Crash Protection in an Elise
Crash Protection in an Elise
Author
Discussion

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
Take a look on wreckedexotics.com for a good look at some very smashed up Elises.

The construction of the tub seems to keep the occupants in pretty good shape with the front and rear of the cars taking a lot of the impact. I'd not particularly want to be hit by a high vehicle though as it'd probably go over the top of you... that said, there are few cars that something like a 4x4, truck, or lorry wouldn't go over though are there?

TBH most Elise accidents seem to be due to driver error with the car departing backwards towards or through the scenery.

This was my first Elise, t-boned by a Fiesta at about 30mph at a junction:


PB9

175 posts

253 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
The elise is very safe.

Somebody I'm sure will post the normal link to the crashed elise site, dont have it to hand.

The elise was the first car to do the 30mph into offset wall crash and still be drivable.

I've written one off by taking it into a field via a twin posted sign as a ramp while spinning 360+ in the wet. Got out without a scratch, door was damaged and the glass had come in, wheels were very bent and some broken suspension. But nothing got into the passenger cell part, which seems to be the case for most crashed elises.

The tub can take a lot and you are sitting well within it with good side protection.

Dont get me wrong, I would hate to be in an elise if a big 4x4 hit me side on as I'm sure it would just drive over the car.

Overall I feel more safe in the elise than I did in my honda civic or saxo.

Would prefer to be in the elise than a TVR thats for sure.

-pete

speedyellow

2,533 posts

258 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
The Lotus chassis is extremely strong, has fantastic side front and rear protection as well as a level of roll over (easy to upgrade if the car doesn't have a motorsport roll hoop).

TVR... sorry to say have a very bad safety record... (sure to get flamed now), but the core strength is in the centre backbone chassis which is strong and made of triangulated tubes (hence the large tunnel in all TVR's, this is the chassis). The side impact is almost non existent, so you could end up crashed against the strong centre section of the chassis.

TVR compares well to a Lotus Esprit from crash protection, the Elise is a generation later.

Tam

135 posts

270 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
Can't find pictures of my poor 111R after my boyfriend hit the central reservation on the A14. He ended up spinning and hit the armco at least four times, and came to a rest with the front end buried under the armco but got out with a small bruise on his knee - car was a write off though

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
Tam said:
Can't find pictures of my poor 111R after my boyfriend hit the central reservation on the A14. He ended up spinning and hit the armco at least four times, and came to a rest with the front end buried under the armco but got out with a small bruise on his knee - car was a write off though


And what damage did you do to him when he told you he'd written off your car Tam?! hehe

PB9

175 posts

253 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
Actually I was very calm about it, I could see it comming and knew I had no control over location I was going to go. But when/if you get an elise you will understand just how much the car tells you, even when its about to crash...

As somebody has linked already, www.wreckedexotics.com/elise/

I've seen other links, I'm sure if you do a search you will find them. Or check www.seloc.org they probably have some more links.

After my crash I was driving a new elise before my insurance had processed the old car, and you will find many people who have broken elises and just gone and got another.

Once you have had your first elise, you will not wish to have a different car. I use mine as my only car and can think of no other car I would change for. Well I can but its a lotus 340R or if I had some extra cash an atom.

Driver training is a must, and getting out on track so you can use the speed and grip to full advantage and in relative safe conditions.

Do test drives, but do the TVR before the elise. Otherwise you might not even test the TVR !!!!

And if possible dont do a 10 minute test drive as the car is not warm. Ask for 30->45 minutes for the drive minimum. Some places just have a small insurance approved route, go do your test drives with somebody else.

Or better still try and blag a ride from an owner near you or on a track. Most track days are open to visitors, www.bookatrack.com or www.lotus-on-track.com/ probably finds you a lot of the uk track elises.

Most of all just get out and try them, you will have your answer.

-pete

PB9

175 posts

253 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
Actually talking about track days reminded me I need to book my next one...

Anyway I'm next at http://bookatrack.com/-p2?655&5 Donington park tuesday 17th october.

If you have the time come over and find me. Will be happy to take you/wife out on track, I'll be in a black S2 111S.

-pete

guytom

5 posts

253 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
I got hit from behind very hard in my S1 and ended up under the rear wheels of the 4X4 in front!!! The cars body was demolished but the 'tub' was strong and with stood the hit very well, obviously with out air bags and stuff like that you might get bruising etc but I was pleasantly surprised at how it took suck a big hit.

When i showed my friends the pics of the car afterwards they couldnt believe I only came out with a slightly stiff neck so I wouldnt really let those sort of worries put me off at all. I bought another as soon as my back was ok and I could get in!!

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
I looked into the safety side of the s1 in a big way as my job is all to do with safety. when i did some research & contacted lotus, all i was told that the only way of being 100% safe is NOT to have an accident! This is the honest truth what i was told & it didnt put me off in any way....

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
boobles said:
I looked into the safety side of the s1 in a big way as my job is all to do with safety. when i did some research & contacted lotus, all i was told that the only way of being 100% safe is NOT to have an accident! This is the honest truth what i was told & it didnt put me off in any way....


Same could be said of any car Boobles.

When I had my smack back in July (driven off the road by someone pulling out on me as I was overtaking!) I hit the kerbs side-on doing about 45mph. I walked out of the car cursing the wrong-doer and other than £4ks worth of subframe and suspension damage all was OK. The tub is amazingly strong and the great thing about the Elise is that even though I knew I was going to run out of road I was able to elect which way to hit the kerbs (front or side on).
I would rather be involved in a smack in an Elise than some of the Euroboxes from ten years ago (AX etc).

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
Yes but what im trying to say is lotus actually recommend that you dont have an accident because there isnt a great deal there to protect you. If i contacted renault who have a 5 star rating at euro ncap & asked them about safety, then im sure i would be on the blower for a very long time whilst they realed of all the safety devices that are in there cars.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
Fair comment Boobles. My S1 isn't equipped with any passive safety aids other than the very strong ally tub and front and rear crash structures - you have to rely on anticipation and the car's inherent nimbless to avoid accidents. That said there are still a lot of cars on the road that are little more than tin cans - I know what I'd rather be in.

Just thought I'd add that I'm not looking to disagree in principal with someone who works in safety. I know the liz isn't perfect but neither is it bad. I'm happy to sacfrifice the passive safety measures in order to gain the soul of the car.

Edited by TIPPER on Monday 9th October 20:40

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
Hey no arguement here mate, i was just pointing out what i was told. Still love the elise & wouldnt change it for any "safe" family car. thumbup

Tam

135 posts

270 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
[quote = Hollywood Wheels] And what damage did you do to him when he told you he'd written off your car Tam?! hehe [/quote]

I was relatively calm - when I saw the fibreglass (both clams) scattered across the road and the car down to the chassis and the police in attendance I thought the worst. Looking at the damage I thought they'd both be a write off

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 9th October 2006
quotequote all
finchy said:
thanks for all the info, real food for thought, as I said on tiv forum, sounds like the bigget issue is my limited ability behind the wheel

probably best to hire each car for a w'end to see if wanted to progress further

Would defo invest in some training, last qucik-ish rwd car I had was Cap-ri 2.8i "back in the day", not on a par with a liz, but certainly iffy in the wet especially when driving in slip on loafers, white sox's & listenig to Level 42 laugh

thanks again
Finchy


OMG! You are my geography teacher!!!

Mark Bailey

658 posts

252 months

Tuesday 10th October 2006
quotequote all
I think I can go one better than Tam, my now wife drove into the back of my S1 at the A12/A14 roundabout about 4 years ago.

I slowed to a stop as a Range Rover was on the roundabout, she didn't and hit me at about 50mph, this then sent me out in front of the Range Rover. It killed the fuel cut off leaving me in the middle of the roundabout, not one person stopped or slowed down so I got out and pushed it by hand across two lanes of fast traffic to the verge.

The Puma she assaulted me with had 4.5k of damage: front bumper, front lights, both wings, Bonnet, Rad, front panel. I expected my liz to be in lots of little bits but she hit me square on the exhaust which folded in, all the back of the rear clam splintered and then went back into shape. Repair cost was about £1400 and I got a new sports exhaust out of it!

The only 'injury' I got was from the seat top which smacked me in the right ear (as I was looking right), drew blood and gave me concussion for a few days.

My parents were always saying change it to something safer but its a tough little car. Some road tests said the best saftey feature of the car was its a ability to drive around an accident (clearly only if you see a bright yellow puma coming!)

PB9

175 posts

253 months

Tuesday 10th October 2006
quotequote all
Driver training is the key to any safe driving, no matter what car you drive.

The only difference is the elise is so pure that you know driver training is a good thing to do.

A lot of the new cars with all the full esp's and stuff to keep the poor drivers on the road just lower the quality of driving. I've seen so many people going way to fast and only keeping on the road because of the things the car is doing for them without them realising.

-pete

andi_p

346 posts

275 months

Tuesday 10th October 2006
quotequote all
I'm Tam's other (better) half and as said had a pretty nasty accident in the elise. One of the rear wheels lost traction and sent it into a spin, unfortunately it was very near the armco so I had no chance. Anyway walked away with nothing more than a bruised knee where it hit the steering column. However the car was wrecked. From the pictures it looks like anyone would be lucky to walk away but in reality despite the clams collapsing the chassis remained structurally sound to protect the driver/passenger. They are way safer than you would think.

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Tuesday 10th October 2006
quotequote all
Techincally a TVR is safer than Elise, as the TVR will have broken down on your drive.

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all

An Elise is as safe as the person behind the steering wheel.......

Defensive driving will count for 99% of how safe you are on the road. Do some driver training (both Walshy days and 'road' days), and stick to some golden rules...

1. Drive with your headlights on, ALL the time...
2. NEVER undertake any vehicle. If you are beside a HGV on a roundabout, stick to his rear offside.
3. Always leave a BIG gap when in soild or slow moving traffic, ie, be able to see where the tyres of the car in front touch the roadway ("Tyres and Tarmac" as I was taught on my Advanced course...)
4. DO NOT get involved in ANY kind of 'Road Rage' incident.
5. Drive where any driver ahead can see you clearly in their mirrors, so that will either be near to the kerb or against the centre line depending on how far in/out the car ahead is.
6. ALWAYS expect other drivers to do the most stupid or dangerous thing possible.
7. Don't be afraid to sound the horn if you feel it would benefit another driver. It's too often looked upon as an aggressive act, but no harm in a quick beep then a 'thank you' gesture when your presence is acknowledged...