Larini or TBular on an S2 K series?
Larini or TBular on an S2 K series?
Author
Discussion

abz 7001

Original Poster:

383 posts

283 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
To clarify this is to go on a 2002 S2 K Series (non VVC) not yota lump.

Just before I take the plunge I wanted to get some last minute opinions. having followed lots of well informed posts in the past I wanted to get the latest view from the ph community.

I was all set on the TBUlar but the only nagging doubt has been the single exit layout as opposed to the default twin pipes on either side which the larini still gives you.

I have the spitfire derived hand built stainless steel jobbie from hong kong via Ebay with decat currently - it is the loudest thing I have ever heard on an elise and is probbaly ASBO inducing (especially since we moved to a nice neighbourhood). As the fit was never perfect and it keeps breaking the mounts due to the pressure I want to change it and dont want the same again especially as think it will be a problem at sale time judging by some of the posts - unless I find a tunnel run addict :-)

What do people think - has anyone heaqrd a tbular on a k series? I have heard Tonys Larini with decat on vid and love it. I have also heard all about Joe Exiges S original TBUlar install. I have spoken to Jim Valentine (who has heard my current exhaust and laughed)and have never heard of any issues from exisiting owners. The larini got some bad press due to fitting teething issues early on so not sure if my early 02 model will be affected. Having had an ill fitting exhaust for the last 18months I would rather avoid this!

Honestly - I am just a phonecall away from ordering a tbular ultra style thing with panel eliminator kit having spoken to Jim before Xmas - I would prefer to get rid of the original rear grills as they keep needing a respray due to rust - I am just having last minute doubts that I will not like the aesthetics and wanted to see what both camps were saying.

All thoughts and views appreciated.

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
Hi!

Well, you know which I'll favour but I will be honest and say I've never heard the tubular exhaust and so I honestly could not say either way which is best.

The one thing I do know is how chuffed I am with my exhaust. It gets so many comments about the exhaust note (positive ones) and is exactly how I wanted my car to sound.

I highly recommend them, but wouldn't want to take anything away from an exhaust I've not heard before.

Regarding the fitting issues you are absolutely right, many did have troubles but Larini were good at sorting, apparently.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
Larini's sound great, Tubulars sound great.

The hand-crafted nature of the Tubular and all the positive comments on here would lead me down that route if I ever needed one. I just love the idea of the bespoke nature of it all.

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
...and, in line with what Tim said, I really would be happy to get a Tubular based on people's recommendations here (if, in my case, for no reason other than to change ).

What will you do with your old exhaust....?

abz 7001

Original Poster:

383 posts

283 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
Good question Tony - last one I had taken off (Janspeed) was blown so threw that away.
This thing is famous though - might mount it in a glass case - or work out how to fashion it onto our modded classic mini :-)

Its still shiny and new as its so well protected up above the rear diffuser - just sooty tips due to the decat!

Will definitely be doing before and after footage this time, we should meet up Tony, then we could do the definitive 3 exhaust comparison and get it on film for every one elses benefit!

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
This test needs to be done somewhere with the correct sound-stage. Dartford or Rotherhithe Tunnel anyone?

abz 7001

Original Poster:

383 posts

283 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
Heathrow exit tunnel is good aswell as you can ride side by side as is the tunnel on M25 near Waltham Abbey and Enfield as you can go 4 abreast. Sounds like a good excuse for a Sunday afternoon blat! Bet it would casue seismic readings!

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
Crap I had a really well formatted post just before the 'blips;.....

anyhow, yup I'd be well up for a Dartford tunnel-a-thon with video cameras. For the viewing public, of course.

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
I'd go with Tony's comments. Larini's are a work of art as much as the Tubulars are so either would look great without the rear panel.

abz 7001

Original Poster:

383 posts

283 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
Dartford tunnel works for me too! Anyword of a ph tunnel run soon? Otherwise I think my next couple of Sundays are looking fairly relaxed so could arrange a tunnel shoot so to speak. Suppose all we need are the two cars in question (and any other variants i.e Janspeed, Quicksilver, Lotus OEM etc for a full product comparison - all decatted if possible) a couple of passengers with camera equipment and a dry day. Do it near dusk and the flames are easier to seeon overrun - and thats from a standard engine! Free anytime soon Tony?

4pot

481 posts

255 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
The 2bular exhaust that I fitted is of excellent quality. Infact the best that I have seen!

The single exit is an issue, in terms of looks, however I fitted the Hanger 111 rear panel eliminator kit and it now looks pretty good. I know that Jim at 2bular is also making up a n/s rear panel, so that the exhaust hole is blanked. This is to the original s2 111s design, so looks standard.

I cannot comment on the Larini as I have never heard one and my 2bular is for a Honda powered car, but ther service and quality of item from 2bular is excellent.

HTH

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
Hmmmm how much for the Honda box 4pot

Davislove

2,295 posts

277 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
abz 7001 said:
To clarify this is to go on a 2002 S2 K Series (non VVC) not yota lump.

Just before I take the plunge I wanted to get some last minute opinions. having followed lots of well informed posts in the past I wanted to get the latest view from the ph community.

I was all set on the TBUlar but the only nagging doubt has been the single exit layout as opposed to the default twin pipes on either side which the larini still gives you.

I have the spitfire derived hand built stainless steel jobbie from hong kong via Ebay with decat currently - it is the loudest thing I have ever heard on an elise and is probbaly ASBO inducing (especially since we moved to a nice neighbourhood). As the fit was never perfect and it keeps breaking the mounts due to the pressure I want to change it and dont want the same again especially as think it will be a problem at sale time judging by some of the posts - unless I find a tunnel run addict :-)

What do people think - has anyone heaqrd a tbular on a k series? I have heard Tonys Larini with decat on vid and love it. I have also heard all about Joe Exiges S original TBUlar install. I have spoken to Jim Valentine (who has heard my current exhaust and laughed)and have never heard of any issues from exisiting owners. The larini got some bad press due to fitting teething issues early on so not sure if my early 02 model will be affected. Having had an ill fitting exhaust for the last 18months I would rather avoid this!

Honestly - I am just a phonecall away from ordering a tbular ultra style thing with panel eliminator kit having spoken to Jim before Xmas - I would prefer to get rid of the original rear grills as they keep needing a respray due to rust - I am just having last minute doubts that I will not like the aesthetics and wanted to see what both camps were saying.

All thoughts and views appreciated.



I'm in the same situation........................

Very tempted by the 2Bular but not sure about the look either.............I've emailed Jim to see if he can make me one with a dummy second outlet but I doubt its worth his while

Regarding the eliminator kit you will still need to position the reflectors somewhere which could look a bit nasty, the blanking grills that are being made at a few places (Jim / Hanger 111) are all catering for 111S models with the 3 piece diffuser which I have found annoying, I suppose the other option is to just leave the original grills on as they are with nothing protruding

Example of 2bular install on standard S2:




Edited by Davislove on Monday 5th February 18:38

Gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
I have a 2bular and it is stunning. Jim made the zorst to my exact requirements. The construction is superb, the service was brilliant. The sound is just WONDERFUL.

I know several people who have had the same experience.

BUT - I have never heard a 2bular on a k-series. The Larini does sound good on a k-series.

To be honest I wouldnt hesitate to get a 2bular.

4pot

481 posts

255 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
Hmmmm how much for the Honda box 4pot


Tim,

I think it was £428 including vat & delivery. As you are going to the Pistonheads meet on the 18th you can see it then. (Bugelise on Seloc)


Davislove, I haven't fitted the reflectors on my eliminator kit.


Edited by 4pot on Monday 5th February 20:22

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Monday 5th February 2007
quotequote all
Nice one Rich, totally unnecessary expense but will be nice to see/hear another option thumbup

Miles_stylus

332 posts

262 months

Thursday 8th February 2007
quotequote all
I too have been looking at the 2bular on my K S2 and slightly put off by the single exit so I contacted 2bular about the possibility of using the R exaust with the twin tip, through diffuser on the K and it would seem possible (though the defuser has to be changed). I have the name of someone who did it however I've been too busy to follow up.

If this works it could be a good solution as it gives a twin pipe solution as well as a wider range of options.

HTH

Miles

Davislove

2,295 posts

277 months

Thursday 8th February 2007
quotequote all
Miles_stylus said:
I too have been looking at the 2bular on my K S2 and slightly put off by the single exit so I contacted 2bular about the possibility of using the R exaust with the twin tip, through diffuser on the K and it would seem possible (though the defuser has to be changed). I have the name of someone who did it however I've been too busy to follow up.

If this works it could be a good solution as it gives a twin pipe solution as well as a wider range of options.

HTH

Miles


Thats sounds like a great idea...........however could be costly, it will mean new rear diffuser + new rear grills (effectively the rear end will look exactly the same as the new Elise S)

Keep us posted on this thread!

Davislove

2,295 posts

277 months

Thursday 8th February 2007
quotequote all
just another thought, perhaps if a few of us with K-series got together Jim would come up with an arrangement from some of the ideas discussed here?

69.9mph

48 posts

259 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
Have any of you guys with early S2's/K series/single piece diffuser resolved the 2bular single exit dilemma?

I've just bought a 2bular, it's waiting to be fitted, but speaking to Jim V of 2bular it doesn't sound as if there's a definitive grille solution yet - he was hoping to find some pictures of a possible solution but couldn't as he'd had a problem with his email. Any details/suggestions/pics gratefully rec'd.