Plasma Screen Experts - Advice needed.
Plasma Screen Experts - Advice needed.
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Friday 2nd March 2007
quotequote all
Are there any Plasma screen experts out there?
My old 42' LG Plasma Screen suddenly stopped working yesterday. (its now 3 years old)
There is no picture at all...just a few random pixels flashing up colours every now and again.
Power is defintely on, I tried selecting different inputs or starting the TV menu options but I get nothing except some pixel static. cry

Doesn't look good - does anyone know if these things are fixable, or is it bye bye plasma screen?

bandit

allnighter

6,663 posts

253 months

Friday 2nd March 2007
quotequote all
That's what happens when you buy an LG or a Philips.Dump the crap and buy s/thing reliable like a Panny , Hitachi or Pioneer.

Zad

13,024 posts

267 months

Saturday 3rd March 2007
quotequote all
Nothing like good advice is there. And that was nothing like good advice.

Look in your local yellow pages for an independent TV repair engineer. Give him a call. It could be something fairly simple. Of course it may not, but he should tell you that if so.

allnighter

6,663 posts

253 months

Saturday 3rd March 2007
quotequote all
Zad said:
Nothing like good advice is there. And that was nothing like good advice.

Look in your local yellow pages for an independent TV repair engineer. Give him a call. It could be something fairly simple. Of course it may not, but he should tell you that if so.


My opinion was formed on what I have seen.I would not touch LG with a barge pole.A family member had his LG 32" LCD pack up on him 13 months and the cost of repair is "un-economical".A good friend of mine had a 2nd LG screen failing on him 5 minutes from the box.It does speak volume about reliability.Now the OP is an intelligent person and I am sure he will make a sensible decision.Throwing good money after bad is not a recommendation of mine.AFAIK these screens are unfixable, and a replacement screen would cost a fortune in parts and labour rendering it uneconomical as my father in law found out.So there!

rich1231

17,340 posts

291 months

Saturday 3rd March 2007
quotequote all
allnighter said:
Zad said:
Nothing like good advice is there. And that was nothing like good advice.

Look in your local yellow pages for an independent TV repair engineer. Give him a call. It could be something fairly simple. Of course it may not, but he should tell you that if so.


My opinion was formed on what I have seen.I would not touch LG with a barge pole.A family member had his LG 32" LCD pack up on him 13 months and the cost of repair is "un-economical".A good friend of mine had a 2nd LG screen failing on him 5 minutes from the box.It does speak volume about reliability.Now the OP is an intelligent person and I am sure he will make a sensible decision.Throwing good money after bad is not a recommendation of mine.AFAIK these screens are unfixable, and a replacement screen would cost a fortune in parts and labour rendering it uneconomical as my father in law found out.So there!


and loads of people rave about LG screens on avforums.

deevlash

10,442 posts

268 months

Saturday 3rd March 2007
quotequote all
from what I heard LG manufacture a lot of plasmas as a third party for the more prestigious brands anyway.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Saturday 3rd March 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice ...and scares.
I'll get in touch with a repair company as suggested and see what the damage is.
If its too much I'll have to bin it.

The LG screen itself was a very early one (I bought it in 2003) but I must say that the picture quality was fantastic (when it was working).

bandit

cjs

11,723 posts

282 months

Saturday 3rd March 2007
quotequote all
A good way to check if the screen has gone is to try and pull up a menu, if you can see the menus then the screen should be okay and you need to look somewhere else for the fault.

PJ S

10,842 posts

258 months

Saturday 3rd March 2007
quotequote all
LOL - wonderful advice from all there!
Are you all so flush with cash that you've forgotten your consumer rights as laid out in the Sale Of Goods Act?
Contact the company whom you bought the screen from, and discuss with them what they plan on offering.
Reasonable time is considered 5 years in Scotland, 6 in the rest of the UK.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Sunday 4th March 2007
quotequote all
cjs said:
A good way to check if the screen has gone is to try and pull up a menu, if you can see the menus then the screen should be okay and you need to look somewhere else for the fault.


Menu doesn't appear - just a few colourful pixels move position.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
Thought I'd let you all know about the right result I had.
After 3 months and many letters and contact with consumer rights group, along with the vendor being unable to repair the screen I have been given a full refund !

Despite the screen being over 3 years old and without warrenty, as they were unable to repair and they couldn't offer me a replacement (no longer made) I have all 2,800 pounds returned - which should actually allow me to buy three 42inch screens in this day and age.

What a result ! smokin

cjs

11,723 posts

282 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
You lucky bugger! Who did you buy it from?

16610LV

311 posts

246 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
Bandit said:
Thought I'd let you all know about the right result I had.
After 3 months and many letters and contact with consumer rights group, along with the vendor being unable to repair the screen I have been given a full refund !

Despite the screen being over 3 years old and without warrenty, as they were unable to repair and they couldn't offer me a replacement (no longer made) I have all 2,800 pounds returned - which should actually allow me to buy three 42inch screens in this day and age.

What a result ! smokin
...you jammy sod!! Well done though! But PLEASE don't buy another LG. Upgrade to 50" if you have the space and if you can wait a couple of months, get the new 8th generation Pioneer plasma (508XD). Well within budget if you want to blow the whole of the refund. For a budget of £1.5k, go for either Panasonic, Pioneer (7th gen) or Samsung.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
16610LV said:
Bandit said:
Thought I'd let you all know about the right result I had.
After 3 months and many letters and contact with consumer rights group, along with the vendor being unable to repair the screen I have been given a full refund !

Despite the screen being over 3 years old and without warrenty, as they were unable to repair and they couldn't offer me a replacement (no longer made) I have all 2,800 pounds returned - which should actually allow me to buy three 42inch screens in this day and age.

What a result ! smokin
...you jammy sod!! Well done though! But PLEASE don't buy another LG. Upgrade to 50" if you have the space and if you can wait a couple of months, get the new 8th generation Pioneer plasma (508XD). Well within budget if you want to blow the whole of the refund. For a budget of £1.5k, go for either Panasonic, Pioneer (7th gen) or Samsung.
I was thinking of a 42inch Pioneer (I think 50" may be a little too large). The store in question only stocks the 7th generation at the moment, so its the PDP427OXD. They also have a 43inch Pioneer, the PDP436FDETA, but I can't really find out that much about that screen.

That should only set me back a grand, that leaves me the rest for other goodies (I'm thinking about a PS3, a new monitor for the PC, a camcorder and a new fridge)

- Its like Xmas (Sorry - shouldn't be so smug) woohoo

16610LV

311 posts

246 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
Pioneer 427XD is a good choice. 436 is older technology so steer clear.

PJ S

10,842 posts

258 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
Hang on!
427 can be problematic with "dirty screen" issue. Also more susceptible to screen burn.
Now, even without discussing the 50" size, you really should be a bit more patient (few weeks) as the 428 will be available.
For circa £2K, the general consensus is that the hype Pioneer were creating over the black levels and so forth was not hype, but pretty much on the money.
Head over for a read of the "Pioneer....8th May" thread on AVForums.com - there's a link to a blog entry of Home Cinema Choice (read mini-review pre-magazine release) which says it all.

As you've been given a refund, then you're under no obligation to spend the money there, so you can buy from a specialist dealer/custom installer, who'll more likely than not, have the screen sooner and the higher spec. The 0 at the end signifies entry model minus a few useful features.
If you go on Pioneer's site, you see the model listing (News section still?) which will let you see if the 4280 is a compromise too far.

If you are sitting 10ft+ back from the screen, then you most definitely can run a 50" without it looking domineering. It will initially, but once you get used to it, it'll blend in just fine.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
You totally lucky bugger. What a result!

So eighteen months ago I bought an LG 50" TV.

A week and half ago it packed up (Wednesday). I have an extended warranty with [NAME WITHELD] so I called 'em. Very efficiently the NEXT DAY Colorsure turned up to try and repair it. No dice. Off it went to their work shop. On Friday I hear "its fecked". On Monday I hear "we'll buy you a new one". They order it. On Monday afternoon [ALSO NAME WITHELD] call ME to say "you know that telly [NAME WITHELD] ordered for you? Its obselete. We don't carry it anymore. You'll have to call 'em back."

Now why that should be my fecking job I don't know but I do. [NAME WITHELD] agree to buy me a different telly. Still a LG 50", mind. I go to Festival of Speed. Call again Saturday to find out that the order has slipped through the cracks of the system - still no TV. On Monday I call, rant gently, and the order is re-issued. [ALSO NAME WITHELD] then call to agree delivery of telly - can't do it until Thursday.

Its interesting doing without TV for two weeks...it happens to be our only one.

1) I spend more time down the Golf range.
2) We've actually booked our holiday (half of it anyway)
3) We've only really started missing it now - as the Mrs wants Wimbledon in HiDef.

With any luck it'll rain until then anyway so we won't miss a thing. rolleyes

I quite like LG kit. But I can't say I trust it anymore. Still - by the time this next one conks out I should be able to buy a LCD 50" for the price of a packet of crisps anyway.

Apache

39,731 posts

315 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
Just a point re the LG ranting. They and Samsung manufacture screens for practically all of the manufacturers at present . I believe Pioneer or Panasonic (always get them mixed up) make their own

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
PJ S said:
As you've been given a refund, then you're under no obligation to spend the money there,
I have been given "gift cards" so I can only spend them at the store. (To be honest thats a good thing otherwise the wife would make me spend the money on something sensible!)

I think I will hangon for the new Pioneer screens then, they did say that they will price match on TV's, its just waiting for them to get them in.

Thanks for the good advice !

bandit

derestrictor

18,764 posts

292 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
The new Pioneers are truly phenomenal but won't be quite so el cheapo as eveything else at the mo.

Best black level since Vin Deisel did that nasty pterodactyls in space flick plus other tweaks rendering greatness, to be sure.