Understeer - tyre related?
Understeer - tyre related?
Author
Discussion

jamiebae

Original Poster:

6,245 posts

242 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
My S1 seems to understeer rather more than I'd expect it to and I suspect it's tyre related.

The fronts and rears are both pretty new, Toyo Proxes on the front (185/55 15) and Dunlop SP Sport 01 on the back (185/something 16). The rears seem to get a lot hotter and stickier than the fronts, if it's driving along the motorway at high speed or having a good thrash along some twisty roads. I reckon my '05 Mini running on 175 15s had more front end grip than the Lotus seems to and felt more adjustable taking roundabouts at high speed and stuff.

So, what do yo guys suggest? Do I junk the Toyos and get a pair of Dunlops for the front, put some Toyos on the rear or something else? Ideally I want to spend as little as possible because the Clio needs a pair of front tyres and the Panda has its first MoT tomorrow so a cheap solution would be good....

SteveoM5

11 posts

236 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Check your tyre pressures....I negelected mine for a month then went for a thrash and nearly came off due to massive understeer on a few tight bends that I'd normally not even break a sweat going round. I checked the tyre pressure at the garage and found my fronts to be down over 10psi a corner !!! Once they were back up to 26 psi normal service was resumed.

jamiebae

Original Poster:

6,245 posts

242 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
What should the pressures be ideally? I'll check when I get home tonight

jaykaybi

3,494 posts

252 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
I just put my front Toyos at 27, usually 26 beforehand. Seem good (they had dropped to 23/24 over time and things had gotten noticeably saggy) at 27.

SteveoM5

11 posts

236 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
I go with 26 front and 29 rear. Not sure Exiges pressures - either wait for an owner to read this thread or ring Lotus themselves.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Same tyres front and rear? Always essential in any car, unless this tyre mixing is a special S1 trick I'm not aware of?

Failing that, a geometry check might be in order. When I was looking at buying Elises, they seemed to vary a lot in steering feel and balance. It turned out this was mainly due to tyre pressures and geometry. Somewhere like Plans Motorsport seem to know a lot about geometry settings etc with respect to handling - a friend of mine has been very pleased with what they've done for him.

I can't speak for the S1, but my S2 is amazingly controllable when it gently starts to understeer, and the understeer can be dialled out simply by the way you drive. An S1 driving friend of mine reports the same lovely handling with his S1.

I run the Bridgestones designed for the S2 all round on my S2 111S and either understeer or oversteer are available at any time, just depending on the way you drive. This applies on a wet or dry track.


Edited by RobM77 on Tuesday 17th April 13:52

cuzza

2,042 posts

284 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Get rid of the rear tyres and put something decent on - firstly they're the wrong size, rears on an S1 should be 205/50/R16 or 225/45/R16 preferably the latter as that's the size Lotus did Neovas in, secondly they're a saloon car tyre (my Passat has SP Sport 01s on it!) - if they've got lots of meat on them, sell them. If you have a decent amount of tread on the fronts, then put the right sized Toyos on the rear (I assume they're T1-R or T1-S?) however none of that really explains the understeer.

Check your pressures as said, I never ran Toyos on my S1 but 27/29 sounds a bit high to although it's probably a good starting point as it sounds like it works for someone so should be OK.

If it's still not right then look at the way you're driving it and then the geo in that order. If you go flying into a roundabout and just twirl the wheel, most cars (even Elises) will understeer - have you got std suspension?

jamiebae

Original Poster:

6,245 posts

242 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Sorry, I was half asleep when I wrote that! The rears are 205/50 16 (correct size)

Suspension is stock and all tyres have lots of tread on them. I was just surprised at how the car seems to understeer and nothing seemed to stop it wanting to plough straight on, whatever I did with the throttle.

Maybe a set of Toyos for the rear and a check of the pressures might be in order then, and possibly some driving lessons!

Edited by jamiebae on Tuesday 17th April 14:13

Gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Dont mix tyres. Bad bad bad.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Gooby said:
Dont mix tyres. Bad bad bad.


When I bought my 325i and my MR2 they had mismatched tyres. Both either understeered or oversteered way too much in the wet depending on which way I swapped the tyres round (Ask me sometime about the amusing incident where I tried the rubbish rears on the MR2 and there was a thunderstorm whilst I was out.. I frightened the whole of Basingstoke stupid!). A complete set of the same tyres solved both cars handling issues.

walker2686

52 posts

240 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
I have Toyo T1-R's all round on my S1 and I have no problem with understeer so I doubt it will be the tyres on the front. Like you say, get the Toyo's on the rear aswell and see how that affects it.