Brake Pads (111R/Sports Racer)
Brake Pads (111R/Sports Racer)
Author
Discussion

macca77

Original Poster:

51 posts

246 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
Help!!

My brake pads desperately need replacing and am confused with the options. Was considering Mintex M1144’s, but unsure if they’re available for the 111R. Not heard great things about EBC Greenstuff, heard nothing about EBD Redstuff and can’t afford the Pagid’s at the mo.

Any advice, specific for my motor??

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
If you're using it for fast road and occasional track, Mintex 1144's are excellent. Avoid Greenstuff like the plague.

Tina K

22,031 posts

243 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
Mintex 1144s are available for the 111R. Try eliseparts.com

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
Mintex 1144's are excellent


yes Word.

Gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
I realise the pagids are expensive BUT they are worth it. They also last very well.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
My experience:

Pagids best but expensive and you need to follow the bedding-in process *to the letter* to avoid nasty squealy nonsense around town. If it's a track slag then the best choice, but if you use it regularly on road then make sure you bed them in properly, unless you don't care about loud squealing coming up to every traffic light in town and everyone staring thinking you don't maintain your car properly

Mintex 1144 great compromise pad, got them on mine.

EBC Greenstuff - avoid like the plague, they are specifically designed to be a low friction pad for easy limit modulation, and low dust to keep your alloys looking good. Not what you need with an Elise, the low friction will scare the shit out of you, and if you don't have a servo then Greenstuff are dangerous.

EBC Redstuff - the ceramic pads are *very* good and IMO between the Mintex and the Pagid for bite and friction. Not much squeal, but don't fade (after loads of laps of Brands GP in a supercharged 911). Don't need to warm up for road driving - IMO better than the Mintex but a bit more aggressive on the discs. Just because the Greenstuff are utter shite, doesn't mean all EBC products are poor - the Red are worth a shot if you can get them cheaper than Mintex, otherwise go with Mintex. Not sure if the Red is that easily available for the 111R though.

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
cyberface said:

EBC Greenstuff - avoid like the plague, they are specifically designed to be a low friction pad for easy limit modulation, and low dust to keep your alloys looking good. Not what you need with an Elise, the low friction will scare the shit out of you, and if you don't have a servo then Greenstuff are dangerous.


Swore I'd ignore brake pad queries but this does make me laugh.

Ran Greenstuffs for a year. They are no different to OEM, during the time I had them a kid on a pushbike started to cross the road 5 yards in front of the car. No alternative but to perform an emergency stop. The brakes were more than adequate.

At no point have I ever had the shit scared out of me and whenever I've been to a meet I've always found a lot of cars running them and the owners saying they're fine.

It's all relative - if you run Pagids then Greenstuffs will be weak in comparision but if you don't go on track, you're not going to die (a very experienced track user even told me he ran them on a trackday once and they didn't melt, shock horror). The Elise is a light car and doesn't need much in the way of braking power at road limits, you'd have to have drum brakes to really suffer.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
Been a lot of threads recently about brake pads and I'm not going to get involved in the relative stopping abilities and fade properties of one vs the other.
My experience on a S1 Elise is that the Mintex 1144s do seem to offer better stopping power than either oem or Greenstuffs but more important to me is that they give me great better feel and I find them easier to modulate (surprising given cyberface's comments on the greenstuffs). That gives me greater confidence in MY ability to stop my car in all circumstances.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
kevin ritson said:
cyberface said:

EBC Greenstuff - avoid like the plague, they are specifically designed to be a low friction pad for easy limit modulation, and low dust to keep your alloys looking good. Not what you need with an Elise, the low friction will scare the shit out of you, and if you don't have a servo then Greenstuff are dangerous.


Swore I'd ignore brake pad queries but this does make me laugh.

Ran Greenstuffs for a year. They are no different to OEM, during the time I had them a kid on a pushbike started to cross the road 5 yards in front of the car. No alternative but to perform an emergency stop. The brakes were more than adequate.

At no point have I ever had the shit scared out of me and whenever I've been to a meet I've always found a lot of cars running them and the owners saying they're fine.

It's all relative - if you run Pagids then Greenstuffs will be weak in comparision but if you don't go on track, you're not going to die (a very experienced track user even told me he ran them on a trackday once and they didn't melt, shock horror). The Elise is a light car and doesn't need much in the way of braking power at road limits, you'd have to have drum brakes to really suffer.

Fair enough, everyone's different, but I don't make statements of this sort without having had personal experience or having read professional studies, I'm no keyboard warrior with an axe to grind.

Check EBC's product data - they have friction and temp ranges for their pads, I've seen data for Green, Red and Yellow. The Green is *very* low friction and they explain why in the text. I've also had Greenstuff on a mk1 MX-5, an S1 Elise with (allegedly 160 bhp), and my VXT came supplied with them. On the Elise and VXT I swapped immediately for Mintex 1144 which is marketed by Mintex as a 'fast road' pad and NOT a high-bite race pad like some of the Pagids, etc.

I still reckon, for general road use, the Green is *worse* than OEM fitment for lightweights like Elises, Exiges and VXs. I've driven a non-servo S2 Elise (my mate's car, trying to keep up with him driving my VXT!) on Greenstuff and the response was frightening.

A lot of the other guys here who say Greenstuff is an inappropriate pad for the Elise also have direct, first hand experience. It's not all some sort of parrot-job of second-hand information, and I most certainly don't have a problem with EBC - since I really rate their Red pads and *loved* their performance on my last car.

Bottom line to me is that it's my opinion, and the opinion of plenty of other owners who have tried multiple brands of pad, that EBC Green doesn't work too well with lightweight cars. I respect your opinion if you disagree, but saying 'it makes you laugh' and dismissing my opinion contemptuously does you no favours at all, old chap.

Janitor

2,372 posts

250 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
I need new pads (apparently). My SportsRacer will be getting the 1144's thumbup

Dealer told me that I had 50 to 100 miles left on mine (whilst being a couple of hundred miles from home). Declined their offer thinking "50 miles of what..?". Motorway will see next to no usage, Walshy Day somewhat different. So what is this '50 miles'..? Distance under 'normal' conditions? 50 miles of actual brake usage?

Struck me as a rather daft summary rolleyes

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Thursday 5th April 2007
quotequote all
How the hell can someone predict 50 to 100 Miles?! Just get 'em replaced when it won't stop anymore! hehe

You won't go wrong with the 1144's fella, I drive like a complete arscensoredole, and they manage to bring me to a halt........err......except when there's a deer in the road.....boxedin

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
cyberface said:
kevin ritson said:
cyberface said:

EBC Greenstuff - avoid like the plague, they are specifically designed to be a low friction pad for easy limit modulation, and low dust to keep your alloys looking good. Not what you need with an Elise, the low friction will scare the shit out of you, and if you don't have a servo then Greenstuff are dangerous.


Swore I'd ignore brake pad queries but this does make me laugh.

Ran Greenstuffs for a year. They are no different to OEM, during the time I had them a kid on a pushbike started to cross the road 5 yards in front of the car. No alternative but to perform an emergency stop. The brakes were more than adequate.

At no point have I ever had the shit scared out of me and whenever I've been to a meet I've always found a lot of cars running them and the owners saying they're fine.

It's all relative - if you run Pagids then Greenstuffs will be weak in comparision but if you don't go on track, you're not going to die (a very experienced track user even told me he ran them on a trackday once and they didn't melt, shock horror). The Elise is a light car and doesn't need much in the way of braking power at road limits, you'd have to have drum brakes to really suffer.

Fair enough, everyone's different, but I don't make statements of this sort without having had personal experience or having read professional studies, I'm no keyboard warrior with an axe to grind.

Check EBC's product data - they have friction and temp ranges for their pads, I've seen data for Green, Red and Yellow. The Green is *very* low friction and they explain why in the text. I've also had Greenstuff on a mk1 MX-5, an S1 Elise with (allegedly 160 bhp), and my VXT came supplied with them. On the Elise and VXT I swapped immediately for Mintex 1144 which is marketed by Mintex as a 'fast road' pad and NOT a high-bite race pad like some of the Pagids, etc.

I still reckon, for general road use, the Green is *worse* than OEM fitment for lightweights like Elises, Exiges and VXs. I've driven a non-servo S2 Elise (my mate's car, trying to keep up with him driving my VXT!) on Greenstuff and the response was frightening.

A lot of the other guys here who say Greenstuff is an inappropriate pad for the Elise also have direct, first hand experience. It's not all some sort of parrot-job of second-hand information, and I most certainly don't have a problem with EBC - since I really rate their Red pads and *loved* their performance on my last car.

Bottom line to me is that it's my opinion, and the opinion of plenty of other owners who have tried multiple brands of pad, that EBC Green doesn't work too well with lightweight cars. I respect your opinion if you disagree, but saying 'it makes you laugh' and dismissing my opinion contemptuously does you no favours at all, old chap.


Try reading my post - you may notice that I speak of FIRST HAND EXPERIENCE, you're the one being contemptuous. Tell me one person that has been killed or injured using Greenstuffs. Frankly your earlier post borders on the libellous and I'm surprised it hasn't been moderated under the naming and shaming policy.

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
EBC on an Elise are, in my experience, worse than OEM. I know of NO specialists or drivers worth their salt who would ever recommend fitting them to an Elise given the alternatives which cost more or less the same. Sure they work fine with other cars, but on the Elise they really are not as good as other similar priced alternatives.

No-one's yet mentioned SBS pads which are highly regarded by at least one LoT regular. Anyone used these?

stitch

933 posts

248 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
S works

I'll tell you of a specialist who fits Greenstuff - Chris Foulds near Huddersfield.

CF is very well respected by the Lotus community up here (to the extent that when a posted a query on here regarding some work Foulds suggested that I had done, on a no names basis - a NYLOC member responded that if it was CF suggesting that the work was necessary - then it was).

I agree with the comments in respect of a low-friction brake pad - which sounds pretty dangerous to me.

In fact I thought the idea of a low-friction brake pad was so concerning that I had a look on EBC's web site myself and found the following overview:

"Triple Max Power Award winning Greenstuff are the ultimate performance/fast street brake pads you can get for your hot hatch or sport compact. These pads have a high friction coefficient, great initial bite from cold, right up to a blistering 650 degrees centigrade. Another major benefit of the Greenstuff compound is its award-winning feature of being LOW DUST."

The piece also recommends the pad for cars producing up to 200 bhp.

For all you track gods out there I'm sure that there are better pads - for the rest of us who like a 'spirited' drive on public roads in our 120bhp+, light weight cars I'm sure that Greenstuff are fine.

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
stitch said:

For all you track gods out there I'm sure that there are better pads - for the rest of us who like a 'spirited' drive on public roads in our 120bhp+, light weight cars I'm sure that Greenstuff are fine.


Spot on, if you're running a Honda, Audi, S/C 'yota or harder suspension then I wouldn't recommend them, certainly S160 owners aren't going to like them, for example. Claiming something is dangerous when it clearly isn't (Pagids say clearly on the box "Not for road use", so you could argue they are dangerous too but I'd disagree) is a bit overdramatic.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Friday 6th April 2007
quotequote all
The politics of this thread and manufacturers blurb aside, different pads will produce different braking characteristics. I never really liked the brake feel of the OE pads - the initial bite is poor compared to other options, although clearly with adequate braking force, they will stop the car effectively. Probably much the same for greenstuff. However, back to back, most people with elises prefer pads that give better initial bite.

For mainly road use, the mintex 1144's are far better than the OE pads, for a very reasonable price. They are fine on track under relatively light use. For harder track use, the Pagid RS 42's offer much more durability and resistance to fade with similar initial bite when cold.

Pagid RS 14's squeal like "Brian Blessed being gang-raped by 42 Tunisian market traders" (Jeremy Clarkson's metaphor). They are a bit scary when cold, eat OE discs, but are the daddy when warmed up and subjected to hard track abuse.

My car as a daily driver and heavily used track toy gets Pagid RS42's. For road use - performance vs costs, there is little reason not to use mintex 1144's.

redlake27

2,255 posts

275 months

Sunday 8th April 2007
quotequote all
I just bought some Mintex Xtremes and used them at a Donington track day.

Very progressive - no fade.

Recommended,

Fast delivery from this ebay trader too..........

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dl

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Sunday 8th April 2007
quotequote all
kevin ritson said:
Frankly your earlier post borders on the libellous and I'm surprised it hasn't been moderated under the naming and shaming policy.

Yeah right, personal and friends' experience and opinion counts as libel? Sue me then rolleyes

Leave the moderating to the moderators eh chap.

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Monday 9th April 2007
quotequote all
cyberface said:
kevin ritson said:
Frankly your earlier post borders on the libellous and I'm surprised it hasn't been moderated under the naming and shaming policy.

Yeah right, personal and friends' experience and opinion counts as libel? Sue me then rolleyes

Leave the moderating to the moderators eh chap.


So tell us who has died or been injured as a direct consequence of using Greenstuffs

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Monday 9th April 2007
quotequote all
Folks - please get this back on track. If you really have to beat each other to death with your handbags, let me know where you are doing it, as I have a quiet week ahead and would really like to watch.




Edited by shangani on Monday 9th April 10:25