How can I get my car back?
Author
Discussion

rob-ix

Original Poster:

27 posts

235 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
I took my car to a garage in 2001 after an accident, I was a student at the time so it took me a while to pay the money for the repair. After eventually paying the money in full the mechanic promised me the car back within a few weeks. A few weeks went by and upon contacting the mechanic he said another two weeks; now this continued for about 4 years. At one point the mechanic needed some more money for a few more bits of work for the MOT, but despite paying the money I kept getting put off, always next month or in a few weeks. Last year the mechanic sold his business, with the exception of my car - this was being held by him on his farm as there was not enough room in his garage to fix it. Since the mechanic sold the business I have spoken to him a few times and he always promised that it'd be two more weeks. Eventually the mechanic became unreachable so I started to send letters formally stating that I want my car back. I have never received a reply to any of these letters. I tried to report the car as stolen but as I could not prove that the mechanic has it at his farm the Police would not investigate it and told me to pursue it in a civil court. I spoke to a civil lawyer and he said it wasn't worth the effort and that I should just take a few large friends to see him one day!

My car is a old classic with FSH, very low mileage and highly sought after - the mechanic even said it's one of the best he's ever driven. All I want to do is get my car back. Having spoken to the mechanic who bought the garage he told me that the former mechanic has a number of valuable customer cars that have been taken in a similar fashion.

I consider the car to be stolen, the mechanic is depriving me of my rightful property with no good reason. Does anyone on here have any guidance I can use for getting my car back?

Sorry for the long post ... but I wanted to include as much detail as possible.

thanks

Rob

BTW: I don't owe the mechanic any money, in fact I've think I've paid for engine rebuild twice!

olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
You're having a laugh right?

And how do you know it has "very low mileage", it did 7 years ago, sounds like it's been his regular motor since then.

If the guy has any brains at all the car will be registered in his name now and will have been for 6 years or so.

Sounds like you've been shafted.

rob-ix

Original Poster:

27 posts

235 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
> And how do you know it has "very low mileage",
> it did 7 years ago, sounds like it's been his
> regular motor since then.

Even if it's done 10k a year it would still fairly low mileage. It's over nearly 42 years old and there's probably only a very limited number in the country and probably in single digits with FSH and condition. Even a complete junker model would be worth some money - not that I'm concerned about the money, I just want it back.

> If the guy has any brains at all the car will
> be registered in his name now and will have
> been for 6 years or so.

I did check and the car is still registered in my name.

This mechanic has a number of other peoples cars that he has stored in his barn. I imagine in a few years time they will fund his retirement.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
Ask him for it back in writing.If he refuses report it as stolen.Tell the police you know where it is......

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
Sounds simple to me, go and see him nicely with 1 friend who waits in the car. If no useful response then get the bailiffs/heavies in.

rob-ix

Original Poster:

27 posts

235 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
> Ask him for it back in writing. If he refuses
> report it as stolen. Tell the police you know
> where it is......

Done that but they said as I couldn't prove it was on his property they would not investigate it. It is probably one of these county's where the Police won't investigate minor car crimes.

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
Minor?

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
rob-ix said:
> Ask him for it back in writing. If he refuses
> report it as stolen. Tell the police you know
> where it is......

Done that but they said as I couldn't prove it was on his property they would not investigate it. It is probably one of these county's where the Police won't investigate minor car crimes.


Since when has car theft been minor...Surely they could go and look.....tell 'em there's a fiver in it for 'em.... If,as you suggest there may be others then it is serious.

boosted ls1

21,200 posts

291 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
It's not simple at all. The mechanic is taking the piss and will say that the contract has kept changing over all these years hence all the new invoices. It probably comes down to the 'last' contract which I bet hasn't been recorded in writing. So, it's a civil matter if you can't grab the car.

The question has to be why is the mechanic hanging on to it? Is he just after a gravy train, regular bills?

I would probably tell him the works crap and threaten to sue him for shoddy workmanship. He may want to get it off his hands then. I'd tell him that an independant engineer will be along shortly to prepare a report of the quality of work done. If you can't get access to the car then bib may have to take note.

Boosted.

mattyb123

2,206 posts

241 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
How long did it take you to pay?

Why didnt you just see him in person at his garage and refuse to leave until you got your car back or he called the police, either way you win!

or "borrow" one of his cars and arrange some sort of "swap"

tbh if you have been waiting years to get it back its your fault for being a silly billy and not standing up to the guy.

p.s. if you know where it is cant you just take it?

rob-ix

Original Poster:

27 posts

235 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
boosted ls1 said:

I would probably tell him the works crap and threaten to sue him for shoddy workmanship. He may want to get it off his hands then. I'd tell him that an independant engineer will be along shortly to prepare a report of the quality of work done. If you can't get access to the car then bib may have to take note.


I don't even know if the work has been done. If I could see the car and get an 'engineer' to it I'd have it back! I'm not bothered about the work
done I just want the car back

boosted ls1 said:

The question has to be why is the mechanic hanging on to it? Is he just after a gravy train, regular bills?


It's fairly unique being 42 years old and is the best model/example of a certain brand of car ever made.

mattyb123 said:

tbh if you have been waiting years to get it back its your fault for being a silly billy and not standing up to the guy.


Due to the type of car its quite common for repairs to take years, or rather the mechanic to take years on the repair.


mattyb123 said:

p.s. if you know where it is cant you just take it?


He's a farmer knowing it's on a farm and where on a farm it is are two different questions. I think I'd be liable for trespassing if I did that, in any case I would not feel safe on a farmers land if they really didn't want me there.


Edited by rob-ix on Monday 23 April 22:08



Edited by rob-ix on Monday 23 April 22:09

byker28i

93,680 posts

248 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
Farmers usually have shotguns.

Go to see him to enquire about the car. Ask to see it. If he asks you to leave phone the coppers, tell them he threatened you with a shotgun. You're word against his. Either way the coppers will arrive.

Or

Turn up with several people, a trailer, bolt cutters etc and take your property back.

deevlash

10,442 posts

268 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
rob-ix said:
boosted ls1 said:

I would probably tell him the works crap and threaten to sue him for shoddy workmanship. He may want to get it off his hands then. I'd tell him that an independant engineer will be along shortly to prepare a report of the quality of work done. If you can't get access to the car then bib may have to take note.


I don't even know if the work has been done. If I could see the car and get an 'engineer' to it I'd have it back! I'm not bothered about the work
done I just want the car back

boosted ls1 said:

The question has to be why is the mechanic hanging on to it? Is he just after a gravy train, regular bills?


It's fairly unique being 42 years old and is the best model/example of a certain brand of car ever made.

mattyb123 said:

tbh if you have been waiting years to get it back its your fault for being a silly billy and not standing up to the guy.


Due to the type of car its quite common for repairs to take years, or rather the mechanic to take years on the repair.


mattyb123 said:

p.s. if you know where it is cant you just take it?


He's a farmer knowing it's on a farm and where on a farm it is are two different questions. I think I'd be liable for trespassing if I did that, in any case I would not feel safe on a farmers land if they really didn't want me there.


Edited by rob-ix on Monday 23 April 22:08



Edited by rob-ix on Monday 23 April 22:09

Have you not got a squad of big mates to go round and "ask" for it back? let him call the police.




Edited by deevlash on Monday 23 April 23:01

mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
It sounds to me as though you have a good case to get this investigated as a theft.

Theft requires several elements before the definition fits the act.

In this case the dishonesty part is fulfilled because it would appear that the mechanic has assumed the rights of the lawful owner.

The mechanic may have a defence to throw at any theft charge but that is for a court to decide whether the defence is appropriate to the circumstances.

4 years is a very long time to spend fixing a car. The length of time alone suggests he has assumed ownership rights of the car by depriving you from having it back.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Monday 23rd April 2007
quotequote all
rob-ix said:
I tried to report the car as stolen but as I could not prove that the mechanic has it at his farm the Police would not investigate it and told me to pursue it in a civil court.


mg6b said:
It sounds to me as though you have a good case to get this investigated as a theft.



confused

hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Tuesday 24th April 2007
quotequote all
So, in order to get the police to investigate a car theft you have to solve the crime yourself first??

Dr.Ickwood

31 posts

235 months

Tuesday 24th April 2007
quotequote all
Sounds like youve tried everything through the correct channels. So give up trying to be nice and simply take the car back.

Do you have a spare key?? If so its a simple 'smash and grab' job. Few big mates, late at night, reclaim what is rightfully yours.

Im defo not saying get involved wiv violence or anything, just be astute!

After all, as deevlash said 'let him call the police if he wants' cos as long as you have all the correct paperwork to say the car is urs and that he is holding it illegally then im certain he wont.

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Tuesday 24th April 2007
quotequote all
tell te police you saw him doing 36 in a 30 - they will be round in a flash!!

boosted ls1

21,200 posts

291 months

Tuesday 24th April 2007
quotequote all
I wouldn't advise a late night visit. Could easily backfire on you.

You could take a friend, witness during the day and ask to see the car and inspect the work because you intend to collect it and need to know it's ready to be trailered. Also, take a small recorder with a concealed microphone and record whatever's said.

Your best bet is to ascertain this is a criminal matter. The mechanic will attempt to make it a civil matter. Try to have him confirm and record that you have paid all your bills to date and owe him nothing.

Boosted.

Dr.Ickwood

31 posts

235 months

Tuesday 24th April 2007
quotequote all
What car is it anyways??

sounds pretty special