long term effect of rev-limiter bouncing
Discussion
You'll knacker your car quicker? Wouldn't taking your car right up to the limiter all the time be putting more stress on the engine then it had really been designed to handle?
I know on all the cars I've driven and hit the limiter on, the engine has always sounded like it's in complete pain before it bouncs down a rev or two...
I know on all the cars I've driven and hit the limiter on, the engine has always sounded like it's in complete pain before it bouncs down a rev or two...
Aren't rev-limiters set up so that they cut-in well before any serious damage can be done?
Or are they set up so that they cut-in just before serious damage might take place?
If it's the former then it won't matter how many times you hit the limiter but with the latter you'd best avoid it.
Or are they set up so that they cut-in just before serious damage might take place?
If it's the former then it won't matter how many times you hit the limiter but with the latter you'd best avoid it.
Apart from being a crap way of driving and showing no mechanical sympathy wit the car, you should not cause any drastic damage to the car as it is there to prevent such things as valve bounce and taking the engine beyond its pre-defined stress limits.
I would think that the drivetrain shunt would not be too kind on the rest of your running gear and your neck!
Always thought that people who hit the limiter in the traffic light Grand Prix looked a bit of a *wat to me.
Nick
I would think that the drivetrain shunt would not be too kind on the rest of your running gear and your neck!
Always thought that people who hit the limiter in the traffic light Grand Prix looked a bit of a *wat to me.
Nick
I you are constantly hitting the limiter and it is hard cut limiter then yes it will add wear and tear to the engine.
I this is something you make a habit of you may want to consider adding a soft cut limit that rather than bouncing the engine on the limit remove power more gradually thus not inflicting damage to the engine.
A good one is the OMEX speed system - soft cut limiter and shift light
I this is something you make a habit of you may want to consider adding a soft cut limit that rather than bouncing the engine on the limit remove power more gradually thus not inflicting damage to the engine.
A good one is the OMEX speed system - soft cut limiter and shift light
Revlimiters will either cut the spark (chucking out unburned fuel down the exhaust - definately not good with cats) or cut the fuel on injected systems . The latter is more common and is like running very lean for a few cycles, with the problems that brings. Although it's better than allowing the engine to rev until things start hitting each other, in itself it's not a good thing.
Apparently it has even worse effects on turbocharged cars, which are chucking in more air and fuel in the first place.
Apparently it has even worse effects on turbocharged cars, which are chucking in more air and fuel in the first place.
DanH said:
Its not exactly frequent, but I don't beat myself up about it
Im the same. I can usually get a gear change in just as the rev limiter is cutting in. Im not too fussed about it .. I always thought the rev limiter was to limit before damage occurs.
I frequently use the over run when in traffic and out on the country roads to induce some nice popping and banging as the revvs decrease. ( also, produces lots of nice flames as the revvs decrease)
Where do you start?
Hands up anyone who thinks OEMs spend all that cash developing a new engine to run at a safe max of say 8000rpm and then think "hang on, better put the limiter at 7k so you can bounce off it safely all day long".
Rev limiters are either:
1 - There because thats what the manufacturer wanted, so the engine was tested up to those revs and no higher.
2 - There because the engine kept failing in testing so they reduced the limit.
Does it cause damage long term? No one knows because it's not tested for. Risk it if you like.
Hands up anyone who thinks OEMs spend all that cash developing a new engine to run at a safe max of say 8000rpm and then think "hang on, better put the limiter at 7k so you can bounce off it safely all day long".
Rev limiters are either:
1 - There because thats what the manufacturer wanted, so the engine was tested up to those revs and no higher.
2 - There because the engine kept failing in testing so they reduced the limit.
Does it cause damage long term? No one knows because it's not tested for. Risk it if you like.
Was speaking to someone who reckons that bouncing off the rev-limiter to get overrun isnt a problem.
-Darren
I think I'm quite correct in saying that your correspondant's "bouncing off the limiter" is no problem to me whatsoever.
However, I make no predictions for the longevity of his engine!
On a related note, I don't see the point in doing this to get some pops+bangs, if the engine is not otherwise predisposed to it. I must be getting old...

Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


