Nitrons or Bilstein???
Discussion
The S2 kit is great, an excellent compromise for road with the occasional track day. Nitrons will need rebuilding every so often and the Billies will last for a long time... '4 Pot' has infact just gone to Nitrons and is selling his old ones for £300 or something.. look in SELOC classifieds... The car is kept in tip top condition, no reason for those ones to do another 20k miles without problem...
I can contact Rich by email/phone if you want to contact me...
I can contact Rich by email/phone if you want to contact me...
Hello mate. I've got a set for sale.
They've done 29k, with on trackday at Abbeville. No leaks, noises etc. Being taken off by Sincs this week and I will ask them to confirm their condition before sale. There up for £275.
If you're interest, send me an e-mail at:
richard.hermida@eliteim.co.uk
Rich
Sorry Edited to say:
I've found the Bilsteins to be 100% fine for fast road use and on track at Abbeville they were very good. I could however see the difference between a Nitron set up compared to mine.
My car is in at sincs due to a buggered fuel pump and I made teh foolish decision to ask Wayne what else I should have done at the same time. I'd always wanted to get the car 100%, by that I mean all the bits, such as:
Nitrons
Alu bells
upgraded rear toe links
etc.
Rich
They've done 29k, with on trackday at Abbeville. No leaks, noises etc. Being taken off by Sincs this week and I will ask them to confirm their condition before sale. There up for £275.
If you're interest, send me an e-mail at:
richard.hermida@eliteim.co.uk
Rich
Sorry Edited to say:
I've found the Bilsteins to be 100% fine for fast road use and on track at Abbeville they were very good. I could however see the difference between a Nitron set up compared to mine.
My car is in at sincs due to a buggered fuel pump and I made teh foolish decision to ask Wayne what else I should have done at the same time. I'd always wanted to get the car 100%, by that I mean all the bits, such as:
Nitrons
Alu bells
upgraded rear toe links
etc.
Rich
Edited by 4pot on Thursday 17th May 14:03
Mark B said:
Nitrons will need rebuilding every so often and the Billies will last for a long time
Sorry but this is complete rubbish. In terms of like for like use (road/road or track/track) Nitrons will need rebuilding no more or less often than any other quality damper as the oil doesnt degrade any faster when operating at thesame temperature.
Yes because Nitrons will take higher loadings on track they will run hotter and therefore degrade faster, but again thats hardly a like for like comparison.
S Works said:
Sorry to hear the car's off the road Rich. I'm sure Sincs will get it sorted for you. That'll be a nice bill with all those bits!
Tell me about it! They very kindly replaced the secondary fuel pump for free, thinking it was that. Turns out it was the original Lotus one which costs £240+VAT!!!!!
I think the bill is going to come to 3k. When I said goodbye to Wayne, after speccing things up. Wayne said "Thank you sir" and I said "It's a pleasure"! What was I thinking
4pot said:
S Works said:
Sorry to hear the car's off the road Rich. I'm sure Sincs will get it sorted for you. That'll be a nice bill with all those bits!
Tell me about it! They very kindly replaced the secondary fuel pump for free, thinking it was that. Turns out it was the original Lotus one which costs £240+VAT!!!!!
I think the bill is going to come to 3k. When I said goodbye to Wayne, after speccing things up. Wayne said "Thank you sir" and I said "It's a pleasure"! What was I thinking
Thank you for making me feel better about the silly amounts I've spent in the last year on mine

hbaumhardt said:
Mark B said:
Nitrons will need rebuilding every so often and the Billies will last for a long time
Sorry but this is complete rubbish. In terms of like for like use (road/road or track/track) Nitrons will need rebuilding no more or less often than any other quality damper as the oil doesnt degrade any faster when operating at thesame temperature.
Yes because Nitrons will take higher loadings on track they will run hotter and therefore degrade faster, but again thats hardly a like for like comparison.
Hans, sorry if misleading, i certainly wasn't meaning to be, but from talking to people who use Nitrons for road use, they have been advised to have them rebuilt on occasions... (Depending on usage - Motorway/B roads) I wasn't trying to mislead, but (I don't think) a road car doesn't need a high performance damper such as a Nitron..... The original question was about Bilsteins which for a road Elise is a very good damper, if you have money to burn go for it, but they aren't required for road use.
With regard to one of your statement, how is a Nitron going to take a higher loading when used like for like? If nothing changes with grip levels, the loading and motion (after all it is velocity that the damper is working with) on the damper will be the same won't it?? If you are going for a stickier tyre on a track and therefore requiring increased grip levels then the higher performance damper is a great decision, but for road use where you have to contend with poor road surfaces and the like, it is unnecessary. (IMHO)
I was also under the impression the Nitron needs rebuilding as the valving performance reduces, not the Oil...
Yes there is little benefit for pure road use in going Nitron, Bilstiens are perfect for the job.
Since valving is a set of disks with holes and whatnot they dont degrade, its just the oil that looses viscoity oh yes, and not looking after the adjusters that looses "clicks".
Nitrons are capable of taking a higher loading becase they can carry higher sping rates and those springs will allow the full grip of cut slicks to be used during cornering without hitting the mechanical bumpstops in the dampers. To illustrate the standard S2 Bilstiens run around 250/300 ish springs and are easy to bottom out on cut slicks in aggresive corners whereas I have yet to hit the stops on the 400/475 spings that the standard valving on 1 way Nitros will handle.
This means you can carry more speed which means more work for the damper which means more heat which means faster degrading damper fluid.
This is also why putting cut slicks on a car without upgrading the suspension is a little pointless - if you want to actually use the capabilities of the premimum tyres you need springs and dampers that will cope.
Shangani and my "from road to race Elise" upgrade results and experiences are all described here http://wiki.seloc.org/a/S2_Track_Modi
Since valving is a set of disks with holes and whatnot they dont degrade, its just the oil that looses viscoity oh yes, and not looking after the adjusters that looses "clicks".
Nitrons are capable of taking a higher loading becase they can carry higher sping rates and those springs will allow the full grip of cut slicks to be used during cornering without hitting the mechanical bumpstops in the dampers. To illustrate the standard S2 Bilstiens run around 250/300 ish springs and are easy to bottom out on cut slicks in aggresive corners whereas I have yet to hit the stops on the 400/475 spings that the standard valving on 1 way Nitros will handle.
This means you can carry more speed which means more work for the damper which means more heat which means faster degrading damper fluid.
This is also why putting cut slicks on a car without upgrading the suspension is a little pointless - if you want to actually use the capabilities of the premimum tyres you need springs and dampers that will cope.
Shangani and my "from road to race Elise" upgrade results and experiences are all described here http://wiki.seloc.org/a/S2_Track_Modi
noodleman said:
Thanks all. I don't feel so silly for considering this now!
I may be interested in your shocks, I just wonder how many more moles they've got left in them?
As you have an S2, I presume I'd also need to buy the mounting brackets?
Noodle.
I may be interested in your shocks, I just wonder how many more moles they've got left in them?
As you have an S2, I presume I'd also need to buy the mounting brackets?
Noodle.
Noodle,
Yes, you'd need mounting brackets as far as I'm aware. In terms of mileage left, well, I bought the car in Oct 2005 with 10k and I have put 19k on since then with one trackday.
The only reason I'm selling is due to Nitrons, otherwise I'd keep them on the car.
Regards
Rich
hbaumhardt said:
Yes there is little benefit for pure road use in going Nitron, Bilstiens are perfect for the job.
Since valving is a set of disks with holes and whatnot they dont degrade, its just the oil that looses viscoity oh yes, and not looking after the adjusters that looses "clicks".
Nitrons are capable of taking a higher loading becase they can carry higher sping rates and those springs will allow the full grip of cut slicks to be used during cornering without hitting the mechanical bumpstops in the dampers. To illustrate the standard S2 Bilstiens run around 250/300 ish springs and are easy to bottom out on cut slicks in aggresive corners whereas I have yet to hit the stops on the 400/475 spings that the standard valving on 1 way Nitros will handle.
This means you can carry more speed which means more work for the damper which means more heat which means faster degrading damper fluid.
This is also why putting cut slicks on a car without upgrading the suspension is a little pointless - if you want to actually use the capabilities of the premimum tyres you need springs and dampers that will cope.
Shangani and my "from road to race Elise" upgrade results and experiences are all described here http://wiki.seloc.org/a/S2_Track_Modi
Since valving is a set of disks with holes and whatnot they dont degrade, its just the oil that looses viscoity oh yes, and not looking after the adjusters that looses "clicks".
Nitrons are capable of taking a higher loading becase they can carry higher sping rates and those springs will allow the full grip of cut slicks to be used during cornering without hitting the mechanical bumpstops in the dampers. To illustrate the standard S2 Bilstiens run around 250/300 ish springs and are easy to bottom out on cut slicks in aggresive corners whereas I have yet to hit the stops on the 400/475 spings that the standard valving on 1 way Nitros will handle.
This means you can carry more speed which means more work for the damper which means more heat which means faster degrading damper fluid.
This is also why putting cut slicks on a car without upgrading the suspension is a little pointless - if you want to actually use the capabilities of the premimum tyres you need springs and dampers that will cope.
Shangani and my "from road to race Elise" upgrade results and experiences are all described here http://wiki.seloc.org/a/S2_Track_Modi
Believe me Hans, valving does degrade, and as far as I am aware it is this that wears in the Nitron shock, not the oil. It is purely down to the sensitivity of the springs and disks that make up the damper.
The damper is actually working less with a stiffer spring rate than with a soft spring rate, but the increased performance of the Nitron is improtant when running stiffer springs to stop the wheel bouncing off the surface of the road, which would, inturn, reduce grip... Less sensitive valving will not work fast enough with a stiffer spring...
I am fully aware of the increased performance of the Nitron and for a track biased car with uprated springs and tyres, the Nitron performance is a great addition, but for road use will offer minimal, if any improvement at a higher cost and less durability..
I have spent many hundreds of miles developing prototype dampers where I was specifying the differet valving to match with spring rates and bushes for numerous different road surfaces. I am constantly amazed at the number of people who say Nitron is the only way to go for a basic road car...
A Bilstein will easily handle 60k miles with minimal loss in performance, I am unsure of the Nitron, but I'd be surprised if it would go through 20k?? But, I will add, this is an opinion only as I have no actual experience of running the Nitrons over long period of time myself... I am just going by the opinions of other who say they need a rebuild at regular intervals...
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



