Autocar Best Handling Car 2006
Autocar Best Handling Car 2006
Author
Discussion

simonk

Original Poster:

908 posts

256 months

Friday 22nd September 2006
quotequote all
Anyone else read this?

Is it just me or do they seem to say that the best handling car comes second in the best handling car awards because its too impractical and compromised as an everyday car?!

Also, the top two cars (exige & cayman) are both available with quite different adjustable damping systems at a reasonable cost. No mention was made to whether the test cars had this (photos would suggest they both did to me) or whether either system was any good etc etc.

Disappointing article i thought.

Simon

kelk

955 posts

244 months

Friday 22nd September 2006
quotequote all
I just thought it was odd that they go to a track to determine which is the best handling and then decide it on which goes to the supermarket the best - very confusing. But then again we wouldn't want to upset Porsche at Autocar now would we?

So if both the 911 and the Cayman are there why not the Exige and the Elise?

I found the article very skewed.

richyboy

3,749 posts

248 months

Friday 22nd September 2006
quotequote all
I don't get that mag anymore, what was the top five?

kelk

955 posts

244 months

Friday 22nd September 2006
quotequote all
In order

1) Cayman S
2) Exige S
3) 911 Turbo
4) Aston Martin DB9 Sport
5) 350Z
6) Ford Focus ST

richyboy

3,749 posts

248 months

Friday 22nd September 2006
quotequote all
That is strange. Last years one went I think noble, litchfield scooby, 111r, evo, exige, csl.... much more worthy cars of such a title.

speedyellow

2,533 posts

258 months

Friday 22nd September 2006
quotequote all
Just finished reading it and thought the same as above... they say the Exige is the best handling car then say it's not good for shopping and hand it over to the Porsche... very strange....

Having done lots of track days with my 240R against Caymens the one thing I find strange is the lap times. Not even the Techart special could keep anywhere near at places like Spa... as they were doing demo runs for prospective customers they even came and asked me if I'd go out at different times to them... the 240R should be a bit quicker than an S due to the extra power and the Ohlins, but I can't beleive the lap times for the Exige are slow in comparision to the Porsche?

Not seen an S on a track day yet to do a proper head to head to see the real difference... must happen very soon I'm sure...

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Friday 22nd September 2006
quotequote all
I'm sure I remember hearing something similar on here last year and wondering what the point of the article was.

If practicality's now a consideration, why not factor in price? After all, you can pay for a lot of taxis from the shops from the change if you don't buy the Porker.

speedyellow

2,533 posts

258 months

Friday 22nd September 2006
quotequote all
Or buy a used Focus as well as an Exige..... ;-)

simonk

Original Poster:

908 posts

256 months

Saturday 23rd September 2006
quotequote all
Yeah thinking about it i think they ran a "best drivers car" or something similar and the top 2 spots were exactly the same with exactly the same reasoning.

I was surprised the caterham didnt do a lot better. I couldnt live with one but if it wins a best handling contest then i can discount it as not for me and look at 2nd best. And so on.

Dont think the S exige is much quicker than a normal exige on most tracks. It only has half the extra power of a 240r/cup but carries all of the extra weight as far as im aware. Think the main benefit is the on road overtaking, being caught in the wrong gear etc etc.

Simon

chris_n

1,232 posts

289 months

Saturday 23rd September 2006
quotequote all
speedyellow said:
I can't beleive the lap times for the Exige are slow in comparision to the Porsche?

Does seem odd. I haven't got the article in front of me now but as i remember there is even a reference in the text about something being awry with the Exige's lap time.

That article was a really poor piece of journalism - they rave about the Exige's handling but then make out is some track-focused impractical monster when nothing could be further from the truth.

richyboy

3,749 posts

248 months

Sunday 24th September 2006
quotequote all
They don't even show the exige in the video test-

www.autocar.co.uk/popups/video.asp?AR=222412

Phil-CH

1,132 posts

295 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
simonk said:
Dont think the S exige is much quicker than a normal exige on most tracks. It only has half the extra power of a 240r/cup but carries all of the extra weight as far as im aware. Think the main benefit is the on road overtaking, being caught in the wrong gear etc etc.


I've been giving this a bit of thought lately. From 0-60 the two cars shouldn't be far apart - it's from 60 to 100mph that the Exige-S will have a significant advantage. I've messured times as well as checked corresponding magazines and the std. Exige will do 60 to 100mph in about ~10 seconds, while an Exige-S will do it in around 6.5 seconds. Truth is, the Yamaha engine without SC has a very steep power-curve which means that even in 2nd cam mode, the car just doesn't have enough power available until you reach around 7000/7500 rpm. An Exige-S on the other hand probably has over 80% of its power available above 6000rpm. This helps it significantly above 60mph.

To add more fuel, even an S1 Exige has more power available within its power-band than the S2 Exige and will do 60-100 in around 9 seconds...

Edited by Phil-CH on Monday 25th September 09:07

simonk

Original Poster:

908 posts

256 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
Thats interesting. Do you have times for the 240r/cup?

Simon

Phil-CH

1,132 posts

295 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
simonk said:
Thats interesting. Do you have times for the 240r/cup?

Simon


Exige-S did it in 6.5s in a magazine from Switzerland. There's another test where the S did it in ~7.5s though. The 240R that was tested by another magazine (Sport Auto) in Germany had ~7.5s. Unfortunately, I don't have more tests of the 240R - but I'd expect them to have more or less equal times since they have the same S/C kit and suffer the same overheating issues that probably hurt the times in Sport Auto a little. Maybe, Sportauto didn't do the gearshifts that well.

Also, the Exige-S was dynod at around ~240hp (or close to it) at one of the Lotus dealers here in a more or less cold state (without any mods), so it's difficult to say how much of a time/performance difference we'd be looking at..

The power/torque data I extracted in my comparasion between are from the 240R and std. Exige.

Edited by Phil-CH on Monday 25th September 10:36


Edited by Phil-CH on Monday 25th September 10:38

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
Porsche are known for thier back hands to the motoring journo's.

kinetic

348 posts

275 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
That lap time for the Exige S at Oulton is very poor. To put this in perspective I can go over 3 seconds faster in a bog standard S1 Exige 190, so either those Journo's can't drive or the Exige S ain't the machine its supposed to be. WEIGHT is the issue here I rekon. Aren't they around the 900kg mark?

Any decent experienced track day driver should be able to match 2.02 at Oulton in a non supercharged S2 Exige!