Any osteopaths/chiropractors on here
Discussion
Im having trouble with my back and would like some advice. Been to doctors had X rays etc for as long as I can remember now. I have a mis aligned vertebrae(Spondy lo something or other) Every now and again and usually for no reason, I trap a nerve or pull a muscle. Can either of the above help my situation, I have been told that unless it gets a lot worse thehey will not operate. Im only 30 and its starting to get me down a bit. I want to be able to do household stuff, gardening and DIY but most times I spend the next few days/weeks in agony any thoughts.
Zippy - I also have a spondolylysis thesis (ls5)
You need to find out exactly what your diagnosis is and makes sure you understand what movement restrictions you have and the longer term implications.
A good Chiropractor will explain best (gps are in my own experience simply not interested in "back pain")
You should also read a bit on the subject. Richard hadlee had the same condition and he was a first class pace bowler well into his thirties. But it needs management - you can go full pace into every situation you need to think about your physical limitations and then make a decision whether or not to do something.
My worse pain spasms are usually when I've been drinking and deciede to firemans lift people or stupid stunts like that.
It needn't be painful but you need to understand good movements and bad posture !
good luck
You need to find out exactly what your diagnosis is and makes sure you understand what movement restrictions you have and the longer term implications.
A good Chiropractor will explain best (gps are in my own experience simply not interested in "back pain")
You should also read a bit on the subject. Richard hadlee had the same condition and he was a first class pace bowler well into his thirties. But it needs management - you can go full pace into every situation you need to think about your physical limitations and then make a decision whether or not to do something.
My worse pain spasms are usually when I've been drinking and deciede to firemans lift people or stupid stunts like that.
It needn't be painful but you need to understand good movements and bad posture !
good luck
Hi Zippy,
I'm a physio.
First off there's a couple of things you can have: Spondylolysis - a defect/stress fracture of the pars articularis (The "pedicle" on these diagrams www.spine-health.com/dir/spine.html ) to the arch that surrounds the spinal cord or a spondylolisthesis where the body of the vertebra has slipped forwards sometimes due to to spondylolysis (most likely given your age), sometimes due to wear and tear.
The pain comes usually due to exessive arching of yor back pushing the vertebral body forwards. This is normally worse with increased loading or sustained positions - carrying something (but not necessarily lifting), lieing on your front (esp propped on elbows).
The good news is that there is a great deal you can do to manage your symptoms and optimise your back function. Management should consist of strategies to stop the pain (heat/ice, analgesia, repeated bending forwards (If arching puts it out, then bending should put it back). Getting the other vertebrae more mobile will reduce the stress on the problem level. Stretching the front of your hip (if its tight) will allow your pelvis to tilt back reducing the pressure forwards on the vertebra. Strengthening your abdominals (especially your "core" musculature), glutes, hip flexors and back muscles will aid your posture and spinal control, and the core work should help you to stabilise the segment.
Basically, as with most back problems, the fitter/stronger you are the better, which is why I'd suggest a physio or possibly an osteo over a chiro. I may be doing a disservice to chiros but they tend not to be very experienced at stabilising/strengthening work as they do more manipulation than anything else. This may well help symptomatically, but longterm will make little difference.
I'm based in Bristol if you're nearby otherwise look for a private physio on www.physiofirst.org.uk/public/default.asp or get your doctor to refer you to the NHS.
Good luck and let me know if you have any other questions.
Bill
Edit: Its common in fast bowlers due to the rotation stresses the put on the spine, its also much more common in eskimos (I shlt you not).
Also I might take time to reply as I am quite busy for the next couple of days, and am therefore trying to avoid the computer (and by extension the time warp that is PH). And then its the weekend

>> Edited by mechsympathy on Wednesday 16th April 09:46
I'm a physio.
First off there's a couple of things you can have: Spondylolysis - a defect/stress fracture of the pars articularis (The "pedicle" on these diagrams www.spine-health.com/dir/spine.html ) to the arch that surrounds the spinal cord or a spondylolisthesis where the body of the vertebra has slipped forwards sometimes due to to spondylolysis (most likely given your age), sometimes due to wear and tear.
The pain comes usually due to exessive arching of yor back pushing the vertebral body forwards. This is normally worse with increased loading or sustained positions - carrying something (but not necessarily lifting), lieing on your front (esp propped on elbows).
The good news is that there is a great deal you can do to manage your symptoms and optimise your back function. Management should consist of strategies to stop the pain (heat/ice, analgesia, repeated bending forwards (If arching puts it out, then bending should put it back). Getting the other vertebrae more mobile will reduce the stress on the problem level. Stretching the front of your hip (if its tight) will allow your pelvis to tilt back reducing the pressure forwards on the vertebra. Strengthening your abdominals (especially your "core" musculature), glutes, hip flexors and back muscles will aid your posture and spinal control, and the core work should help you to stabilise the segment.
Basically, as with most back problems, the fitter/stronger you are the better, which is why I'd suggest a physio or possibly an osteo over a chiro. I may be doing a disservice to chiros but they tend not to be very experienced at stabilising/strengthening work as they do more manipulation than anything else. This may well help symptomatically, but longterm will make little difference.
I'm based in Bristol if you're nearby otherwise look for a private physio on www.physiofirst.org.uk/public/default.asp or get your doctor to refer you to the NHS.
Good luck and let me know if you have any other questions.
Bill
Edit: Its common in fast bowlers due to the rotation stresses the put on the spine, its also much more common in eskimos (I shlt you not).
Also I might take time to reply as I am quite busy for the next couple of days, and am therefore trying to avoid the computer (and by extension the time warp that is PH). And then its the weekend


>> Edited by mechsympathy on Wednesday 16th April 09:46
Go see www.quackwatch.org/ then. "Chirobase" specifically. Then "Cheers and jeers", makes for scary reading - if only cos of the proliferation of poor spelling and capitals, cos they REALLY WANT TO MAKE A POYNT.
mechsympathy said: Hi Zippy,
I'm a physio.
spondylolisthesis where the body of the vertebra has slipped forwards sometimes due to to spondylolysis (most likely given your age), sometimes due to wear and tear.
This is what I have. I have previously tried a physio, I was given excersises to do which has helped, but I would like more done, I have had this for over 20 years at least and Ive reached my limit now. cheers for the help, Im off to the doctors to hopefully get reffered to someone else.
>> Edited by zippy500 on Wednesday 16th April 10:54
Zippy - I am currently off sick with a bad back and am receiving treatment from a Physio. I have been in pain on and off for the last 15 years and in constant pain for the last 4 months and currently have displaced my L4. Having seen Chiros & Osteopaths I would certainly recommend the Physio. Other than that the best advice is to keep fit. Swimming is the best exercise you can do as your weight is supported. I also benefit from gentle cycling and pilates.
I can sympathise with you about the restricted lifestyle. I also have arthritis in my knees and it is miserable when you watch other people enjoying their lives knowing that you are unable to do the same. I am keen on gardening and it is frustrating not being able to make the most of this nice weather and I know I am never going to be able to cope with the clutch of our Griffith.
Try searching on google for more information on your condition. You may find a help group who can give you advice and support. Good luck.
Debs
I can sympathise with you about the restricted lifestyle. I also have arthritis in my knees and it is miserable when you watch other people enjoying their lives knowing that you are unable to do the same. I am keen on gardening and it is frustrating not being able to make the most of this nice weather and I know I am never going to be able to cope with the clutch of our Griffith.
Try searching on google for more information on your condition. You may find a help group who can give you advice and support. Good luck.
Debs
Just to speak up for Chiropractors for a moment - there are situations where they can help. Worked for me. After a particularly stupid skiing pratfall - over extended my back on snowblades - I went to a GP who shrugged, as they do, and agreed that a Chiro might help. Several sessions later I now have no pain and full mobility - this was just soft tissue stuff so maybe there's the difference...
Just my 2(000) liras worth....
Just my 2(000) liras worth....
zippy500 said:
mechsympathy said: Hi Zippy,
I'm a physio.
spondylolisthesis where the body of the vertebra has slipped forwards sometimes due to to spondylolysis (most likely given your age), sometimes due to wear and tear.
This is what I have. I have previously tried a physio, I was given excersises to do which has helped, but I would like more done, I have had this for over 20 years at least and Ive reached my limit now. cheers for the help, Im off to the doctors to hopefully get reffered to someone else.
>> Edited by zippy500 on Wednesday 16th April 10:54
Have you kept up with the exercises? The core stability work (transversus - if its been explained to you) takes dedication. Also did the physio look at everything I have mentioned above (and probably more).
Where did you find the physio, how long ago did you see them? If it was NHS then their time was probably limited, especially if you weren't suffering badly at the time. I know I'm a physio and therefore biased but I really do feel its the way to go. But by all means try other treatments, but try to go with a recommendation as there are practitioners (Physios too!
) out there who will try and take advantage. On the subject of referral elsewhere, the hard reality is where? The surgeons won't consider operating as there are risk involved in the surgery, the results are not guaranteed and there is every likelihood that if you are active the fixation will break down.
You're only down the road from me, so if you fancy a drive out, pie and a chat let me know.
Edit: sorry for the hard sell, I'm a lot more relaxed in person!
>> Edited by mechsympathy on Wednesday 16th April 12:09
It was a NHS Physio, I went a few times then she left me to my own devices to carry on the exercises, I must admit I havent kept them up very well. Although I swim once a week and do very small situps evey night. This has definatley improved my lower back muscles. I always tence my abdominals when bending over and this does help lower the pain level. What I find most difficult is going from a sitting state toa standing state, just cant straighten my body without really bad pain. This problem comes and goes, I would say though 2 times per month at least.
Very surprised to see Chiros & oesteos getting a hard time in my experience
I have seen three physios - none of whom knew anything about the condition
My chiro always gets the thesis back into line and relieves the tension in my upper back - which actually iswhere the pain is. It takes a while to find a good one you trust and can relax whilst they batter you.
Anyway - good advice on here regarding the core muscles.....now wheres that pie gone
I have seen three physios - none of whom knew anything about the condition
My chiro always gets the thesis back into line and relieves the tension in my upper back - which actually iswhere the pain is. It takes a while to find a good one you trust and can relax whilst they batter you.
Anyway - good advice on here regarding the core muscles.....now wheres that pie gone
Do not head those that say Osteopaths and Chiropractors are quacks - make up you own mind.
I have had problems with my spine for 20 years (scoliosis - curvature of the spine). I found that Physios were very good are getting rid of the symptoms by working on the soft tissue to stop the muscle spasms, however they were not good at treating the underlying problem (subluxation, when the vertebrae get out of alignment). I have found that regular chiropractor visits have kept my back virtually pain free. If I stop going as I did 3 or 4 years ago, I'm fine for 8 or 9 months and then have a episode where I can hardly walk for 2 weeks. £25 once a month is more than worth it for me.
A word of warning however, as with all things, go by word of mouth if you can, there are great chropractors and average chiropractors - make sure you find a good one that does not see you as a cash cow.
I have had problems with my spine for 20 years (scoliosis - curvature of the spine). I found that Physios were very good are getting rid of the symptoms by working on the soft tissue to stop the muscle spasms, however they were not good at treating the underlying problem (subluxation, when the vertebrae get out of alignment). I have found that regular chiropractor visits have kept my back virtually pain free. If I stop going as I did 3 or 4 years ago, I'm fine for 8 or 9 months and then have a episode where I can hardly walk for 2 weeks. £25 once a month is more than worth it for me.
A word of warning however, as with all things, go by word of mouth if you can, there are great chropractors and average chiropractors - make sure you find a good one that does not see you as a cash cow.
It used to be the case and AFAIK still is (maybe mechsympathy can confirm?) that anyone can set themselves up as an osteopath without any formal qualifications or even knowledge. A few years ago, my mum (an NHS physio) had a spate of patients coming to her with problems after seeing a local osteopath who turned out to be a redundant former TV repair man who'd done nothing but a brief correspondence course in osteopathy before setting himself up in business.
Dunno what the situation is with chiropracters, but I'd certainly go to a qualified physio any day rather than risk entrusting my spine to Mr Radio Rentals.
Dunno what the situation is with chiropracters, but I'd certainly go to a qualified physio any day rather than risk entrusting my spine to Mr Radio Rentals.
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


