350Z Vs 111R
Author
Discussion

bing

Original Poster:

1,946 posts

269 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
Guys the other night i had a little play with a 06' 350Z and for some reason I just could not keep up in my 111r , I kept the car on 2nd cam all the time changed at the right time and nope just couldn't catch up not even on the bends!!! I now the 350Z has low down toque but this took the p!ss!!!

No w I'm no F1 driver but am quite competent!!!

I was just wondering is the 350Z really that much quicker then a stock 111r??? Or am I just a crap driver!!! I was going to buy one of these but found it's handling wasn't up to scratch and the drive boring really!!!!

Views plz!!!

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
I would have thought that the 350z would be quicker certainly top speed but not so sure around the twisties ? It shouldnt be as good on the bends surely.

TheYeti

656 posts

247 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
Believe me, the 350Z in a striaght line will monster most things this side of Porsche or stupid money cars.........my friend reluctantly sold his recently and I tried to keep up with mine and couldn't get anywhere near him on a straight..........

In the twists I got him though, but even then, the sheer grip of the Z was pretty damn impressive.

I would have one "when I grow up"........

Phil-Ch

1,132 posts

295 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
bing said:
Guys the other night i had a little play with a 06' 350Z and for some reason I just could not keep up in my 111r , I kept the car on 2nd cam all the time changed at the right time and nope just couldn't catch up not even on the bends!!! I now the 350Z has low down toque but this took the p!ss!!!

No w I'm no F1 driver but am quite competent!!!

I was just wondering is the 350Z really that much quicker then a stock 111r??? Or am I just a crap driver!!! I was going to buy one of these but found it's handling wasn't up to scratch and the drive boring really!!!!

Views plz!!!


Before I had the supercharger fitted, I once had a 350Z in front of me on the highway/autobahn. We both accelerated hard from 2nd all the way till 3rd - seemed to me the cars were pretty even, given he did not get away from me at all. I knew I would probably lose out eventually.

Maybe it was a modified 350Z you encountered? They're not that hard to mod and easy to get quite a lot of power out of...

On the other hand, I'm a bit surprised that you didn't catch him in the bends - then again, always depends what kinds of roads and how close to the limit you are using the car...

Gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
I nailed one. Coming off roundabouts I thought he had given up. They are quick in a straight line but that is about it.

tricky 100

954 posts

273 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
I met one last night that i thought wanted to play , but when i finally got a clear road he melted away , must of changed his mind .

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
Nice cars those 350's, I'd have one. Creaaaaamy V6 and apparently sublime on-limit handling. With it's grunt I imagine it'd be similar to a 111R to about a ton, and then start pulling away.

boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
Blown 350z into the weed's coming off the light's at Princess Road in Dartford, (Me 111R Z4 3.0 & 350Z) Couldn't stop laughing when they got to the roundabout looked like comedy Car's

Boggy

piddy

45 posts

236 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
I am quite surprised that you were not keeping up with it. Over 100mph I could understand but up to 100 it should be in the elises favour. 1/4 mile times seem to favour the elise over the 350Z by approximately a second. Not much I know but I would have expected there to be very little in it on the straight with the Elise showing its colours in the twisites.

Phil-Ch

1,132 posts

295 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
piddy said:
I am quite surprised that you were not keeping up with it. Over 100mph I could understand but up to 100 it should be in the elises favour. 1/4 mile times seem to favour the elise over the 350Z by approximately a second. Not much I know but I would have expected there to be very little in it on the straight with the Elise showing its colours in the twisites.



The thing is, while the Elise 111R is quicker off the lights to around 60, the 350Z makes up for it from 60-100 mph. In in-gear acceleration, the 350Z should be quicker, gaining an advantage the faster it gets. I would presume that's where the Elise lost it to the 350Z and wasn't able to make much of a difference in the corners...

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
...my thoughts exactly.

piddy

45 posts

236 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
Phil-Ch said:
piddy said:
I am quite surprised that you were not keeping up with it. Over 100mph I could understand but up to 100 it should be in the elises favour. 1/4 mile times seem to favour the elise over the 350Z by approximately a second. Not much I know but I would have expected there to be very little in it on the straight with the Elise showing its colours in the twisites.



The thing is, while the Elise 111R is quicker off the lights to around 60, the 350Z makes up for it from 60-100 mph. In in-gear acceleration, the 350Z should be quicker, gaining an advantage the faster it gets. I would presume that's where the Elise lost it to the 350Z and wasn't able to make much of a difference in the corners...



I know what you are saying. But IIRC (and I am making this up from memory) its is still 4.9 to 60 and 13.00 to 100 for the elise along side 5.4 to 60 and 14.00 to 100 for the 350Z. I would have expected it to still be holding its own at this point.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
Don't forget that the Elise's acceleration figures from rest are helped hugely by the engine being mounted over the driven wheels - the rear end grip in an Elise is phenomenal. Also, a good power/weight ratio is good for acceleration up to about 60 odd, but once up to higher speeds outright power and drag (the determiners of top speed) play more of a part. The Elise's crowning glory is its almost magical ride and handling, which means that if you truly are nuts I don't reckon anything would keep up with one down a twisty B road - not even a Caterham (and that's a Caterham owner speaking!).

I've driven a Nissan 350Z, and to be honest the steering was too heavy and leaden with very little feel, and the drive by wire throttle had a jerky delay that was pretty hideous to use. There was no way I would buy one as the controls were just rubbish. It's a shame, because the handling was good and the engine was very strong and sounded lovely. It was also quick.

I'd far rather be in the Elise!! You made the right choice of car.

bean455

674 posts

239 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
Come on one of our runs,will show you what a 350 can do.

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
its surprising, in real life, how much power difference you need to put some air between you and another car.

As mentioned above - once you are rolling then it comes down to a lot of other factors other than the paper 0-60 and 0-100 (largely unachieveable anyway)

My RS6 estate, in the real world, on anything other than a twisty B road on a dry day, is faster than my 300bhp Elise.

Even when you get to the twisty stuff, you need a ton of confidence and skill to extract anything like the best out of an Elise..and even then, you will probably be at 80% ..in a "normal" (ish) performance car with traction/stability control etc its much easier to drive them faster/closer to the limit with confidence IMO

Can anyone remember that EVO review a few years back when they benchmarked a lot of hot tackle down a section of twisty road? - as a benchmark, they had a 1.6 Ford Focus...it was pretty eye opening just how little difference there was between it and some so called "performance cars"

as for the 350Z - they are pretty cool at what they do - I suspect that from 60-150mph it would leave most factory Elises except for the supercharged models...the in gear times from Autocar are like .4sec different from a 111R/Exige so I suspect if you were caught out a few hundred revs away from optimal gear etc you would lose.....of course the other thing is it may not have been std

motaboy

91 posts

248 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
5.4 secs to 60? I didn't think they were that quick, more like 5.8. My mate's got one and they are a cracking car but I wouldn't swap one for a moment.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
Very true bogie. The key point in my post above is "if you truly are nuts"... I've been racing since I was 22 and karting since 17, and I'm therefore quite comfortable driving to the absolute limit and beyond. However, I simply run into a barrier when I try and drive fast on the road - that barrier is called my sanity! A madman in a Corsa could probably have me in the Lotus on a B road!

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
RobM77 said:
Very true bogie. The key point in my post above is "if you truly are nuts"... I've been racing since I was 22 and karting since 17, and I'm therefore quite comfortable driving to the absolute limit and beyond. However, I simply run into a barrier when I try and drive fast on the road - that barrier is called my sanity! A madman in a Corsa could probably have me in the Lotus on a B road!



exactly ...I often have fun with other cars but always leave myself 10-20% in the car and my own abilities just in case the unexpected is waiting around the next corner...I have on a few occasions let some lunatic with a death wish come past me, in far inferior vehicles ....overtaking on blind bends and inconveniencing other road users with dodgy manouveres is not my style!

21TonyK

13,414 posts

240 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
RobM77 said:
Very true bogie. The key point in my post above is "if you truly are nuts"... I've been racing since I was 22 and karting since 17, and I'm therefore quite comfortable driving to the absolute limit and beyond. However, I simply run into a barrier when I try and drive fast on the road - that barrier is called my sanity! A madman in a Corsa could probably have me in the Lotus on a B road!


This is so true. It's the "fear of death" that prevents more experienced and mature drivers from aggressive road racing. IMHO a bit of fun on a B road is okay when not taken seriously. I used to let many a teen-driven-corsa-bean-tin-exhaust-ridden-two-tone-paint-with-NOS-strickered-?car? beat me in my M3 purely because I valued my family and my life. More importantly I knew that if pushed they'd probably run out of luck before me and I'd then feel responsible for them as well.

Track fun is one thing, the road is another.

clubsport

7,420 posts

289 months

Friday 13th April 2007
quotequote all
fitting a supercharger to a 350Z is not that uncommon...if that makes you feel any better