Insurance - no claims bonus problem
Insurance - no claims bonus problem
Author
Discussion

111Rmeupbaby

Original Poster:

25 posts

242 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
Hi all,

I have a day to day car with max NCD and considering the Lotus as a second car, but nobody is taking into consideraton the full NCD I have built up on my main car, so all the quotes for the liz are ouotrageous, yet I am 34 with 'only' 2 SP30s.

Anyone know of a solution?

Thanks ...

Yee haa!

590 posts

247 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
yeah, it's a pain in the arse isn't it? Unless you have a particularly good broker insure both motors with the same company that will mirror no claims. elephant/admiral is one good example, i'm sure there are others out there that will do it.

NathanK

80 posts

253 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
Careful .. on admirals multi car policy they require a separate No Claims for each of the cars on it.. just like having separate policies. The benefit is the lower costs around having one single policy (less admin for them etc), and not only needing one NCD for all the cars on the policy.

I swapped the NCD to the elise, and put the daily car on 0 NCD. Lots of insurance companies want new business and it wasn't vastly more.

rico

7,917 posts

286 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
What about getting a separate insurance policy for day-to-day car and using the NCB on the Lotus?

greg_pearson

3 posts

263 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
I had the same problem earlier this year and switched both cars to Elephant. I used the full NCD for the Elise and then they gave me an 'introductory' no claims on the policy for the Focus (only downside was they wouldn't allow me to protect the introductory no claims in the first year).

Both are completely separate policies so I will be free to move either or both of them elsewhere when renewal time comes round.

Hope this helps


Greg

111Rmeupbaby

Original Poster:

25 posts

242 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
Just had a quote from Norwich Union Direct who do both my existing cars, (me and the missus's) both of which have full NCD. They reckoned they would apply maximum discount and give the equivalent of full NCD to the Lotus without affecting the other two cars.

£800 fully comp, 6000 miles per year - me and missus to drive, no Tracker required but assuming standard CAT1 immobiliser (is that right?) on an 05 111R. £750 excess!! Myself age 34 with 6 scamera points and missus is 30 with 6 scamera points, no accidents/claims etc.

Said it was a group 20 car etc etc

What do you reckon chaps?

tom_allen

119 posts

262 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
111Rmeupbaby said:
£800 fully comp, 6000 miles per year - me and missus to drive, no Tracker required but assuming standard CAT1 immobiliser (is that right?) on an 05 111R. £750 excess!! Myself age 34 with 6 scamera points and missus is 30 with 6 scamera points, no accidents/claims etc.

Said it was a group 20 car etc etc

What do you reckon chaps?


Doesn't sound to bad, I'm 25 and pay £1001 exactly for my 99 111S, I had a bump last year though and lost some no claims so now I only have 3 years. I also have 2 cars insured with elephant. A Corsa for bombing to work in and the Elise for playtime. When I took out the policy for the Elise they said I couldn't use my existing no claims on it, after I said I'd go elsewhere they said, as I'm already a customer they would see what they could do and gave me 2 years NCB.

mike_knott

344 posts

255 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
111rmeupbaby,

I was in a similar position to you a couple of years ago when i bought an 18 month old 111S. I had over 5 years NCD with norwich union, and had tried just about every insurance company around with quotes ranging from £1000 to £4000 (clean licence, 32 years old, good post code, and transferring my NCD from my daily runaround to the Elise, which would have put the runaround insurance up to about £700, on a car that was worth about a tenner!).

I had just about come to terms with having to pay about a grand AND get a tracker fitted, when i tried AON (on the dealer's recommendation). They only charged about 800, and that was with no NCD and they didn't even need a tracker fitted.

If you haven't tried AON, give them a go, as it was well worth it for me. I am not saying AON will better any quote you have had, but you never know! (Although I believe they are not so good if your plan to use your car for commuting, or if it isnt garaged.)

And no, I don't work for them.

Mike...

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
lie

999

402 posts

243 months

Monday 25th September 2006
quotequote all
gooby said:
lie

What is ?

claypigeon60

841 posts

249 months

Tuesday 26th September 2006
quotequote all
I was in almost the same boat - also 34 (at the time), also 6 points, also had quite a lot of NCD on primary car ... went to Adrian Flux in the end and paid about ukp1200 for a 5,000 mile policy. I did try ringing other insurers but when I told them how much the AF quote was you could almost hear them blanching, followed by 'no way we can match that' ...

111Rmeupbaby

Original Poster:

25 posts

242 months

Tuesday 26th September 2006
quotequote all
so my Norwich quote seems good then - they don't want tracker or owt.

Does the 111R come with Thatcham 1 approved security as standard? Norwich have made an assumption according to something on their system that it does (I don't want to get caught out by taking their assumption that it does)

midas029

184 posts

253 months

Tuesday 26th September 2006
quotequote all
I put my other car through my Mum. She owns the car and the policy is in her name. Me and my girlfriend drive it third party through our own insurance. Costs me about £120 in insurance for it.

Hanslow

838 posts

276 months

Tuesday 26th September 2006
quotequote all
Looking at Direct Line's website they state the following:

Direct Line Website said:

Use your No Claims Discount on your second car

If you are the only person insured on your Direct Line car insurance policy and you purchase a second car that will only be driven by you, we will match your No Claim Discount on the policy for your new vehicle.

In addition we will give you a 10% discount on the additional vehicle followed by 5% every year there after.

More details on Direct Line car insurance.
Buy online today and receive a further 10% discount.


Would it be possible to insure yourself as sole driver on main vehicle, gain the bonus matching insuring yourself on the other vehicle, run that for a year, and then effectively have two full separate no claims discounts on both cars if / when deciding to switch to another more specialist place?

Linus27

152 posts

243 months

Tuesday 26th September 2006
quotequote all
Direct line insist that the Elise comes with a tracker. I am having the same problem as I want to insure my S1 Elise which I should be picking up tomorrow and I currently have insurance with Direct line. They want me to pay £300 plus for a tracker which I don't want to do. So now I have to cancel my insurance policy with them, lose my no claims discount that I get for this year and go with somebody else. However, the RAC quoted me £480 fully comp with my 6 years no claims bonus, £200 excess, up to 5000 miles and my 25 year old wife as named driver. I am also 37 years old. So looking at going with them.

111rmeupbaby

Original Poster:

25 posts

242 months

Tuesday 26th September 2006
quotequote all
Bizarrely, I called Norwich back to see what it would be to go from 6,000 miles per annum to 12,000 - the quote was the same, just over 800quid!

AON said no way they could get near that unles it was garaged (no) and NEVER used to commute to work (can't claim that as sometimes it would be and no point pretending otherwise)...

Beginning to think I have had a decent price from the 'Quote me as fed up with your cheesy quote me happy adverts' brigade????

mxdi

13,994 posts

280 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2006
quotequote all
Any more joy with NU quote? Direct Line mirror no claims if you are still deciding

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Wednesday 4th October 2006
quotequote all
tom_allen said:
111Rmeupbaby said:
£800 fully comp, 6000 miles per year - me and missus to drive, no Tracker required but assuming standard CAT1 immobiliser (is that right?) on an 05 111R. £750 excess!! Myself age 34 with 6 scamera points and missus is 30 with 6 scamera points, no accidents/claims etc.

Said it was a group 20 car etc etc

What do you reckon chaps?


Doesn't sound to bad, I'm 25 and pay £1001 exactly for my 99 111S, I had a bump last year though and lost some no claims so now I only have 3 years. I also have 2 cars insured with elephant. A Corsa for bombing to work in and the Elise for playtime. When I took out the policy for the Elise they said I couldn't use my existing no claims on it, after I said I'd go elsewhere they said, as I'm already a customer they would see what they could do and gave me 2 years NCB.


That's outrageous. My insurance is just over £800, 350 excess, proteted FNCB with unlimited mileage. Got it through First Alternative.

Don't have a tracker either; mind you depends on where you live _ plenty of chavs where you are? rolleyes

zebra

Edited by zebra on Wednesday 4th October 08:36

tricky 100

954 posts

273 months

Wednesday 4th October 2006
quotequote all
Elephant insure my exige as my second car and still give me my no claims bonus on both cars , just over £500 a year for the exige. Richard.

GRL

252 posts

255 months

Wednesday 4th October 2006
quotequote all
I'm with First Alternative too. 35 years old, garaged, sports exhaust - £550 p.a. Mind you, that was with a clean licence. I got a NIP through the post at the weekend - mobile video of me doing 81 in a 60 shoot cop I think I might need a remote garage door opener as winter is approaching hehe