111s vs 111r Any concerns on the Rover engine
Discussion
Hi all,
I am looking to buy my first Elise. I had set my heart on a low mileage 111s but as I started to do some research I realised this car runs on the Rover engine. With the (not so recent) demise of Rover I have become concerned about being able to maintain the engine.
I have even gone as far as looking at the 111r with the Toyota engine but the price,at the moment, is a little bit too much for me to swallow.
I would be looking to keep the car for 3 years (minimum) so I would be grateful for any comments/assurances that I would be making the right decision.
Thanks in advance
Ian
I am looking to buy my first Elise. I had set my heart on a low mileage 111s but as I started to do some research I realised this car runs on the Rover engine. With the (not so recent) demise of Rover I have become concerned about being able to maintain the engine.
I have even gone as far as looking at the 111r with the Toyota engine but the price,at the moment, is a little bit too much for me to swallow.
I would be looking to keep the car for 3 years (minimum) so I would be grateful for any comments/assurances that I would be making the right decision.
Thanks in advance
Ian
Unipart was sold off so parts shouldn't be an issue - may even get cheaper once China produces
You need to try both really but Toyota power delivery not to everyone's taste and buying now would put you back into the steeper part of the depreciation curve.
For me I'd go 111s but make sure you don't pay too much - Low mileage attracts a premium though I'm not sure why. Tis just a run of the mill engine so service history kills the need for a low mileage example. If you'll do lots of miles then may level it out otherwise I'd go for well cared for before over mileage.......
Enjoy
You need to try both really but Toyota power delivery not to everyone's taste and buying now would put you back into the steeper part of the depreciation curve.
For me I'd go 111s but make sure you don't pay too much - Low mileage attracts a premium though I'm not sure why. Tis just a run of the mill engine so service history kills the need for a low mileage example. If you'll do lots of miles then may level it out otherwise I'd go for well cared for before over mileage.......
Enjoy
I've just bought an S2 111S. I didn't look into it in any depth but there are so many cars out there with K-series engines that I can't see parts supply being a problem. There will always be a market for them so SOMEONE will always find it worth while to make them.
You can still buy parts for the B-series in my MG and that's been out of production for decades.
You can still buy parts for the B-series in my MG and that's been out of production for decades.
uglymug11 said:
I am looking to buy my first Elise. I had set my heart on a low mileage 111s but as I started to do some research I realised this car runs on the Rover engine. With the (not so recent) demise of Rover I have become concerned about being able to maintain the engine.
I have even gone as far as looking at the 111r with the Toyota engine but the price,at the moment, is a little bit too much for me to swallow.
I have even gone as far as looking at the 111r with the Toyota engine but the price,at the moment, is a little bit too much for me to swallow.
Hi
Welcome and just to say that I was in your position about 6 months ago (wanting 111s, not being able to aford a good example of an R if I wanted one) and got my 111S and loved it. Parts aren't a problem, the rover is known from suffering head gasket failure more than most engines (but get a £60 a year RAC parts & labour warrenty and sleep easy), but it also gives great economy (better than 111R and less C02), and a different driving experience... but lets not go into that in case we start the 111S/R debate again.
PS - "S"
Your primary question should be "which one do I like best" from the driving seat. Both engines have very different characters, you should try both.
Don't worry about the K-series. LOADS of specialists to maintain them, plenty of spares around. If you have one concern it will probably be HGF (head gasget failure), which can be offset by taking an AA Breakdown Parts & Labour warranty for ~£60 a year. That will cover the costs of all but the worst HGF (which are pretty uncommon to be honest in well maintained cars).
Don't worry about the K-series. LOADS of specialists to maintain them, plenty of spares around. If you have one concern it will probably be HGF (head gasget failure), which can be offset by taking an AA Breakdown Parts & Labour warranty for ~£60 a year. That will cover the costs of all but the worst HGF (which are pretty uncommon to be honest in well maintained cars).
Gooby said:
kevin ritson said:
if anything the Toyota would be harder, there are relatively few cars using that engine.
Eh? How do you figure that? They are used in Celica's, MR2's and it is still in production.... It is also produced by the OEM, not by a spare part manufacturer.
IIRC, as well as Lotus (and one Caterham that I know of) the 2ZZ is used in the Celica, which is out of production and the Corolla T-Sport, which is a niche model Corolla.
Rover K-series was used in pretty much everything Rover made from the late '80s until they went out of business, plus countless Caterhams, Lotuses and a whole range of Kit cars. It was the Crossflow of the '90s/'00s.
They are still OEM in China, since Nanjing have plans to resurrect Longbridge, expect further supply in the UK.
Corolla T-Sport is now out of production too - supercharged one engineered by Lotus was the last of the line..... So don't think any Toyota's use it now ?
That said with a major outfit like toyota they will supply parts for years to come. It's even a requirement for USA that you supply OEM parts for 10yrs.
Toyota car not without it's issues - a few blow ups lots of mil lights and gremlins there too. More limited scope for tuning also. But as said drive both - wouldn't be a wasted afternoon
That said with a major outfit like toyota they will supply parts for years to come. It's even a requirement for USA that you supply OEM parts for 10yrs.
Toyota car not without it's issues - a few blow ups lots of mil lights and gremlins there too. More limited scope for tuning also. But as said drive both - wouldn't be a wasted afternoon

i went through the same thoughts before buying my elise, ended up buying a 111R but i spoke to people who had reccommended the 111S as well - i think its got to just be a personal choice at the end of the day.
i don't regret getting the extra bhp at all and you def won't regret the purchase no matter which one you opt for
don't think the maintenance should be a prob with either
i don't regret getting the extra bhp at all and you def won't regret the purchase no matter which one you opt for
don't think the maintenance should be a prob with either
Edited by S9AJE on Wednesday 18th April 10:23
I had a vvc engine in my mgf for 5 years it ran like clockwork, same as my 111s.
As long as you let it warm up properly before giving it a thrashing you'll be fine.
Incidently if anyone banks with LLoyds TSB, upgrade your current account to premier & you get the aa package mentioned above.
As long as you let it warm up properly before giving it a thrashing you'll be fine.
Incidently if anyone banks with LLoyds TSB, upgrade your current account to premier & you get the aa package mentioned above.
I had a vvc engine in my mgf for 5 years it ran like clockwork, same as my 111s.
As long as you let it warm up properly before giving it a thrashing you'll be fine.
Incidently if anyone banks with LLoyds TSB, upgrade your current account to premier & you get the aa package mentioned above.
As long as you let it warm up properly before giving it a thrashing you'll be fine.
Incidently if anyone banks with LLoyds TSB, upgrade your current account to premier & you get the aa package mentioned above.
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


