a Exige-S not all that far apart, go for the cheaper Exige, get used to it and enjoy it for a year until you have more money and want more performance, come to Switzerland (Bemani) or drop by at Komotec in Germany and get supercharger that will surpass even a 240R. Like this, you have the best of both worlds and don't have to spend all your money on everything on the first day. And if you're happy with the Exige's performance, you saved yourself a bit of money on what you would have payed if you had went directly with a Exige-S.
2005 Exige...
had the advantage of being a bit cheaper, being a bit lighter and more raw than the newer model. The response is better since it is not drive by wire and the seats were much more for my liking since they are not as wide as the new probax seats. I also didn't like the new LED rear-lights, though that's purely subjective.
2006 Exige...
What I do like over the 2005 Exige was that with the drive-by-wire, the pedals are definately more geared towards a heel&toeing. It's possible in my 2005 Exige, but it's taking me a bit of time to get used to. I also like the new non-linear rev counter...
Exige-S
Basically a 2006 Exige with the supercharger, but at a hefty price.
If I were you and you find the performance figures between a standard Exige and a Exige-S not all that far apart, go for the cheaper Exige, get used to it and enjoy it for a year until you have more money and want more performance, come to Switzerland (Bemani) or drop by at Komotec in Germany and get supercharger that will surpass even a 240R. Like this, you have the best of both worlds and don't have to spend all your money on everything on the first day. And if you're happy with the Exige's performance, you saved yourself a bit of money on what you would have payed if you had went directly with a Exige-S.
www.pistonheads.com/sales/93113.htm this is the one i want...... begin the coutdown to september 29th
L888DER said:
www.pistonheads.com/sales/93113.htm this is the one i want...... begin the coutdown to september 29th
lovely car...
Storm Titanium with Touring pack, very nice - identical to my old car except I had a Stage 1 rather than Stage 2 exhaust. Seeing that price compared to what I sold mine for does make me think you might want to haggle hard or consider buying privately. They are pretty bullet-proof mechanically so if it has been serviced on time I don't think you can go too far wrong. Obviously the normal HPI check to make sure it's not been stuffed and you're sitting pretty.
Reading your comments, I think you could have an awful lot of fun in one of those. Strangely enough where the S really scores over the standard car is if you're using it as a daily driver, due to the greater flexibility of the engine. As you've said you're after a fun car you'll probably find you don't mind having to drive it a bit harder to keep it on the second cam.
Anyway, good luck and have fun choosing!
Chris
Reading your comments, I think you could have an awful lot of fun in one of those. Strangely enough where the S really scores over the standard car is if you're using it as a daily driver, due to the greater flexibility of the engine. As you've said you're after a fun car you'll probably find you don't mind having to drive it a bit harder to keep it on the second cam.
Anyway, good luck and have fun choosing!
Chris
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



