Insurance liability
Author
Discussion

jb111s

Original Poster:

393 posts

249 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Wonder if anyone in the know re these things can help, if so much appreciated.

When working over the weekend I managed to prang my car in a clients car park. As I was using the car for business purposes transporting some computer hardware this means I was technically using the car for work.

Therefore, is my company liable for any damage caused to my car as my own insurance restricts me using it for work purposes. Getting a few conflicting reports but my company is quite big (around 5,000) so would assume that they would have some kind of insurance cover for such mishaps.

Our HR dep is useless & hasn't got a clue, so before I write a sh*tty email to the partners would like to know if anyone else has had a similar experience & would know where I would stand.

Thanks

shnozz

30,694 posts

302 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
I cant see any way in such a case whereby there would be any liability within the hands of your employer to be honest. I would expect it to fall at the hands of your own motor insurers, at least in the first instance.

planty67

27 posts

236 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Usually it depends on your contract of employment.

If this says that you are obliged to use your car for business purposes then the company assumes you will insure your car accordingly and you are liable.
If there is no such clause then the company have to insure you if they expect you to use your own car - they are liable.
If they provide alternatives (hire car, pool car etc) then they can argue that you used your car by choice and you are liable.
Sometimes companies will pay a high mileage rate for you to use your own car and they will argue that this covers your fuel costs, wear and tear, tax and insurance.

I hope it's no 2. Good luck.

jb111s

Original Poster:

393 posts

249 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Cheers guys.

My own insurance only covers me for social & domestic use only. I originally wanted to jump in an adison lee minibus cab who we have an account with but my boss was against this as it would cost the company too much money so I was told to drive down to the client site.

So I was technically instructed to use my car if this makes a difference ?

planty67

27 posts

236 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Sounds like you might be on a winner.

I'm assuming your contract of employment doesn't say you have to use your own car - strike option1.
You were instructed NOT to use the alternative (presumably the alternative is company policy given there is an account in place) - strike option 3 by default.
I assume you don't get any additional mileage rates for using your car - strike option 4.

By instructing you to use your car your boss has put option 2 in play. Your insurance won't pay up because you are only covered SD&P so your company should cover you for any loss. You might need to argue a bit though ("I assumed I would be covered under a company policy when you instructed me etc etc".

Hope you get it sorted.

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
I always thought that damage caused on company turf would result in you having to go through your own insurance as you generally park there etc at your own risk. Do you have buisness insurance cover with your standard insurance? because if not, they may not pay up as your were driving your vehicle for buisness purposes.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
So you took your car, which you knew wasn't covered, and then you caused (whether you meant to or not) damage to it as a result. Sorry dude, you'll have to take this one on the chin I think.

walker2686

52 posts

240 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
So you took your car, which you knew wasn't covered, and then you caused (whether you meant to or not) damage to it as a result. Sorry dude, you'll have to take this one on the chin I think.


I agree. If you are using your own car for business use then it's down to you to ensure that your insurance covers this. You are driving with no insurance in these circumstances at the end of the day. It's down to you to make sure you are insured.

I doubt your company will pay out for damage like this, as I doubt very much that they will have insurance to cover this. Is having your own car part of your contract, or do you get a car allowance for it and are expected to use it for business? If so then it might be different.

motaboy

91 posts

248 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Even with a car allowance, as the car is yours you're usually expected to cough up for everything insurance-related - they always say the payment is to cover insurance costs etc. In that situation damage caused to a car in any way would have to be sorted through your own insurance. I'd agree with the others and say you'll be lucky to get anything from the company. Plus, if the car wasn't insured for business use that could definately be a bit painful in the wallet area - made worse by the company pleading poverty in the first place.

sramdeen

416 posts

251 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
[quote] my own insurance restricts me using it for work purposes[/quote]

How will they know you were there on official 'business'? They certainly don't have to know that you were transporting equipment etc. Can't you simply say that you were working in another location on that particular day? (That's even if they ask) Surely it would then be classed as commuting?

jb111s

Original Poster:

393 posts

249 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
Technically I wasn't supposed to be using the car for work. We had recently acquired another company and I was having to work at the weekend to assist in the migration. I never use my car for work purposes as I work in the city, I only drove the car upto town in the first place because I've been working such long hours cabs are too expensive and trains cease running at the times I was going in.

My superior asked me to drive & forbade me from getting a cab. I couldn't take a tube as I was lugging around 5k worth of IT equipment.

I see the points saying I wasn't insured & should of said no, but obviously one doesn't think of these things at the time. I was carrying out busines critical work for my employer at the time and they were desperate to get me on site asap. After working a 75 hour week on this project I'm hoping they will sympathise with my plight. They are considering my plea & I've got a quote for 500 quid + vat from sinclaires for them to mull over.

Incidently one of the partners there is also an owner of a lovely glacier blue elise which is identical to mine. If he is on this forum please put in a good word!!

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
An issue to consider in future: Had you had the accident on the way to work from home, you would not have been covered either.

Categories:
Social, domestic and pleasure
Social, domestic and pleasure + commuting
Business use

If you carsh while commuting you aren't covered technically. Worth considering as many people use their cars for commuting while not being insured for this use. (unkowingly in the most part I suspect)

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
jb111s - hope you get it sorted. I wasn't being rude above, just trying to focus on the facts. I hope your employer shows you some goodwill and makes a contribution to the repair.