shockers......
Author
Discussion

peter2704

Original Poster:

237 posts

239 months

Thursday 19th April 2007
quotequote all
i know there is a bulk buy on seloc for the s2 kit for s1's,but due to wifes car packing up, cash for shocks has gone,so offer will have closed by time funds recovered,just wondering if avo's or gaz or other alternatives any good ?have some spax on the westfield i had ......not too bad,all road work at moment,inputs welcome

greysquirrel

786 posts

258 months

Thursday 19th April 2007
quotequote all
i have heard that the gaz ones are cack..

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Thursday 19th April 2007
quotequote all
I know how you feel Peter. I want to improve the suspension on my S1 but the only two options on my list are either Bilsteins or Nitrons. Have a check around elsewhere (seloc) and someone has found one of the other alternatives could be dangerous (cracking mounts). Not sure if its either of the two you've mentioned and I know others have been happy with these choices but I think the most development for the Elise has taken place with either the Bilsteins or Nitrons. I'd wait till funds recover and fit a good upgrade.

walker2686

52 posts

240 months

Thursday 19th April 2007
quotequote all
I don't think that Spax ones are particularly cheap tbh, they cost more than the S2 upgrade, especially at the £450 offer price.

cej

961 posts

253 months

Thursday 19th April 2007
quotequote all
greysquirrel said:
i have heard that the gaz ones are cack..


Not that bad actually. Done 10k miles with mine. But yeah,a lot of people say they suck. However,I haven't seen anyone who's actually tried them say it.
They were on the car when I bought it and I like how it handles. Sure it would be nice if I could afford some Nitrons,but not at the present time

Mark B

1,671 posts

296 months

Friday 20th April 2007
quotequote all
Buy some cheap Koni's off Ebay that are in good nick, then save your money. Bilsteins are great dampers for road use and reasonable on track...

Keep your eye on the classifieds, 2nd hand ones do come up for reasonable money!

talkwrench

910 posts

264 months

Friday 20th April 2007
quotequote all
Funny how different groups of people (or cars!) come to different conclusions.
I fitted S2 Bilsteins to my S1 and think that theyre superb. I also have fitted Bilstein sports to my BMW 850CSi and theyre brilliant on that too. I was swayed away from Gaz for the Lotus by several comments in this forum.
However, pop over to the TVR forum and theyre all ripping out the inadequate Bilsteins that TVR fitted to upgrade to Gaz! They rate them as the dogs whiskers if you can't stretch to Ohlins or Nitrons.
I guess the bottom line is that it is personal preference.
Having said that, Koni clearly made a mistake with the original Lotus shockers. Theyre noisy, they leak and they don't last long. Yet Koni have been one of the most respected names in dampers for years and are still the very best fitment for many cars. You'd think that a company with all that experience and expertise would get such basic fundamentals right.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Friday 20th April 2007
quotequote all
The key issue is not the manufacturer specifically - Not all Bilstein dampers are the same. The lotus bisteins were designed, built and tuned specifically for the elise. They work very well on the elise. The same dampers might be rubbish on a different car. The nitrons and ohlins were also specifically valved for the elise.

Compared to the lotus bilsteins, the Gaz are not as good on an elise. The opposite may well be true for other cars.

s111dpc

1,519 posts

260 months

Friday 20th April 2007
quotequote all
I had a set of Spax adjustables on my S1 and wasn't that impressed to be honest. I changed them last year to the S2 bilstien set up and there was a marked improvement.

Not necessarily what you want to hear, but based on my experience I'd hold off until you can afford the S2 kit.

crackthatoff

3,314 posts

244 months

Friday 20th April 2007
quotequote all
I belive my 135r susp can be ajusted is it worth someone having a quick fiddle with it?

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 20th April 2007
quotequote all
Only the platform height. Just get it set-up properly by somewhere that can geo an Elise properly.

peter2704

Original Poster:

237 posts

239 months

Friday 20th April 2007
quotequote all
cej,
your running gaz.....any koni type clunking or are they quiet?,i know everybody says billy's and i would hopefully like to get some,but on a tight budget are gaz or avo worth a shot,they cant be that bad or else they wouldn't sell them surely,and gaz run a 2yr guarantee!!

cej

961 posts

253 months

Friday 20th April 2007
quotequote all
No clunking. They are pretty quiet. As much as can be in a very noisy car where you can hear everything

I think the ride quality is brilliant, firm but not more than it's tolerable. I like it . thumbup

bod27

230 posts

244 months

Friday 20th April 2007
quotequote all
Just had my S1 fitted with the S2 suspension at JPS (bought them off SteveB) the ride home was loads better than the run up to Newcastle this morning.

Great service again from Dan.

peter2704

Original Poster:

237 posts

239 months

Saturday 21st April 2007
quotequote all
come on guys somebody else must have avo/spax or gaz on there car inputs welcome

peter2704

Original Poster:

237 posts

239 months

Saturday 21st April 2007
quotequote all
come on guys,more than 1 person must have them on?or is it like someone mentioned,1 person didnt like them and mud sticks,now everybody hates them even those who haven't tried them
cheers
peter

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Sunday 22nd April 2007
quotequote all
peter2704 said:
come on guys somebody else must have avo/spax or gaz on there car inputs welcome


I am onthe same situation. My LSS suspension in my view has always been too soft, noisy and just not good enough. I too looked at Gaz an Avo, spax etc.. but no one had really ever tried them appart from the Spax ones, and a few have said they were'nt very good. I rang Gaz a bit back for a chat. They have made a new set for the elise, if you look on the website, its the anodised blue set. These are machined from a block just like you would get from Nitron and not welded types like the Avo. They are not mono tubes like the Nitrons, but they reckon if you dont track the car much, then you wont get any benifit from them on the road in realy terms. I know that designing suspension is a bit of black art and involves a lot of work, but surely the likes of Gaz and Avo cant be that bad, or you wouldnt see competition cars out there running them?

Cje is the only person I have come accross that runs them on his elise and he likes them. Gaz manufacture to a high standard and this is something to bear in mind ! Also remeber that Nitron are about the release a budget damper under the name of Racing Red, around the £500 - £600 mark. Do remeber though that these are not designed or built by Nitron and are simply bought from Japan and sold under the Nitron Brand. Nitron say they are very good and equal to the Bilstein S2 kit.

After all this, I am still going to go for the Nitrons. I know they cost twice as much, but I dont want to spend £600 on something else only to find they are not quite what I wanted.

It a tricky decision, but I hope this has helped a bit....

peter2704

Original Poster:

237 posts

239 months

Sunday 22nd April 2007
quotequote all
yep cheers,minefield like you say????

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Sunday 22nd April 2007
quotequote all
As you say Peter, deffo a minefield. I tend to take the view that there is generally a good reason why particular kit is favoured for a particular car. If others far more knowledable than me have spent money doing the experimenting then why go out on a limb? I'll definately be going for Bilsteins or Nitrons, just depends how much money the kids spend over the next few months!!

peter2704

Original Poster:

237 posts

239 months

Sunday 22nd April 2007
quotequote all
tipper i agree ,its just that i dont track,my konis are shot,gaz/avo/protech,are more affordable,than billys at £550,i still cant believe there all cack! its a fine balance ,money for car or family,cant justify £1000 on nitrons.......i like my testicles where they are