Tower Bridge London
Author
Discussion

JohnSW20

Original Poster:

886 posts

267 months

Tuesday 10th October 2006
quotequote all
Hi All,

I travel over the bridge twice a day and there are the average speed scam-eras, the speed limit is 20; but everyone seems to be going quicker if I go 20 MPH I have someone on my bumper pushing me.

Does anyone know if they are working.

Cheers

John

puggit

49,821 posts

278 months

Tuesday 10th October 2006
quotequote all
I've certainly read of enough people with tickets over time yes

jasandjules

72,626 posts

259 months

Tuesday 10th October 2006
quotequote all
I would imagine they are working as the volume of traffic would them profitable.

AdvocatusDiaboli

2,278 posts

261 months

Tuesday 10th October 2006
quotequote all
Oh it works alright. Girlfriend got caught "breaking the law" at 3am last doing 28.

gently bentley

964 posts

241 months

Tuesday 10th October 2006
quotequote all
I used to barracked in HM Tower of London. Its a great place so why would anybody want to drive faster than 20mph? Enjoy the view!

muffles

516 posts

252 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
i guess they must be forward-facing cameras? i used to travel over tower bridge on my way to work (bike) before i decided to go the rotherhithe tunnel way...i never spotted any speed cameras, only the congestion charge ones! where are they?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

247 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
muffles said:
i guess they must be forward-facing cameras? i used to travel over tower bridge on my way to work (bike) before i decided to go the rotherhithe tunnel way...i never spotted any speed cameras, only the congestion charge ones! where are they?


They are SPECS cameras & they double up with loops in the surface to also prosecute over weight vehicles.

smeggy

3,241 posts

269 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
gently bentley said:
I used to barracked in HM Tower of London. Its a great place so why would anybody want to drive faster than 20mph? Enjoy the view!

So long as you keep your eyes on the road ahead!

smeggy

3,241 posts

269 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
They are SPECS cameras & they double up with loops in the surface to also prosecute over weight vehicles.

Interesting. Can you confirm that VH?

Being the great engineer that I am, I wouldn't have thought that induction loops could infer the mass, conductive loop or otherwise, of a vehicle with any significant precision and accuracy.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

247 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
smeggy said:
vonhosen said:
They are SPECS cameras & they double up with loops in the surface to also prosecute over weight vehicles.

Interesting. Can you confirm that VH?

Being the great engineer that I am, I wouldn't have thought that induction loops could infer the mass, conductive loop or otherwise, of a vehicle with any significant precision and accuracy.


There you go

deva link

26,934 posts

275 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
smeggy said:

Being the great engineer that I am, I wouldn't have thought that induction loops could infer the mass, conductive loop or otherwise, of a vehicle with any significant precision and accuracy.

Going back 20 yrs now, I used to have a customer based in Nottingham who made such systems - although I don't remember exactly how they worked, they could weigh vehicles at motorway speeds. It was quite tricky to do it at speed then, but electronics has come on a long way since.

xxxxxxrich

188 posts

275 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
smeggy said:
vonhosen said:
They are SPECS cameras & they double up with loops in the surface to also prosecute over weight vehicles.

Interesting. Can you confirm that VH?

Being the great engineer that I am, I wouldn't have thought that induction loops could infer the mass, conductive loop or otherwise, of a vehicle with any significant precision and accuracy.


I have often wondered if they would do this. The way I would imagine it to work is when the truck or whatever passes over the loop it creates some sort of pattern that will be possibly unique to a type of vechicle and they can tell what type of vechicle it is passing over rather than the weight of it. This is how the coin mech in a vending machine works, someone puts thousands of each type of coin in and records them as each denomination. The coin mech can then tell what type of coin is passing through.
I would imagine it is possible to build up some sort of database of vechicles too.

turbobloke

117,331 posts

290 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
If the loops are piezoelectric strips rather than inductive detectors then weight activation would be possible, but neither I nor the ABD know whether the loops mentioned are used for the purpose suggested. Interested to see what emerges!

As to the 20 mph limit, we discovered that it's there to protect the bridge structure, but then there's the weight limit so it's less justifiable. Enquiries we've made get responses which don't quite know why it's still there or whether it should stay or go. But it's definitely still active in terms of detection as otehrs have pointed out.

smeggy

3,241 posts

269 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
smeggy said:
vonhosen said:
They are SPECS cameras & they double up with loops in the surface to also prosecute over weight vehicles.

Interesting. Can you confirm that VH?

Being the great engineer that I am, I wouldn't have thought that induction loops could infer the mass, conductive loop or otherwise, of a vehicle with any significant precision and accuracy.


There you go

Thank you.

However, following some research I'm now convinced that induction loops do not determine the mass of a vehicle. The induction loop detects vehicle presence (just like they always have done); use of ‘Class 1’ piezo electric sensors enable weigh-in-motion (a gold star to turbobloke).

I realise I'm probably being pedantic but there you go.

smeggy

3,241 posts

269 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
deva link said:
Going back 20 yrs now, I used to have a customer based in Nottingham who made such systems - although I don't remember exactly how they worked, they could weigh vehicles at motorway speeds. It was quite tricky to do it at speed then, but electronics has come on a long way since.

You can’t use induction loops to measure metallic mass. Different configurations of the same conductive mass (spherical or looped, height, offset from centre, conductivity of metal) will result with different reactance of the coil. No amount of clever elec-trickery can compensate.

peaktorque

1,807 posts

241 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
Bet the over-loaded buses that travel over the bridge don't get penalised. Use the bridge all the time and the speed camaras are not painted the familiar yellow, they are black, guess that means the profits go to the treasurey, rather than lining plods pocket.

deva link

26,934 posts

275 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
smeggy said:
deva link said:
Going back 20 yrs now, I used to have a customer based in Nottingham who made such systems - although I don't remember exactly how they worked, they could weigh vehicles at motorway speeds. It was quite tricky to do it at speed then, but electronics has come on a long way since.

You can’t use induction loops to measure metallic mass. Different configurations of the same conductive mass (spherical or looped, height, offset from centre, conductivity of metal) will result with different reactance of the coil. No amount of clever elec-trickery can compensate.

The link that VH provided doesn't actually say they weigh the vehicles - merely that they take all sorts of other readings and then check the vehicle classification using ANPR. So it could be that they're simply looking for max laden/unladen weight (or whatever) figures from the DVLA database and they prosecute based on those.

smeggy

3,241 posts

269 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
deva link said:
The link that VH provided doesn't actually say they weigh the vehicles - merely that they take all sorts of other readings and then check the vehicle classification using ANPR. So it could be that they're simply looking for max laden/unladen weight (or whatever) figures from the DVLA database and they prosecute based on those.

Yes that could well be; however, given that the link stated that piezo-electric sensors are used within the Weight Limit Enforcement system I can only conclude these sensors are used to directly measure weight - speed is done by other means, so what else could these sensors be used for?

Note, traffic systems exist which use piezo sensors for weigh-in-motion stations.
I assume the induction loops are used to identify the beginning and end of vehicles (i.e. which axles belong to a vehicle mass).

deva link

26,934 posts

275 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
smeggy said:
deva link said:
The link that VH provided doesn't actually say they weigh the vehicles - merely that they take all sorts of other readings and then check the vehicle classification using ANPR. So it could be that they're simply looking for max laden/unladen weight (or whatever) figures from the DVLA database and they prosecute based on those.

Yes that could well be; however, given that the link stated that piezo-electric sensors are used within the Weight Limit Enforcement system I can only conclude these sensors are used to directly measure weight - speed is done by other means, so what else could these sensors be used for?

It mentions height is measured. Ultrasound usually uses piezo-electric sensors. Could also be used for axle counting.

stevieb

5,253 posts

297 months

Wednesday 11th October 2006
quotequote all
Inductive loops are used to give the type of classification of vehicle. if the sensor deems the vehicle over a certain magnetic signature it will send a signal to the camera to take a picture.

ANPR is then used to cross check with the DVLA and only then a a NIP will be issued if the DVLA records show that the weight limit was exceeded.