how fast is too fast in the wet???
Discussion
driving home today i saw a number of different approaches to driving in the rain we were confronted with.
1. mine
2. the MGF's
3. everyone else's
1. i drove down clapham bypass at my usual 80mph (though sometimes faster in the dry) keeping a good distance from any cars and not going fast amongst traffic,
when i got on to country roads i drove at basically the same speed i always do, knowing that my car can still corner at this speed comfortably in the wet as it can in the dry.
on a couple of occasions i went through corners a little slower than if it was dry, but realised it was not neccesary, on 1 corner i noticed the backend starting to slip-out but not much and it was easily controllable.
the only adjustment to my driving on the country lanes was to not accelorate out of junctions quickly until my wheels were pointed straight, as the inside rear wheel tends to have a tendancey to spin in the dry, so it spins alot in the wet...
don't think i annoyed anyone, didn't take any longer in reality to get home and i feel it was totally safe, better than sticking RIGHT behind a slower moving vehicle and getting complacent.
2. the MGF down clapham bypass was doing 100-110mph in the wet, as soon as i saw he was coming up quite quickly i moved over and let him through and he continued merryly on his way, despite dowing 30-40mph over the speed limit he was driving well and only ever got close to the car in front when some numpty wouldn't move out of the way in a vectra
3. everyone else was crawling down the bypass at about 50mph, from lorries to metros to beemers, to scared to overtake (duel carridgeway) going slower and slower tailgating each other in everyone's spray, right up close, when the first guy brakes, everyone slams on the brakes behind... whats the point?
on the country roads it was no better... they were doing 30 in 60's and approaching corners like they were a wild tiger that you you'd just cut its balls off then insulted its mother!
which would you do? i was quite happy with no. 1 (driving basically the same as normal), 2's a bit excessive and 3 is just plain wrong. opinions.
1. mine
2. the MGF's
3. everyone else's
1. i drove down clapham bypass at my usual 80mph (though sometimes faster in the dry) keeping a good distance from any cars and not going fast amongst traffic,
when i got on to country roads i drove at basically the same speed i always do, knowing that my car can still corner at this speed comfortably in the wet as it can in the dry.
on a couple of occasions i went through corners a little slower than if it was dry, but realised it was not neccesary, on 1 corner i noticed the backend starting to slip-out but not much and it was easily controllable.
the only adjustment to my driving on the country lanes was to not accelorate out of junctions quickly until my wheels were pointed straight, as the inside rear wheel tends to have a tendancey to spin in the dry, so it spins alot in the wet...
don't think i annoyed anyone, didn't take any longer in reality to get home and i feel it was totally safe, better than sticking RIGHT behind a slower moving vehicle and getting complacent.
2. the MGF down clapham bypass was doing 100-110mph in the wet, as soon as i saw he was coming up quite quickly i moved over and let him through and he continued merryly on his way, despite dowing 30-40mph over the speed limit he was driving well and only ever got close to the car in front when some numpty wouldn't move out of the way in a vectra
3. everyone else was crawling down the bypass at about 50mph, from lorries to metros to beemers, to scared to overtake (duel carridgeway) going slower and slower tailgating each other in everyone's spray, right up close, when the first guy brakes, everyone slams on the brakes behind... whats the point?
on the country roads it was no better... they were doing 30 in 60's and approaching corners like they were a wild tiger that you you'd just cut its balls off then insulted its mother!
which would you do? i was quite happy with no. 1 (driving basically the same as normal), 2's a bit excessive and 3 is just plain wrong. opinions.
Too many factors to have an opinion. If you could honestly say that you could stop quickly and safely, were properly aware of your environment and weren't endangering other etc then its probably fine. Only comment is that you have a fairly old car which likely has lesser breaking abilities than a modern car, and I suspect you won't have the best quality boots on it (which can have a really big effect on breaking)? Doesn't mean its dangerous but I don't doubt the MGF could stop (and spin 720!) faster.
Maybe get some advanced driver training if you want to learn how to recognise the limits and practise what to do when you approach/cross them? I drive a car with no ABS too, and breaking with maximum force without locking up requires practise. I'm still shit compared to my instructor, but improving
i honestly can say i don't think i ever got into a situation where i couldn't stop if i had too... i made sure of this 'cos i was doing 80 in the wet!!!
my car is old, but the brakes and tyres are about 9 and 6 months old respectively, thats new discs, pads, calipers and mastercylinder so i probably had better brakes than the MG!!!
i also feel i was endangering the 3 cars i overtook less by passing them cleanly, quickly and safely, LESS than if i had stayed behind them and got caught in their spray etc...
this thread is a matter of everyones opinions (thats why i posted it) and thats mine.
my car is old, but the brakes and tyres are about 9 and 6 months old respectively, thats new discs, pads, calipers and mastercylinder so i probably had better brakes than the MG!!!
i also feel i was endangering the 3 cars i overtook less by passing them cleanly, quickly and safely, LESS than if i had stayed behind them and got caught in their spray etc...
this thread is a matter of everyones opinions (thats why i posted it) and thats mine.
The MGF has ABS and presumably you don't? Frankly however good a driver you are, you can't really compete with that I'm afraid. ABS can control break pressure to each wheel independently, you (and I) have to modulate all 4 at the same time, and its a bloody art form and if wheels are getting different levels of grip we can't compete.
Not knocking your car as clearly I have no idea what its able to do, I was just guessing from what it was

Too fast is:
i) If you can't stop in the distance you can see to be clear
ii) If a vehicle in the adjacent lane pulls out or an unexpected hazard appears ahead of you, you are unable to avoid it due to speed differential or available space.
This applies pretty much whatever the conditions.
If it's wet there's spray and reduced light or glare, visibility reduces & stopping distances increase dramatically. The delicacy with which one must pilot around any obstacle increases tremendously - especially in a low tech boat like yours, Graham - I've had one so don't tell me otherwise.
If it's a narrow dual carrangeway rather than motorway grade road, manouevring space is limited and in all likelyhood there was a poor road surface.
If the traffic on the inside lane was doing 50 so I'd say that you were probably going too fast to avoid a potentially calamatous numpty encounter and the MG, with a speed differential of 50mph from traffic on the inside, some of which might be getting impatient, I'd say he was utterly crazy. Even in something that could handle and stop like a 996. An MG doesn't. In any case, if spray limits visibility and a car is gaining on you at 50mph, thing about how little time the inside laner has to make a decision to pull out and then gain speed.
Obviously this only applies if I've interpreted the conditions correctly, not knowing the road etc, but I'd say you were both a bit barmey.
Not that I haven't been myself in the past
i) If you can't stop in the distance you can see to be clear
ii) If a vehicle in the adjacent lane pulls out or an unexpected hazard appears ahead of you, you are unable to avoid it due to speed differential or available space.
This applies pretty much whatever the conditions.
If it's wet there's spray and reduced light or glare, visibility reduces & stopping distances increase dramatically. The delicacy with which one must pilot around any obstacle increases tremendously - especially in a low tech boat like yours, Graham - I've had one so don't tell me otherwise.
If it's a narrow dual carrangeway rather than motorway grade road, manouevring space is limited and in all likelyhood there was a poor road surface.
If the traffic on the inside lane was doing 50 so I'd say that you were probably going too fast to avoid a potentially calamatous numpty encounter and the MG, with a speed differential of 50mph from traffic on the inside, some of which might be getting impatient, I'd say he was utterly crazy. Even in something that could handle and stop like a 996. An MG doesn't. In any case, if spray limits visibility and a car is gaining on you at 50mph, thing about how little time the inside laner has to make a decision to pull out and then gain speed.
Obviously this only applies if I've interpreted the conditions correctly, not knowing the road etc, but I'd say you were both a bit barmey.
Not that I haven't been myself in the past

fair do's!!!
i personally thought i was safe!
- i always left space to stop between me and cars i was following
- however, there was not space if someone pulled out in front of me...
unfortuantly you cannot predict this, and people do it in all weathers all roads and all cars, so unfortuantly you cannot factor numptisim into normal driving imo.
hmm, are you trying to suggest my car is not the best at handling braking :scratchin:
down the bypass i was probably going too quickly, but on the country roads there was less traffic so i felt it was safer to drive at "normal" speeds.
to be honest i was also annoyed at the guys doing 50, not everyone was, there was just a line of people who were caught in each others spray refusing to overtake (fine) OR dropback out of the spray!!!
i personally thought i was safe!
- i always left space to stop between me and cars i was following
- however, there was not space if someone pulled out in front of me...
unfortuantly you cannot predict this, and people do it in all weathers all roads and all cars, so unfortuantly you cannot factor numptisim into normal driving imo.
hmm, are you trying to suggest my car is not the best at handling braking :scratchin:
down the bypass i was probably going too quickly, but on the country roads there was less traffic so i felt it was safer to drive at "normal" speeds.
to be honest i was also annoyed at the guys doing 50, not everyone was, there was just a line of people who were caught in each others spray refusing to overtake (fine) OR dropback out of the spray!!!
unfortuantly you cannot predict this, and people do it in all weathers all roads and all cars, so unfortuantly you cannot factor numptisim into normal driving imo.
Don't really agree on this. I factor numptyism into my evaluation of every other car on the road. I don't care what they are driving, I just assume that they are either :
a) hopelessly incompetent.
b) hopelessly overconfident.
Most people fit one or both of the above I find - I'm probably a bit of both, but trying to learn and doing the extra training

DanH said:
Don't really agree on this. I factor numptyism into my evaluation of every other car on the road. I don't care what they are driving, I just assume that they are either :
a) hopelessly incompetent.
b) hopelessly overconfident.
Most people fit one or both of the above I find - I'm probably a bit of both, but trying to learn and doing the extra training
i agree with your two discrptions, and i factor it in slightly, like if your following a car when the brake lights come on all the time, you drop back etc...
but you can't judge your driving entirely on "oh, they may do this..." otherwise you'd never go quickly at all!!!
in fact, i know someone who drives like this and it was big news when he hit 65mph the other day, he had his mum in the car screaming at him to slow down "incase..."...
littlegearl said:
deltaf said: Just go slower than you do in the dry......works for me![]()
how much slower though?
which is kind of my point...
hedge-steer, no never go that, did get verge steer once though!!!
Cant really quantify it (sorry if that makes me sound like some kind of scientist gimp
). Rough guess; no more that 70-80 on the motorway (my brakes are shite), not much different anywhere else unless it really is pi$$ing it down.
Oh, and I go quicker round roundabouts in the wet

yep.
the picture looks worse than it is...
although my car's old its probably in better condition (don't just mean bodywork) than most the other cars on the road, plud other than the aforemention MG i basically had the outside lane to myself with everyone else sitting in a 50-70mph que(sp?) so although it was wet it was probably safer than me doing 80 down their on the way TO work this morning 'cos although it was dry the road was alot buisier...
80 in a cavalier or 70 in a metro, i know which i'd prefer to be in!!!
the picture looks worse than it is...
although my car's old its probably in better condition (don't just mean bodywork) than most the other cars on the road, plud other than the aforemention MG i basically had the outside lane to myself with everyone else sitting in a 50-70mph que(sp?) so although it was wet it was probably safer than me doing 80 down their on the way TO work this morning 'cos although it was dry the road was alot buisier...
80 in a cavalier or 70 in a metro, i know which i'd prefer to be in!!!
but you can't judge your driving entirely on "oh, they may do this..." otherwise you'd never go quickly at all!!!
Definitely, but there are things you can anticipate. On motorways, I try to avoid being parallel with two cars in the other lanes at once. Also I don't pull in a lane on a motorway parallel or in the blind spot of anyone. If someone slows down on a road, I don't instantly overtake, as chances are they are about to turn right (a friend wrote off his Elise doing this). Its all obvious shit, but its factoring in numptyism and I don't doubt you do it too.
Maybe read roadcraft? I don't agree with it all, but it makes you think about things you may not have previously considered particularly with regards to hazard observation. There are worse ways you could spend 14 quid.
Here are some interesting things that you may not have considered but are obvious when you thing about it (they are examples from roadcraft). They are split into observation, and what it probably entails :
cluster of lampposts ahead on - roundabout.
a single lampost on its own - a junction.
no gap in trees ahead - road curves before trees.
fresh mud or other deposits on the raod. newly moan grass etc. - slow moving vehicles/animals around the bend.
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




