Best new battery?
Best new battery?
Author
Discussion

Duke Thrust

Original Poster:

1,680 posts

269 months

Thursday 25th January 2007
quotequote all
I think I might have to splash out on a new battery - fine until this really cold spell, temperature gets close to freezing and the battery chugs the engine over for a bit then dies.

Can anyone recommend a decent replacement?


Steve_T

6,356 posts

302 months

Thursday 25th January 2007
quotequote all
Cheapest option I've found are Bosch batteries at Costco in reading - £47 + VAT. I've been down the same path with my bike, where a crap battery can mean a dead starter clutch at the cost of £600. I found an Odyssey battery for the bike (£90 delivered but US Military spec versus about £70 for a normal one). In a car size they're very expensive (£165 for a battery suitable for an Aston Martin). There's also Optima batteries as a possible.

Steve.

Duke Thrust

Original Poster:

1,680 posts

269 months

Thursday 25th January 2007
quotequote all
That's a good idea, I'll be one junction down from CostCo tomorrow so will pop in.

Ratten

223 posts

253 months

Thursday 25th January 2007
quotequote all
Other option is to grab one of the calcium ones from Halfrauds. 4 year guarantee. think they're about 70 - 80 quid, but i expect to get my full use of it...

Steve_T

6,356 posts

302 months

Thursday 25th January 2007
quotequote all
Ratten said:
Other option is to grab one of the calcium ones from Halfrauds. 4 year guarantee. think they're about 70 - 80 quid, but i expect to get my full use of it...


We've got one in the regular motor and it's been fine. Strong enough to help spin the Cerb over when needed too. I couldn't find one in the necessary size when I looked though.

Cyclone1

2,614 posts

276 months

Thursday 25th January 2007
quotequote all
Halfords is an 072 type.

esso

1,849 posts

247 months

Thursday 25th January 2007
quotequote all
Banner battery-£70-whatever make you buy make sure the external dimensions are EXACTLY the same as the one in the car,i first bought a 072 battery from Halfords and it was too tall,didnt fit in the aperture in the wing.

trackcar

6,453 posts

256 months

Thursday 25th January 2007
quotequote all
Steve_T said:
Cheapest option I've found are Bosch batteries at Costco in reading - £47 + VAT. I've been down the same path with my bike, where a crap battery can mean a dead starter clutch at the cost of £600. I found an Odyssey battery for the bike (£90 delivered but US Military spec versus about £70 for a normal one). In a car size they're very expensive (£165 for a battery suitable for an Aston Martin). There's also Optima batteries as a possible.

Steve.




600 pounds for a starter? someone's having your pants down big style.

Cyclone1

2,614 posts

276 months

Friday 26th January 2007
quotequote all
esso said:
first bought a 072 battery from Halfords and it was too tall,didnt fit in the aperture in the wing.


I've had three 072s from Halfords and never had a problem with fitting. The current design definitely fits.

Jules.

nadirv8

139 posts

245 months

Friday 26th January 2007
quotequote all
I'd also recommend Halfrauds. Over the xmas didnt drive the Cerb for 2 weeks and accedently left the cabin light on. Since getting in, trickle charging for 1 day(which isn't actually enough) it started and charged up.Now its still as powerful as new. Also, if you run into problems Halfords do a free replacement batt if it is less than 3 yrs old... cashback!

Steve_T

6,356 posts

302 months

Friday 26th January 2007
quotequote all
trackcar said:
Steve_T said:
Cheapest option I've found are Bosch batteries at Costco in reading - £47 + VAT. I've been down the same path with my bike, where a crap battery can mean a dead starter clutch at the cost of £600. I found an Odyssey battery for the bike (£90 delivered but US Military spec versus about £70 for a normal one). In a car size they're very expensive (£165 for a battery suitable for an Aston Martin). There's also Optima batteries as a possible.

Steve.




600 pounds for a starter? someone's having your pants down big style.


No Joolz, not the starter motor, the sprag clutch, which sits between the starter motor and the crank. The story goes as follows. The battery starts dying, the starter motor kicks and it fooks the sprag clutch. No one will sell you the parts you need from a secondhand lump and new from a dealer the parts are allegedly £600. It's a bit of a joke when I've seen complete motors on ebay with only 4k on them for £750 and no takers. Anyway, my point was a decent battery is worth it, even it if seems a bit dear. What I'm wondering is a similar uprated battery actually be worth it in the Cerb, or is it a waste of cash?

Steve.

Cyclone1

2,614 posts

276 months

Friday 26th January 2007
quotequote all
Steve_T said:
What I'm wondering is a similar uprated battery actually be worth it in the Cerb, or is it a waste of cash?

Steve.


I think it's definitely worth investing in an uprated battery than the one that is currently recommended for the Cerb. Had I not had the three year warranty through Halfords then I would have definitely looked elsewhere for a higher rated battery. Interestingly when Halfords realised that I was on my 3rd battery FOC in three years they had a look to see if they could find an uprated one in their range that would fit the Cerb, but unfortunately they didn't have one.

Duke Thrust

Original Poster:

1,680 posts

269 months

Friday 26th January 2007
quotequote all
Just bought a battery from CostCo - they listed the Cerb in their charts so I got the specified battery.

Looks on the tall side to me, will keep you all posted. (Good price though, 39 quid for the top spec)

Editied to say it's a Bosch


Edited by Duke Thrust on Friday 26th January 14:34

Steve_T

6,356 posts

302 months

Friday 26th January 2007
quotequote all
This is apparently an extreme 4x4 owners favourite, although I don't know if it would fit. Should cope with the starter though with 825CCA!

Julian64

14,325 posts

284 months

Friday 26th January 2007
quotequote all
Steve_T said:
trackcar said:
Steve_T said:
Cheapest option I've found are Bosch batteries at Costco in reading - £47 + VAT. I've been down the same path with my bike, where a crap battery can mean a dead starter clutch at the cost of £600. I found an Odyssey battery for the bike (£90 delivered but US Military spec versus about £70 for a normal one). In a car size they're very expensive (£165 for a battery suitable for an Aston Martin). There's also Optima batteries as a possible.

Steve.




600 pounds for a starter? someone's having your pants down big style.


No Joolz, not the starter motor, the sprag clutch, which sits between the starter motor and the crank. The story goes as follows. The battery starts dying, the starter motor kicks and it fooks the sprag clutch. No one will sell you the parts you need from a secondhand lump and new from a dealer the parts are allegedly £600. It's a bit of a joke when I've seen complete motors on ebay with only 4k on them for £750 and no takers. Anyway, my point was a decent battery is worth it, even it if seems a bit dear. What I'm wondering is a similar uprated battery actually be worth it in the Cerb, or is it a waste of cash?

Steve.


I assume the bit that's actually got is a stripped cog. For much less than that you could hardface, or even get a local engineering firm to build one out of adamantium. I've never heard of an adamantium cog failing.

Steve_T

6,356 posts

302 months

Friday 26th January 2007
quotequote all
Hmmmm ... Adamantium you say scratchchin

Duke Thrust

Original Poster:

1,680 posts

269 months

Monday 29th January 2007
quotequote all
Okay, can confirm that the Bosch battery doesn't fit. Only out by a few mm but it's just too tall.

Had to by a Halfords one at twice the price - grr!

Steve_T

6,356 posts

302 months

Monday 29th January 2007
quotequote all
When you say too tall, too tall to get over the nut welded to the plate, or too tall to get in the box at all?

Duke Thrust

Original Poster:

1,680 posts

269 months

Monday 29th January 2007
quotequote all
Too tall to fit in the wing, real shame as it looks like a decent bit of kit.

pia1361

228 posts

244 months

Tuesday 21st August 2007
quotequote all
hello

as my battery is on the way out i bought a type 072 from Halfords last night but have realised that the terminals arent recessed into the battery itself whereas i have a feeling that they are on the one thats fitted at the moment.

Can someone reassure me that i've bought the right one ?

Cheers smile

John