Sars 'has potential to be more serious than Aids'
Sars 'has potential to be more serious than Aids'
Author
Discussion

mrs fish

Original Poster:

30,018 posts

289 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
A UK medical expert has warned the Sars virus has the potential to be more devastating than the Aids epidemic. Dr Patrick Dixon said it was not inevitable, but there was a 25% chance of a global Sars pandemic.

Dr Dixon, who is an expert on Aids and considered Europe's leading futurist, predicting global trends, said the crisis needed to be taken out of the hands of health chiefs and handled by world leaders.

He said: "This is not a yuppie disease contracted by air travellers. That is a pathetic reaction that will put the whole world at risk. It is worth remembering that Aids has infected 80 million people so far over a 15 to 20 year period.

"Aids spreads slowly so we can track it and plan for it. We have effective anti-viral drugs which can prolong life. But this is different, we don't have the time. This is a far more serious epidemic potentially than Aids."

Dr Dixon said his main concern was not the number of infections in Beijing, but rural, isolated areas in China and around the world. He said: "China has draconian measures in place in a bid to contain the virus, but in a country like India which is chaotic with minimum health provision, the potential for spreading the virus is huge."

Dr Dixon, a fellow at the Centre for Management Development at London Business School, said if current trends continued there could be a billion cases within 60 weeks. He has called on world leaders to address the problem as a matter of national security. He added: "Unless the virus spontaneously mutates into a less dangerous form, the only hope we have is to mount an immediate aggressive global response at the highest levels against Sars, something we've not yet seen.

"If things continue as they are, with a mixture of denial, confusion, delay, ignorance, bad decisions, poor data gathering, official decision-making paralysis, incompetence, concealment, secrecy and government apathy in some parts of the world, then a pandemic is surely only a matter of time."

plipton

1,302 posts

289 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Bored again are we, dear?

mrs fish

Original Poster:

30,018 posts

289 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all

plipton said: Bored again are we, dear?


As always my dear Mr P.....

Just like to make sure no-one else gets as bored as I am.... hence all the crap stories

plipton

1,302 posts

289 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Well, rather than find crap stories, why not invent a few of your own?

Much more satisfying - especially if you can wind up a few eejuts along the way

gargamel

16,432 posts

292 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
same experts who predicted that aids would have killed half the population of the world by 2005 ?

Discredited - scaremongering to keep their funding up.

Himans have not yet found the cure to a single virus as yet - so I won't hold my breathe for the Sars cure

(anyway at fatality rates of less than 3% of the infected population - hardly a big worry is it ?)

agent006

12,058 posts

295 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all

gargamel said:
(anyway at fatality rates of less than 3% of the infected population - hardly a big worry is it ?)


That would depend on whether you were the 3% or not. Might be a bit worrying then.

phil1

621 posts

313 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Read that it had a fatality rate of 3.7%, just below the 4% of the 1918 flu epidemic which killed 20 million!!

Toffer

1,528 posts

292 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
These nasty viruses always seem to have rather odd origins...just goes to show what happens if you get intimate with chickens

Didn't AIDS come from camels...must have been nasty seeing how those viruses got into humans

Today, Toronto has been closed for air transfers as one of my colleagues has been told today that he has to fly through Seattle instead of Toronto...

gargamel

16,432 posts

292 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Phil

apples and onions old fruit

we are a far more healthy nation and race since 1918
when many in europe had been on low rations - poor housing etc throughout the war

many people at a low ebb healthwise

Now in 2003 - central heating - more understand of rehydrating during flu outbreaks etc

different prospect

icamm

2,153 posts

291 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all

gargamel said: Phil

apples and onions old fruit

we are a far more healthy nation and race since 1918
when many in europe had been on low rations - poor housing etc throughout the war

many people at a low ebb healthwise

Now in 2003 - central heating - more understand of rehydrating during flu outbreaks etc

different prospect
Sorry I don't follow you. Most of the third world do not have better conditions than 1918.

If 4% fatality rate killed 20 million it follows that 500 million were infected. That's not just the UK being infected.

If the current SARS rate is 3.7% then and it's spreading rapidly worldwide with no cure then the real worry is how fast and how far. If 500 million get infected world wide 18.5 million will die.

It may possibly be a lower fatality rate in the healthier countries than in the least healthy but at the moment the 3 or 3.&% is based on what we know. We don't know much about China's size of the problem really.

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Dr Dixon may be an expert on AIDS but is he/she an expert on sars? If not then what is the opinion worth?

If 18.5 million people die just think of the extra space on the roads.

ATG

23,878 posts

303 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
There are so many differences btwn 1918 and 2003 that any comparisson should be made very carefully. Conditions in developing countries have changed enormously too. Transportation and communication have been revolutionised. This is not obviously a good or a bad thing. It means a panicing population could try and leg it creating refugee camps that would be a tinder box for infection. It could also mean that the spread of the disease can be better monitorred and resources moved into effected areas.

SARS doesn't appear to be particularly infectious. It should be relatively easy to contain through quarantine. It would appear that in China the process is being royally f**ked up through little more than incompetence. The outbreak seems to be largely in hospitals and their staff ffs.

p.s. this Dr Dixon geeze is a "futurist"?? Gnuh? What is needed is good honest epidemiology ... and a good honest one will answer almost any question by saying "haven't got a clue". Too many factors to consider, too many unknowns, virtually no way of doing pertinent experiments. It's like Economics, only less precise.

>> Edited by ATG on Wednesday 23 April 18:36

Mr E

23,108 posts

290 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Just got back from Beijing about 3 weeks ago. Got a fever about 9 days afterwards.

Crapped myself.

icamm

2,153 posts

291 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all

voyds9 said: Dr Dixon may be an expert on AIDS but is he/she an expert on sars? If not then what is the opinion worth?
Oh I agree on this. Plus I think he's been proved wrong with his AIDS predictions so the report itsel doesn't count for much. I just didn't understand the argument about the difference between the 1918 flu epidemic and the potential of SARS (not that it's wrong I just didn't understand what the point was ).

If 18.5 million people die just think of the extra space on the roads.
Unfortunately that's likely to be in 3rd world countries or the Far East. So won't benefit us much

icamm

2,153 posts

291 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
ATG,

Agreed. The world has changed and rapid transport and technology is both helping the spread but also the speed to find a cure.

The problem will get really bad if it hits some of the poorest of the world whose health is probably as bad, or worse, than in 1918. The weakest and least able to fit off even the normal flu.

As I said, the biggest worry is how far and how fast, and as you said it appears to be fairly slow moving at the moment (in terms off number of infections). However, it is also, apparantly, mutating rapidly so who knows what's next.

As atleast one Doctor has said on the news. The problem for scientists is that they have mainly ignored this type of virus becuase the worst it got to until now was the flu.

At the moment there is no real need to worry but it certainly is worth keeping an eye on the situation.

They have now effectively quaranteed parts of Canada as well as Hong Kong and China so it's definately moving.

John_S4x4

1,364 posts

288 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
On a side note, I was reading about the bird flu problem in the Netherlands. 16 million birds killed so far Perhaps Mrs Fish would like to divulge the details on that one. I then read that the SARS virus is related to the Bird flu virus !!
Regards John S

garethsm

457 posts

283 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
We're forgetting something... yes the world has changed for the better in that sanitation and healthcare has improved for all but the furthest reaches of the world, but so too has transportation and globalisation. The world is a much smaller place now, and whereas in 1918 it was extremely unusual for people to travel beyond their country's borders, in 2003 there are thousands upon thousands taking to the skies each day.

And all of these 'planes are notorious for spreading more minor bugs via the air-con systems to all passengers, so imagine what it could do with the SARS virus. In 1918 the epidemic spread outwards from an epicentre, gradually working it's way around the world. With SARS, infected areas are already all around the world - hundreds of 'epicentres' could easily make this a WORSE epidemic than 1918, even with the improvements in healthcare worldwide.

Best not to think about it too much, I guess... I read another article at the weekend which said the human race would be lucky to survive to the next century, so I'm just living each day as it comes.

I'll hop down off the now to give everyone else a chance!

Peace out

Psychobert

6,318 posts

287 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Lets not get back onto the evolution thread again, but if one accepts that with so many more millions on the planet stomping around these days compared to days of old, there are consequently a lot more bugs, (each human hosting quite a few), then the chances of one of these bugs changing into something nasty are far greater. Basic ecology; periods of huge population growth are usually followed by something that brings the numbers back down again, the plague for example. Aids was doing the job fairly well, but to me SARS looks far more likely to do the job better. Its possible to infect so many more in a given space of time..

Without doubt we are spreading this faster than it would naturally. This I think also means we are more likely to reach someone with a natural immunity. No idea how bad it will get, might just be a flash in the pan. Would have to say this one looks more unpleasant than the last couple..

planetdave

9,922 posts

284 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
We appear to have outrun our viability. Diseases are becoming resistant to our best efforts. Considering the overpopulation problem it may well be time that we get overun by the bugs. Shame on us humans but we are killing the planet

Mark.S

473 posts

308 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2003
quotequote all
Nature seems to have a habit of redressing the balance. Looks like the scales are tipping again!