Young drivers insuring an elise
Young drivers insuring an elise
Author
Discussion

r200mgr

Original Poster:

103 posts

279 months

Sunday 15th April 2007
quotequote all
Hello,

Been thinking recently about a car for the summer and can afford an elise now! I've always loved them and from owning mg's and rover's the elise seems a reasonable progression. The only problem is that I'm only 18 so Ithe insurance will probably laugh at me does anyone have any experience with getting insured on an elise at a young age? My dad also loves them and is interested in getting one so there might be the oppurtunity of going on his policy.

Cheers for any advice!

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Sunday 15th April 2007
quotequote all
Do a search on the forum - this topic has come up before.

I think it's probably fair to say that if you're only 18, anyone who is willing to insure you at all is going to butt you royally for the privilege.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Sunday 15th April 2007
quotequote all
You're going to have trouble insuring one - check the specialist insurers out but I guess your age is going to count seriously against you. It's a shame really because they're great little cars and even the low-power Elises aren't that fast - but they cost a lot to repair in terms of bodywork, and plenty of people spin them, so I guess the insurance is high for clam repair / replacement alone.

You could try a normally aspirated VX220 - this will be faster than base Elises because of the bigger engine, but handles slightly differently - the N/A car is closer to Elise balance than the VXT though. That said, the young guys trying to get insured competitively on VX220s on the vx220.org.uk forum seem to be finding it difficult.

Seems that 20 or younger gets £2k premiums unless you're lucky. One lad on vx220.org got insured at 20 for less than a grand on a VX220 but he turned out to be a police officer. Presumably lower risk??? hehe

VXs definitely lower insurance than Elises though in general. If the badge bothers you then you will have to pay for the Elise insurance. May be worth a year in a cheaper VX, put the difference to the insurance, then chop in for a fast Elise or Exige when you've got some experience / NCD and know the cars a little. You can get an early, sheddy Elise for less than a cheap VX, but the cheap VX will be a *lot* newer and better condition than a comparable price Elise. The difference in purchase price could fund your insurance...

Moist1

9 posts

235 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
VX220 would be a much better bet than an Elise for you from an insurance perspective.

Come to think of it, it is a better car from any perspective!



lawrence5

1,254 posts

266 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
120bhp S1 is group 17 most others are 19/20..... you will struggle - make sure you get some driver training too. Whatever your experience level it's always beneficial....

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
Get an MX5 or a Cater-field. You'll have just as much fun, much cheaper to buy, maintain and insure, and probably a better car if you're a less experienced driver.

jamiebae

6,245 posts

242 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
lawrence5 said:
120bhp S1 is group 17 most others are 19/20..... you will struggle - make sure you get some driver training too. Whatever your experience level it's always beneficial....


Seconded on the driver training. A guy I went to school with was bought a new S1 as his first car, a few months later he lost it at high speed going through a series of bends and hit a tree. It destroyed the car and he was killed, as was his best friend who was in the passenger seat.

I think the suggestion of an MX5 is a good one, especially as the insurance on the Elise is likely to cost almost as much as the car!

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
I guess all you can do is run some quotes but insurance companies, quite unfairly to you, will not want your business due to the last generation of 18 year old drivers causing too many problems for them.

As far as they are concerned, an 18 year old lad in a sportscar is the absolute worst risk on earth, and now matter how mature and sensible you otherwise are, they ain't gonna listen.

However, we are supposed to live in a free democracy, so you will get quotes....only the insurers will pip them so high you are, effectively, unable to get insurance.

Try www.moneysupermarket.com for loads of quotes.


It may help a real lot if you agree to low annual miles, have a garage and, curiously, add another driver - your sister, perhaps ( then don't ever let her drive it, of course ).

You could register and insure the car in your Dad's name with you as an additional driver, but insurance companies have cottoned onto this and normally slam you even more than if in your name. Many will not give you any NCD then, just your Dad ( although Direct Line will, as will Tesco I think, but they both demand trackers and were not cheap for me )

Still worth a go, though - especially with the internet search engines

cej

961 posts

253 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
Moist1 said:
VX220 would be a much better bet than an Elise for you from an insurance perspective.

Come to think of it, it is a better car from any perspective!





No it's not . Now go away and post in the VX forum

Chr1sG

39 posts

235 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
tesco value insurance.

cheap and simple

Alex_S

75 posts

249 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
As has been said you're gonna have trouble to be honest mate. I insured an elise S2 111S when i was 20, £3500!!!! and that was the cheapest i could get with the few companies that would even insure me. Obviously the 111S is a bit more expensive than the lower powered models but not by much im afraid, cant speak for VX220's, maybe worth a try. Trying to put yourself on your dads policy is pretty pointless aswell, i tried this and it was more expensive than having my own policy! plus you dont get any no claims. Your best bet is to wait until you're 21, I know it sounds like a long time but i was in the same position as you not long ago and its certainly worth the wait! driving

kermitman

5,426 posts

240 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
Alex_S said:
Obviously the 111S is a bit more expensive than the lower powered models but not by much im afraid



bizarrely for me to insure a 111s its cheaper than a standard S2!

work that out, also if i stayed with directline for my 2nd policy every type of elise or exige would require a tracker fitted apart from a 135r elise and 240r exige.

now that baffles me even more.confused

also isnt a 111s cheaper to tax now than a standard elise?

woza

1,253 posts

267 months

Saturday 12th May 2007
quotequote all
i got an insurance quote for an s1, im 21 with no ncb and it came out at around £1100. not too bad, im sure it wont be much more for you?

Alex_S

75 posts

249 months

Sunday 13th May 2007
quotequote all
kermitman said:
bizarrely for me to insure a 111s its cheaper than a standard S2!


That is weird! always been the other way round for me. thats the insurance lottery for you i suppose!

woza said:
i got an insurance quote for an s1, im 21 with no ncb and it came out at around £1100. not too bad, im sure it wont be much more for you?


youll find insurance companies will ask stupid prices for anyone under 21, after that it drops dramatically. same again at 25 it seems. the day before my 21st birthday it would cost me £3500 to insure my car, the day after, about £1500, im sure my driving hasnt improved that much in the space of 3 days! madness.

Moist1

9 posts

235 months

Wednesday 16th May 2007
quotequote all
cej said:
Moist1 said:
VX220 would be a much better bet than an Elise for you from an insurance perspective.

Come to think of it, it is a better car from any perspective!





No it's not . Now go away and post in the VX forum



Oh dear, touchy!

hahithestevieboy

845 posts

245 months

Wednesday 16th May 2007
quotequote all
Getting an mx5 or a toyota mr2 is good advice. You may find that the elise is too expensive for you to run. Alternatively, if you are desparate, you could get your dad to insure it and take you to trackdays (which will be the only chance you get to drive it properly anyway). Driver training is also a must at your age. I would reccomend an old and cheap boggo s1. Do all the fixing of it yourself etc...

ganglandboss

8,568 posts

234 months

Sunday 3rd June 2007
quotequote all
cej said:
Moist1 said:
VX220 would be a much better bet than an Elise for you from an insurance perspective.

Come to think of it, it is a better car from any perspective!

smile
No it's not . Now go away and post in the VX forum
Couldn't have put it better myself! If anyone needs further proof, watch the video on youtube of Tiff Needell putting them both round a track.

Shnozz

30,693 posts

302 months

Monday 4th June 2007
quotequote all
David Blunkett said:
VX220 would be a much better bet than an Elise for you from an insurance perspective.

Come to think of it, it is a better car from any perspective!

smile
apart from the front, side and rear perspective.

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Monday 4th June 2007
quotequote all
Look in the insurance teckwiki on www.seloc.co.uk

It lists all of the main insurers Elise owners use, some of which have dedicated people who look after Lotus owners.

Several of them also give a discount for Seloc members.

S9AJE

240 posts

239 months

Monday 4th June 2007
quotequote all
i'm 25 with full NCB and my 111R costs me £1300 - ok so i've got some points but you may struggle - good luck