In support of the French....
In support of the French....
Author
Discussion

CarZee

Original Poster:

13,382 posts

298 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all
www.fredoneverything.net/France.shtml

Confessional

In Which Fred Reveals A Horrible Truth About Fred

Sometimes a writer craves to bare his soul and lighten his burden of hidden sin--yes, to admit that he hasn't always lived as a Christian, that he has played cards in low dives, and done shameful things with floozies in foreign ports. He wants to make a clean breast of it before the world, to say, "There. You see me in all my sordid sorrow and moral wretchedness. Forgive me if you can." Well, I'm at that pass. I'm going to confess.

I like the French.

All right. I'll leave town. (Actually, come to think of it, I've left town.)

Yes, I've written harsh things about the French. The French like the French awfully well, and I figured that here was a teeter-totter that needed some balance to it. So I laughed at them. There was no malice in it. I was just being professionally disagreeable.

But now our tub-thumping patriots are whooping it up most frightfully against France. The reason? The French saw no reason to blow up Arabs in a contrived war of dissembled purpose. Neither did I. Nor do I remember that the French are corporals in our army. Anyway, if we don't support their opposition to the war, why shouldn't they oppose our support?

The patriots call the French "cheese-eating surrender monkeys." It's embarrassing--though not because they insult the French. I just wish we had a patriot who sounded more than eleven years old.

I grant you that the French are imperfect. They live on a reputation they do not deserve. I refer to their famous intolerance of visiting Americans, which is a tourist attraction, and listed in travel guides. One expects a Parisian to sight down his nose as if taking a measurement, sniff, and be supercilious.

But no. You cannot trust a Frenchman.

In former years I often went to Paris for the Air Show. Always the French were tiresomely civil. I had expected the heathen rudeness one associates with moral crusaders. I considered bringing a case at law: I had spent all that money in expectation of gorgeous churlishness, and didn't get any.

I waited everywhere for lightning to flash, for some spark to ignite the powder magazines of Gallic abrasiveness. Surely something would provoke them to vile manners. In particular I had been warned that they would not suffer Americans who had not been born with a perfect fluency in French.

The rascals would not perform. My wife of the moment entered a drug store in Paris to buy cough syrup. She thought she was asking for medicine, but was in fact asking for a doctor ("medecin"). The help were astonished as she went about peering at shelves, in the apparent belief that in France doctors were kept in little boxes.

When the mistake was understood, the French…laughed. They were friendly. They were helpful.

It was low treachery.

Patriots make much of the dismal record of the French in matters military. Well, yes. It's hard to argue with failure. I note however that the French have Germany on their borders, a condition associated with military failure for everybody enjoying the same circumstances. Americans cannot always distinguish between military prowess and the Atlantic Ocean. In fact a great many Americans cannot find the Atlantic Ocean.

The Yankee record in festive slaughter may not be quite as good as we puff it up to be. The United States came late to the parade of WWI after everybody else had done the fighting, and declared itself victorious. America won splendidly in WWII, drew in Korea, and lost in Vietnam. The United States has only a fairish record in wars against helpless countries: Lost in Cuba, Somalia, Lebanon, Cambodia, and Laos, but won in Grenada, Panama, Iraq I and, maybe, Iraq II and Afghanistan II.

In our percentage of wars won we rank high in the standings, and would make the playoffs, but on the percentages the British would be well ahead.

If the French have declined in war since Napoleon, they still have style. I wish we had some. Our current emperor always gives the impression that he has just finished eating a peanut-butter sandwich. His speeches sound like the winning entry in the seventh-grade elocution contest in Texarkana. By contrast, you can look at almost any French minister without suspecting that he was dressed by his mother, and the merest of them radiates an air of worldly understanding and intelligence that would get him jailed in America. A French cab driver has more class than a Congressman, and probably fewer gravy-stains.

The French respect intelligence, whereas we are deeply suspicious of it. I'm not sure that intelligence has much place in diplomacy, other than to let one make bad choices in better prose. Still, misjudgment engaged in with class at least makes better reading for later students of history. Whatever their failings, the French do not cultivate boorishness as a compulsory credential of democracy, lie systematically to their children, or endeavor to crush intellectual endeavor. We didn't either, once.

America used to have a brash, rough, leather-breeches style with a cornpone but genuine appeal. The genius of America was the pawky outsider laughing at European pretensions, the lethal wit of Twain, Bierce, Mencken, Hunter Thompson. The country wielded canny frontiersman like Davy Crockett, enjoyed the cracker-barrel shrewdness of Andrew Jackson, who figured you put Bourbon in branch water and not on thrones.

Thing is, backwoods virility doesn't well make the transition to suburbia. The American unease with ideas didn't sit badly on Huck Finn, Daniel Boone or, in the Heroic Age of American technology, the buzz-cut engineers working on Apollo. But put Tom Sawyer on Ritalin in deliberately crippled suburban schools to keep him from being a boy; teach him that to be manly is sexist and to be educated, elitist; wean him from independence and self-determination but give him nothing to replace them; rigorously discourage intellectual enterprise--and you get the polar opposite of a Frenchman.

Europeans, and assuredly the French, like to believe that the tremulous age of Europe makes them proof against the jejune lunging of the young United States. I see blessed little evidence of it. But there is something appalling in the boobish anti-civilization now eagerly embraced by the America. Much of our noisy patriotism is not readily distinguished from the bad temper of congenitally hostile louts. We have a president who probably thinks Oat Cuisine is something one feeds to horses. I'm not sure that, before we put our own house in order, we are a position to look down too scornfully on the French.

mikeylad

34,634 posts

284 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all

www.fredoneverything.net/France.shtml


In our percentage of wars won we rank high in the standings, and would make the playoffs, but on the percentages the British would be well ahead.





i remember reading somewhere that the British are the only nation to have a 100% record in modern warfare. does anyone recognise this and can anyone put some numbers to 'modern warfare'?

nevpugh308

4,454 posts

300 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all

In fact a great many Americans cannot find the Atlantic Ocean.


plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all
Modern Warfare = Since we lost the War of Independance.

Played 17, won 17 I think...

Matt.

JohnL

1,766 posts

296 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all
Ahem, Suez?

I quite like the French too on the whole

AlexH

2,505 posts

315 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all
I think its odd that one often judges a country by the performance/behaviour of its politicians on the international stage, when most people if they take a moment to think, that while elected, a very good proportion of politicians are not that representative of the people they are purported to represent.

ATG

23,878 posts

303 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all
Very true. Chirac elected beoz the alternative was a fascist. Bush elected (just) because the alternative was Gore.

Rather presciently The Dead Kenedeys predicted the rise of w*nkers like Al Gore back in the 80s ... phrases like "suede denim secret police" and a nice denunciation of Al's wife, Tipper, on "Give me convenience or give me death". Ah, the good old days.

planetdave

9,922 posts

284 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all
Anyone know 'The War Of 1812'
Americans flush with the success of the war of independance decide it was time to liberate their Canadian cousins. Think for just one minute. (Yes Canada still there)
Cue allmighty buttkicking, culminating in British forces occupying Washington DC and burning down the White House.
I love asking 'the cousins' about this one, strangely it does not appear in their text books
And the French
Lovely people, good food, lots of attitude.
Good that they have their own country again

JohnL

1,766 posts

296 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all
That true PlanetDave? Got any sources?

planetdave

9,922 posts

284 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all
Errr...went to a good school and can remember the funny bits.
BTW It does appear that you have access to the www.
Or you could just trust me on this one
Good isn't it

jmorgan

36,010 posts

315 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all
Its true.

planetdave

9,922 posts

284 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all

Size Nine Elm

5,167 posts

315 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all

plotloss said: Modern Warfare = Since we lost the War of Independance.

Played 17, won 17 I think...

Matt.

But I think there were a few where we came back strongly in the second half...

Thom

2,745 posts

304 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all

www.fredoneverything.net/France.shtml|


Hmmmmm...
This guy is American - do NOT believe what he says !

ATG

23,878 posts

303 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all
if memory serves, the reason the white house is called the "white" house is coz the british paid a visit and set the place on fire, hence it had to be repainted.

mikeylad

34,634 posts

284 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all

planetdave said: Anyone know 'The War Of 1812'
Americans flush with the success of the war of independance decide it was time to liberate their Canadian cousins. Think for just one minute. (Yes Canada still there)
Cue allmighty buttkicking, culminating in British forces occupying Washington DC and burning down the White House.
I love asking 'the cousins' about this one, strangely it does not appear in their text books



har har har! In your face, Hank and Wilbur!!! Once more unto the breech dear friends! da dada da da.... Don't think we'll need to burn down the white house again though - the americans should do that on their own.

marki

15,763 posts

301 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all

Thom said:

www.fredoneverything.net/France.shtml|


Hmmmmm...
This guy is American - do NOT believe what he says !



Spoken like a true French man

gargamel

16,439 posts

292 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all

Carzee

did you pick that site up from the link I put on the should we teach maths thread ?

I must admit I got it from another site I use where it was quoted. actually some great nostalgia on there and also some good honest non PC common sense.

all good stuff

MilnerR

8,273 posts

289 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all

JohnL said: Ahem, Suez?

I quite like the French too on the whole


We won the military action in Suez (3 days!) but the politicians lost what little nerve they had.

MilnerR

8,273 posts

289 months

Monday 28th April 2003
quotequote all

JohnL said: Ahem, Suez?

I quite like the French too on the whole


We won the military action in Suez (3 days!) but the politicians lost what little nerve they had.