Is it just me ? The soft top on an S1
Is it just me ? The soft top on an S1
Author
Discussion

grinnders

Original Poster:

1,558 posts

235 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
It's a little bulbous isn't it.

Although I really like my car, I look at the flatter profile of the S2 roof construction and envy it greatly. Ok It may be a loss of an inch or so of headroom but at nearly 6ft with a bald scalp I feels there's a good couple of inches excess headroom that wouldn't be missed.

Is there any aftermarket solution for an S1 where the battons are less arched and the roof fabric consequently reduced to create a less pram like roofline ?

I used to think the original Boxster had a roof akin to a Silver Cross Pram, but it may be all this time my roofline wasn't so flattering either.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
Not that I know of. It's worth remembering that the roof was an afterthought. The original design was for a car which didn't have one. Apparently the marketing people shat the bed over it and they were forced to knock something up quickly.

marandlau

334 posts

242 months

Friday 4th May 2007
quotequote all
S Works said:
Not that I know of. It's worth remembering that the roof was an afterthought. The original design was for a car which didn't have one. Apparently the marketing people shat the bed over it and they were forced to knock something up quickly.


yes

the original design was for a doorless step-in style body with no roof. Regulations stated they had to drop the stepin part of the side by so many millimeters, which they thought spoilt the look of the cars, and so it evolved to have doors and a roof. It wasn't quite a last minute thought, more of a portable solution to the removable hard top. It was revised though to stick up les, in the same way the lights were reshaped etc for the S2

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Saturday 5th May 2007
quotequote all
Note to self: Must read the Elise book I got for crimbo

marandlau

334 posts

242 months

Saturday 5th May 2007
quotequote all
S works said:
Note to self: Must read the Elise book I got for crimbo



biglaugh
read

Got it for my birthday!

ludo

5,308 posts

235 months

Saturday 5th May 2007
quotequote all
grinnders said:

Although I really like my car, I look at the flatter profile of the S2 roof construction and envy it greatly. Ok It may be a loss of an inch or so of headroom but at nearly 6ft with a bald scalp I feels there's a good couple of inches excess headroom that wouldn't be missed.


being more than a couple of inches taller, and with hair distressing similar to this:



I beg to differ

grinnders

Original Poster:

1,558 posts

235 months

Monday 7th May 2007
quotequote all
.... and someone kindly bought me the double "video" of the Elise history for Christmas
Curiously I've never got beyond the first 30 minutes... andd if the roof genuinely is an after thought I may never get to such a fascinating section.

Anyone else here got that version and willing to give me a 100 word precis..... it sounds far too much like a quote from Lord Flashheart when he asks the girls to "look at his machinery....."

Anyway, doesn't mean to say you can't improve on the design... afterall nearly everyone here seems to have "tinkered" with something and that's NOT a sexual innuendo !

Esprit

6,373 posts

314 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
PERSONALLY, I think the Elise has one of the best looking soft-tops on the market.... VERY few convertibles manage to look proportioned with the hood up or down, but the Elise manages it.

Sure it looks a little ad-hoc, but that's what it is... it's just another element of why I LOVE the Elise.... I'm probably the only person that reckons it was a step BACKWARDS when the Elise gained a Short-roof on the S2... and aircon... and electric windows, and ABS, and a Yota engine....

now where's the "fat smiley"?

kambites

71,739 posts

252 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
Esprit said:

... I'm probably the only person that reckons it was a step BACKWARDS when the Elise gained a Short-roof ...

...now where's the "fat smiley"?


Surely the short roof is lighter though cos it's, um, shorter.

Esprit

6,373 posts

314 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
kambites said:
Surely the short roof is lighter though cos it's, um, shorter.


Well technically yes, BUT... the short roof has heavier cant rails than the long roof, and also the short roof has a longer rollbar cover, which would make up any shortfall

Janitor

2,372 posts

250 months

Tuesday 8th May 2007
quotequote all
grinnders said:
It's a little bulbous isn't it.


Nah