Should Maths 'should be optional'?
Should Maths 'should be optional'?
Author
Discussion

mrs fish

Original Poster:

30,018 posts

289 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Maths could be replaced by numeracy skills, suggests the union president

Secondary school pupils should be able to drop maths for GCSE and study more practical numeracy skills, says a teachers' union leader.

"Mathematics has always been a main subject, but why?", said Terry Bladen, president of the National Association of Schoolmasters Union of Women Teachers. Speaking at the union's annual conference in Bournemouth, Terry Bladen, who teaches maths, suggested a more radical re-think of what was compulsory for older pupils.

"I would always argue that pupils should be numerate, with numeracy taught throughout all the key stages, but numeracy can be divorced from mathematics.

"How often do the majority of people need or use mathematical concepts once they have left school?"

Allowing pupils to drop maths at the age of 14 would create more time in the curriculum and would alleviate the shortage of specialist maths teachers, Mr Bladen suggested, And it would still allow enthusiastic pupils to choose the subject for GCSE if they wanted.

"Maths classes would for the first time be made up of pupils who actually enjoyed and wanted to pursue the subject.

"This would also help schools to some extent overcome the problem of recruiting specialist maths teachers. It would also allow more time in the curriculum for other subjects," he said.


I'm a unsure about this. On one hand thinking back to when I was at school, I hated Maths with a passion and would have loved the opportunity to opt out of it, but now I am older it makes me wonder whether getting rid of Maths as we know it would be the start of an even greater decline in education. I'm definitely on the fence on this one.

But saying that, I have never needed to remember anything I was taught in Maths, apart from the obvious that is.

plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Why not make school as a whole optional...?

FFS whatever next, English to be replaced with a linguaphone course?

And we wonder why this country is going down the armitage shanks.

Matt.

miniman

30,237 posts

293 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
A good knowledge of Maths would lead you to deduce that:

Mega = 1000
Giga = 1000000
Nano = 0.00001

Thus Googol wins you a million pounds!

See, maths does have a purpose!

Gaffer

7,156 posts

308 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
IIFC in South Africa Maths is optional as is most of our Core subjects.

Claire

lois22

14,706 posts

283 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
I loved maths at GCSE but DESPISED it at A level so quit!!!
I still have to do Application of number which is things that are more suitable for future use. Who's ever going to need all the "completing the square" equations?!

eric mc

125,946 posts

296 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Numeracy - what's that? We used to call it Arithmetic.
In many ways I agree - I studied higher maths at college. That included Euclidean geometry, trigonometary, algebra, differental calculus, statistics, probability theory etc. I can safely say that virtually none of this information has been of any practical use to me in "the real world" - and I'm an accountant.
Granted, if we'd been taught some of the practical spplications of some of this escoteric stuff, it might have been more interesting. For example, it was only years afterwards that I discovered that calculus had been invented by Isaac Newton to try and calculate orbits and paths of planets, satellites and comets.

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Maths was fine until it goes stupid with rubbish like;

i squared = -1

incorrigible

13,668 posts

292 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all

miniman said: A good knowledge of Maths would lead you to deduce that:

Mega = 1000
Giga = 1000000
Nano = 0.00001

Thus Googol wins you a million pounds!

See, maths does have a purpose!
No that would be the latin influence over the SI unit nomenclature

Buffalo

5,488 posts

285 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
The only reason that these dumbasses want to get rid of maths is because they have already done this country out of industry...

Of course nobody needs maths anymore, because nowadays when kids leave school, instead of doing aprenticeships for engineering firms, or technical skills in house at manufacturers etc, they become telephone sales people and leisure managers etc etc

Go on get rid of maths, science, english etc etc, see if i care, but don't come running to me in twenty years time, when all thats left of britain is a jobless schmuck of a once decent nation....

[pi55ed off rant mode turned off now.... ]

lois22

14,706 posts

283 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
I'm on a maths and science scholarship @ college but that doesn't stop me hating maths!!
The option on "traditional" maths should be there for the odd person who wants to do it!!!

Buffalo

5,488 posts

285 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
>>>>>>>"This would also help schools to some extent overcome the problem of recruiting specialist maths teachers. " <<<<<<<<

This is the real reson for dropping subjects - they can't get the staff, so are making arguements for dropping the subjects saying kids don't need them!!

It fg bollox and this guy should hang for it, cos i wouldn't want him teaching my kids.....

incorrigible

13,668 posts

292 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
Maths is usefull because it teaches abstract concepts, (like i squared is -1) Without the ability to learn things that don't make sense you couldn't possibly imagine building a working microwave oven for instance

This cooks your dinner quicker so you can spend more time in the garage

The downgrading of maths to arithmetic is just plain wrong

big_treacle

1,727 posts

291 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
think i had a drunken argument on a similar topic over the weekend. i recall we decided that a big problem with the whole giving-kids-too-many-education-options is that they'll ditch subjects without really realising how useful they are. i remember being in a maths lesson and demanding to know the point of learning quadratic equations and matrices. now that i'm a software developer i'm quite glad i bothered to learn! of course, my friends who are drug rehab officers & tree surgeons probably don't have to do much rearranging of formulas on a regular basis. but at least they have a basic understanding so that they could possibly change career slightly easier at a later date. sort of thing. maybe. paerhaps they should give kids a really good idea of jobs & things that they couldn't do if they give a particular subject up.

eric mc

125,946 posts

296 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
That was the point I was making. If the practical applications of the more "ethereal" elements of pure maths was emphasised, then maybe students would find the subject more interesting.

As it is, I come across young people who don't know how many feet or yards there are in a mile, or even more inexcusable, how many metres there are in a kilometre!

lois22

14,706 posts

283 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
1000

big_treacle

1,727 posts

291 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
i heard a girl ask her boyfriend once, 'how many halves are there in a football match?'

lois22

14,706 posts

283 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
lol! U do get some thick people @ footy matches!
I heard a girl on saturday - must have been about 16 so must know thr rough rules of footy say "so is it whoever scores 1st wins?" durr!

incorrigible

13,668 posts

292 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all

big_treacle said: i heard a girl ask her boyfriend once, 'how many halves are there in a football match?'
Don't know whether to answer this or let Loiss

Completely agree Eric, people say what's the use of calculus in the real world ? But a friend asked me what the volume of a pyramid was (don't ask) Only A-level maths saved the day that time

big_treacle

1,727 posts

291 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
then again, a friend of mine with a degree in chemistry asked why, if asbestos is soooo dangerous, they don't just dispose of it by BURNING it. i guess education is useful so long as you have a brain made of brain and not mashed potato.

egomeister

7,614 posts

294 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2003
quotequote all
What are they trying to do, make it so there is no challenge left at all in eductation? Don't they realise that if there is no maths, then there wouldn't be computers, cars and all those other things that everyone takes for granted?