A GT3 or not?
Author
Discussion

bobd

Original Poster:

973 posts

250 months

Friday 16th February 2007
quotequote all
Currently cosidering a GT3 at the moment, having test driven it two days ago. Only trouble is will I miss the TVR or be happy in the Porker? The performance feels smoother, but not as quick or agressive as my T350.
Your comments appreciated.

chumley-warner

310 posts

287 months

Friday 16th February 2007
quotequote all
Had a Cerbera - very smiley.

GT3 will work, even on the bad days. If you can get over the boring interior and the fact that is might not *feel* as fast, or sound quite as good, you'll probably find you will actually drive it faster and the slightly smug feeling that it won't break (much) is the sweet after the sour. Like "Vanilla Sky" - "Only after you have experience the depths of the sour, can you truly appreciate the sweet" (Or something like that)

articm

183 posts

238 months

Friday 16th February 2007
quotequote all
bobd said:
Currently cosidering a GT3 at the moment, having test driven it two days ago. Only trouble is will I miss the TVR or be happy in the Porker? The performance feels smoother, but not as quick or agressive as my T350.
Your comments appreciated.



about the same straight line speed - one of the GT3s weaker points (raw drag performance) is similar to the TVRs strongest point.

so if your looking at it that way, keep the TVR - and you will be more content.

was this a question or a statement?

identti

2,389 posts

255 months

Friday 16th February 2007
quotequote all
articm said:
bobd said:
Currently cosidering a GT3 at the moment, having test driven it two days ago. Only trouble is will I miss the TVR or be happy in the Porker? The performance feels smoother, but not as quick or agressive as my T350.
Your comments appreciated.



about the same straight line speed - one of the GT3s weaker points


Well EVO eeked 0-60 in 4.1 and 0-100 in 9.2secs out of a Mk2 996 GT3. Hardly call that shoddy. I think the TVRs feel faster but in reality theres not much in it really.

nervous

24,050 posts

260 months

Friday 16th February 2007
quotequote all
bobd said:
Currently cosidering a GT3 at the moment, having test driven it two days ago. Only trouble is will I miss the TVR or be happy in the Porker? The performance feels smoother, but not as quick or agressive as my T350.
Your comments appreciated.


having owned both, i can tell you that honestly, sadly, nothing compares to the '3. ive just picked up a sagaris, and fast as it is, its no-where near as accomplished as the gt3.

but then, its not meant to be.

911wise

1,887 posts

239 months

Friday 16th February 2007
quotequote all
chumley-warner said:
Had a Cerbera - very smiley.

GT3 will work, even on the bad days. If you can get over the boring interior and the fact that is might not *feel* as fast, or sound quite as good, you'll probably find you will actually drive it faster and the slightly smug feeling that it won't break (much) is the sweet after the sour. Like "Vanilla Sky" - "Only after you have experience the depths of the sour, can you truly appreciate the sweet" (Or something like that)

EEErr is that a yes or a no?

chumley-warner

310 posts

287 months

Friday 16th February 2007
quotequote all
911wise said:

EEErr is that a yes or a no?


Both

articm

183 posts

238 months

Friday 16th February 2007
quotequote all
identti said:
articm said:
bobd said:
Currently cosidering a GT3 at the moment, having test driven it two days ago. Only trouble is will I miss the TVR or be happy in the Porker? The performance feels smoother, but not as quick or agressive as my T350.
Your comments appreciated.



about the same straight line speed - one of the GT3s weaker points


Well EVO eeked 0-60 in 4.1 and 0-100 in 9.2secs out of a Mk2 996 GT3. Hardly call that shoddy. I think the TVRs feel faster but in reality theres not much in it really.


i mean weaker in a relative sense - also in autocar 997 Gt3 0-150 in 22secs just 0.5secs off an F430 so faster than most


Edited by articm on Friday 16th February 19:37

DanH

12,287 posts

290 months

Friday 16th February 2007
quotequote all
nervous said:
ive just picked up a sagaris


I know they are made like canoes, but that's still quite a feat of lifting.

Personally I think the GT3 is a superior car in most every axis. It is a more subtle charm though, so you will fall in love with it more as you discover its depths. I find this in contrast to British marques I've owned where the opposite is the case.

Edited by DanH on Friday 16th February 19:40

bobd

Original Poster:

973 posts

250 months

Friday 16th February 2007
quotequote all
Thanks guys and keep the comments coming. The GT3 would be an 04 996, and my T350 has a close ratio box and quick diff plus very good dyno figures, if that helps

Globulator

13,847 posts

261 months

Friday 16th February 2007
quotequote all
DanH said:
nervous said:
ive just picked up a sagaris


I know they are made like canoes, but that's still quite a feat of lifting.
Well he's a strong lad you know

Got any photos yet Matt? (I guess it may be a little dark this evening).

Re. the GT3 - I'd go that if I possibly could, Pork tends to grow on you and the GT3 sounds like it would - based on all I've read about it. I think you need more test drives before you decide.

ricardo60

166 posts

251 months

Saturday 17th February 2007
quotequote all
I had a Tuscan & loved it, but with my limited driving ability only felt able to use the performance 20% of the time. Ended up binning it. Able to use 90% of GT3 performance 100%. Different propositions, but GT3 gets my vote.

carreraboy

826 posts

248 months

Saturday 17th February 2007
quotequote all
Buy the GT3 and leave the bostick alone.....

Sarbs

264 posts

266 months

Sunday 18th February 2007
quotequote all
I see TVR's as very beautiful cars that I would like to drive but never own.
A porsche GT3 is an icon that gets better and better as the driver improves.
Porker all day long in my book.

AdvocatusDiaboli

2,278 posts

261 months

Monday 19th February 2007
quotequote all
I just drove both these cars back to back over Sunday. MK2 GT3 and a the prussian blue Sagaris at Dream Machines. I drove two 911 turbos as well but they felt soggy (to me) compared to the other two.

Both immense machines, but it was the GT3 was the one that really took my breath away... That short throttle and that wonderful engine note! The Sagaris was wonderful to drive as well, I could feel so much and the car felt exceedingly "true", however my first impressions aren't as positive as the GT3. The Sagaris engine note made me smile though, it really feels "old school" like my Lancia. But I must admit (and I realise I will be in the minority here), the GT3 symphony sounded more urgent, more exciting.

As for fast? The Sagaris was very, very quick, but the GT3 (perhaps I was not driving the Sagaris correctly) felt just as quick and a little more stable. Either way, 5 tenths of a second to 60 really doesn't matter to me.

As for handling, there was a very tight little left handed corner where I slowed right down and then stamped on it... the Sagaris snapped out a bit (super easy to correct though, I must add) but that GT3, it went around it like it was on rails! Jaw dropping. I am pretty damned sold.

Both are fabulous but you really do need to drive both! Nervous, if I may would like to email you about that fabulous GT3 you owned and the Sagaris you currently own. Your input as an owner/driver on both would be most useful!

Edited to add: Would be grateful if someone could pointed out the differences between the MK1 and MK2. Is the Mk2 a substantial improvment?




Edited by AdvocatusDiaboli on Monday 19th February 09:55

Dr S

5,154 posts

256 months

Monday 19th February 2007
quotequote all
bobd said:
The performance feels smoother, but not as quick or agressive as my T350.


Surely the TVR feels faster as body panels are flying around your head, the engine is close to blowing up and the gear box whines like hell...


and I didn't mention any electrics yet...


great cars nonetheless

nervous

24,050 posts

260 months

Monday 19th February 2007
quotequote all
AdvocatusDiaboli said:
Nervous, if I may would like to email you about that fabulous GT3 you owned and the Sagaris you currently own. Your input as an owner/driver on both would be most useful!



sure thing. however, you might need to be aware that my input as a 'driver' will be limited, as i have trousers with more talent behind the wheel than me.

AdvocatusDiaboli

2,278 posts

261 months

Monday 19th February 2007
quotequote all
nervous said:
AdvocatusDiaboli said:
Nervous, if I may would like to email you about that fabulous GT3 you owned and the Sagaris you currently own. Your input as an owner/driver on both would be most useful!



sure thing. however, you might need to be aware that my input as a 'driver' will be limited, as i have trousers with more talent behind the wheel than me.


Thats makes two of us. I'll be in touch!

AndrewD

7,659 posts

314 months

Monday 19th February 2007
quotequote all
With his talented trousers?

ross

219 posts

314 months

Tuesday 20th February 2007
quotequote all
buy one. I got mine (99 GT3 MK1) after several TVRs inc. a 4.5 cerbera which I loved. The GT3 is every bit as 'raw' an experience in its own way as the Cerb. It's probably y no.1 fave car ever, ahead of my old Cerbera, Chimera, 306 XSi and AX GT!

I still have a Griff though for old time's sake and to scare myself witless every now and again.