Anyone else disappointed?
Discussion
I'd always wanted an Elise, and, while owning one has been fun, I've never enjoyed it to the point where I'm willing to overlook its shortcomings. I really liked the philosophy behind the design and wanted to be blown away by it, but it never really happened.
It's a reasonably entertaining drive, but is that really a good enough reason to overlook the laughable design & build issues? They aren't every day cars, and I know the development budget was limited but if you accept they're only weekend toys, why not sacrifice any pretence of practicality and drive a Caterham?
Moving towards the other end of the spectrum, there are cars like the Boxster - more weight than an Elise but a similar layout and arguably a better though-out package with 90% of the real-world performance.
I just sometimes feel the Elise is neither here nor there.
Perhaps it's just been a bad day - I spent most of today's journey mopping the sills, watching water piss in and trying to clear the screen
It's up for sale now - maybe I'll look back and regret selling but at the moment, ownership isn't what I hoped it would be!
It's a reasonably entertaining drive, but is that really a good enough reason to overlook the laughable design & build issues? They aren't every day cars, and I know the development budget was limited but if you accept they're only weekend toys, why not sacrifice any pretence of practicality and drive a Caterham?
Moving towards the other end of the spectrum, there are cars like the Boxster - more weight than an Elise but a similar layout and arguably a better though-out package with 90% of the real-world performance.
I just sometimes feel the Elise is neither here nor there.
Perhaps it's just been a bad day - I spent most of today's journey mopping the sills, watching water piss in and trying to clear the screen
It's up for sale now - maybe I'll look back and regret selling but at the moment, ownership isn't what I hoped it would be!
Edited by risotto on Monday 23 April 17:57
I think this is true of any car (or most things!)
1 You start looking around for something
2 You whittle the choices down
3 You make your choice and get excited about it
4 You anticipate ownership
5 You obtain it
6 You enjoy it and relish in the novelty
7 Novelty subsides
8 Enjoyment becomes normality
9 Shortcomings and faults become apparent
10 Shortcomings and faults become annoying
I'm at 6, your at 10 by the sounds of it. Done this on any and everything from £500 VW's to £100K porkers. Doesn't matter what it is or what it costs. For me, same old routine. I reckon the only thing that will stop me is a MacF1 or a Zonda but it's exactly the same with PC's, hi-fi's, TV's etc.
You just have to draw the line somewhere!
1 You start looking around for something
2 You whittle the choices down
3 You make your choice and get excited about it
4 You anticipate ownership
5 You obtain it
6 You enjoy it and relish in the novelty
7 Novelty subsides
8 Enjoyment becomes normality
9 Shortcomings and faults become apparent
10 Shortcomings and faults become annoying
I'm at 6, your at 10 by the sounds of it. Done this on any and everything from £500 VW's to £100K porkers. Doesn't matter what it is or what it costs. For me, same old routine. I reckon the only thing that will stop me is a MacF1 or a Zonda but it's exactly the same with PC's, hi-fi's, TV's etc.
You just have to draw the line somewhere!
I used my S2 everyday for 2years 50K miles ..and now its 5 years old/75K miles ...never had any leaks at all - the biggest thing that used to get on my nerves was the lack of decent heater in the winter months/demisting etc and thats been solved in the later cars with HVAC
the new 111R/Exige is a league ahead on the S1 and even early S2 in terms of daily use
I take it you have an S1 ?
..saying that for the last 3 years Ive had 2nd cars (need to go to the airport a lot with lots of luggage) and you do tend to "go soft" after a while...on a winters morning if the choice is 4WD, heated seats etc or Elise then of course theres no choice in the matter...but an Elise everyday isnt that bad a proposition
I guess it depends if you use it the rest of the time to get the benefit from it ie. trackdays etc ...for an only car, that you can drive to a track, and use daily (at a push) there is no substitute - thats what the Elise packages is about.
A late Elise/Exige is competitive right out of the box, useable daily...and cheap to run in comparison with other cars of similar performance - I regular turn up at sprints and compete against Caterhams, 911s,4WD jap stuff...pretty much everything and beat them all other than single seaters on slicks ...drive there, compete, drive home on same tank of petrol...and then have it serviced for £90 - thats what the Elise is all about to me
the new 111R/Exige is a league ahead on the S1 and even early S2 in terms of daily use
I take it you have an S1 ?
..saying that for the last 3 years Ive had 2nd cars (need to go to the airport a lot with lots of luggage) and you do tend to "go soft" after a while...on a winters morning if the choice is 4WD, heated seats etc or Elise then of course theres no choice in the matter...but an Elise everyday isnt that bad a proposition
I guess it depends if you use it the rest of the time to get the benefit from it ie. trackdays etc ...for an only car, that you can drive to a track, and use daily (at a push) there is no substitute - thats what the Elise packages is about.
A late Elise/Exige is competitive right out of the box, useable daily...and cheap to run in comparison with other cars of similar performance - I regular turn up at sprints and compete against Caterhams, 911s,4WD jap stuff...pretty much everything and beat them all other than single seaters on slicks ...drive there, compete, drive home on same tank of petrol...and then have it serviced for £90 - thats what the Elise is all about to me

21TonyK said:
I think this is true of any car (or most things!)
1 You start looking around for something
2 You whittle the choices down
3 You make your choice and get excited about it
4 You anticipate ownership
5 You obtain it
6 You enjoy it and relish in the novelty
7 Novelty subsides
8 Enjoyment becomes normality
9 Shortcomings and faults become apparent
10 Shortcomings and faults become annoying
I'm at 6, your at 10 by the sounds of it. Done this on any and everything from £500 VW's to £100K porkers. Doesn't matter what it is or what it costs. For me, same old routine. I reckon the only thing that will stop me is a MacF1 or a Zonda but it's exactly the same with PC's, hi-fi's, TV's etc.
You just have to draw the line somewhere!
1 You start looking around for something
2 You whittle the choices down
3 You make your choice and get excited about it
4 You anticipate ownership
5 You obtain it
6 You enjoy it and relish in the novelty
7 Novelty subsides
8 Enjoyment becomes normality
9 Shortcomings and faults become apparent
10 Shortcomings and faults become annoying
I'm at 6, your at 10 by the sounds of it. Done this on any and everything from £500 VW's to £100K porkers. Doesn't matter what it is or what it costs. For me, same old routine. I reckon the only thing that will stop me is a MacF1 or a Zonda but it's exactly the same with PC's, hi-fi's, TV's etc.
You just have to draw the line somewhere!
I think you're right - familiarity breeds contempt, at least it does with me and cars! I always think the next one will be a keeper but there's always something else that looks like a better proposition. So many cars to try, so little time!
bogie said:
I take it you have an S1 ?
It's actually an early S2 - I must be a real wuss to make such a fuss! It's not just the roof alone, and none of the irritations are serious - it's just that together they drive me mad sometimes! The screen mists up, so I open the vents, but as there doesn't seem to be any sort of filter in the ventilation system, the dashboard gets covered with dead leaves/grit/surprised rodents.
Similarly, although it's handy not to have to switch the lights on manually, I do sometimes wonder why they regularly come on by themselves when I start the car. Etc, etc, etc.
I take your point about trackdays though, the car's at its best in that sort of environment.
Edited by risotto on Monday 23 April 18:27
Interesting post. I had an early 2001 S2 which was a bit of a Friday afternoon car. I quickly PX'd it for a new 2002/52 111S and that was fantastic. It had to be seriously persisting down with rain for a small trickle of water to seep in from the top corner of the windows. My was an everyday drive come rain, wind and a couple of times, snow.
I agree the heater leaves a lot to be desired and the stereo wasn't up to much, but then you pays yer money and takes yer choice I suppose.
I agree the heater leaves a lot to be desired and the stereo wasn't up to much, but then you pays yer money and takes yer choice I suppose.
answer to original question. HELL NO !!!!!! if you have exploited all of the handling skills of the elise (recon I'm on 20 % ish) then yes I can understand your point, I mean you must have anticipated a few niggly little problems... I must admit if I drive mine for a week constantly I start thinking about tvrs for extra grunt but then you meet a country b road twister, and come out grinning like a cheshire cat !
I suppose it depends what you bought it for, a bit of posing with the occasional thrash off the lights down a dual carrage way will leave you feeling empty! remember what it was designed for
give her another chance over summer its going to be great !
I suppose it depends what you bought it for, a bit of posing with the occasional thrash off the lights down a dual carrage way will leave you feeling empty! remember what it was designed for
give her another chance over summer its going to be great !
Edited by crackthatoff on Monday 23 April 18:38
Sounds like you had a duff one.
There's a LOT of variability with Lotus when it comes to quality.
I had an S1 Elise that I ended up hating for many of the reasons you describe, but now have a VXT (which is more S2-like in build quality) and absolutely love it. It is 98% weatherproof, fast, handles superbly, and I can do 450 miles in a day and get out feeling fine. Equally I've driven a K-series S2 Elise that felt like it was about to fall apart compared to my VXT. And then sitting in top-spec new Exiges at a dealer made the VXT feel primitive.
There are definite Friday afternoon cars floating around, but if you get a well-screwed-together car and maintain it properly, then you won't be complaining.
FWIW I'm no hardcore Lotus fan - a lot of people here are full-on enthusiasts and forgive virtually all Lotus faults. I've always been a Porsche enthusiast and appreciate the build quality and reliability, so perhaps closer to your attitude - but this VXT has really got under my skin. And since the S2s are meant to be even better than the VXs (Lotus learnt from the VX development process) then I'm sure a good example would satisfy you.
There's a LOT of variability with Lotus when it comes to quality.
I had an S1 Elise that I ended up hating for many of the reasons you describe, but now have a VXT (which is more S2-like in build quality) and absolutely love it. It is 98% weatherproof, fast, handles superbly, and I can do 450 miles in a day and get out feeling fine. Equally I've driven a K-series S2 Elise that felt like it was about to fall apart compared to my VXT. And then sitting in top-spec new Exiges at a dealer made the VXT feel primitive.
There are definite Friday afternoon cars floating around, but if you get a well-screwed-together car and maintain it properly, then you won't be complaining.
FWIW I'm no hardcore Lotus fan - a lot of people here are full-on enthusiasts and forgive virtually all Lotus faults. I've always been a Porsche enthusiast and appreciate the build quality and reliability, so perhaps closer to your attitude - but this VXT has really got under my skin. And since the S2s are meant to be even better than the VXs (Lotus learnt from the VX development process) then I'm sure a good example would satisfy you.

I think that maybe you have expected slightly to much from your car & have been dissapointed. Has it been reliable? & it very much is an every day car as im living proof as i have owned mine for 10 months & driven 11k in this time & love every single moment of this! I had know experience whatsoever of Lotus & went in fairly blind & didnt quite know what to expect but it has been truely amazing & i cant see me ever moving away from the name & i intend to upgrade to a new one in the near future! I just dont understand why it didnt appeal to you or maybe you just expected to much, i just dont know mate.
Not disappointed at all, in previous cars any little squeak would annoy me, I hardly notice all the rattles in the Elise, my S1 leaks like a sieve, but I don't care.
When I bought it I wasn't sure i would be able to cope with it as an every day drive, 10 Months and 14,000 miles later, I hate driving any other car. Anything else just feels like a a bus to drive.
Until I bought the Elise I was seriously thinking about buying another big bike (despite Mrs Wombles disagreement) I think this may be one of the only cars that will take that craving away.
When I bought it I wasn't sure i would be able to cope with it as an every day drive, 10 Months and 14,000 miles later, I hate driving any other car. Anything else just feels like a a bus to drive.
Until I bought the Elise I was seriously thinking about buying another big bike (despite Mrs Wombles disagreement) I think this may be one of the only cars that will take that craving away.
risotto said:
bogie said:
I take it you have an S1 ?
It's actually an early S2 - I must be a real wuss to make such a fuss! It's not just the roof alone, and none of the irritations are serious - it's just that together they drive me mad sometimes! The screen mists up, so I open the vents, but as there doesn't seem to be any sort of filter in the ventilation system, the dashboard gets covered with dead leaves/grit/surprised rodents.
Similarly, although it's handy not to have to switch the lights on manually, I do sometimes wonder why they regularly come on by themselves when I start the car. Etc, etc, etc.
I take your point about trackdays though, the car's at its best in that sort of environment.
Edited by risotto on Monday 23 April 18:27
you should be able to fix the roof leaks and filter issue quite easily.
For roof - get the windows aligned somewhere where they know what they are doing, then apply some black silicone sealant along all edges where fabric meets rubber, then coat the roof in Fabsil (tent proofing stuff from Millets etc) - that will sort it
For the heater - either get the pre-made filters (Tigga used to sell them on SELOC) that fit on the entry vents, or just stick some cut up womens tights over the vents
..not much you can do for demist/heating except get a later car - the S2111S with aircon onwards sorted it out
other than that, try to enjoy it and do things in it you cant do in other cars...get out on track, learn to drive it fully and run rings around all sorts of "performance" cars
I guess today was a bit of a bad day, I appreciate the encouragement guys, thanks!
I do use mine daily, so I suppose each journey is perhaps less of an 'event' than it might be if I only used it at weekends.
In terms of it being a Friday afternoon car, I can't make my mind up. It's got full service history and has been well cared for but there are lots of small irritations.
Good tip about the vent filters, thanks (it's just a shame people have to start stuffing women's tights into their car because the manufacturer didn't think things through properly!)
At the moment I'm just struggling to see what it does that a Caterham weighing half as much couldn't do equally well.
I suppose we all have good days and bad days - I'll probably be more willing to forgive it when the sun's out again!
I do use mine daily, so I suppose each journey is perhaps less of an 'event' than it might be if I only used it at weekends.
In terms of it being a Friday afternoon car, I can't make my mind up. It's got full service history and has been well cared for but there are lots of small irritations.
Good tip about the vent filters, thanks (it's just a shame people have to start stuffing women's tights into their car because the manufacturer didn't think things through properly!)
At the moment I'm just struggling to see what it does that a Caterham weighing half as much couldn't do equally well.
I suppose we all have good days and bad days - I'll probably be more willing to forgive it when the sun's out again!
Edited by risotto on Monday 23 April 19:39
risotto said:
21TonyK said:
I think this is true of any car (or most things!)
1 You start looking around for something
2 You whittle the choices down
3 You make your choice and get excited about it
4 You anticipate ownership
5 You obtain it
6 You enjoy it and relish in the novelty
7 Novelty subsides
8 Enjoyment becomes normality
9 Shortcomings and faults become apparent
10 Shortcomings and faults become annoying
I'm at 6, your at 10 by the sounds of it. Done this on any and everything from £500 VW's to £100K porkers. Doesn't matter what it is or what it costs. For me, same old routine. I reckon the only thing that will stop me is a MacF1 or a Zonda but it's exactly the same with PC's, hi-fi's, TV's etc.
You just have to draw the line somewhere!
1 You start looking around for something
2 You whittle the choices down
3 You make your choice and get excited about it
4 You anticipate ownership
5 You obtain it
6 You enjoy it and relish in the novelty
7 Novelty subsides
8 Enjoyment becomes normality
9 Shortcomings and faults become apparent
10 Shortcomings and faults become annoying
I'm at 6, your at 10 by the sounds of it. Done this on any and everything from £500 VW's to £100K porkers. Doesn't matter what it is or what it costs. For me, same old routine. I reckon the only thing that will stop me is a MacF1 or a Zonda but it's exactly the same with PC's, hi-fi's, TV's etc.
You just have to draw the line somewhere!
I think you're right - familiarity breeds contempt, at least it does with me and cars! I always think the next one will be a keeper but there's always something else that looks like a better proposition. So many cars to try, so little time!
Thats very true . If your bored flog it and move on , its just a car .
Sorry to hear the Elise hasn't lived up to your expectation risotto. My story couldn't be more different to yours.
I bought my S1 in December 2005 and after some initial issues (favourably resolved) concerning what servicing the supplying dealer should and shouldn't have done and a black period during last summer when the car was off the road following a smack (run off the road by a Ka of all things!)I couldn't be happier. I've now covered 19k very enjoyable miles in her including a trash up to Hethel and back in a day (700 miles) and a return trip to Brands from Plymouth. She's cost me a bit of money in tyres and brakes and a service (another due soon!) but other than that hasn't cost me a penny due to any reliablity issues. She's silver and came with a blue interior and blue roof and the standard 12 spoke late S1 alloys. She now has a black roof and sits on black 10 spoke 340R delivery wheels and has a carbon black and Lotus green leather interior with S2 seats. The next job on my list of things to do (happy with her cosmetically now) is a suspension refurb and new dampers and then I'll be looking for a bit more power. When I went up to Brands there must have been 300 Elises parked up together and I doubt any two were identical. Thats one of the things I love about the car - it ends up with a bit of you in it (I'm nearly 50 and thought I was well past that sort of thing!).
I'm surprised that you seem underwhelmed by its driving charecteristics. A well set up Elise is nothing short of amazing and particularly love the fact that even at fairly modest (legal!) road speeds its still a hoot as you can play with it and feel the weight moving around but nothing drastic happening. At sensible money only a Caterham type car would better it for pureness but I doubt you'd want to take a Caterham on a touring holiday (I know a chap of 65 who has just done that with his wife).
Bloody amazing little car. You can commute in it, shop in it, holiday in it, you could even pick up your Christmas tree in it - and you can still blow the socks off a lot of exotica on track.
I can't see myself ever being parted from mine.
Oh nearly forgot. Niggles? Nah, thats character
I bought my S1 in December 2005 and after some initial issues (favourably resolved) concerning what servicing the supplying dealer should and shouldn't have done and a black period during last summer when the car was off the road following a smack (run off the road by a Ka of all things!)I couldn't be happier. I've now covered 19k very enjoyable miles in her including a trash up to Hethel and back in a day (700 miles) and a return trip to Brands from Plymouth. She's cost me a bit of money in tyres and brakes and a service (another due soon!) but other than that hasn't cost me a penny due to any reliablity issues. She's silver and came with a blue interior and blue roof and the standard 12 spoke late S1 alloys. She now has a black roof and sits on black 10 spoke 340R delivery wheels and has a carbon black and Lotus green leather interior with S2 seats. The next job on my list of things to do (happy with her cosmetically now) is a suspension refurb and new dampers and then I'll be looking for a bit more power. When I went up to Brands there must have been 300 Elises parked up together and I doubt any two were identical. Thats one of the things I love about the car - it ends up with a bit of you in it (I'm nearly 50 and thought I was well past that sort of thing!).
I'm surprised that you seem underwhelmed by its driving charecteristics. A well set up Elise is nothing short of amazing and particularly love the fact that even at fairly modest (legal!) road speeds its still a hoot as you can play with it and feel the weight moving around but nothing drastic happening. At sensible money only a Caterham type car would better it for pureness but I doubt you'd want to take a Caterham on a touring holiday (I know a chap of 65 who has just done that with his wife).
Bloody amazing little car. You can commute in it, shop in it, holiday in it, you could even pick up your Christmas tree in it - and you can still blow the socks off a lot of exotica on track.
I can't see myself ever being parted from mine.
Oh nearly forgot. Niggles? Nah, thats character
I think most of us have probably gone through the same kind of feelings. I certainly have. Thing is, 2 or 3 days without driving it (it's used v. regularly but not a daily driver) and I can't wait to get back in it. One of my friends has a Boxster and I'd considered one once but there's no way I'd swap the Lotus. OK, there are things I'd change but even when it's cold and dreary, the thought of driving it home still cheers me up. I've had many different sports cars and never had that experience.
i have a 99 S1. I use it every single day, going to work included. Couldnt be more happy with it. I have a hardtop on it and there is no leaks. Do u really expect a elise soft top to keep the rain out? If the bumps and rattles annoy you why did u buy a car like the elise? what were you expecting?
"It's a reasonably entertaining drive" You really aint driving it right!!
"It's a reasonably entertaining drive" You really aint driving it right!!
porteouz said:
Do u really expect a elise soft top to keep the rain out?
I must admit to thinking that was its primary function, yes.
Silly me...
The bumps and rattles, I don't mind. I love simplicity too, but don't you find it even slightly annoying that they couldn't even make these simple cars properly? Wind up windows for example - been around for decades, but do they work reliably in an Elise? Do they buggery.
Some owners seem to take a perverse pride in the fact that the most basic elements of their cars were designed in such a way as to make them terminally useless - usually the same owners who come out with the line about the driving experience being the only thing that matters. I bet other car companies would kill for customers like that!
I bought it because I thought it would be fun and simple and it is - it really is fun and I've enjoyed it. My only point was that it could have been so much better if it had been designed well rather than quickly.
To be fair it sounds as if a lot of these issues have been ironed out in the later cars but I can only speak from experience, hence why I was interested in the opinions of other owners.
Edited by risotto on Monday 23 April 23:07
Sorry to hear your Elise experience has been soured.
My experience couldn't have been sweeter!
'98 S1, had it for 2 years and we're still like a couple on honeymoon! Had a few issues, but nothing that I can't blame on my own fastidious nature and quest for perfection.
Only niggle is completely and utterly hopeless dealer support here in NZ in terms of parts supply (been waiting 5 months now for a set of Advan Neovas!) but that's what you get with a car as exclusive as the Elise (only 65 or so in the country!).
Few cars meet with as universal praise by passers by as the Elise, I've had it parked next to brand new Porsches and Ferraris in the past and the Elise still manages to entice a few away from the German and Italian competition
My experience couldn't have been sweeter!
'98 S1, had it for 2 years and we're still like a couple on honeymoon! Had a few issues, but nothing that I can't blame on my own fastidious nature and quest for perfection.
Only niggle is completely and utterly hopeless dealer support here in NZ in terms of parts supply (been waiting 5 months now for a set of Advan Neovas!) but that's what you get with a car as exclusive as the Elise (only 65 or so in the country!).
Few cars meet with as universal praise by passers by as the Elise, I've had it parked next to brand new Porsches and Ferraris in the past and the Elise still manages to entice a few away from the German and Italian competition
Edited by Esprit on Tuesday 24th April 14:13
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


