Dull S1 Elise questions
Discussion
Hi,
I'm starting to seriously consider buying an earlyish S1 Elise over the winter. I'm in the process of reading through most of the threads on here, but have two some what dull questions.
Do they leak, and would a hardtop cure this at all. Am I right in thinking the hood design changed throughout the production run?
For a standard early S1, is it generally worth getting it serviced at main dealers, or indy specialists, or can I get away competent local garages?
Thanks
I'm starting to seriously consider buying an earlyish S1 Elise over the winter. I'm in the process of reading through most of the threads on here, but have two some what dull questions.
Do they leak, and would a hardtop cure this at all. Am I right in thinking the hood design changed throughout the production run?
For a standard early S1, is it generally worth getting it serviced at main dealers, or indy specialists, or can I get away competent local garages?
Thanks
Some cars leak more than others, this is down to 3 main things in my experiance.
1) The condition of the roof, in specific when it was last treated with a barrier product.
2) How well the windows and roof are adjusted to fit.
3) Which roof you have, the early S1 roof's are not as good as the later ones, they changed late 98 if I remember correctly.
Re Servicing most experianced folks use a specialist they trust to do the work, there are several around. Sinclaires, Maidstone sports car, Plans motor sport, horison, steve williams to name a few.
There is also loads to read over on www.seloc.org and what is now becoming a pretty good wiki.
1) The condition of the roof, in specific when it was last treated with a barrier product.
2) How well the windows and roof are adjusted to fit.
3) Which roof you have, the early S1 roof's are not as good as the later ones, they changed late 98 if I remember correctly.
Re Servicing most experianced folks use a specialist they trust to do the work, there are several around. Sinclaires, Maidstone sports car, Plans motor sport, horison, steve williams to name a few.
There is also loads to read over on www.seloc.org and what is now becoming a pretty good wiki.
Try:
www.elise-faq.info/content/buying/index.php
Also:
www.elises.co.uk/index.html
Re servicing IMHO the Local Specailist is the best place to go.
Hardtop is good for the winter when it gets really cold. The soft top is thin and heat drains out on cold days, the Hardtop keeps the heat in.
The car is basic so you donot get creature comforts and do not expect it to be quite in the cabin.
www.elise-faq.info/content/buying/index.php
Also:
www.elises.co.uk/index.html
Re servicing IMHO the Local Specailist is the best place to go.
Hardtop is good for the winter when it gets really cold. The soft top is thin and heat drains out on cold days, the Hardtop keeps the heat in.
The car is basic so you donot get creature comforts and do not expect it to be quite in the cabin.
Edited by garydvo on Thursday 12th October 12:30
black_potato said:
Some cars leak more than others, this is down to 3 main things in my experiance.
1) The condition of the roof, in specific when it was last treated with a barrier product.
2) How well the windows and roof are adjusted to fit.
3) Which roof you have, the early S1 roof's are not as good as the later ones, they changed late 98 if I remember correctly.
Re Servicing most experianced folks use a specialist they trust to do the work, there are several around. Sinclaires, Maidstone sports car, Plans motor sport, horison, steve williams to name a few.
There is also loads to read over on www.seloc.org and what is now becoming a pretty good wiki.
1) The condition of the roof, in specific when it was last treated with a barrier product.
2) How well the windows and roof are adjusted to fit.
3) Which roof you have, the early S1 roof's are not as good as the later ones, they changed late 98 if I remember correctly.
Re Servicing most experianced folks use a specialist they trust to do the work, there are several around. Sinclaires, Maidstone sports car, Plans motor sport, horison, steve williams to name a few.
There is also loads to read over on www.seloc.org and what is now becoming a pretty good wiki.
I haven't ever treated my roof (although Ido plan to at some point splash some renovo on it) and I have found the canvass to be absolutely watertight.
the only issue I have is that you have to fit the roof perfectly correctly otherwise it will leak at the A pillar...in a very heavy storm the water will drain through the doors and may well collect at the bottom of the door seals - but you aren't going to get wet as the sill is a good 6" tall
the hardtop is total crap IMHO as it doesn't meet the window tops and therefore does not seal properly. the result is water pissing through when it rains - something you do not get with the soft top as it has a sort of lip or gutttering running the length of it where it meets the windows which stops this problem.
the only benefit to the harptop as far as I can see (apart from better security although I wouldn't leave it anywhere dodgy) is that it looks fcking cool!
- if in doubt, check profile
i've actually got my hard top for sale in the classifieds...but it's a half hearted sale as it does look so damn good with it on!
minimax said:
black_potato said:
Some cars leak more than others, this is down to 3 main things in my experiance.
1) The condition of the roof, in specific when it was last treated with a barrier product.
2) How well the windows and roof are adjusted to fit.
3) Which roof you have, the early S1 roof's are not as good as the later ones, they changed late 98 if I remember correctly.
Re Servicing most experianced folks use a specialist they trust to do the work, there are several around. Sinclaires, Maidstone sports car, Plans motor sport, horison, steve williams to name a few.
There is also loads to read over on www.seloc.org and what is now becoming a pretty good wiki.
1) The condition of the roof, in specific when it was last treated with a barrier product.
2) How well the windows and roof are adjusted to fit.
3) Which roof you have, the early S1 roof's are not as good as the later ones, they changed late 98 if I remember correctly.
Re Servicing most experianced folks use a specialist they trust to do the work, there are several around. Sinclaires, Maidstone sports car, Plans motor sport, horison, steve williams to name a few.
There is also loads to read over on www.seloc.org and what is now becoming a pretty good wiki.
I haven't ever treated my roof (although Ido plan to at some point splash some renovo on it) and I have found the canvass to be absolutely watertight.
the only issue I have is that you have to fit the roof perfectly correctly otherwise it will leak at the A pillar...in a very heavy storm the water will drain through the doors and may well collect at the bottom of the door seals - but you aren't going to get wet as the sill is a good 6" tall
the hardtop is total crap IMHO as it doesn't meet the window tops and therefore does not seal properly. the result is water pissing through when it rains - something you do not get with the soft top as it has a sort of lip or gutttering running the length of it where it meets the windows which stops this problem.
the only benefit to the harptop as far as I can see (apart from better security although I wouldn't leave it anywhere dodgy) is that it looks fcking cool!
- if in doubt, check profile
i've actually got my hard top for sale in the classifieds...but it's a half hearted sale as it does look so damn good with it on!
The side window height needs adjusting when fitting the hardtop and vis versa when you go to the soft top. I read this on Seloc, never bothered though. My hardtop is water tight the soft top just lets the water in.
My S1 leaked stacks when I bought it. I developed a kit of seals that are applied to the actual roof and door seals etc. Its now totally rain proof, and even when jetwashing the car, only a couple of drops get in. Some are worse than others but there was a later roof design which improved this. Mine already had this and was still usless. And because I didnt have a garage, I had to cure the leak problem.
sato said:
The reason for the question about the leaking roof is that I don't have access to a garage.
To switch the question slightly, is it a problem if water does get in? The interior appears very utilitatian so I'm guessing that will be ok, but will it effect the electrics?
To switch the question slightly, is it a problem if water does get in? The interior appears very utilitatian so I'm guessing that will be ok, but will it effect the electrics?
Not from my experience......had about 10mm of water in the footwells once after an extended driving session in heavy rain and no roof.
Had puddles developing in the bowl of the dash before and no problems with electrics.
The standard electrics seem robust to water (not sure if that is by design or fluke). I don't have a radio / CD fitted so not sure how that would stand up to a drenching.
Seats can just be wipped dry (or the cushions removed and dried over night if required - as per 135 seats). The only problem I get is that the seat belts retain water in the weave and that takes a day or two to dry out.
Water can get through the spark plug cover on the engine. The solution is to spary WD40 over the plugs and vasaline on the spark plug cover which then keeps it water tight.
Re the windows try this on Elise FAQ:
www.elise-faq.info/content/windows/index.php
Gary
Re the windows try this on Elise FAQ:
www.elise-faq.info/content/windows/index.php
Gary
sato said:
The reason for the question about the leaking roof is that I don't have access to a garage.
To switch the question slightly, is it a problem if water does get in? The interior appears very utilitatian so I'm guessing that will be ok, but will it effect the electrics?
To switch the question slightly, is it a problem if water does get in? The interior appears very utilitatian so I'm guessing that will be ok, but will it effect the electrics?
I used mine as my only car, daily driver for a few years no problem at all.
As said above, hardtops require window adjustment, then they are pretty good.
Water on the inside is no problem at all. That said there is a known problem with corrosion in the footwells caused by dampness trapped under the rubber mats. This should be resolved by refixing the mats so the undersides can breath & dry, but lots of water pouring in regularly and sitting under the mats is probably not good in the long term. There is a Lotus fix for cars with more severe corrosion (pitting) of the ali footwell panel.
I have often driven my car though heavy rain, or simply not bothered to put the roof on when its sitting if it doesn't look like getting to badly soaked.
Get a shower cap. This is a very quick fitting lightweight cover that goes over the cockpit. It can be used by itself as a much quicker & easier way to keep the rain out than putting the softtop up & down (can't drive with it on though)
It can be put on by itself or over the top of the softtop/hardtop then it;
Totally prevents leaks as it comes down past the sealing points like the top of the A pillar
Keeps the softtop dry so when you take it off in the morning you don't have to put a wet softop in the boot.
Keeps the ice from forming on the windscreen in winter.
Keeps the car from baking in the summer as it covers the glass.
The Eliseparts.com one is here.
www.eliseparts.com/shop/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=140&products_id=512
There are also alternatives.
garydvo said:
Water can get through the spark plug cover on the engine. The solution is to spary WD40 over the plugs and vasaline on the spark plug cover which then keeps it water tight.
Re the windows try this on Elise FAQ:
www.elise-faq.info/content/windows/index.php
Gary
Re the windows try this on Elise FAQ:
www.elise-faq.info/content/windows/index.php
Gary
spot on with that link, perfect!
...don't think i'm going to sell my hard top now!
Agree with pretty much all that has been said above. My car is a 99 S1 and I've found if I'm lazy fitting the roof it will leak. However 30 seconds spent carefully positioning the leading edge means my car stays pretty dry - even the recent monsoons have seen only a few drops in the car in the morning.
Mine has lived on the drive for the past 2 1/2 years with no problems whatsoever. As above, spend a little time fitting the roof and you should have no significant leaks. I have a hardtop, looks great on but has lived in the garage since I owned the car; 2 reasons - 1. My soft top doesn't leak too much, 2. Can't whip the hard top off for the run home if the weather turns out nice. As for servicing, it is a simple car (fiddly but simple) so any good mechanic will be able to service; a few quid off ebay will get you a workshop manual if you don't live near any of the main independents.
At the end of the day the only thing that I've regreted about Elise ownership is the years since it was introduced when I didn't own one.
At the end of the day the only thing that I've regreted about Elise ownership is the years since it was introduced when I didn't own one.
turnamere said:
At the end of the day the only thing that I've regreted about Elise ownership is the years since it was introduced when I didn't own one.
incidentally on your point re: hardtop ownership and use...today I put my hardtop on for the first time in months...and it's unseasonably warm and bright sunshine/blue skies!

Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




oh well 