Insurance quotes
Author
Discussion

racegirl

Original Poster:

696 posts

291 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all
Hi, just bought me a lovely car, and calling around for insurance quotes. Tesco seem to be wiping the floor with everybody at the moment. Rather than me ringing around, does anybody know of any other company that compete with Tesco??

Graham.J

5,420 posts

290 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all
www.norwichunion.co.uk

www.cis.co.uk

Insurance is a nightmare, I was quoted £750 on a 3.5V8 Range Rover on my Mum's insurance, and £900 for a Smart Car on Mums insurance.

>> Edited by Graham.J on Monday 14th April 16:08

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all
direct line are on the money - slightly more expensive but you get a courtesy car if you go wrong

- I booked tesco in my stupidity, got run off the road (long story) and had to hire a car for 6 weeks.

pistol pete

805 posts

294 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all
CIS has always been there or there abouts for me. Be aware also that there are some benefits not included with a policy from tesco, which I was not aware of when i took out cover with them (and promptly canceled wien the paperwork came through). eg. if you take out a fully comp. policy with CIS you will get 3rd party cover on any vehicle you do not own. You do not get this with Tesco if you are under 25.

Not sure about curtosy cars -if this would be an issue for you, and also, tesco do not want an estimate of your vehicles value, which i suspect could mean that, were the worst to happen, they would pay out even less than you could scrape outof anyone else.

If you are only looking at 3rd party then these may not be an issue. -also, check fully comp. quotes as when i was 18(ish) these came out cheaper than 3rd party.

Pete

>> Edited by pistol pete on Monday 14th April 16:19

nmlowe

1,666 posts

298 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all
I went with AXA/RAC (Same company)

Norwich union quoted me over £3000 + £400 excess for my astra, The AA quoted £1700 aprox. Direct line came in at about £950 but AXA were £686.
that was as a student, fully comp, no points on license, no previous convictions, 3 years NCB
£125 voluntary excess + £250 compulsory excess.
I think it depends a lot on who you are, what you do, what you drive and where you live to get the best quote.
Some people get really high quotes from a company, whilst others get low quotes, otherwise half the insurance companies would be out of business by now.

To be on the safe side, try as many companies as you can find phone numbers for.

nmlowe

1,666 posts

298 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all

minimax said: direct line are on the money - slightly more expensive but you get a courtesy car if you go wrong

- I booked tesco in my stupidity, got run off the road (long story) and had to hire a car for 6 weeks.


I was talking to a mate of my dads who owns a garage where he repairs cars to insurance standard for the insurance companies. He said that if a customer comes in for a repair and they are with direct line, they usually turn it down because direct line take forever to pay up for the work.

BCA

8,651 posts

288 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all
Tesco just beat CIS for our quote. What car is it?? I just bought a Smart Passion (picking it up saturday - armed with L plates) Cant wait!!

tonybav

15,539 posts

296 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all
Try:-

www.liverpoolvictoria.co.uk

Worked out cheapest for my son, 18, 1 year on road, 1 accident. Still not cheap I pay for it

raceboy

13,940 posts

311 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all

BCA said: What car is it?? I just bought a Smart Passion (picking it up saturday - armed with L plates) Cant wait!!

She's gone and bought a Clio 1.4RT and I haven't even seen it yet
I think Tesco's are coming in just under £500 fully comp which for a fresh out of L plates driver I thought wasn't bad, but you've got to try everyone before going back and buying from the 1st place you tried, after all thats what all you women do when shopping for clothes

chrisgr31

14,298 posts

286 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all
I thought Direct Line were the underwriters for Tesco? I am with Direct Line and if I have a courtesy car I have to phone up to get it insured, and when I had a Citreon often had to pay an excess as the courtesy car would be a higher group. Not such a problem with the WRX.

Did have a claim with Direct Line last year for vandalism. They seemed efficient, got a courtesy car from the garage, and although they did object about paying for 2 new tyres when only one was ruined, when I explained that Subaru said I needed to replace both on that axle that paid up with no further action needed.

alan_driver

1,281 posts

288 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all

Graham.J said: www.norwichunion.co.uk



Without mentioning any companies in particular, there are some insurance companies that are worse that useless. My parents insurance company still hasn't paid out for there car that was written off 2 years ago by a drunk driver. Obviously my parents want to switch from this particular company ASAP, but cannot do so as they have an on-going claim.

icamm

2,153 posts

291 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all
Try all the online ones. Elephant were good for my shopping trolley this year (but very bad for other people). Norwich Union direct have been good on both cars in the past. Every person I have ever spoken to has had different experiences with insurance companies and two very similar people in terms of age, experience and driving history can get wildly different quotes from the same place. You can even get wildly different quotes from the same insurance company but different brokers due to the incentive schemes brokers get.

tvrbob

11,197 posts

286 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all
If your car is group 12 or under then Tesco can't be beat. They are simply acquiring market share, I guess a few years from now, when they have the market they need, they'll stop accepting the loss and raise their prices to the market norm. My advice, take it while you can. It won't last for ever.

alunr

1,676 posts

295 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all

chrisgr31 said: I thought Direct Line were the underwriters for Tesco? I am with Direct Line and if I have a courtesy car I have to phone up to get it insured, and when I had a Citreon often had to pay an excess as the courtesy car would be a higher group. Not such a problem with the WRX.

Did have a claim with Direct Line last year for vandalism. They seemed efficient, got a courtesy car from the garage, and although they did object about paying for 2 new tyres when only one was ruined, when I explained that Subaru said I needed to replace both on that axle that paid up with no further action needed.


Direct Line, Priviledge (SP?), Tesco and Natwest are all underwritten by Royal bank of scotland I think.

alunr

1,676 posts

295 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all

nmlowe said:comes in for a repair and they are with direct line, they usually turn it down because direct line take forever to pay up for the work.


Thats because they like DL drivers to go to DL bodyshops - and they pay them superquick!

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all

raceboy said: but you've got to try everyone before going back and buying from the 1st place you tried, after all thats what all you women do when shopping for clothes


your not wrong there matey

Insurance is hatefull stuff, ringing round speaking to moron after moron is THE most soul sucking experience bar having to work for a living.

davidy

4,492 posts

315 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all


tvrbob

If your car is group 12 or under then Tesco can't be beat. They are simply acquiring market share, I guess a few years from now, when they have the market they need, they'll stop accepting the loss and raise their prices to the market norm. My advice, take it while you can. It won't last for ever.




Its not just less than group 12, I have a saab9-5 Estate (Group 14) insured with Tescos (just £350) and previously had an Audi A8 (Group 20) for less than £550. One of their big advantages is that they automatically cover policyholder+partner (spouse) for business use..big saving over many other insurance companies. It also means that I can use either of my cars for business as both are insured with Tescos (one in my name and one in the wifes)

davidy

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all
How about this.

Got a renewal through for the Supra from AA £818.

I tried the Tesco web site, got a quote of £717.
Tried to get back into the site the other evening and it kept saying there is a technical problem.

Tried the next evening and same thing happened, phoned Tesco and they said try later.

I gave up in the end told the AA I had a quote from Tesco for £717, and they matched it.

All I've got to do now is check that they haven't taken the full amount.

Lee.

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Monday 14th April 2003
quotequote all

minimax said: direct line are on the money - slightly more expensive but you get a courtesy car if you go wrong



oh no you dont!!! Direct Line do not do what it says on the tin ......