i got spanked!
Author
Discussion

marky999

Original Poster:

230 posts

236 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
Just raced my best mate...on a safe, empty dual carriageway - him in his M5, me in my 111R. Was equal up to 60....but after that I might as well have been in a Morris Minor. I've driven his M5 many times, including at the Nurburgring, and have to confess that while I wouldn't swap wheels with him, there's no comparison in overall speed.

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
You probably don't want to post anything with "race" and "road" in it on a public forum.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
Well, on the road I've been owned by 1 litre VW Lupos, Diesel family wagons, people movers etc - I just don't try and drive fast.

I reality, the straight line grunt of most cars would murder most elises at speeds over a ton, especially an M5. I only get up to any speed on track, so the other cars for comparison tend to be track orientated. However, high drag and a small engine does not make for good top speed. Doesn't bother me though, I enjoy leaving them behind on every corner.

mahju

407 posts

242 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
The elise handels really well, looks really good, but is as aerodynamic as a brick... and you'll find that drag is equal to velocity squared, and as such as drag becomes a really big problem as you get faster.

tricky 100

954 posts

273 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
So would that be 5L V10 ? Not really surprising if so .

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
the E39 V8 with 400bhp leaves most factory Elises above 80mph anyway never mind about the 500bhp one !

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
As Shangani says... high drag and a small engine don't make for impressive top end performance.

Power:weight ratio is all very well, but it doesn't take account of aerodynamic drag. Light cars can have massive power:weigh ratios, but once the power is absorbed by aerodynamic drag, there's nothing left for acceleration.

Since - as Mahju says - drag is equal to the square of the speed, it rises exponentially as the speed increases and a car that has stunning acceleration up to 60mph due to its light weight suddenly hits an aerodynamic brick wall in the upper speed ranges.

Look on the bright side - the Elise feels like it's travelling faster at 70mph than the M5 does at 140! smile

marky999

Original Poster:

230 posts

236 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
tricky 100 said:
So would that be 5L V10 ? Not really surprising if so .
yes was the new V10!

21TonyK

13,413 posts

240 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
marky999 said:
tricky 100 said:
So would that be 5L V10 ? Not really surprising if so .
yes was the new V10!
Surprised you only describe it as "spanked". Against a 500hp V10 I don't think any original engined Lotus (bar 240's) would stand much of a chance once the M5 gets moving. Having very briefly driven an E60 M5 (in 400hp mode) it was certainly pretty formidable and this was having had a 434hp M3 for 2 years which (in theory) should have been similar. In reality the torque of the V10 was pretty pant wettingly nice.

Bit "David and Goliath"?

21TonyK

13,413 posts

240 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
marky999 said:
tricky 100 said:
So would that be 5L V10 ? Not really surprising if so .
yes was the new V10!
Surprised you only describe it as "spanked". Against a 500hp V10 I don't think any original engined Lotus (bar 240's) would stand much of a chance once the M5 gets moving. Having very briefly driven an E60 M5 (in 400hp mode) it was certainly pretty formidable and this was having had a 434hp M3 for 2 years which (in theory) should have been similar. In reality the torque of the V10 was pretty pant wettingly nice.

Bit "David and Goliath"?

marky999

Original Poster:

230 posts

236 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
marky999 said:
tricky 100 said:
So would that be 5L V10 ? Not really surprising if so .
yes was the new V10!
Surprised you only describe it as "spanked". Against a 500hp V10 I don't think any original engined Lotus (bar 240's) would stand much of a chance once the M5 gets moving. Having very briefly driven an E60 M5 (in 400hp mode) it was certainly pretty formidable and this was having had a 434hp M3 for 2 years which (in theory) should have been similar. In reality the torque of the V10 was pretty pant wettingly nice.

Bit "David and Goliath"?
true, true.....but perhaps if one car can make a driver feel deluded that he can outpace anything, it's the Elise!

purpleperil

1,226 posts

315 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
Against a 500hp V10 I don't think any original engined Lotus (bar 240's) would stand much of a chance once the M5 gets moving.
Mine's got it's original engine and I'll be doing the spanking from now on! rofl

kelk

955 posts

244 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
mahju said:
.. and you'll find that drag is equal to velocity squared,
Actually not quite - drag is directly proportional to velocity squared, other factors are Cd (drag co-efficient) and cross sectional area amongst others.

Saying "equal to" kind of ruins the figures completely.

21TonyK

13,413 posts

240 months

Saturday 26th May 2007
quotequote all
marky999 said:
21TonyK said:
marky999 said:
tricky 100 said:
So would that be 5L V10 ? Not really surprising if so .
yes was the new V10!
Surprised you only describe it as "spanked". Against a 500hp V10 I don't think any original engined Lotus (bar 240's) would stand much of a chance once the M5 gets moving. Having very briefly driven an E60 M5 (in 400hp mode) it was certainly pretty formidable and this was having had a 434hp M3 for 2 years which (in theory) should have been similar. In reality the torque of the V10 was pretty pant wettingly nice.

Bit "David and Goliath"?
true, true.....but perhaps if one car can make a driver feel deluded that he can outpace anything, it's the Elise!
Very true, amazing how well an Elise holds its own against a lot of cars but got to be realistic about it.

Having said that I just covered 150 miles in a new'ish Elise S and bar sitting in traffic for 3 of the 2 hours (A303 on bank holiday!) it was one of the most rewarding drives in years. Plus it took less that £20 of petrol! In all my previous cars I would have had to full-up again when I got home.

And, my last post should had been a 343hp M3... not 434... too tired to type after 8 hours driving plus 2 hours an Combe in one day.

Saied

1,575 posts

250 months

Sunday 27th May 2007
quotequote all
Sam_68 said:
Look on the bright side - the Elise feels like it's travelling faster at 70mph than the M5 does at 140! smile
yes

The main reason I bought mine was to obtain some feeling and sensation at sensible-ish speeds we have to travel at on congested UK roads.

Straight line performance of the 111R is good but there will be cars faster. I had a play with a Sierra Cosworth recently (on my private dual carriageway) who ate me for breakfast on acceleration. He was running a fair bit of boost though, judging from the amount of grey smoke exiting his tailpipe as we both came to a stop. biggrin

cinqster

1,057 posts

310 months

Sunday 27th May 2007
quotequote all
Sam_68 said:
Look on the bright side - the Elise feels like it's travelling faster at 70mph than the M5 does at 140! smile
And you don't look lke a toss*r driving one!

azureblue118

31 posts

272 months

Sunday 27th May 2007
quotequote all
Saied, I've recently sold my Carrera 2 to come back into the Lotus fold, for the same reasons you post.
Far more involving at lower speeds, 40 - 60 on my commute to work down B roads is great fun.
The same buzz required considerably more speed and then had to be A type roads with sweeping bends.
Oh and my fuel consumption has been halved.
That said there is still no substitute for cubic inches.