Elise Series 1 advice
Elise Series 1 advice
Author
Discussion

MGYoung

Original Poster:

2,384 posts

248 months

Thursday 26th April 2007
quotequote all
Hi there,

Later this year I'll be in a position to buy either a cheap Elise or a Caterham for between £8K and £8.5K. The car will be a second vehicle and garaged at night. my thoughts at the moment are as follows.

1. Fun factor - Caterham wins
2. Practicality - Elise wins.
3. Running costs - Caterham wins
4. Value for money - Elise wins
5. Depreciation - a draw?
6. Looks - Down to personal preference but I like both for different reasons.
7. Straight line Performance - Probably an Elise win at this money.
8. Handling - Different but both have a good reputation.

So I'm torn between the two. Is there anything is partuclar that I should look out for on an early S1?

Thanks and all the best.

MGYoung

Original Poster:

2,384 posts

248 months

Thursday 26th April 2007
quotequote all
Thanks!

toxic frog

3,227 posts

298 months

Thursday 26th April 2007
quotequote all
buy the caterham....

we don't want your sort around here....



only joking...

as far as i can see, if you want a car to go for short blasts on occasional weekends, buy a Caterham... it's like mainlining pure petrolheaded adrenelin.

if you want to go further and more frequently, buy an elise... you still get the adrenelin but you also get enough comfort to drive all day without turning into a zombie

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 26th April 2007
quotequote all
There's a lot more to it than that, come on toxic, you should be better drilled at this by now!

Really think about what you'll want to use it for. If you want to do trackdays/weekends away etc., consider what you generally take with you, the distances travelled etc.

The Cat will be a quality car for the occasional blat and trackdays within an hour or two's drive, but few people have the constitution to drive them longer than that. I think of them as like motorbikes with 4 wheels.

The Elise is just that bit more practical.

Both will give huge amounts of enjoyment though.

cej

961 posts

253 months

Thursday 26th April 2007
quotequote all
MGYoung said:
Hi there,

Later this year I'll be in a position to buy either a cheap Elise or a Caterham for between £8K and £8.5K. The car will be a second vehicle and garaged at night. my thoughts at the moment are as follows.

1. Fun factor - Caterham wins
2. Practicality - Elise wins.
3. Running costs - Caterham wins
4. Value for money - Elise wins
5. Depreciation - a draw?
6. Looks - Down to personal preference but I like both for different reasons.
7. Straight line Performance - Probably an Elise win at this money.
8. Handling - Different but both have a good reputation.

So I'm torn between the two. Is there anything is partuclar that I should look out for on an early S1?

Thanks and all the best.

not so sure about 3, the elise can be quite cheap to keep running as well. Haven't spend much on my 'liz yet, only problem is that you can get all sorts of cool stuff for it and it's hard to resist buying it

7: who cares ? It's more more fun to drive on the small twisty roads thumbup

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Thursday 26th April 2007
quotequote all
cej said:
not so sure about 3, the elise can be quite cheap to keep running as well.


yes You could have a point, there. At that price range the Caterham would likely be a Crossflow engined model that's a good few years old. I think it might depend on whether you do your own maintenance: the Caterham is dead simple and cheap to service yourself, but quite labour intensive to maintain, with things like replacement A-frame bushes every 6,000 miles or so, valve adjustment every 3000 miles, oiling the front trunnions every thousand miles if you want them to last, etc.

Handling is very different indeed. Crossflow Caterhams don't have anything like the grip of an Elise on typical (grotty) British public road tarmac, but are very predictable and easy to play with. The Elise is a lot more supple and better suited to road use, has much higher limits than a typical Crossflow Caterham when driven at 7/10ths, but can be a snappy little bastard when you do reach its limits, requiring fairly quick, correct reactions if you want to catch it before it spins. Both are great to drive, but I'd advise a degree of caution with the Elise if you've not driven many mid-engined cars before!

Jay Dee

75 posts

250 months

Monday 30th April 2007
quotequote all
Before i bought my Elise i was on the verge of buying a kit car, eg a bec! I test drove both and had my mind set on the kit car just for the sheer fun factor, then the last kit car i test drove the weather was cold and as i was out it started to rain......this was NO fun at all! I didnt enjoy it one bit and my mind was changed to the elise for useability!
Im now over the moon with my elise and cant get out of itdrivingthumbup
Im v happy that i went with the elise now!!

wetny

486 posts

243 months

Tuesday 1st May 2007
quotequote all
Was thinking along the lines of westfield and TVR chim before buying Elise. Decided that TVR was a plastic chariot of death and westfield was just a little bit extreme. At least with an elise you get a decent bit of weather protection etc. I think that the elise draws a bit more toty.

toxic frog

3,227 posts

298 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
There's a lot more to it than that, come on toxic, you should be better drilled at this by now!

Really think about what you'll want to use it for. If you want to do trackdays/weekends away etc., consider what you generally take with you, the distances travelled etc.

The Cat will be a quality car for the occasional blat and trackdays within an hour or two's drive, but few people have the constitution to drive them longer than that. I think of them as like motorbikes with 4 wheels.

The Elise is just that bit more practical.

Both will give huge amounts of enjoyment though.


listen here doughnut boy... you can't get away with simply rewording exactly what i said and trying to steal the glory.... go polish your honda civic and hang your head in shame!

jamiebae

6,245 posts

242 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2007
quotequote all
I did 2,000 miles in 9 days in my S1, Oxford to St Tropez and back again, via the Alps, Macon and Le Touquet. It was reasonably comfortable, sat happily at 95mph on the autoroutes and along with my Eliseparts luggage rack carried clothes for 2 people, a tent, a folding table, 2 folding chairs, cooking equipment and a lot of other associated guff with no problems whatsoever. I don't think a Caterham would have managed that.

Obviously it depends on what you want to do with the car but one of my favourite things to do is go driving around the South of France - the roads are better surfaced, there's a lot less traffic and far fewer police than here, but the thought of doing that many miles in a Caterham (and with no luggage) doesn't sound too fun to me!