Do I buy an Elise or not? How long to take the roof off?
Discussion
I'm trying to decide what to replace my Mini with, I want a RWD 2 seater which is fun to drive but it will be my daily driver so it needs to be reliable and vaguely practical.
The 2 options I'm considering are an S1 Elise (budget of up to £10k) or a new MX-5 1.8. The Mazda is more expensive but I can use it for business mileage and that covers part of the running costs as well as the fuel, the Elise will be too old for that, plus the MX-5 has a 3 year warranty which the Elise obviously won't!
In my heart I want the Lotus but there are a couple of issues....
How long does it take to remove the roof and how long to put it back? I don't have a garage so the roof will have to be on overnight but I have a 25 minute drive to work so I'd like to be able to take the roof off quickly for that if I feel like it. With the mazda it's about 5 seconds up and the same again down, I'm told the Elise takes more like 10 minutes, have I been mis-informed?
How good is the heater? My other half has a medical condition where she gets cold very easily and her fingers and toes go blue so the car has to have a heater which works vaguely well!
Finally, what are servicing and repair costs like? I have access to a good garage which used to effectively be a Rover worshop where I pay substantially reduced labour rates so I guess that's good for routine servicing and the inevitable HG repairs! What about the rest, is there much that's beyond the wit of a competent DIY mechanic or a normal garage?
Cheers!
The 2 options I'm considering are an S1 Elise (budget of up to £10k) or a new MX-5 1.8. The Mazda is more expensive but I can use it for business mileage and that covers part of the running costs as well as the fuel, the Elise will be too old for that, plus the MX-5 has a 3 year warranty which the Elise obviously won't!
In my heart I want the Lotus but there are a couple of issues....
How long does it take to remove the roof and how long to put it back? I don't have a garage so the roof will have to be on overnight but I have a 25 minute drive to work so I'd like to be able to take the roof off quickly for that if I feel like it. With the mazda it's about 5 seconds up and the same again down, I'm told the Elise takes more like 10 minutes, have I been mis-informed?
How good is the heater? My other half has a medical condition where she gets cold very easily and her fingers and toes go blue so the car has to have a heater which works vaguely well!
Finally, what are servicing and repair costs like? I have access to a good garage which used to effectively be a Rover worshop where I pay substantially reduced labour rates so I guess that's good for routine servicing and the inevitable HG repairs! What about the rest, is there much that's beyond the wit of a competent DIY mechanic or a normal garage?
Cheers!

Well I just bought an S1 at the weekend and the guy said do you want to test drive with the roof on or off. I said off and so he took it off in less than 5 mins. When we finished he said shall we put the roof on so I said ok. He said right yo udo that side and I do this side. It is piss easy and this was my first time.
1. Clip the two beans across the roof (Beam with plug on each end which pops into hole in roof)
2. Clip front of cover into little groove at top of windscreen (Kid of tounge and groove setup)
3. Fold over side flaps and pop the 4 poppers clossed ( Old seventies coats had this little poppers that you squeeze together to fasten. Well its 4 of those on each side.
4. Insert the end flaps into the holes in ear bodywork and turn allen key to secure
5. Lift the two beans up to hold in place
See, its that easy and I have only done it once. Yes its not the best design but I would say 3 mins to take on and 3 mins to take off.
Watch this, its shows you how to do the roof despite Tiff making a bit of a song and dance about it.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=FMq0_BLmSzQ
1. Clip the two beans across the roof (Beam with plug on each end which pops into hole in roof)
2. Clip front of cover into little groove at top of windscreen (Kid of tounge and groove setup)
3. Fold over side flaps and pop the 4 poppers clossed ( Old seventies coats had this little poppers that you squeeze together to fasten. Well its 4 of those on each side.
4. Insert the end flaps into the holes in ear bodywork and turn allen key to secure
5. Lift the two beans up to hold in place
See, its that easy and I have only done it once. Yes its not the best design but I would say 3 mins to take on and 3 mins to take off.
Watch this, its shows you how to do the roof despite Tiff making a bit of a song and dance about it.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=FMq0_BLmSzQ
If you can afford a new MX5, isn't there any way you could stretch to a new Elise S(£23k)?
I know it's a lot more money but it will hold its value superbly.
You'll probably find that with a PCP (final balloon payment to make in the future) that the monthly payments aren't that different.
You could easily use that every day, you can take the roof on and off in 1 minute and it will have a full warranty (not that the Toyota engine will go wrong)
All the benefits of the MX5 plus ...
one of the greatest drives on the planet
I know it's a lot more money but it will hold its value superbly.
You'll probably find that with a PCP (final balloon payment to make in the future) that the monthly payments aren't that different.
You could easily use that every day, you can take the roof on and off in 1 minute and it will have a full warranty (not that the Toyota engine will go wrong)
All the benefits of the MX5 plus ...
one of the greatest drives on the planet
Sorry but the elise is in a totally different league & i am 100% sure that you wouldnt regret getting an elise! Sod the warranty, sod the mileage allowance because you simply will not have a bigger smile on your face by driving & owning an elise! Come on if someone askes you "what car do you drive" , ("oh an MX5"
"nice car mate", or if you reply "i drive a lotus" the reply would be quit different let me tell you. 
"nice car mate", or if you reply "i drive a lotus" the reply would be quit different let me tell you. 
The MX5 would be on a PCP and I can't streach to a new Elise unfortunately
I'm sure the Elise would be a better drive but I'm not sure it I'll get enough opportunities to appreciate the improvements over the MX5. I can't see myself having enough time to go driving just for the sake of it and the Mazda is still a great fun car to drive. The only time since Ive had the Mini when I've had a chance to really give it some stick was when I went on a weekend run tot he South of France and that put a massive smile on my face, even though it's a 1.6 litre FWD hatchback.
I'd love to be able to say 'sod the warranty' but it's a big bonus knowing that if something major does go wrong it'll be fixed FoC. The company mileage thing is also quite handy, I do a couple of hundred miles a month on average which covers the insurance on the Mini now, if I get the Lotus technically I have to do those miles in a 3 year old Focus pool car
Is the Elise really a viable day-to-day car? It'll have to drive me to work at least a couple of times a week (unless the Mrs can be persuaded that we should take her car all the time!) and it'll live outside in all weathers. What's the steering like on the Elise, is it very heavy if you're trying to park? My girlfriend is 5 foot 3 and a size 8 and she'll need to be able to drive it too!
I'm so indecisive I've talked myself out of getting one and then changed my mind again in the space of 1 post!
I'm sure the Elise would be a better drive but I'm not sure it I'll get enough opportunities to appreciate the improvements over the MX5. I can't see myself having enough time to go driving just for the sake of it and the Mazda is still a great fun car to drive. The only time since Ive had the Mini when I've had a chance to really give it some stick was when I went on a weekend run tot he South of France and that put a massive smile on my face, even though it's a 1.6 litre FWD hatchback.
I'd love to be able to say 'sod the warranty' but it's a big bonus knowing that if something major does go wrong it'll be fixed FoC. The company mileage thing is also quite handy, I do a couple of hundred miles a month on average which covers the insurance on the Mini now, if I get the Lotus technically I have to do those miles in a 3 year old Focus pool car
Is the Elise really a viable day-to-day car? It'll have to drive me to work at least a couple of times a week (unless the Mrs can be persuaded that we should take her car all the time!) and it'll live outside in all weathers. What's the steering like on the Elise, is it very heavy if you're trying to park? My girlfriend is 5 foot 3 and a size 8 and she'll need to be able to drive it too!
I'm so indecisive I've talked myself out of getting one and then changed my mind again in the space of 1 post!

The S1 roof drove me mad, one of the reasons I flogged it. It was my second car and in the end it didn't get used if the weather was iffy. And many a time at work I'd have to dash out in the peeing rain to put it or the shower cap on much the amusement of colleagues.
I'll get an S2 next with short roof.
Never driven an MX 5 but I'm sure it's not a patch on the Elise.
I'll get an S2 next with short roof.
Never driven an MX 5 but I'm sure it's not a patch on the Elise.
The S1 roof drove me mad, one of the reasons I flogged it. It was my second car and in the end it didn't get used if the weather was iffy. And many a time at work I'd have to dash out in the peeing rain to put it or the shower cap on much the amusement of colleagues.
I'll get an S2 next with short roof.
Never driven an MX 5 but I'm sure it's not a patch on the Elise.
I'll get an S2 next with short roof.
Never driven an MX 5 but I'm sure it's not a patch on the Elise.
So it sounds like your mind is made up on the MX5?
Ive owned my elise for 10 weeks now & have covered 3 thousand miles in that time & when i came to selling my other car (seat ibiza tdi sport), i drove it to birmingham (2 hour drive) & my back was killing me, where as the elise is so comfy on a run.
Ive owned my elise for 10 weeks now & have covered 3 thousand miles in that time & when i came to selling my other car (seat ibiza tdi sport), i drove it to birmingham (2 hour drive) & my back was killing me, where as the elise is so comfy on a run.
Edited by boobles on Sunday 17th September 17:18
jamiebae said:
The MX5 would be on a PCP and I can't streach to a new Elise unfortunately
I'm sure the Elise would be a better drive but I'm not sure it I'll get enough opportunities to appreciate the improvements over the MX5. I can't see myself having enough time to go driving just for the sake of it and the Mazda is still a great fun car to drive. The only time since Ive had the Mini when I've had a chance to really give it some stick was when I went on a weekend run tot he South of France and that put a massive smile on my face, even though it's a 1.6 litre FWD hatchback.
I'd love to be able to say 'sod the warranty' but it's a big bonus knowing that if something major does go wrong it'll be fixed FoC. The company mileage thing is also quite handy, I do a couple of hundred miles a month on average which covers the insurance on the Mini now, if I get the Lotus technically I have to do those miles in a 3 year old Focus pool car
Is the Elise really a viable day-to-day car? It'll have to drive me to work at least a couple of times a week (unless the Mrs can be persuaded that we should take her car all the time!) and it'll live outside in all weathers. What's the steering like on the Elise, is it very heavy if you're trying to park? My girlfriend is 5 foot 3 and a size 8 and she'll need to be able to drive it too!
I'm so indecisive I've talked myself out of getting one and then changed my mind again in the space of 1 post!
I'm sure the Elise would be a better drive but I'm not sure it I'll get enough opportunities to appreciate the improvements over the MX5. I can't see myself having enough time to go driving just for the sake of it and the Mazda is still a great fun car to drive. The only time since Ive had the Mini when I've had a chance to really give it some stick was when I went on a weekend run tot he South of France and that put a massive smile on my face, even though it's a 1.6 litre FWD hatchback.
I'd love to be able to say 'sod the warranty' but it's a big bonus knowing that if something major does go wrong it'll be fixed FoC. The company mileage thing is also quite handy, I do a couple of hundred miles a month on average which covers the insurance on the Mini now, if I get the Lotus technically I have to do those miles in a 3 year old Focus pool car
Is the Elise really a viable day-to-day car? It'll have to drive me to work at least a couple of times a week (unless the Mrs can be persuaded that we should take her car all the time!) and it'll live outside in all weathers. What's the steering like on the Elise, is it very heavy if you're trying to park? My girlfriend is 5 foot 3 and a size 8 and she'll need to be able to drive it too!
I'm so indecisive I've talked myself out of getting one and then changed my mind again in the space of 1 post!

With all respect, the Elise really is a car that you want to DRIVE. It's not like other cars where you just point it in the direction you want to go and let it take you there. You DRIVE it there. It's very basic. No power steering (although you don't need it), no assisted brakes, no-where to put anything inside the car. I do have a car for everyday use, but I've been taking the Lotus to work because I just love driving it. We live in the countryside, so it's perfect for all the twisty roads.
The steering? Dead easy. I'm 5 foot nothing, and we've just bought our first Elise, an S1. We were lucky enough to find one with extended runners and I use a Lotus booster cushion because I find the seating position too uncomfortable otherwise.
Our car came with a hardtop, which may be an idea if you're parking the car outside in all weathers (although the soft top doesn't leak). As for the heater. I rarely use it. By the time the car has warmed up, the engine makes the cab very hot.
You need to drive an Elise to really appreciate it.
From what you've said i think you'll get annoyed with the elise v. quickly.
Chances are the S1 will leak to some extent if its kept outside.
The standard blower/heater is rubbish ( but the car will warm-up eventually - radiator pipes through the sill help)
For a 25 minute journey you wont bother taking the roof down coz its too much of a pain.
Your girlfriend will hate getting in and out.
Go and test drive an s1 at a dealer -you'll love the drive but need to balance that against the down sides. Then go drive the mazda and compare them. If i were a gambling man i'd say you go with the mazda (which is a great roadster)
tup
Chances are the S1 will leak to some extent if its kept outside.
The standard blower/heater is rubbish ( but the car will warm-up eventually - radiator pipes through the sill help)
For a 25 minute journey you wont bother taking the roof down coz its too much of a pain.
Your girlfriend will hate getting in and out.
Go and test drive an s1 at a dealer -you'll love the drive but need to balance that against the down sides. Then go drive the mazda and compare them. If i were a gambling man i'd say you go with the mazda (which is a great roadster)
tup
Hmmm, so some people say the hood is fine, others say it's rubbish! I do need to go and drive one really!
I think I can live with the boot space and I'm pretty sure I could get a luggage rack (or fabricate one) to put a tent etc on top of the boot lid, it's just the roof and leakyness that concerns me...
Does anyone live near Thame in Oxfordshire and fancy letting me have a nose roud their car so I can see for myself?
I think I can live with the boot space and I'm pretty sure I could get a luggage rack (or fabricate one) to put a tent etc on top of the boot lid, it's just the roof and leakyness that concerns me...
Does anyone live near Thame in Oxfordshire and fancy letting me have a nose roud their car so I can see for myself?

Not in my case! My gfriend would kill me if i sold the elise, especially for an mx5.... She loves it big time!
I live in hampshire & your more than welcome to have a nosey round mine... Its a w reg (2000) so the roof doesnt leak very much at all. Something i can certainly live with.
I live in hampshire & your more than welcome to have a nosey round mine... Its a w reg (2000) so the roof doesnt leak very much at all. Something i can certainly live with.
Edited by boobles on Sunday 17th September 17:27
Well I currently have a 55 plate Mini and she has an 04 plate Panda! She doesn't like the look of the Lotus but she does admit that it would be quite cool to be able to say 'we have a Lotus' to her friends
Are there any nasty expensive problems the Elise might enounter? Am I right in thinking the engine and box come straight from a Rover 200 so should be easy to replace if the worst happens? Are there any wiered and expensive parts for them? I work for a very large car parts supplier (who's name I can't mention on here due to company policy) so anything that could come from a motor factor is fine. Was I right in hearing that it has ally brake discs in that 5th gear vid posted earlier?
Are there any nasty expensive problems the Elise might enounter? Am I right in thinking the engine and box come straight from a Rover 200 so should be easy to replace if the worst happens? Are there any wiered and expensive parts for them? I work for a very large car parts supplier (who's name I can't mention on here due to company policy) so anything that could come from a motor factor is fine. Was I right in hearing that it has ally brake discs in that 5th gear vid posted earlier?
Fruitcake said:
.. well, you only live once, right?
That's exactly why I'm looking at these 2 cars and not the Alfa 147 JTD or BMW 118d which were the two cars I started off looking at!
It;s just a case of if the Elise will annoy me, or if the MX5 will make me wish I'd got the Elise every time I see one!
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


