BT Home Hub, Apple Airport, Apple Aport Express....
Discussion
olf said:
Is anybody here using all this junk together and if so hows it going?
A mate of mine set up his new shiny airport extreme with a printer and external harddrive, plugged into his homehub and it worked 'out of the box' (his words)
He's not a geek. He didnt ring me during setup/install of above 'junk'
So it must have worked 'out of the box'...I will be switching to BT Total Broadband this week hopefully (if I can get a MAC out of Pipex) and getting the Home Hub. I will initially be connecting via Ethernet which I assume is pretty straight forward. Only had a USB modem before.
However, long term I am planning to buy an Airport Extreme card for my Imac to go wireless, this will allow me to give BT Vision a try. Can someone confirm for me, that I can connect to the Home Hub with just the Airport Extreme card and that I don't need an Airport Base Station? BT's website says just a card but all the Mac literature relating to Airport sort of implies you need a Base Station too.
For wireless connection, BT say the minimum system requirements for a Mac are OS 10.42 (
That's not a typo). I'm somewhat behind the times on 10.3.9, anyone know if it will work?
Has anyone tried BT Vision yet? It seems a pretty cheap way to get a Freeview enabled PVR if nothing else, I'm particularly interested in the practicalities of the On Demand content. As it comes over the broadband connection i was wondering what the picture quality was like, whether it streams smoothly, or you have to wait for downloads.
However, long term I am planning to buy an Airport Extreme card for my Imac to go wireless, this will allow me to give BT Vision a try. Can someone confirm for me, that I can connect to the Home Hub with just the Airport Extreme card and that I don't need an Airport Base Station? BT's website says just a card but all the Mac literature relating to Airport sort of implies you need a Base Station too.
For wireless connection, BT say the minimum system requirements for a Mac are OS 10.42 (
That's not a typo). I'm somewhat behind the times on 10.3.9, anyone know if it will work?Has anyone tried BT Vision yet? It seems a pretty cheap way to get a Freeview enabled PVR if nothing else, I'm particularly interested in the practicalities of the On Demand content. As it comes over the broadband connection i was wondering what the picture quality was like, whether it streams smoothly, or you have to wait for downloads.
bluest2 said:
I will be switching to BT Total Broadband this week hopefully (if I can get a MAC out of Pipex) and getting the Home Hub. I will initially be connecting via Ethernet which I assume is pretty straight forward. Only had a USB modem before.
Yep easy. Works better with Apple.bluest2 said:
However, long term I am planning to buy an Airport Extreme card for my Imac to go wireless, this will allow me to give BT Vision a try. Can someone confirm for me, that I can connect to the Home Hub with just the Airport Extreme card and that I don't need an Airport Base Station? BT's website says just a card but all the Mac literature relating to Airport sort of implies you need a Base Station too.
Confirmed. No problem.bluest2 said:
For wireless connection, BT say the minimum system requirements for a Mac are OS 10.42 (
That's not a typo). I'm somewhat behind the times on 10.3.9, anyone know if it will work?
BT speaking out of their arse. I'm bang up to date at 10.4.1 so figure that out! You'll be fine with 10.3.9. I'm pretty sure WPA security is supported with 10.3.9 as well.
That's not a typo). I'm somewhat behind the times on 10.3.9, anyone know if it will work?In short I have dumped my Airport base station. Once you work out how to configure the BT Home Hub it actually works very nicely indeed and my Airport Expresses are actually working a lot better when piping music around the house.
Apple Airport (whether Extreme or not) is just a brand name for 802.11 wireless ethernet aka Wifi.
In the PC world it's often found that wireless cards work best with routers / base stations from the same manufacturer, however I've never had trouble connecting to any third-party wireless base station from a Mac (and I've had them all from the first Airport 802.11b to the latest 802.11g/n)
Why else do you see all those sad Maclots in coffee shops with their iBooks/MacBooks/PowerBooks/MBPs???
Connecting a Mac (either laptop or desktop) with Airport built-in to a base station (whoever makes it) is just a question of discovering the network (should be automatic with basic settings), connecting, then setting up security the way you want it. I advise MAC address filtering and WPA2 encryption but you may not want to go that far. Refer to the base station's manual for what it supports and go for the maximum security you can (and choose a
ing complicated password).
Now the tricky thing is this Airport Express. I don't have one so don't have first-hand info on how to configure one. The general idea is that it's configured by your Mac to be on the same subnet and security as your main base station (which I assume is the Home Hub?). Once this is the case, the Airport Express acts as a Wifi repeater, but also appears in iTunes Preferences as 'remote speakers' which you can play tunes through (with the line-out on the Airport Express).
I assume it's similar to the AppleTV, which I do have, and you definitely need to configure it somehow to connect to the home wireless network. Difference is that the AppleTV has an interface, and you can tell it which network to connect to. The Airport Extreme is just a box connected to the wall...
Of course, if your mate plugged it in and it all 'just worked' - of course it did, but the entire wireless network would be wide open for any neighbour to use his bandwidth to download anything he liked, or if he was a clueless Windows user, could be up to the eyeballs in viruses and trojans and launching attacks on remote sites, which would look like it came from your network.
Secure your wireless network, it's amazing how many people still don't. I won't bore you with my tale of wandering round the Square Mile with a hacked Linux scanner and finding tens of open networks in various big companies, but if you're paying for broadband then you should get to use it all and not have someone else be downloading torrents off it and slowing it down for your home.
Once you've added some security, it can get tricky. It's easy enough to plug a laptop into your Home Hub (assuming this has an Ethernet port, I have no idea what a Home Hub is but I'm assuming it's a generic wireless router) and configure it via the internal web interface. The trick will be, once secured, accessing the Airport Express and telling it to use the new security settings.
It will probably be as easy as using the Airport Admin Utility in /Applications/Utilities on the Mac, to be honest. Either that or iTunes will find it.
I've set my sister's family up with a Mac Mini and a MacBook, and both connect to their broadband line using a OneTel-supplied wireless router, which is meant to suck. But it works, and it worked first time. Don't be scared, Apple kit tends to do what it says on the tin.
Of course, any other Apple questions, I'm here
In the PC world it's often found that wireless cards work best with routers / base stations from the same manufacturer, however I've never had trouble connecting to any third-party wireless base station from a Mac (and I've had them all from the first Airport 802.11b to the latest 802.11g/n)
Why else do you see all those sad Maclots in coffee shops with their iBooks/MacBooks/PowerBooks/MBPs???

Connecting a Mac (either laptop or desktop) with Airport built-in to a base station (whoever makes it) is just a question of discovering the network (should be automatic with basic settings), connecting, then setting up security the way you want it. I advise MAC address filtering and WPA2 encryption but you may not want to go that far. Refer to the base station's manual for what it supports and go for the maximum security you can (and choose a
ing complicated password).Now the tricky thing is this Airport Express. I don't have one so don't have first-hand info on how to configure one. The general idea is that it's configured by your Mac to be on the same subnet and security as your main base station (which I assume is the Home Hub?). Once this is the case, the Airport Express acts as a Wifi repeater, but also appears in iTunes Preferences as 'remote speakers' which you can play tunes through (with the line-out on the Airport Express).
I assume it's similar to the AppleTV, which I do have, and you definitely need to configure it somehow to connect to the home wireless network. Difference is that the AppleTV has an interface, and you can tell it which network to connect to. The Airport Extreme is just a box connected to the wall...
Of course, if your mate plugged it in and it all 'just worked' - of course it did, but the entire wireless network would be wide open for any neighbour to use his bandwidth to download anything he liked, or if he was a clueless Windows user, could be up to the eyeballs in viruses and trojans and launching attacks on remote sites, which would look like it came from your network.
Secure your wireless network, it's amazing how many people still don't. I won't bore you with my tale of wandering round the Square Mile with a hacked Linux scanner and finding tens of open networks in various big companies, but if you're paying for broadband then you should get to use it all and not have someone else be downloading torrents off it and slowing it down for your home.
Once you've added some security, it can get tricky. It's easy enough to plug a laptop into your Home Hub (assuming this has an Ethernet port, I have no idea what a Home Hub is but I'm assuming it's a generic wireless router) and configure it via the internal web interface. The trick will be, once secured, accessing the Airport Express and telling it to use the new security settings.
It will probably be as easy as using the Airport Admin Utility in /Applications/Utilities on the Mac, to be honest. Either that or iTunes will find it.
I've set my sister's family up with a Mac Mini and a MacBook, and both connect to their broadband line using a OneTel-supplied wireless router, which is meant to suck. But it works, and it worked first time. Don't be scared, Apple kit tends to do what it says on the tin.
Of course, any other Apple questions, I'm here

Thanks Olf and Cyberface, most comprehensive and answers my concerns.
Cyberface - The Home Hub is the name BT give to the ADSL router they supply, the only difference to any other, I think, is that it can be used to receive BT Vision TV service as well. They supply a set top box that connects to it wirelessly (is that a word?). This I intend to try in the new year.
I wont be using Airport Express in my ADSL set up, just the Airport card in the Mac communicating with Home Hub. What is likely effective range. The Hub will have to be close to the TV in the living room and the Mac is in the back bedroom upstairs. This is a straight line of about 12m through one floor and a brick wall.
Thanks for your help.
Cyberface - The Home Hub is the name BT give to the ADSL router they supply, the only difference to any other, I think, is that it can be used to receive BT Vision TV service as well. They supply a set top box that connects to it wirelessly (is that a word?). This I intend to try in the new year.
I wont be using Airport Express in my ADSL set up, just the Airport card in the Mac communicating with Home Hub. What is likely effective range. The Hub will have to be close to the TV in the living room and the Mac is in the back bedroom upstairs. This is a straight line of about 12m through one floor and a brick wall.
Thanks for your help.
bluest2 said:
Thanks Olf and Cyberface, most comprehensive and answers my concerns.
Cyberface - The Home Hub is the name BT give to the ADSL router they supply, the only difference to any other, I think, is that it can be used to receive BT Vision TV service as well. They supply a set top box that connects to it wirelessly (is that a word?). This I intend to try in the new year.
I wont be using Airport Express in my ADSL set up, just the Airport card in the Mac communicating with Home Hub. What is likely effective range. The Hub will have to be close to the TV in the living room and the Mac is in the back bedroom upstairs. This is a straight line of about 12m through one floor and a brick wall.
Thanks for your help.
Depends on the Hub.Cyberface - The Home Hub is the name BT give to the ADSL router they supply, the only difference to any other, I think, is that it can be used to receive BT Vision TV service as well. They supply a set top box that connects to it wirelessly (is that a word?). This I intend to try in the new year.
I wont be using Airport Express in my ADSL set up, just the Airport card in the Mac communicating with Home Hub. What is likely effective range. The Hub will have to be close to the TV in the living room and the Mac is in the back bedroom upstairs. This is a straight line of about 12m through one floor and a brick wall.
Thanks for your help.
I've got 4 bars of reception on all my Mac laptops upstairs, in any of the rooms (1st floor) with the Airport Base Station in the office (basement, -1st floor).
Assuming the Home Hub has the same wifi transmit power as the Airport base station, you won't have any problems whatsoever.
Bluest2,
From my experience, one wall and a floor should be ok for wireless range. I am running a Netgear router with an Airport Express for AirTunes and wireless printing. It worked with my BT Home Hub as well but I ditched the hub due to stability problems and the fact that it liked to randomly update itself when it felt like it.....
I'm thinking about BT Vision as well at some point but, rather than having the hub sited next to the TV, have come round to the idea of PowerLine networking. I bought some Home Plug thingies last week and have been very impressed. One goes into the router and I have another upstairs going into a switch with server & NAS attached. They give me a nice stable 200Mb (rated) connection and you can have them sited at strategic points around the house where you need reliable LAN access.
Just my tuppence worth
kris.
ps. my mac works fine with it all as well....
From my experience, one wall and a floor should be ok for wireless range. I am running a Netgear router with an Airport Express for AirTunes and wireless printing. It worked with my BT Home Hub as well but I ditched the hub due to stability problems and the fact that it liked to randomly update itself when it felt like it.....
I'm thinking about BT Vision as well at some point but, rather than having the hub sited next to the TV, have come round to the idea of PowerLine networking. I bought some Home Plug thingies last week and have been very impressed. One goes into the router and I have another upstairs going into a switch with server & NAS attached. They give me a nice stable 200Mb (rated) connection and you can have them sited at strategic points around the house where you need reliable LAN access.
Just my tuppence worth

kris.
ps. my mac works fine with it all as well....
bluest2 said:
Thanks Olf and Cyberface, most comprehensive and answers my concerns.
Cyberface - The Home Hub is the name BT give to the ADSL router they supply, the only difference to any other, I think, is that it can be used to receive BT Vision TV service as well. They supply a set top box that connects to it wirelessly (is that a word?). This I intend to try in the new year.
I wont be using Airport Express in my ADSL set up, just the Airport card in the Mac communicating with Home Hub. What is likely effective range. The Hub will have to be close to the TV in the living room and the Mac is in the back bedroom upstairs. This is a straight line of about 12m through one floor and a brick wall.
Thanks for your help.
The range of my homehub far exceeds that of the Apple Airport.Cyberface - The Home Hub is the name BT give to the ADSL router they supply, the only difference to any other, I think, is that it can be used to receive BT Vision TV service as well. They supply a set top box that connects to it wirelessly (is that a word?). This I intend to try in the new year.
I wont be using Airport Express in my ADSL set up, just the Airport card in the Mac communicating with Home Hub. What is likely effective range. The Hub will have to be close to the TV in the living room and the Mac is in the back bedroom upstairs. This is a straight line of about 12m through one floor and a brick wall.
Thanks for your help.
I used to use two airport expresses to extend the range of the Airport. With the homehub I don't need to do this.
The homehub is on the 2nd floor of our house and good signal strength is available in all rooms through thick walls. 12m will be no problem at all.
krispy said:
Bluest2,
From my experience, one wall and a floor should be ok for wireless range. I am running a Netgear router with an Airport Express for AirTunes and wireless printing. It worked with my BT Home Hub as well but I ditched the hub due to stability problems and the fact that it liked to randomly update itself when it felt like it.....
I'm thinking about BT Vision as well at some point but, rather than having the hub sited next to the TV, have come round to the idea of PowerLine networking. I bought some Home Plug thingies last week and have been very impressed. One goes into the router and I have another upstairs going into a switch with server & NAS attached. They give me a nice stable 200Mb (rated) connection and you can have them sited at strategic points around the house where you need reliable LAN access.
Just my tuppence worth
kris.
ps. my mac works fine with it all as well....
BT seem to think that the auto update facility is a benefit. What problems does it cause you? Am I correct in thinking that you can't use BT Vision unless you use the BT Home Hub? Have you seen BT Vision working, I don't know of anyone using it and don't really want to be the early adopter lumbered with something that isn't very good. That's the only thing that's stopping me ordering it at the same time as the BroadbandFrom my experience, one wall and a floor should be ok for wireless range. I am running a Netgear router with an Airport Express for AirTunes and wireless printing. It worked with my BT Home Hub as well but I ditched the hub due to stability problems and the fact that it liked to randomly update itself when it felt like it.....
I'm thinking about BT Vision as well at some point but, rather than having the hub sited next to the TV, have come round to the idea of PowerLine networking. I bought some Home Plug thingies last week and have been very impressed. One goes into the router and I have another upstairs going into a switch with server & NAS attached. They give me a nice stable 200Mb (rated) connection and you can have them sited at strategic points around the house where you need reliable LAN access.
Just my tuppence worth

kris.
ps. my mac works fine with it all as well....
I think I'll leave the power line networking for now (sounds quite in depth), and see how we get on with the basic setup. It all starts to get very confusing very quickly once I'm out of my comfort zone. my brain is starting to hurt just thinking about one Mac and a wireless router.
As the MAC code still hasn't arrived from Pipex yet I can't actually do anything. As soon as it does i'll sign up for broadband, get it working via ethernet and then look at getting the Airport card and going wireless.
bluest2 said:
BT seem to think that the auto update facility is a benefit. What problems does it cause you? Am I correct in thinking that you can't use BT Vision unless you use the BT Home Hub? Have you seen BT Vision working, I don't know of anyone using it and don't really want to be the early adopter lumbered with something that isn't very good. That's the only thing that's stopping me ordering it at the same time as the Broadband.
It depends what you are using the broadband for, but (and I am quite unlucky with things like this) I found the thing tended to update itself at really inconvenient moments, such as when I was in the middle of a large download. I can imagine that if it did it in the middle of a skype or other VOIP call it might be a little irritating. It might be ok now that they've been around for a while, but when I got mine it was continually either updating itself or restarting for no reason at all. As I already had the Netgear, I just went back to using that.bluest2 said:
I think I'll leave the power line networking for now (sounds quite in depth), and see how we get on with the basic setup. It all starts to get very confusing very quickly once I'm out of my comfort zone. my brain is starting to hurt just thinking about one Mac and a wireless router.
The powerline stuff is a piece of cake and just as simple, possibly simpler, as setting up wireless properly. Two units that are like over-sized power plugs with an ethernet socket on each. You plug one in to a socket near the router and connect it to the router with an ethernet cable. Plug another one in to a socket near the remote computer/XBox/PVR/whatever and again connect with a cable. The things automatically find each other across your home electrical network and work out of the box. I got Devolo (http://www.devolo.co.uk) units and they run with 128bit AES encryption once you run the small setup utility. They work for me but I know there are more ways than one to skin a cat 
bluest2 said:
As the MAC code still hasn't arrived from Pipex yet I can't actually do anything. As soon as it does i'll sign up for broadband, get it working via ethernet and then look at getting the Airport card and going wireless.
Best of luck 
Many thanks for your help. BT Home Hub is up and running, works perfectly with Apple Airport Extreme. It was quite a surprise that the installation cd worked perfectly. I might do some experiments to test the range around the house when i'm off next week.
I'm a touch dissapointed by the speed of the broadband. It seems to fluctuate between 2Mbps and 3Mbps, was hoping for a bit more as it's advertised as upto 8Mbps, and I'm told I'm quite close to the exchange. I have a feeling that it may be the wiring in the house as it looks very old and crusty in places.
I'm a touch dissapointed by the speed of the broadband. It seems to fluctuate between 2Mbps and 3Mbps, was hoping for a bit more as it's advertised as upto 8Mbps, and I'm told I'm quite close to the exchange. I have a feeling that it may be the wiring in the house as it looks very old and crusty in places.
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


