For other nightowls - Caterham on BBC2
For other nightowls - Caterham on BBC2
Author
Discussion

FourWheelDrift

Original Poster:

92,406 posts

315 months

Friday 25th April 2003
quotequote all
Trouble at the top repeat (2000) with Reynard partnership......

littlegearl

3,139 posts

288 months

Friday 25th April 2003
quotequote all
yeah watching it...

agree with the bloke saying "the public doesn't trust caterham to build anything but the 7..."

jvaughan

6,025 posts

314 months

Friday 25th April 2003
quotequote all

littlegearl said: yeah watching it...

agree with the bloke saying "the public doesn't trust caterham to build anything but the 7..."


enough .. time for bed ...

jamesc

2,820 posts

315 months

Friday 25th April 2003
quotequote all
I thought Simon Nearn came over quite well; I liked his pro British stance and it is sad that Reynard folded. The concept of a sub £20,000 carbon tub had great appeal. I would rather buy a sub £20K high tech British car than a £30 motorbike contraption made accross the water. Simon wants to keep the Caterham British and has extended his deal with MG.

Good Luck to all at Caterham cars and here is to another 40 years.

James

bigairbox

51 posts

284 months

Friday 25th April 2003
quotequote all
hey guys cant belive that a post was put up so quickly on that...Im a little late because I taped a lot of it and was watching it again!!! Seriously want a 7 as a fun car and some piece of shit to drive to work when it rains...Ill be earning only 25K from auguast and just cant see that happening...I havent properly looked into it cos it just sounds like it would be too good to be true...maybe you know better. Insurance would screw me too cos Ill be only 23. Help my dream come true!!

Graham.J

5,420 posts

290 months

Friday 25th April 2003
quotequote all
Buy a 2nd hand one (westfield ), they can be picked up for as little as £4000 and insurance isn't that pad, I was quoted £1800 on my westfield for next year and I'll be 18.

eric mc

125,976 posts

296 months

Friday 25th April 2003
quotequote all
"Buy a 2nd hand one (Westfield)". Excuse me, a Westfield is NOT a Seven - as decided in the English courts in 1988. The best you can say is that Wesfields ( and all the other similar makes) are cars inspired by the Seven. The only Sevens are those originally built by Lotus (1957 to 1973) or those currently built by Caterham.

By the way, I am not against other manufacturers making these types of cars - just don't refer to them as "Sevens".

Graham.J

5,420 posts

290 months

Saturday 26th April 2003
quotequote all
History Shmishtory, you will get a nice example of a Westi for the same price as a shabby Caterham more often than not.

REAL Sevens are overpriced usually because of the 'history' behind the name, badge snobbery thats all it is


**Disclaimer: I have nothing against Caterham owners, we all afterall, own kit cars and must stick together in our sevenesque exploitations

eric mc

125,976 posts

296 months

Saturday 26th April 2003
quotequote all
Of course - but that is part of the motoring scene.

To some of us the history IS important. The fact that I own a car that was essentially designed by the great Colin Chapman matters to me. I grew up in the sixties and seventies when Chapman was probably the greatest racing car designer in the world and the Seven was part of all that.

I have nothing against Westfields. I think they are great cars too - but they are not Caterhams and they are not Sevens.

And regarding sosts - residual values are an inherent factor when deciding on a car. I can safely say that if I sold my Seven tomorrow I would probably get about £1,000 less than what I paid for it in 1996. In reality they are very cost effective cars to own and run - it's only the initial outlay that hurts.

superlightr

12,920 posts

294 months

Saturday 26th April 2003
quotequote all
the 7 also has the record for a production car around the 'ring. cant get better than that.

egomeister

7,614 posts

294 months

Saturday 26th April 2003
quotequote all

littlegearl said: yeah watching it...

agree with the bloke saying "the public doesn't trust caterham to build anything but the 7..."


I don't think that this is quite it. I don't think Caterham know how to build anything but the 7. Westfield (and other manufacturers) have embraced technology like bike engines and carbon and expanded into other areas with cars like the XTR2. I think the direction that Caterham are taking of developing their sole product further with a slightly more powerful engine or less weight will cost them dear. Caterham seem content to have history whilst others will be making it.

Graham.J

5,420 posts

290 months

Saturday 26th April 2003
quotequote all
Well said Steve, Westfield, history in the making

Have Westfield tried to beat the Caterhams time around the 'ring, I'm sure a 'busa would give the equivalent 7 a run for it's money.

smeagol

1,947 posts

315 months

Saturday 26th April 2003
quotequote all

eric mc said: Of course - but that is part of the motoring scene.

To some of us the history IS important. The fact that I own a car that was essentially designed by the great Colin Chapman matters to me. I grew up in the sixties and seventies when Chapman was probably the greatest racing car designer in the world and the Seven was part of all that.

I have nothing against Westfields. I think they are great cars too - but they are not Caterhams and they are not Sevens.

And regarding sosts - residual values are an inherent factor when deciding on a car. I can safely say that if I sold my Seven tomorrow I would probably get about £1,000 less than what I paid for it in 1996. In reality they are very cost effective cars to own and run - it's only the initial outlay that hurts.

This has been discussed Eric on here:
www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?p=3&f=30&t=33954&h=0

Seems to me you're looking through rose tinted specs. The modern Caterham was not designed by Colin Chapman in that there are very few components that are based on the original Lotus 7. The car has been developed and modified (and rightly so) but to argue that your car is essentially the Colin Chapman design and the Dax/Westfield are not, is not true. The other sevenesk cars have an equal right to say that the original concept was designed by the great Colin Chapman. Caterham have the right to call the name 7 (as you rightly say) because they bought the rights from Colin and can claim to be part of that history of the car but thats about as far as it gets. Don't forget that colin wanted to move on in technology as he always was a great innovator and certainly would not have developed the seven as it is now. I don't mean this as any disrepect I like what Caterham have done and believe it is a design icon.

The caterham is a fine car but it IS overpriced £30k+ for the R400 is far too much. Second hand sales are cheap if the car has been driven (see my calculations in the previous thread you're talking a minimum of 30p/mile depreciation which is a lot) You'll only sell yours for about £1k less since 1996 if you haven't driven it. If you have I'm afraid you're talking b*ll*cks and I suggest you actually do a search for Caterhams for sale on the web you'll find that only the very low milers get a good residual. This was one of the reasons that I DIDN'T buy a Caterham. (and I was very close to buying one)

Both Dax and Westfield have embraced new technology and have other cars in their repotoir. Caterham need to do the same if they are going to survive. The yuppie years helped to keep caterham afloat (where people were willing to pay over the odds). There is a whole market out there similar to me that would love a seven but no way would pay the kind of money they are asking for it esp with it having a modified K series engine and such cars as the Exige, Modified Elises etc on the market for less.

>> Edited by smeagol on Saturday 26th April 12:43

>> Edited by smeagol on Saturday 26th April 12:51

eric mc

125,976 posts

296 months

Saturday 26th April 2003
quotequote all
Smeagol - I agree with most of your points (although I do take exception to being accused of "talking Bollocks"). I DO think new Sevens are overpriced, especially when viewed against their likely direct competitors (Dax, Westfirld etc). This problem cropped up before. Back in the early 90s Caterham realised they were losing sales at the lower end of the market. Their solution was the live axle "Classic" which was a success. Unfortunately, this type of Classic is no longer available new so their base models are now De Dion equipped and therefore expensive. If you do source major components yourself, then you could, in theory, keep the price reasonable. Most Sevens are sold to a market which is somewhere between the basic "Kit Car" segment and the straight "turn key" segment. I would hazard a guess that the cost of a straight turn key Westfield would not be that far removed from an equivalent Seven ( I may very well be taliking bollocks here as I have not got a clue of Westfield's current price lists).

My Seven is a 1996 Classic and is very similar to the Lotus 7 Series III. It even has the hand brake under the dash, as designed (rather sloppily) by Chapman back in 1957.

smeagol

1,947 posts

315 months

Saturday 26th April 2003
quotequote all
Fair enough, the talking b*ll*cks was a bit harsh (had a bad night) , but the point I was raising is that a lot of Caterham owners and salespeople say that the car doesn't depreciate much, which I cannot agree with. Their basis is on the year not on mileage which is the wrong way to think about it. When I looked into Caterham I was looking at it as my only car. I had driven my own kit car for 7.5 years with very little weather protection and so knew that I was mad enough to do this. I was at the time looking at spending £15-20k for a real nice example but noticed that if it was going to cover the mileage ie at least 10,000 miles per year then the resale value was not good. This is still reflected now especially if you buy from new.

The Westfield is seriously competitive for example their latest offer on their website:

www.westfield-sportscars.co.uk/offers.htm

Which is an 1800 Westfield with new EVERYTHING for £12.5k compare that to the Caterham kit prices:

www.caterham.co.uk/downloads/Tech_pricesheet.pdf

its clear to see the caterham a clearly more expensive esp when you add "options" such as engine, wheels, black pack, stack dash display etc. by my calculations the equivalent to Westfield above is £18k+ (both prices quoted are including VAT)

Caterham have a problem IMHO, I do believe they need to take their heads out of the sand a look at whats happenning to their market.

eric mc

125,976 posts

296 months

Saturday 26th April 2003
quotequote all
They need to bring back a "new" live axle model as an "Entry Level" car.

bigairbox

51 posts

284 months

Sunday 27th April 2003
quotequote all
Hey guys, great to see so much enthusiasm on something im willing to learn more on ie, the 7-style cars.
whats a ive axle cpmpared to a De Dion?!

Farmer

1,287 posts

305 months

Sunday 27th April 2003
quotequote all

bigairbox said: Hey guys, great to see so much enthusiasm on something im willing to learn more on ie, the 7-style cars.
whats a ive axle cpmpared to a De Dion?!



Live axle is a solid axle with diff. driveshafts , brakes etc in a heavy unit suspended under the car ie unsprung , advantages being wheels always perpendicular to the road and low centre of gravity / potentialy low body roll, and fairly predictable handling . Dissadvantages, High unsprung weight makes them potentialy clumsy on rough surfaces drasticly reducing grip because both wheels are affected by one wheels problem, and rough ride for the same reason

De-Deon is a light "dead" beam axle conecting the two wheels and keeping them good control and perpendicular like the live axle but the Diff unit is attached to the chassis and thus it's weight and half the weight of the driveshafts are carried on the suspension as in a fully independant sytem , drasticly reducing the inertia forces on the aforementioned rough road thus increasing grip and ride comfort /body control.
A good compromise set up on a 7 type car used by Caterham and several others now.
Hope that makes sense

Farmer

1,287 posts

305 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all
as the tumbleweed exits stage left and the wind moans through the telegraph wires, not a living thing stirs

Graham.J

5,420 posts

290 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all

Farmer said:as the tumbleweed exits stage left and the wind moans through the telegraph wires, not a living thing stirs






>> Edited to help the picture make more sense.

>> Edited by Graham.J on Monday 28th April 05:34