Buying an Exige... do I 'need' the supercharger....?
Buying an Exige... do I 'need' the supercharger....?
Author
Discussion

tony*t3

Original Poster:

20,911 posts

278 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
OK, been saving up to get an Exige S2 in the nearish future....

But the question I have is, do I need an Exige S or should I stick with a regular non Supercharged model.....???

I'm not 'the king of speed', but I like the occasional track day. Previous car was a Cooper S with tuning up to around 230bhp, so I was kind of addicted to the supercharged performance and upgrading.

So the question is, if I buy a regular Exige, will it have enough power, or will I always crave the Exige S?

Also, should I buy new or second hand? I'd prefer it if someone else took the early depreciation, but is it risky buying a second hand exige.....? And does a non supercharged Exige make a better second hand buy than a second hand Exige S???

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
There are a couple of very well kitted Exige S cars for sale at the moment. You could get one around 30K. To me the exige S is a far better road car than the standard exige, but not that much difference on track. If the difference in price was spent sorting handling / brakes etc on the standard exige, it would be quicker on track.

Personally I would only buy an elise / exige with the yota engine if it was forced induction.

_Lee_

7,520 posts

274 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all

subaqua

892 posts

243 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
Agree with much of what Andrew said. I have a 111R and on the road the extra low down torque of the supercharged versions makes swift progress through traffic much easier as maintaining your momentum in the standard versions requires lots of revs, but on track, it seems a lot of that advantage dissipates (but maybe thats because the drivers of Exige S's Ive seen, aren't quite so familiar with the handling of the cars).

As I have an unsupercharged Yota, I wouldn't pay the difference the upgrade to an Exige S (I did toy with the idea though), I'd get much better value by spending that money on other mods. You don't need the supercharger... but you might prefer it... drive the cars back to back with a dealer to see whether you prefer the flatter torque curve of the S to the mad frenzy of the standard car when the second cam comes in.

Either wat there is great value in some of the nearly new cars you'll see on here.... for an S 30k ish will get you a high spec low mileage car which would cost you the best part of 45 new..... and a lightly used standard Exige wouldn't cost much more than 20k.

You could always buy a standard one now.... and upgrade to one of the aftermarket charger conversions once the newness has worn off



Edited by subaqua on Thursday 12th April 11:00

tricky 100

954 posts

273 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
Depends how much money you want to spend really . Ive got the non supercharged model and think its more than enough , i wouldn't pay an extra 8-10 k for the extra 25ish BHP .

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
Get the Exige S ! Its much quicker than the exige in a straight line. and further down the line you can always get the boost uprated on the Exige S if you want even more speed ! I tried an S and it really does feel a lot quicker.

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
If you have the funds then get the 'S' but at just over £30K you will still lose a lot of money in depreciation.

If the car will be for mostly road use then the standard car is fine.

I had one of the best drives of my life on Saturday in Mid Wales. The roads were empty and the sum was out. I stopped after one 12 mile section completely wired with adrenalin and asked myself if I would ever really need to go any faster on a public road. The answer was a very big no.

Extra grunt of the S would be nice to have on track but for me its not worth the extra premium over the standard car

chris_n

1,232 posts

289 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
I agree with Shangani - where the S really scores is on the road where its extra torque in the mid range really makes a big difference to the driving experience (I've owned both a standard and supercharged Exige and done close to 10k road miles in each so speak from experience). The S isn't really all that much more powerful overall so I can well believe that on the track the difference counts for less than driver skill.

Don't be afraid to buy used - they are dead reliable. Also don't hesitate to buy privately (subject to the normal sensible precautions e.g. has it been serviced etc) as any S you look at will still have a year of manufacturer's warranty left of it.

Chris

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
Hmmm let me think a S1 Honda vs S2 Exige ...... http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?d

I'd look at some other options too, if you want power. Plenty of Honda/Audi converted cars that put out more than the Exige S.

David Segal

16 posts

278 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all

I tried a standard 111R first but decided to wait for the supercharged version. Unless you enjoy always revving the nuts off the car when you drive it I'd recommend you get a blown car.

Its not the extra power but the far wider power band - with the blower it pulls from low revs to the limiter so much so that (despite my stated comments about revving the engine hard) I find on the track I still cant stop it bouncing off the limiter fairly regularly. All the excitement in the standard car comes in a fairly narrow rev band starting at 6250!! with the adjustable Ohlins suspension i think the s/c car is just brilliant - but possibly too fast for UK roads if you dont pay close attention to ensuring you keep your licence

At least...Drive both and then decide

chris_n

1,232 posts

289 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
(responding to Paul RN below, though agree with DS's post that came in the meantime too!)

Good point. Also worth thinking about now is the option of modding an S to 280PS for just over £3k (Komo-tec). Sounds to me like the option S owners have been waiting for - who needs the new GT3 @ >£50k! Shame I just sold my S!!!

Chris


Edited by chris_n on Thursday 12th April 14:19

architect1

10 posts

272 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
I like to think it boils down to fun. You buy a lotus to have fun. So try them both and then buy the one that you find the most fun when YOU drive it.

(I choose the NA S2 exige BTW - which is a bit lighter lest we forget)

clubsport

7,420 posts

289 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
Assuming both were in your price range, I would be amazed if you drove the S2 after the S and prefered it......I drove the regular car around Hethel and then tried the S....a revelation

VTECMatt

1,373 posts

269 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
Get the supercharged the standard is not that quick

Saied

1,575 posts

250 months

Thursday 12th April 2007
quotequote all
architect1 said:
The S2 exige...is a bit lighter lest we forget

yes Important point.

Another option would be to go for the normally aspirated car with a remapped / upgraded ECU. This would bring the 2nd cam changeover point down to 5,800 rpm, making it much easier to keep 'on cam' between gearchanges. Useful both for overtaking on the road and in certain situations on track, e.g. when short shifting.


Justin

mrdemon

21,146 posts

296 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
"Get the supercharged the standard is not that quick" !!!

the S is no quicker on track infact I think an S is slower on track than an N/A
due to it weighing shed loads more, having to soft suspension and having heat soke problems.

the S is a better road car but is it 8k better ( 2nd hand values)

If you spend 8k on a NA it would walk all over an S so its your choice.

I would rather have a NA for 22k, Komotec 265Bhp 6k, Nitrons and AP disks total 30k than a standard S for the same money.

or buy a 240R or cup car for 34k


Edited by mrdemon on Friday 13th April 14:20

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
Mr demon probably has the right suggestion to be honest. Get an NA S2, drive it for a bit and upgrade suspension & brakes for track use. Then if you need more go for an aftermarket charger.

Janitor

2,372 posts

250 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
Mr demon probably has the right suggestion to be honest.


I'd have to agree too

One thing that is without question, all Elise models and derivatives are full of character and loads of fun in their own right. I guess 'typical usage' should really dictate over choice available

I have an Elise 111R and as much as I love the Exige, the R was more for me personally all round. I have to admit that the Toyota engine was a major turning point for me - if Lotus were still using Rover engines, I couldn't have got past that and would never have had such an amazing car! I can't back that up with technically grounded reasoning however… I just have a deep-seated hate for all things Rover really! Daft when you consider what I would have been missing out on though I must admit

Back on the subject - as said, the NA Exige will be stunning. The S may well be a better proposition on the road, so if that's your 99% intended usage, then perhaps the S should be your choice. I think you should get a standard one, use it, love it and then see where you want to go. From there, you may well have more effective options as Mr Demon listed above

With all that said, I'm really fighting a burning desire for an S1 Exige with an Audi lump in the back! Not to replace the R... but as well as! Still, that won't happen for a day or two just yet

Either way, enjoy looking and see what does it for you thumbup

driving

cloud9

beer

VTECMatt

1,373 posts

269 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
OK put bluntly I couldnt drive an Exige S2 quicker than an S2 111S on track.

Scuffers

20,887 posts

305 months

Saturday 14th April 2007
quotequote all
VTECMatt said:
OK put bluntly I couldnt drive an Exige S2 quicker than an S2 111S on track.

which sort of summs it up really... (real world comparision and all)