Queuing Numpties
Discussion
Have just driven into my office in Northampton. Came in along the A45 dual carriageway eastbound. They are doing some road works on the first roundabout you get to (by Sixfields for those who know it) and have closed off lane one about 75m from the roundabout.
800 yards from the lane closure is a sign warning that lane one will be closed in 800 yards! So what happens? Everybody, and I mean everybody is in lane two, queuing like sheep. There’s a Merc SLK in front of me who chooses to go down lane one and I follow him. But then some tosser in an Omega decids to pull out of the lane two queue in front of the Merc and proceed to drive at the same speed as the queue – about 3mph! There is nothing in front of him in lane one for as far as you can see!
Myself an the Merc trundle behind him until about the 400y lane closure warning sign when fortunately there is a left turning off the dual carriageway with a “stretched” entrance. Omega Numpty is going so slowly that I am able to pretend to be turning left and use the length of the turning’s entrance to slip up his inside past the Merc and him. Now I can see there is nothing in lane one for the next 400ish yards until the lane closes.
I proceed at about 40 mph which seems a like safe speed. Then some absolute fcuking w*nker in a Mondeo decides I should be pointlessly queuing with everyone else and moves into lane one to try and block me. I am forced to take the only sensible option when faced with Numptiness of this magnitude: Use the horn liberally and drop a cog. Mondeo numpty realises that the angry snarling red Tuscan behind him is actually gathering pace rather than slowing down and swerves back into his queue.
I can now proceed unimpeded to the point at which lane one closes. I slow, indicate politely and I’m let in by a nice numpty in a focus.
WTF is it with these people? Why can’t they use both lanes to queue? What is the point of leaving 800 fcuking yards of dual carriageway empty and queuing in lane two? Why to they dangerously try to stop anybody making use of this 800yard space? And where can I buy a missile launcher to use on lunatic numpties in mondeos?
800 yards from the lane closure is a sign warning that lane one will be closed in 800 yards! So what happens? Everybody, and I mean everybody is in lane two, queuing like sheep. There’s a Merc SLK in front of me who chooses to go down lane one and I follow him. But then some tosser in an Omega decids to pull out of the lane two queue in front of the Merc and proceed to drive at the same speed as the queue – about 3mph! There is nothing in front of him in lane one for as far as you can see!
Myself an the Merc trundle behind him until about the 400y lane closure warning sign when fortunately there is a left turning off the dual carriageway with a “stretched” entrance. Omega Numpty is going so slowly that I am able to pretend to be turning left and use the length of the turning’s entrance to slip up his inside past the Merc and him. Now I can see there is nothing in lane one for the next 400ish yards until the lane closes.
I proceed at about 40 mph which seems a like safe speed. Then some absolute fcuking w*nker in a Mondeo decides I should be pointlessly queuing with everyone else and moves into lane one to try and block me. I am forced to take the only sensible option when faced with Numptiness of this magnitude: Use the horn liberally and drop a cog. Mondeo numpty realises that the angry snarling red Tuscan behind him is actually gathering pace rather than slowing down and swerves back into his queue.
I can now proceed unimpeded to the point at which lane one closes. I slow, indicate politely and I’m let in by a nice numpty in a focus.
WTF is it with these people? Why can’t they use both lanes to queue? What is the point of leaving 800 fcuking yards of dual carriageway empty and queuing in lane two? Why to they dangerously try to stop anybody making use of this 800yard space? And where can I buy a missile launcher to use on lunatic numpties in mondeos?
um from experience i found that (all traffic) using both lanes right til the very end usually results in a much slower movement of traffic... (at the bottle neck most people can't handle 2 lanes going into 1 from what i've seen, esp if its to join another road/motorway lane)... besides I always think its funny to hold up people in their merc. they flash and hoot, i wave. if they get out to thump me they'll realise their protective, comfy merc is sitting in the road behind them, and i've driven off
besides when they get closer they realise i'm listening to scary music and usually calm down 
besides when they get closer they realise i'm listening to scary music and usually calm down 
I always find it a bit weird when the sign states that lane 1 is closed ahead and people still use it at up to the last minute. It's usually more of an obstruction when people in lane 1 are trying to squeeze in to lane 2 at the last minute. if everyone was in lane 2, then they could all go through in single file, no problems. But you always get someone trying to jump the queue by going down the lane that is closed for as far as possible. No wonder people don't let them in. cheeky barstuards!!
shadowninja said: um from experience i found that (all traffic) using both lanes right til the very end usually results in a much slower movement of traffic... (at the bottle neck most people can't handle 2 lanes going into 1 from what i've seen, esp if its to join another road/motorway lane)... besides I always think its funny to hold up people in their merc. they flash and hoot, i wave. if they get out to thump me they'll realise their protective, comfy merc is sitting in the road behind them, and i've driven offbesides when they get closer they realise i'm listening to scary music and usually calm down
shadowninja, what's the difference between you holding up someone because they’re driving a Merc and a**holes in Mondeo's etc (BTW I drive one - but not like that
) holding up someone because they drive a sports car or because they think he should be queuing like everyone else when there's plenty of empty road to use ? If the merc want's to get past and there's space why not just move over and let them through ? >> Edited by t1grm on Sunday 27th April 14:39
As Ninja eli alludes, if people could handle the 2 into 1 lane combining then using both would make sense. However it doesn't work so the alternative is a self policed queue (which is the brits strongest talent to be sure), some squillion miles from the actual closure.
If you don't play ball and join the queue then you'll be treated like a no-good queue jumping arse. If you looked you would probably have seen others in the queue applauding the efforts of the mondeo and other's appearing to "teach you a lesson" in manners.
The whole thing is truly odd, if people were REALLY socially minded then the use of both lanes round-robin merging would be possible. (And indeed drivers in other european countries find it quite easy)
If you don't play ball and join the queue then you'll be treated like a no-good queue jumping arse. If you looked you would probably have seen others in the queue applauding the efforts of the mondeo and other's appearing to "teach you a lesson" in manners.
The whole thing is truly odd, if people were REALLY socially minded then the use of both lanes round-robin merging would be possible. (And indeed drivers in other european countries find it quite easy)
Yeah, depressing isn't it. But I agree, I can't see the point of leaving half a mile of road empty simply because numpties can't handles merging. If you drive up the empty lane slowly and considerately, making it clear this is not some burn-up mission, I really cannot see what's wrong with it..
But the problem isn't numpties who can't handle merging.
its simple science, the road at closure is only wide enough for single file, so therefore traffic will flow through more smoothly if it is already in single file, the merging of cars from the lane that is closed are the ones causing the hold up because it takes time to compress two lanes of traffic into one, whether merging is succesful or not.
By leaving the lane that is closed for 800yds empty the queuing cars are conforming to the format required to flow through the obstruction in the most efficient way.
There is no reason why a single file of traffic couldn't just flow through at a reasonable speed,
but when every car has to stop to let someone across from the closed lane, the stopping and starting gradually slows the whole thing up and you end up with a traffic jam.
Besides, woudn't it be better to leave the lane free just for emergency veichles? especially if the obstruction is a road accident!
>> Edited by nmlowe on Sunday 27th April 16:11
its simple science, the road at closure is only wide enough for single file, so therefore traffic will flow through more smoothly if it is already in single file, the merging of cars from the lane that is closed are the ones causing the hold up because it takes time to compress two lanes of traffic into one, whether merging is succesful or not.
By leaving the lane that is closed for 800yds empty the queuing cars are conforming to the format required to flow through the obstruction in the most efficient way.
There is no reason why a single file of traffic couldn't just flow through at a reasonable speed,
but when every car has to stop to let someone across from the closed lane, the stopping and starting gradually slows the whole thing up and you end up with a traffic jam.
Besides, woudn't it be better to leave the lane free just for emergency veichles? especially if the obstruction is a road accident!
>> Edited by nmlowe on Sunday 27th April 16:11
like I said, I've noticed that the queue moves quicker (in front of me at least!) when I block cars coming up in the empty lane (not necessarily a merc, but they're the ones who generally expect me in my lowly japanese or british car to bow down before them and get out of their way, or move aside to let them pass in a narrow road, when it's clearly obvious that it would have made more sense that they move their oversized tank out of the way). So i will continue to make my (and 800 yards of other road users') journey quicker in a courteous fashion :P
PS Ninja Eli drives a red car and I drive a blue car
PS Ninja Eli drives a red car and I drive a blue car

manek said: But the traffic has to merge at SOME point. If it does so 800 yards earlier than it needs to, the road capacity is decreased by that amount.
But if everyone moved over to the correct lane before reaching the queue, i.e. whilst doing 60-70 and seeing the queue/signs in the distance, then the merging would be done quicker. obviously, the traffic will only be going 30-40 through the obstruction, but merging at the bottleneck will usually take longer because people haven't left enough time to merge before needing to stop/push in.
Ideally everyone should que in both lanes, right up to the end, thus using max spac etc.
It would work if people then took in alternate turns to merge.
But, due to widepsread numtyism this will never happen. People would push in, people would block, people would get pi$$ed off etc etc......
But in reality, when I approach 800 yards of queing traffic I always pull in coz I feel like a tit belting down the outside lane and pulling in at the last minute!
It would work if people then took in alternate turns to merge.
But, due to widepsread numtyism this will never happen. People would push in, people would block, people would get pi$$ed off etc etc......
But in reality, when I approach 800 yards of queing traffic I always pull in coz I feel like a tit belting down the outside lane and pulling in at the last minute!
Good, glad to see the majority agrees with me. Moving over whilst traffic is still free moving has to be the most efficient approach. Trying to squeeze in at the bottleneck slows the whole thing down. If you’re in this for all the drivers on the road then you slip in to the correct lane before you reach the tailback. Anything else is queue jumping, it has to be, your passing cars that arrived before you. You're simply in it for yourself. Thank god the majority chooses to queue and accepts that patience is the best resort.
Oooo, I seem to have started a slight argument this afternoon between the “mergers” and the “queuers”.
I maintain that leaving 800 yards of empty carriageway is a totally inefficient use of space. At about 600 yards from the start of the queue was a right turn. Imagine how annoying it must have been for people wishing to turn right there who had to queue for 600 yards unnecessarily even though they weren’t even going as far as the lane closure.
As for merging at the lane closure, I merged carefully and courteously without having to cut anybody up. I did not belt up the inside, I drove at about 40mph (70 limit) and only exceeded this a little when Mondeo Numpty needed persuading back into the queue he was so fond of.
This press release from the Institute of Advanced Motorists tackles the issue quite well: www.iam.org.uk/Pressroom/News_Releases/Archive/nr0115.html
I’m sorry tvrbob, I just had to reply to your post. I do not intend any offence, but I must disagree:
Every time I overtake I'm passing cars that arrived at a certain point in the road before me - should overtaking be banned?
Of course I am - why the hell would I be in it for anybody else?
Thank god they do! It means people who actually want to get somewhere can bypass them all. If you look at many things in life, following what the majority does is rarely the best way to really succeed – if it was we could all have £1m salaries and drive Lamborghinis – but in reality, only those who do not follow what Mr Average does will have the chance to achieve more than Mr Average does.
All in all, in a perfect world everybody should “zip merge”. But as the world is unlikely to ever be perfect, please will everybody continue to queue so that I don’t have too!
I maintain that leaving 800 yards of empty carriageway is a totally inefficient use of space. At about 600 yards from the start of the queue was a right turn. Imagine how annoying it must have been for people wishing to turn right there who had to queue for 600 yards unnecessarily even though they weren’t even going as far as the lane closure.
As for merging at the lane closure, I merged carefully and courteously without having to cut anybody up. I did not belt up the inside, I drove at about 40mph (70 limit) and only exceeded this a little when Mondeo Numpty needed persuading back into the queue he was so fond of.
This press release from the Institute of Advanced Motorists tackles the issue quite well: www.iam.org.uk/Pressroom/News_Releases/Archive/nr0115.html
I’m sorry tvrbob, I just had to reply to your post. I do not intend any offence, but I must disagree:
tvrbob said: If you’re in this for all the drivers on the road then you slip in to the correct lane before you reach the tailback. Anything else is queue jumping, it has to be, your passing cars that arrived before you.
Every time I overtake I'm passing cars that arrived at a certain point in the road before me - should overtaking be banned?
You're simply in it for yourself.
Of course I am - why the hell would I be in it for anybody else?
Thank god the majority chooses to queue and accepts that patience is the best resort.
Thank god they do! It means people who actually want to get somewhere can bypass them all. If you look at many things in life, following what the majority does is rarely the best way to really succeed – if it was we could all have £1m salaries and drive Lamborghinis – but in reality, only those who do not follow what Mr Average does will have the chance to achieve more than Mr Average does.
All in all, in a perfect world everybody should “zip merge”. But as the world is unlikely to ever be perfect, please will everybody continue to queue so that I don’t have too!
Well if at the point of the road closure everyone moved into the single lane alternatively then the problem would be resolved. The queues would be of equal length, and would move at the highest average speed.
The problem with all queuing in one lane is that someone will always go down the empty lane and cut in at the last moment, and that of course slows down the queue. If both queues are of equal length this can't happen.
I note that some roadworks now have signs saying "Merge in turn", some numpties ignore them still though!
The problem with all queuing in one lane is that someone will always go down the empty lane and cut in at the last moment, and that of course slows down the queue. If both queues are of equal length this can't happen.
I note that some roadworks now have signs saying "Merge in turn", some numpties ignore them still though!
Tell you what, TSS and those of similar persuasion: if I find you carving up a queue I've dutifully sat in, having merged well in advance of the closure, I'll pull my poxy little 5-grand Corsa Combo van out in front of your expensive sports car and you can rear-end it. No loss to me: it's on the company insurance. Plenty loss to you: you'll have been 'unable to stop in the distance you could see clear'. Your insurers will have a field day. Assuming you do stop in time, you will find that I don't. Should you then use your greater horsepower to apprehend me in some fashion to, presumably, admonish me, you will not find me prepared to sit and discuss the incident with you in a calm and rational fashion.
Then, perhaps, we can observe ourselves on News at Ten and Police, Camera, Action.
Of course, it may not be me, but some knife-wielding psycho with whom you have a similar altercation...
Ian
Then, perhaps, we can observe ourselves on News at Ten and Police, Camera, Action.
Of course, it may not be me, but some knife-wielding psycho with whom you have a similar altercation...
Ian
This sounds like the same situation you get at traffic lights - you are a few cars back and can see the lights. You are ready to go and see the lights change but have to wait for about 10 seconds for everyone in front to start moving, by which time the lights have changed again
Being realistic it's much better to get in lane early because although you may be further back the traffic is likely to be moving more quickly - people cutting in at the last moment will always cause the flow of traffic to slow down as people brake to let them in and eventually a mile or so back up the road everyone will stop as each car slows a little more than the one in front
Being realistic it's much better to get in lane early because although you may be further back the traffic is likely to be moving more quickly - people cutting in at the last moment will always cause the flow of traffic to slow down as people brake to let them in and eventually a mile or so back up the road everyone will stop as each car slows a little more than the one in front

Sorry TSS, but you don't get my vote either. There was another thread on this topic some time back on which I explained why merging early and maintaining momentum was always going to clear a queue faster than the actions of queue jumping numpties like you.
In my work we regularly have to design product merging systems (ie, taking wide product streams down into narrow product streams) and the golden rule is always to merge the lines early and keep them moving. Having someone "join the queue at the front" acts as a flow disruptor and thereby stops the whole line, adding to the delay for all. Its to do with action and reaction times and the multiplication thereof over numbers of drivers.
Its a scientific fact that bods like you make the queues worse for everyone!
Andy 400se
In my work we regularly have to design product merging systems (ie, taking wide product streams down into narrow product streams) and the golden rule is always to merge the lines early and keep them moving. Having someone "join the queue at the front" acts as a flow disruptor and thereby stops the whole line, adding to the delay for all. Its to do with action and reaction times and the multiplication thereof over numbers of drivers.
Its a scientific fact that bods like you make the queues worse for everyone!
Andy 400se
On this subject I have noticed more people "blocking" lanes of queuing traffic.
Picture this;
800 yards of traffic inline before a lane closure. Truck sees a car approaching on the "empty" other lane and pulls across the road, blocking both lanes and forcing any car that wants to push in to sit behind and wait.
This seems to be happening more and more, cant say I agree with it, its a bit extreme!
Picture this;
800 yards of traffic inline before a lane closure. Truck sees a car approaching on the "empty" other lane and pulls across the road, blocking both lanes and forcing any car that wants to push in to sit behind and wait.
This seems to be happening more and more, cant say I agree with it, its a bit extreme!
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




Sunday drivers. 