best free firewall for windows XP?
best free firewall for windows XP?
Author
Discussion

_deano

Original Poster:

7,414 posts

284 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
I've just rebuilt me PC and instead of putting Norton's Personal Firewall back on there, which i find slow and bloated, is there a free personal firewall that does what it says on the tin and is small a quick, which doesn't take up much memory?
I've also swtich over to AVG anitvirus and found that this freebie is better cmopared to the big 2.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
Zonelabs

GregE240

10,857 posts

298 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
Think AVG do a free firewall product as well?

mcflurry

9,191 posts

284 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
Zonelabs

ditto

AdvocatusDiaboli

2,278 posts

262 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
Sygate do a fantastic product. I found zonealarm to sometimes f up things...

annodomini2

6,974 posts

282 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
mcflurry said:
Plotloss said:
Zonelabs

ditto


Yup

gizard

2,272 posts

314 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
AdvocatusDiaboli said:
Sygate do a fantastic product. I found zonealarm to sometimes f up things...

Zonelabs messes up wireless connectivity good and proper!!!!

pdV6

16,442 posts

292 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
annodomini2 said:
mcflurry said:
Plotloss said:
Zonelabs

ditto


Yup

yes

AdvocatusDiaboli

2,278 posts

262 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
gizard said:
AdvocatusDiaboli said:
Sygate do a fantastic product. I found zonealarm to sometimes f up things...

Zonelabs messes up wireless connectivity good and proper!!!!


Glad someone agrees! Both great products, I used ZA for 2 years till it went AWOL. Have used sygate since, absolutely painless...till now!

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
Windows XP SP2 has a built-in firewall. It's rather basic but does what it says on the tin.

[k]ar|

963 posts

277 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
Sunbelt-Kerio Personal Firewall

[k]

madras

329 posts

240 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
use the firewall in xp sp2. AV - AVG free.

che6mw

2,560 posts

256 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
Windows XP SP2 has a built-in firewall. It's rather basic but does what it says on the tin.


out of interest how does Windows own flavour of protection stack up with the free versions out there ? Being Microsoft I'm imagining 9/10 for market share, 1/10 for ability ?

Edited by che6mw on Friday 24th November 22:17

madras

329 posts

240 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
no, it's actually pretty good. IMO.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
che6mw said:
ThePassenger said:
Windows XP SP2 has a built-in firewall. It's rather basic but does what it says on the tin.


out of interest how does Windows own flavour of protection stack up with the free versions out there ? Being Microsoft I'm imagining 9/10 for market share, 1/10 for ability ?

Edited by che6mw on Friday 24th November 22:17


It's very basic. It has no understanding of secure/unsecure network works, and simply does basic port blocking based on applications (i.e. if you install Apache it will ask if Apache can be allowed access). However, as long as you aren't surfing dodgy sites it's more than enough for basic internet stuff (it'll stop viruses and messenger spam).

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Friday 24th November 2006
quotequote all
Best free firewall is the one that comes in the router when you throw the USB thing away. IMHO.

Its invulnerable to user cockup and blocks most inboudn only attacks, which is 80% of everything. Add the XP firewall to that, and its pretty much parent proof.

_deano

Original Poster:

7,414 posts

284 months

Saturday 25th November 2006
quotequote all
madras said:
use the firewall in xp sp2. AV - AVG free.


this is my setup at the moment and i have a netgear router with built in firewall. But i feel that i need some extra protection as i want to download some files from bit-torret.

hornet

6,333 posts

281 months

Saturday 25th November 2006
quotequote all
I've been using Comodo of late - seems to be getting good reviews.

[k]ar|

963 posts

277 months

Saturday 25th November 2006
quotequote all
The other issue with the XP Pro in-built firewall, as I understand it, is that it won't block outgoing connections *at all*. Therefore, if you do happen to encounter any malware, there would be nothing to stop it connecting out to other machine or to "phone home".

My own system protection consists of my D-Link router with NAT and built-in firewall, as well as Sunbelt Kerio Personal Firewall for anything else that gets through. I'm generally pretty careful with emails and websites and deliberately don't use IE or Outlook. I only have a rudimentary free AV scanner which I run from time to time.

You can see how visible your system is to the rest of the 'net by using the free ShieldsUp service here...

https://www.grc.com/x/ne.dll?bh0bkyd2

[k]

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Sunday 26th November 2006
quotequote all
[quote=kar|]The other issue with the XP Pro in-built firewall, as I understand it, is that it won't block outgoing connections *at all*. Therefore, if you do happen to encounter any malware, there would be nothing to stop it connecting out to other machine or to "phone home". [/quote]

It will and it won't.

Often when you install something that the firewall doesn't know about (i.e. Apache, a game, etc.) it will prompt for what you want to do (block this time, keep blocking and never prompt again, don't block) although it won't do that with any system services; so if something gets in to the system and pretends to be say svchost.exe then it's off and running.
But then again, even ZoneAlarm would fall for that if you've already given the regular generic Win32 version permission to escape.


Edited by ThePassenger on Sunday 26th November 16:51