Testing temperature gauge - How?
Testing temperature gauge - How?
Author
Discussion

JohnL

Original Poster:

1,766 posts

296 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
I've a funny hot running/overheating problem (in another thread under "engines").

I'm beginnning to suspect that maybe it's just that the temp gauge itself is faulty. Is there any way of testing it, in or out of the car, other than fitting a new one to see if it makes any difference?

plipton

1,302 posts

289 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
If the motor's overheating it isn't down to the gauge.

Check/replace the otter switch and/or fit an over-ride switch to switch on the fans. Also, make sure the cooling system is sound and leak free and it isn't blocked at all.

JohnL

Original Poster:

1,766 posts

296 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Some evidence suggests it really is overheating, and some suggests it isn't and the gauge/sensor is making it up.

If I switch off and immediately back on (either the engine or just the ignition) again, it reads several degrees cooler. I've flushed out the cooling system, which seemed to help for a few days, but it's running hot, on and off, again now. The (Vauxhall) main dealer has replaced the temp sensor and the thermostat, which haven't made much difference.

I was looking for a good (ie quick, easy and cheap!)way of testing whether or not the gauge is telling pork pies.

plipton

1,302 posts

289 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Does the rad fan come on OK?

Is so then that proves the thermostat, otter and fan's OK and chances are the gauge is duff. If not there could be a problem in the cooling system (knackered water pump etc).

Assuming the temp gauge sender is a heat-variable resistor or similar, then a multimeter should find the problem fairly quickly(assuming you can find the spec for the sender on the Internet fairly easily)

>> Edited by plipton on Wednesday 23 April 13:59

cnh1990

3,035 posts

294 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Easy way is to stick a thermometer in the coolant and compare it to the temp gauge in the car. I use the type found in a kitchen section to test the temp of roasting meat in the oven. Just start the car from cool with the radiator or header tank cap off so you don't get scalded by the coolant and warm the car up at idle.

Calvin

HiRich

3,337 posts

293 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
To check the sender units, you'll need:
- A primus stove and beaker of water (or a kettle)
- some anti-freeze in the water (this should allow you to squeeze 100 degrees out without the water boiling)
- A multimeter (fan switch) or jury-rigged fly leads (gauge sender)
- A wire coat hanger
- A mate
- A thermometer

Remove the gauge, and use the coat hanger to rig it into the beaker so only the 'wet' end sits in the water (obviously you don't want to dip the terminals in the water).
To test a switch, you can move from the car, and connect the multimeter to seek continuity.
To test the sender, you need the flyleads (it's not wise to have a primus stove under the engine bay!). You can test the unit away from the car, and the flyleads connect it back to the wiring loom. Have your mate turn on the ignition (but of course don't start up, because you won't hav any coolant in the engine), and sit watching the temp gauge.

Start warming the water, and watch the thermometer.
For the switch, you will see it connect. Note the temp it does this.
For the temp gauge, compare notes with your mate (it might be worth him having write it down). If your gauge is calibrated, compare 60/70/80/90/100 degrees points on gauge and thermometer.
If your gauge just has marks, note the thermometer temperature at "gauge starts to move", "normal" and "the point the gauge goes to that's worrying you" and also the gauge position at 60/70/80/90/100 degrees.

You then know the true temperature for any gauge reading (and so whether the reading is accurate, and whether the problem is true overheating or a sender/gauge inaccuracy).

plipton

1,302 posts

289 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all

cnh1990 said: Easy way is to stick a thermometer in the coolant and compare it to the temp gauge in the car. I use the type found in a kitchen section to test the temp of roasting meat in the oven. Just start the car from cool with the radiator or header tank cap off so you don't get scalded by the coolant and warm the car up at idle.

Calvin

Good idea but be VERY careful.

The pressure cap stops the coolant boiling at too-low a temperature. Make sure you switch off and let he engine cool down once you are happy or otherwise about the gauge.


Under no circumstances allow the engine to reach a high enough temperature for the fan to cut in with the pressure cap off

Good luck

Oi_Oi_Savaloy

2,315 posts

291 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
How about just giving it a spelling test?

JohnL

Original Poster:

1,766 posts

296 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Thanks folks, a few things to try here.

The dealer was suggesting a head gasket failure, which (a) has me worried and (b) is almost certainly wrong (no loss of coolant, no residual pressure, no mayonnaise).