ISA Server
Author
Discussion

pebbledash

Original Poster:

795 posts

297 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
Are there any Microsoft ISA Experts out there?

I have installed ISA and am having big problems getting it to do NAT on an internal net. all other nets etc work exept this one........

CarZee

13,382 posts

298 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all


it's a funny old beast innit..

To be honest, with ISA server, I'd bill you for even helping out on here because it 's such a pain in the arse product.. there's no correlation whatsoever between the configuration you set and the way it behaves.

Hope this helps

dontlift

9,396 posts

289 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
I would agree with CZ,

For small installations i would recommend the 3com Office Connect Firewall with DMZ as a one box solution to what ISA does.

But it all depends on your application.

pebbledash

Original Poster:

795 posts

297 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
Ah..

Problem sloved... I will just go for a anyway...

Problem is there is not Config.. I have set it up as open. all filters all rules all sites etc.... any nets with public type IPs have always worked. but any private ones just get lost on the internet...

so it is
then..

P.S. nacnud you are driving later..

pebbledash

Original Poster:

795 posts

297 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
The ISA server has 4 network card. one DMZ public, one internal coms net, one external coms net, and a private net.... Oh and before you say it... I did not do the original N/W design...

CarZee

13,382 posts

298 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
the problem is that ISA server really only supports 1 external interface/route - to create the illusion of a DMZ, you need to put 2 ISA servers back to back..

There's a white paper on it at microsoft.com.. but until the world runs out of beer, you won't want to read it..

pebbledash

Original Poster:

795 posts

297 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
Plan B Time.
I am very tempted to put the ISA server between the existing server and the internet.. just off to the pub to have a and think about that one.....

Marshy

2,751 posts

315 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
Sounds like MS didn't learn their lesson when they tried the firewall thing with Kerplunk. Er, Catapault, sorry.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
Can I just add how much I loathe and hate ISA Server and how I wish its evil perpetrators would be brought to justice and made to use the fcuken thing endlessly without remission until Hell freezes over.

Thank you for listening....

plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all

CarZee said:

it's a funny old beast innit..

To be honest, with ISA server, I'd bill you for even helping out on here because it 's such a pain in the arse product.. there's no correlation whatsoever between the configuration you set and the way it behaves.

Hope this helps



Well then, thanks for passing it onto me for use as a web server!

Matt.

CarZee

13,382 posts

298 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all

plotloss said:Well then, thanks for passing it onto me for use as a web server!


if I recommended it to you, it's because it is suitable for the application you described - I use it at home and publish a webserver from behind it - it's also the best (easiest) 1-in/1-out transparent software proxy/cache/firewall you can run on a PC...

It just doesn't fill the boots of a Firewall 1 box & doesn't understand the concept of DMZs..

Hmm.. undigging the hole... lol...

>> Edited by CarZee (moderator) on Thursday 17th April 15:26

pebbledash

Original Poster:

795 posts

297 months

Thursday 17th April 2003
quotequote all
Ok I get it.....

WORMS AND A CAN OF........