Something I wrote
Discussion
The Evening Standard had something about "isn't it dreadful that speed cameras are set to 43mph" missing the point about speeding and accidents entirely. I sent them a letter which I believe they printed (I was on holiday) but when they phoned me about it they said it would be shortened to fit.
I thought PH'ers might like to see the full text:
I read Paul Barker’s rant in yesterday’s paper and disagreed with it all bar the last paragraph. Yes an accident at 20mph is much more survivable than one at 55mph, but that’s not an argument for lower speed limits it’s an argument for not having accidents. The government’s own statistics show that speed was the major factor in just 7% of accidents but you won’t find many people that know this. Instead the lie that “speed kills” has been propagated by the ignorant and through Gobbelesque repetition has come to be believed.
Barker seems outraged that cars drive at 80mph on the motorways. In fact it’s only kept down to that speed by the underinvestment in our infrastructure which has resulted in so much of our roadspace being stationary that the average is 80mph. A good proportion of traffic travels very much faster than 80mph and yet our motorways are the safest roads in Europe. Italy has recently increased its speed limits to reduce boredom and make its roads faster.
The key to reducing accidents is to separate pedestrians and drivers. To upgrade the major routes so that drivers don’t resort to residential streets. Speed humps and pinch points are a spiraling farce. Reducing roads is like shutting down all the good restaurants in a bid to reduce heart disease. You can build a case but it’s fatuous.
There are three elements to road safety: Education, Engineering and Enforcement. Speed Cameras are blunt (revenue generating) instrument. With properly built roads, with good sight lines, banked curves and roundabouts you’d reduce accidents. With good education to teach people where to look and how to use roundabouts better you’d improve not just traffic flow – reducing congestion – but improve economy. It’s a great green solution. We might need annual driving tests and to be stricter on who it is that is allowed to pilot a tonne of metal but I suspect that it’s the people Paul Baker reviles, those that like and understand cars, who appreciate the difference between torque and brake horsepower, that make the safest drivers.
We need the North and South Circular improved to motorway standards. Proper junctions and slip roads. We need a second orbital motorway and an acknowledgement that we don’t live in a society where the car is in competition with the train but that they complement each other. Adequate parking at tube stations is an incentive to use the tube not an evil invitation to drive to the station.
My view of three rings around London isn’t my view, it’s the original proposal for the M25. This was whittled down to the inadequate road we have now.
So what was it that I agreed with? It was the sentence “The law should be enforced or officially abandoned”. There are a million speeding tickets issued a year. Ghandi didn’t have a fraction of the support for his campaign for civil disobedience. The speed limits are clearly bad laws.
I thought PH'ers might like to see the full text:
I read Paul Barker’s rant in yesterday’s paper and disagreed with it all bar the last paragraph. Yes an accident at 20mph is much more survivable than one at 55mph, but that’s not an argument for lower speed limits it’s an argument for not having accidents. The government’s own statistics show that speed was the major factor in just 7% of accidents but you won’t find many people that know this. Instead the lie that “speed kills” has been propagated by the ignorant and through Gobbelesque repetition has come to be believed.
Barker seems outraged that cars drive at 80mph on the motorways. In fact it’s only kept down to that speed by the underinvestment in our infrastructure which has resulted in so much of our roadspace being stationary that the average is 80mph. A good proportion of traffic travels very much faster than 80mph and yet our motorways are the safest roads in Europe. Italy has recently increased its speed limits to reduce boredom and make its roads faster.
The key to reducing accidents is to separate pedestrians and drivers. To upgrade the major routes so that drivers don’t resort to residential streets. Speed humps and pinch points are a spiraling farce. Reducing roads is like shutting down all the good restaurants in a bid to reduce heart disease. You can build a case but it’s fatuous.
There are three elements to road safety: Education, Engineering and Enforcement. Speed Cameras are blunt (revenue generating) instrument. With properly built roads, with good sight lines, banked curves and roundabouts you’d reduce accidents. With good education to teach people where to look and how to use roundabouts better you’d improve not just traffic flow – reducing congestion – but improve economy. It’s a great green solution. We might need annual driving tests and to be stricter on who it is that is allowed to pilot a tonne of metal but I suspect that it’s the people Paul Baker reviles, those that like and understand cars, who appreciate the difference between torque and brake horsepower, that make the safest drivers.
We need the North and South Circular improved to motorway standards. Proper junctions and slip roads. We need a second orbital motorway and an acknowledgement that we don’t live in a society where the car is in competition with the train but that they complement each other. Adequate parking at tube stations is an incentive to use the tube not an evil invitation to drive to the station.
My view of three rings around London isn’t my view, it’s the original proposal for the M25. This was whittled down to the inadequate road we have now.
So what was it that I agreed with? It was the sentence “The law should be enforced or officially abandoned”. There are a million speeding tickets issued a year. Ghandi didn’t have a fraction of the support for his campaign for civil disobedience. The speed limits are clearly bad laws.
i like your '3 'e's of road safety, i hadn't heard those before, and have to say i agree.
wouldn't use the gandhi defence though - rather tenuous IMO...
heres a useful ghandi quote though:
"first they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win." Mohandas Gandhi
believers unite!
>> Edited by mikeylad on Saturday 26th April 03:41
wouldn't use the gandhi defence though - rather tenuous IMO...
heres a useful ghandi quote though:
"first they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win." Mohandas Gandhi
believers unite!
>> Edited by mikeylad on Saturday 26th April 03:41
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


