Advantages
Author
Discussion

ibb

Original Poster:

24 posts

274 months

Saturday 14th October 2006
quotequote all
Going to replace my standard s1 tyres 185 front and 205 rear, is there any advantges in fitting 195 front and 215/225 rear
regards

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Saturday 14th October 2006
quotequote all
Hi ibb. In a word, Yes. Bit of explanation though.
First I'll assume your running Pirelli P-zeros at the mo: chuck 'em. Never really worked that well on the Elise as they were designed for a heavier type of car. That's why the car can understeer so easily in the wet and snap into oversteer easily too and why the S1 got a reputation for being 'tricky'. Also when Lotus conceived the Elise they weren't in a position to get tyres developed specifically for the car so they had to pick something 'off the shelf'.
Since then a tyre has been specifically developed for the Elise - Yokohama Neovo Advan LTS available from Lotus dealers and some specialist. The LTS part of the moniker is important - it specifies the tyre developed soley for the S1 and comes in 195/50 fronts and 225/45 rears.
Excellent alternatives more widely available (and cheaper) are the BF Goodrich G force profiler and Toyo T1-R. Both in above sizes.
The Goodriches are extremely popular amonst the Seloc fraternity with the Toyos having some fans but also coming in for a bit of stick due to a possible issue with sidewall flexibility.
I swopped to the Goodrich's from Pirellis a few months ago and have been amazed by the improvement. Grip, particularly in the wet, is far, far better and on the limit they feel much more progressive. Initially I thought that some of the steering feel had gone but I soon got used to it and the car still has far better steering than any other car I've ever driven (possible exception being my old beloved '78 Alfasud). The turn-in also felt a little slower but this may also have been linked to the feel issue. I've since had a full suspension geo (well worth having done BTW) and discussed this with the garage. Result - better feel, almost agressive turn-in, and a fantastic feeling of the car being planted and stable at all times. She's probably better than when she left the factory.
Don't have any experience of the Toyos on the Elise but I have fitted them all round to my MG ZT this year and have been very impressed. Bear in mind though that the ZT is a very different type of car. I still fitted the Goodrichs to my Elise despite my ZT experience.
One more thing. Order of preference is probably the Yokohamas followed by Goodrich then Toyos.
And finally..... Just remembered the Yokohama have recently introduced a new tyre, the C-Drive LTS in 185 and 205 sizes, for the S1. Don't know anything about them. Don't think anybody on here or Seloic has fitted 'em yet.
Hope that helps.