crashed why?
Author
Discussion

x luckyrob x

Original Poster:

10 posts

235 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
I'm looking to get an Elise soon and was wondering if anyone could shed some light onto why quite a few seem to have been crashed? I was under the impression that Elises were supposed to handle superbly so why the high crash rate? Is simply that people can't drive or is it that they suffer from similar handling to the old MR2s due to being mid-engined rear wheel drive?
Also are there any nicer aftermaket wheels you can get for them that won't affect the handling too much?
Any info would be appreciated.

concerned cat

367 posts

240 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
x luckyrob x said:
I'm looking to get an Elise soon and was wondering if anyone could shed some light onto why quite a few seem to have been crashed? I was under the impression that Elises were supposed to handle superbly so why the high crash rate? Is simply that people can't drive or is it that they suffer from similar handling to the old MR2s due to being mid-engined rear wheel drive?
Also are there any nicer aftermaket wheels you can get for them that won't affect the handling too much?
Any info would be appreciated.


I didn't think there was much trolling on Pistonheads.....

4pot

481 posts

255 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
The Elise is one of the very best handling cars out there. The issue being, that you need to treat it with some respect. Alot of people tend to buy them around the winter months when they are cheaper. These said people, have no experience of rear wheel drive cars and find that the first time they take a corner or roundabout in the wet, the car bites.

They need to be driven with a bit more care in the wet or cold conditions. In the dry they really do handle like their on rails. Uprate the suspension, and that takes it to another level.

If you buy one, just take car in the wet.You'll never look back! thumbup

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Hi and welcome. There are a number of reasons why elises crash. Excluding crashes involving other cars, the reason is usually driver error. The elise does not behave like a front wheel drive car on cornering. The weight is near the back and the car is very sensitive to balance from front to back. It demands a lot from the driver to get the best from the car in terms of ultimate handling and it can punish you for stupidity.

Two main things happen:
1) Driver does not realise how fast he/she is entering a corner - turns in and then lifts off the throttle or dabs the brakes. Weight shifts forward, reducing rear end traction - next thing you know the back steps out. That can even be fun when you know what you are doing - Here is an example of sliding an elise on a wet track:
http://media.putfile.com/Copse-Corner

Unfortunately many people do not react in time or react the wrong way, spinning the car off the road.

2) Too much throtle out of wet roundabouts - similar result.

Most elises that get binned into the scenery are driven by drivers who have not had them long and haven't learned the principles of how to drive a rear wheel drive mid engined car.

The elise is not an intrinsically dangerous car - it just shouldn't be pushed beyond the limits in adverse conditions by people unfamiliar with them. Don't fear the car - just develop and understanding slowly and progressively, rather than cane the heck out of the car from day one like it is a 1.4 citroen saxo FWD.

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
There are some blingin aftamarket rims for da Elise, ma man said he gonna get sum chromed up 22 inch ones wiv da spinners for me and ma bredrin, to go cruizin wiv ma bitches innit. Elise is well fast man, u ave to be wicked driva to keep it on road. I mash up sum evo at da lights da ova day innit, it was mission for im to catch me again innit. Da Elise quicka dan da formula 1 cars innit. Aiiiiiiiiiiii!!! thumbup

x luckyrob x

Original Poster:

10 posts

235 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
ahh i see, so it is the same reason as the MR2. Cheers for the advice. I've already learnt how to drive a mid-engined rwd car by owning an MR2.
Thanks again.

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Hollywood Wheels said:
There are some blingin aftamarket rims for da Elise, ma man said he gonna get sum chromed up 22 inch ones wiv da spinners for me and ma bredrin, to go cruizin wiv ma bitches innit. Elise is well fast man, u ave to be wicked driva to keep it on road. I mash up sum evo at da lights da ova day innit, it was mission for im to catch me again innit. Da Elise quicka dan da formula 1 cars innit. Aiiiiiiiiiiii!!! thumbup


lol, HW you make me laugh sometimes.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
x luckyrob x said:
ahh i see, so it is the same reason as the MR2. Cheers for the advice. I've already learnt how to drive a mid-engined rwd car by owning an MR2.
Thanks again.


Then barring being daft, you will have a lot of fun in an elise. Just learn the limits progressively (not on the road) and it will reward you like almost no other car.

4pot

481 posts

255 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
[quote=Paul RN
lol, HW you make me laugh sometimes.
[/quote]

What are you doing here!

sramdeen

416 posts

251 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Hollywood Wheels said:
hwthumbup

lmfao

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
I've just got an Elise and to be honest I struggle to understand why there are so many crashed cars around. Even in the wet it's not a hard car to drive unless you're a complete idiot with it and in that case any car will bite you in the end.

I suppose that if you do lose it you're more likely to do serious damage to an Elise than most cars because (1) you're more likely to be going backwards and (2) it's made of plastic. Anyway, I personally feel that the Elise is, of all the cars I've owned, the least likely to bite me.

jonbrydges

199 posts

242 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
You may also want to try this:

www.carlimits.co.uk

Gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
I learnt to drive a rwd mid engined car in a Mk1 MR2 (Supercharged) and it would swap ends in a blink. You will find the s2 elise far more forgiving. There are still muppets out there who have not figured out that rear weight bias is directly opposite to 99% of cars and not had the time and respect to realise what that means.

As for bling rims? Wrong forum, wrong car.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
Gooby said:
I learnt to drive a rwd mid engined car in a Mk1 MR2 (Supercharged) and it would swap ends in a blink. You will find the s2 elise far more forgiving. There are still muppets out there who have not figured out that rear weight bias is directly opposite to 99% of cars and not had the time and respect to realise what that means.

As for bling rims? Wrong forum, wrong car.

Unless he edited his post, I didn't really think he meant 'bling rims' - just aftermarket wheels that don't affect the handling i.e. light as OEM or better... I don't think that fancying a different to OEM style wheel is a sin, do you?

I suppose I'm biased because I can only get proper tyres by buying aftermarket rims rolleyes and to be honest, Lotus have had some blindingly good designs of OEM wheel, so I'm sure one of the many Lotus styles should be acceptable to virtually everyone.

But given how much you Lotus guys tweak and personalise your cars, why the snipe at 'bling rims' ??? confused

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
Gooby said:
As for bling rims? Wrong forum, wrong car.


Fortunately just Hollywood taking the proverbial. When is the next Boloc's run? (other than Sunday when you should be at Snett supporting the lotus "massiv"

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
In defense of the OP, he did say aftermarket not "22 inch spinners" - so I guess the OZ racing wheels would be favourites?

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
Until you've ever spun and/or crashed an Elise (I have the dubious priviledge of being able to tick both those boxes, although I hasten to add that the crash was me being T-boned) it's easy to say "they're quite hard to stack".

They're not, they're very, very easy to crash if you don't know about how the car's dynamics work. They are so bloody good at what they do, that the limit of grip is so far beyond that of the limit of most people's balls, it's rare that very high speed crashes occur (from what I can tell from the forums).

Most tend to be low-ish speed spins, skids etc. in the wet when the car's weight balance comes into play.

There is an envelope for correction but as many of us know, you have to push hard to find it in the dry, and when you do, there's only a limited window for you to react. So you'd better be ready.

As for aftermarket wheels - plenty of options (bling or otherwise). See the SELOC techwiki for more info.

ROB1979

221 posts

236 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
kambites said:
I've just got an Elise and to be honest I struggle to understand why there are so many crashed cars around. Even in the wet it's not a hard car to drive unless you're a complete idiot with it and in that case any car will bite you in the end.



The worst thing you can do is trick yourself into believing that! I had mine for a year and a half of pretty hard driving before it finally taught me the lesson i probably deserved. It was in the wet admittedly, but i was far from pushing it to where i have in the past and it just took my head off nearly coming off a roundabout. I agree with Sworks on this, you can't say it's hard to stack until you've done it.

apprentice

1,219 posts

291 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
ROB1979 said:
kambites said:
I've just got an Elise and to be honest I struggle to understand why there are so many crashed cars around. Even in the wet it's not a hard car to drive unless you're a complete idiot with it and in that case any car will bite you in the end.



The worst thing you can do is trick yourself into believing that! I had mine for a year and a half of pretty hard driving before it finally taught me the lesson i probably deserved. It was in the wet admittedly, but i was far from pushing it to where i have in the past and it just took my head off nearly coming off a roundabout. I agree with Sworks on this, you can't say it's hard to stack until you've done it.


Quite so..... Ignore this advice at your peril!

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Wednesday 18th April 2007
quotequote all
and to kambites - you've only just picked it up, so probably haven't driven on cold wet January roads - prepare to be outcornered by reliant robins!!