Boxster / Caymen owners... Wanna be 911 owners!
Boxster / Caymen owners... Wanna be 911 owners!
Author
Discussion

Rochester BMW

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

237 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
Good afternoon,

Last weekend I had the 'joys' of having my parents round for dinner and as usual me and my dad ended up having some sort of 'heated discussion about cars...

This time it was...

"You would only buy a Boxster or a Gaymen if you cant afford a 911...."

This is my point of view. My dads is that they are all bought on there own merits....

My case is this....

Porsche as a brand is iconic! FACT! They make arguably THE best all round sports car money can buy... The 911. It has been the bench mark for all other manufactures to beat for decades....

The reason people want to own a porsche is because of the image and excellence that comes with that badge... that image and excellence is all due to the 911...

This is the important bit.

The Boxster and Caymen are fantastic cars in their own right. BUT.... They are bought by people who wished it was a 911.

Porsche IS the 911.... people want to own a porsche because of the reputation the 911 has earned it over the years...

its not because of the 944 or the 928 or even the 959.

Theres something about the boxster / caymen that annoys me....I wouldn't buy a fake watch... I wouldn't buy fake sunglasses, and i wouldn't buy a fake 911....

they are even designed to look like a 911 so that people can pretend that they own a 911 porsche...

In my opinion... owning a Boxster or a Caymen is the best way of advertising that your life hasn't exactly turned out the way you'd hoped!

Let the debate begin...Opinions please....















Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
sleep

Bull996

1,442 posts

240 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
Talk about lighting the bkue touchpaper and retiring to safe distance yikes

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
Bull996 said:
Talk about lighting the bkue touchpaper and retiring to safe distance yikes


Don't worry, mate. Since he won't be driving any of 'em shortly I reckon his opinion doesn't really count.


Ba dum tish.

Rochester BMW

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

237 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
Bull996 said:
Talk about lighting the bkue touchpaper and retiring to safe distance yikes


I know hehe, its true though... No other marque was (is) built around one model for so many years.... everything else it makes is just riding off the back of it and people buy it because they want to jump on the band wagon...

Imagine the conversation...

What do you drive?

Ive got a Porshe!

Oh really, a 911?

No a boxster....

oh.... nevermind, one day though aye....

rumplestiltskin

1,084 posts

253 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
I am slumming it tomorrow in a Boxster S when my 996TT goes in for an MOT. How will I make it through the day......

Rochester BMW

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

237 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
rumplestiltskin said:
I am slumming it tomorrow in a Boxster S when my 996TT goes in for an MOT. How will I make it through the day......


Just make sure no one sees you....

fergus

6,430 posts

306 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
how about the fact that they're not a lot slower, and in the right hands perhaps as fast? Perhaps someone doesn't want either £60k sat in the driveway or being financed up to the hilt, and can make their cash work a lot harder for them?

I presume you're a BMW dealer then? Is that not the same as saying that all 530i owners want an M5 - I don't think so.

Not everyone aspires to own the most expensive item available to the brand (OK some pr1cks do).... i.e. why buy a rolex when you can get a far more classy patek, or why buy sony's £2k plasma rather than their £4k one? etc etc :yawn:

What a f*cking rediculous statement you've just made.

rumplestiltskin

1,084 posts

253 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
....will be using the Sat Nav to avoid built up areas.....

911wise

1,887 posts

240 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
A new boxster or cayman could easily run you a bill up of over 50k. I'd feel a right tramp driving a car round that only cost that much, the shame of anyone I know seeing me in it and knowing that my life hasn't exactly turned out as I wanted because the car I drive only cost 50k.... The shame.

rumplestiltskin

1,084 posts

253 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
Actually I had to get the Boxster S insured for the day, phoned up the OPC for its value....£48,000 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

R.

BliarOut

72,863 posts

270 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
rumplestiltskin said:
I am slumming it tomorrow in a Boxster S when my 996TT goes in for an MOT. How will I make it through the day......

Careful, everyone I have heard of who had a loaner Boxster absolutely loved it.

GreigM

6,740 posts

280 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
I sold my GT3 to buy a boxster - how does that fit into your logic?

kayc

4,492 posts

252 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
GreigM said:
I sold my GT3 to buy a boxster - how does that fit into your logic?
How does that fit in anyones logic?laugh

Rochester BMW

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

237 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
fergus said:
how about the fact that they're not a lot slower, and in the right hands perhaps as fast? Perhaps someone doesn't want either £60k sat in the driveway or being financed up to the hilt, and can make their cash work a lot harder for them?

I presume you're a BMW dealer then? Is that not the same as saying that all 530i owners want an M5 - I don't think so.

Not everyone aspires to own the most expensive item available to the brand (OK some pr1cks do).... i.e. why buy a rolex when you can get a far more classy patek, or why buy sony's £2k plasma rather than their £4k one? etc etc :yawn:

What a f*cking rediculous statement you've just made.



no hear me out.... the boxster and caymen are fantasitc cars! Im not doubting that at all.

All im saying is that in the car buyer market people go for badges... BMW, merc, audi etc... and porsche is no different... people buy porsches because of the reputation they have of making the best sports cars...(car) but where porsche is different is that it has built that reputation off the back of ONE model, the 911....

BMW, MB, Audi, Ferrari all have fantastic reputations for what they are good at, but none of them have built that reputation off just one of its models... they have built that reputation up by producing lots of very good cars...

Porsche however... makes one car the 911. The best sports car money can buy no question! The boxster / caymen will vanish into history one day and the 911 will continue...

its not about how fast they are, its about the REASON why people buy a boxster....

Porsche's have always been dream mobiles.... now they are making cars at more everyday prices so you get the middle aged bloke who had posters of a 911 on his wall as a boy buying a boxster, just because its his little bit of living a dream...

the dream is the 911... it never has been a 928, 944, 968, boxster or caymen, and it never will be....

and no in not a dealer, just someone with an opinion...


anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
I agree with your dad. I can afford a 911 but would only consider Cayman (I've has Boxsters so now looking at tin tops) because I prefer it's looks and practicality for me as a singleton!!! Couldn't give a stuff about 911's - they just don't do it for me!

Nice GT3 maybe though!!

Lurking Lawyer

4,535 posts

256 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
911 cabriolets have always looked rather ungainly to me - especially the older ones (993 and before), and even the newer ones still look "wrong". I think it's the hump-back look and the fact that it looks like someone has taken a tin-opener to the coupe.

The Boxster was designed from the outset as a roadster, so has greater torsional rigidity built into it. If soft-top driving is what you're after, and the driving experience is more important than the image, I'd probably take a Boxster S over a 911 cabriolet.

wanta996

5,622 posts

238 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
So which Ferrari is a real ferrari using your logic - F430?F575?F612?Enzo?

I am a 512tr man myself.

Rochester BMW

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

237 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
why buy a boxster over a S2000????

The badge.. thats why!

GreigM

6,740 posts

280 months

Monday 26th February 2007
quotequote all
kayc said:
GreigM said:
I sold my GT3 to buy a boxster - how does that fit into your logic?
How does that fit in anyones logic?laugh

No time for a track car anymore, the boxster is a far better road car in many ways - not as quick but fundamentally a better drive.