Discussion
now then, I'm about to pick up my new car, an elise 111s (2003). My question is this: is it worth fuelling with a higher octane fuel like the tescos 99 RON rather than the usual 95 stuff? I know it made a difference with my Boxster but I'm unsure whether the trusty K-series has the neccesary gubbins in it to know what fuel it has and make any adjustments to the ignition etc.
I've been reading about RON and his Knock sensors...
A
I've been reading about RON and his Knock sensors...
A
Hollywood Wheels said:
No knock sensors on the K series, so I believe it will make no difference. Please don't ask what a knock sensor is because I haven't got a clue, just trying to sound like I know what I'm talking about....
Simplistic explanation: A knock sensor is a sensor that detects 'knock', otherwise known as 'pinking' or it's more destructive high-speed brother, 'detonation' (ie. the fuel exploding earlier than it is supposed to, in an uncontrolled manner, while the piston is still moving upwards).
In the olden days of clockwork ignition systems, maximum power was obtained by advancing the ignition so that the spark fired (giving controlled combustion) at a point just before knock set in. Too much retard was safe but would reduce power, too much advance and detonation would destroy your engine, so naturally most people erred on the side of caution. Traditional technique is to drive the car up a steep hill in high gear, and if it starts to pink under large throttle openings, you retard the ignition a little bit, until it stops!
High octane fuel will stand more ignition advance before knock sets in, so you can adjust the engine to produce more power with fuel of a higher octane rating.
On a modern engine management system with a knock sensor, the computer can advance the ignition to the point where it starts to sense knock, so adjusting for the octane rating of the fuel and making maximum power without destroying the engine. In other words... the computer is doing the equivalent of 'listening' for the pinking and retarding the ignition slightly if it 'hears' it, with continuous adjustment while the car is actually running. In actual fact, a knock sensor is nothing more than an electronic 'ear' fixed to the engine block, which can sense the sharp shocks of pinking/detonation.
The K-series doesn't have a knock sensor - it uses a fixed ignition map, set up to err on the side of caution (for 95 RON fuel) so higher octane is, in theory, a waste of money on the Elise.
.... having said all which, the more expensive 'premium' brands of high octane fuel will usually have bigger doses of additives that look after your valves, pistons and piston rings and are often reported - subjectively - to burn smoother than 95 RON by some people who use them, even in cars with a fixed ignition map.
Personally I wouldn't bother with an Elise (I have to run high octane in my Elan, because the old Lotus Twin Cam is very prone to detonation on 95 RON), but each to their own...
I think BP state on their website that their top octane fuel contains 5 times as many detergents as standard fuels.
Not sure if this is the same with Tesco, but Shell say the same of their Optimax, or whatever it is now called.
These detergents are supposed to keep your engine internals clean and happy, and the cleaner burning should mean more mpg.
There was a chap on Seloc who checked his mpg and it really was a lot better, so the extra cost was offset.
Not sure if this is the same with Tesco, but Shell say the same of their Optimax, or whatever it is now called.
These detergents are supposed to keep your engine internals clean and happy, and the cleaner burning should mean more mpg.
There was a chap on Seloc who checked his mpg and it really was a lot better, so the extra cost was offset.
Nice one Sam.
Where it gets interesting is when you realise that higher octane fule contains no more calories than standard fuel. It simply has an additive that makes the fuel 'atomise' or form smaller droplets (finer vapour) when forced through the engine. Because the fuel has a finer vapour it burns quicker and more completly thus releasing more of the energy in a shorter period. This can contribute to pinking (duh!).
So keep your carb needles fine and clean and your injectors in tip top condition, probably by using a good quality fuel.
I have been having trouble with my car misfiring on a high revving, neutral throttle, a couple of tanks of 'super' seems to have cured the problem...
Where it gets interesting is when you realise that higher octane fule contains no more calories than standard fuel. It simply has an additive that makes the fuel 'atomise' or form smaller droplets (finer vapour) when forced through the engine. Because the fuel has a finer vapour it burns quicker and more completly thus releasing more of the energy in a shorter period. This can contribute to pinking (duh!).
So keep your carb needles fine and clean and your injectors in tip top condition, probably by using a good quality fuel.
I have been having trouble with my car misfiring on a high revving, neutral throttle, a couple of tanks of 'super' seems to have cured the problem...
Edited by Gooby on Saturday 7th April 12:10
Gooby said:
Where it gets interesting is when you realise that higher octane fule contains no more calories than standard fuel.
Perfectly correct. Octane rating is a rating of anti-knock properties, not how much energy there is in the fuel. The methanol fuel used on some dragsters and hillclimb cars (banned in most other categories of motorsport) actually has much lower calorific value than petrol, but it burns much cooler, hence avoids detonation again. To get the power from methanol, though, you have to burn enormous quantities of it in comparison to petrol...
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




