Failed LEDs in brakes?
Discussion
Two individual LEDs on the brake lights have failed, both next to each other and even more spookily on both left and right brakes! Other than that they work fine. These were retrofitted without any resistors etc which I understand are just to stop radio interference.
Very odd. Dealers happy to replace them but just wondered if anyone else had had something similar happen?
Very odd. Dealers happy to replace them but just wondered if anyone else had had something similar happen?
MiniDiva said:
I've seen a couple of S2's where one or 2 of the led's aren't working - kind of ruins the effect of the lights really. I though LED's were pretty indestructible?! (compared to traditional bulbs anyway)
They are supposed to be but no doubt Lotus has done this on the cheap...21TonyK said:
Two individual LEDs on the brake lights have failed, both next to each other and even more spookily on both left and right brakes! Other than that they work fine. These were retrofitted without any resistors etc which I understand are just to stop radio interference.
Very odd. Dealers happy to replace them but just wondered if anyone else had had something similar happen?
I can't see how the resistors would prevent radio interference, it seems more likely that the resistors are there to drop the voltage from the battery down to that required for the LEDs (unless they have internal resistors in there already). Either way, I wouldn't leave them out if they were supposed to be there. Very odd. Dealers happy to replace them but just wondered if anyone else had had something similar happen?
ludo said:
21TonyK said:
Two individual LEDs on the brake lights have failed, both next to each other and even more spookily on both left and right brakes! Other than that they work fine. These were retrofitted without any resistors etc which I understand are just to stop radio interference.
Very odd. Dealers happy to replace them but just wondered if anyone else had had something similar happen?
I can't see how the resistors would prevent radio interference, it seems more likely that the resistors are there to drop the voltage from the battery down to that required for the LEDs (unless they have internal resistors in there already). Either way, I wouldn't leave them out if they were supposed to be there. Very odd. Dealers happy to replace them but just wondered if anyone else had had something similar happen?
That keeps costs down when making light clusters, because you'd need an awful lot of resistors, or a single tunable resistor to make up for the sum of differences in the individual diodes.
LED's work by allowing electrons to tunnel through the depletion region of a PN junction. Each time one of these tunneling events occurs, the electron must loose it's potential when it tunnels, because it is travelling from a region of high potential to one of low potential. To do this, it releases a photon of light. This is why the LED makes light.
The trouble is that it's not just a photon of light that is emitted. The tunneling process happens very fast. Like attaching a marble to a spring, drawing it back, and letting go suddenly. It pings across the gap, with instant acceleration to somewhere near the speed of light, before returning equally rapidly to the more normal drift speed.
Obviously you need more than one photon to give good light. A single photon really isn't much light at all. When the LED is on, many many photons are generated in a second.
The pinging action of the electrons sets up a disturbance in the wires that supply the LED like ripples on a pond. Those ripples find their way into your FM radio, and upset the superhet receiver, because there is nothing to stop those ripples in the cars wiring system, which as a consequence of being high current is also pretty high bandwidth. It sounds like a hiss, and in electronics, it's called noise. Remember that the light cluster was wired such that it doesn't need lots of resitors, or a single tunable resistor, to keep costs down.
The resistor is usually of very low value, and does not need to be tunable. It provides some resistance solely for the relatively low power noise source that the LED cluster represents. It doesn't make much difference to the LED brightness, because the overall power requirement for illuminating the cluster is comparitively large. What it does do, is stop the intermittent hissing that you hear on he radio when your LED indicator is switching on and off.
Anyone got a job?
Edited by dilbert on Monday 28th May 23:51
dilbert said:
ludo said:
21TonyK said:
Two individual LEDs on the brake lights have failed, both next to each other and even more spookily on both left and right brakes! Other than that they work fine. These were retrofitted without any resistors etc which I understand are just to stop radio interference.
Very odd. Dealers happy to replace them but just wondered if anyone else had had something similar happen?
I can't see how the resistors would prevent radio interference, it seems more likely that the resistors are there to drop the voltage from the battery down to that required for the LEDs (unless they have internal resistors in there already). Either way, I wouldn't leave them out if they were supposed to be there. Very odd. Dealers happy to replace them but just wondered if anyone else had had something similar happen?
That keeps costs down when making light clusters, because you'd need an awful lot of resistors, or a single tunable resistor to make up for the sum of differences in the individual diodes.
LED's work by allowing electrons to tunnel through the depletion region of a PN junction. Each time one of these tunneling events occurs, the electron must loose it's potential when it tunnels, because it is travelling from a region of high potential to one of low potential. To do this, it releases a photon of light. This is why the LED makes light.
The trouble is that it's not just a photon of light that is emitted. The tunneling process happens very fast. Like attaching a marble to a spring, drawing it back, and letting go suddenly. It pings across the gap, with instant acceleration to somewhere near the speed of light, before returning equally rapidly to the more normal drift speed.
Obviously you need more than one photon to give good light. A single photon really isn't much light at all. When the LED is on, many many photons are generated in a second.
The pinging action of the electrons sets up a disturbance in the wires that supply the LED like ripples on a pond. Those ripples find their way into your FM radio, and upset the superhet receiver, because there is nothing to stop those ripples in the cars wiring system, which as a consequence of being high current is also pretty high bandwidth. It sounds like a hiss, and in electronics, it's called noise. Remember that the light cluster was wired such that it doesn't need lots of resitors, or a single tunable resistor, to keep costs down.
The resistor is usually of very low value, and does not need to be tunable. It provides some resistance solely for the relatively low power noise source that the LED cluster represents. It doesn't make much difference to the LED brightness, because the overall power requirement for illuminating the cluster is comparitively large. What it does do, is stop the intermittent hissing that you hear on he radio when your LED indicator is switching on and off.
Anyone got a job?
Edited by dilbert on Monday 28th May 23:51

Explains why you don't *need* the resistors. Like you say, probably just a dodgy bit of soldering. Will monitor the next set carefully. Thanks.

dilbert said:
An LED would typically be operating normally at 30mA DC. All of them vary a little bit, but this corresponds to a voltage drop across a sigle diode of of about 3V. Clearly if you put four diodes in series, you don't need a resistor. It does mean though that if one diode fails, three others will stop working. LED's are very reliable, that's why they can put them in series, and why it's more than likely a mechanical fault.
The operating current for an ordinary LED might be 30mA, a high brightness one e.g. for a brake light would be more like 350 mA. The voltage across a red LED would be 1.8 to 2.1 volts, a white one would be about 3 volts.If you put four white LEDs in series, the voltage drop would indeed be ABOUT 12v, however the current through an LED (being a dioide) is an approximately exponential function of the voltage above the threshold. Given that minor variations in the operating voltage for the LEDs may gives a total drop of less than 12 volts, which would result in much larger currents than intended. The purpose of the resistor is to limit the maximum possible current through the LEDs. As the resistor weighs practically nothing, and is a doddle to fit, why leave it out?
dilbert said:
That keeps costs down when making light clusters, because you'd need an awful lot of resistors, or a single tunable resistor to make up for the sum of differences in the individual diodes.
A "tunable resistor" is only needed if you are connecting the LEDs in parallel and you would need one per parallel branch (which may contain more than one LED connected in series). dilbert said:
LED's work by allowing electrons to tunnel through the depletion region of a PN junction. Each time one of these tunneling events occurs, the electron must loose it's potential when it tunnels, because it is travelling from a region of high potential to one of low potential. To do this, it releases a photon of light. This is why the LED makes light.
The trouble is that it's not just a photon of light that is emitted. The tunneling process happens very fast. Like attaching a marble to a spring, drawing it back, and letting go suddenly. It pings across the gap, with instant acceleration to somewhere near the speed of light, before returning equally rapidly to the more normal drift speed.
Obviously you need more than one photon to give good light. A single photon really isn't much light at all. When the LED is on, many many photons are generated in a second.
The pinging action of the electrons sets up a disturbance in the wires that supply the LED like ripples on a pond. Those ripples find their way into your FM radio, and upset the superhet receiver, because there is nothing to stop those ripples in the cars wiring system, which as a consequence of being high current is also pretty high bandwidth. It sounds like a hiss, and in electronics, it's called noise.
This makes no sense. For a start the principal advantage of FM is that it is good at rejecting additive noise in the signal (noise in the power supply would be rejected by the power supply circuits in the radio). This kind of noise might affect an AM radio, but not an FM one. Also there is a much better source of RF noise in a car, namely the spark plugs that would drown any possible noise from a few LEDs. The trouble is that it's not just a photon of light that is emitted. The tunneling process happens very fast. Like attaching a marble to a spring, drawing it back, and letting go suddenly. It pings across the gap, with instant acceleration to somewhere near the speed of light, before returning equally rapidly to the more normal drift speed.
Obviously you need more than one photon to give good light. A single photon really isn't much light at all. When the LED is on, many many photons are generated in a second.
The pinging action of the electrons sets up a disturbance in the wires that supply the LED like ripples on a pond. Those ripples find their way into your FM radio, and upset the superhet receiver, because there is nothing to stop those ripples in the cars wiring system, which as a consequence of being high current is also pretty high bandwidth. It sounds like a hiss, and in electronics, it's called noise.
The amount of noise generated by an LED would also be miniscule, if not, why would they be used in radio alarm clocks? I did a search for RF/EM noise and LED and came up with nothing. If you have a reputable source for this, I would be genuinely interested to read about it (yes, I am that sad
).The high current means high bandwidth is also incorrect, you can pass huge currents through an inductor (basically a coil of wire), but it won't have a high bandwidth.
dilbert said:
Remember that the light cluster was wired such that it doesn't need lots of resitors, or a single tunable resistor, to keep costs down.
True, but it should still have one resistor as a current limiting device.dilbert said:
The resistor is usually of very low value, and does not need to be tunable. It provides some resistance solely for the relatively low power noise source that the LED cluster represents. It doesn't make much difference to the LED brightness, because the overall power requirement for illuminating the cluster is comparitively large. What it does do, is stop the intermittent hissing that you hear on he radio when your LED indicator is switching on and off.
How exactly can a resistor combat noise? A reactive component (e.g. a capacitor or an inductor) and you might have a point, but I can't see how a resistor would help.Edited by dilbert on Monday 28th May 23:51
Basically, the resistor is there as a current limiter, if it were my car, I would not leave it out. Mind you, I'd rather listen to my engine than the radio anyway

ludo said:
This makes no sense. For a start the principal advantage of FM is that it is good at rejecting additive noise in the signal (noise in the power supply would be rejected by the power supply circuits in the radio). This kind of noise might affect an AM radio, but not an FM one. Also there is a much better source of RF noise in a car, namely the spark plugs that would drown any possible noise from a few LEDs.
For the less technically gifted (me definitely included)... the part which lotus supply to suppress interference is called an inductor jump harness (by them at least). I have no idea what it is - but what it does is cure interefence on AM radio signals.I have an earlyish 55 reg 111R with LEDS, which did not (originally) have the harnesses fitted. Radio on FM and DAB was fine, but on AM (DAB signal in Dorset is pants) while running with lights on (hence LED tail lights) was ok, just the mildest graze of the middle pedal sent a huge shock of static through the speakers... the first time it happened, I nearly stacked the car.
Upshot is, if you think you might want to use AM radio, make sure you get the harness with your LEDs - if you are never going to use it - there's probably no need.
Edited by subaqua on Tuesday 29th May 11:34
I agree with ludo on this, there are a few ways to limit the current through an LED but using a resistor is the simplest, and most common.
I struggle to see how a resistor could be used to damp any noise generated by an LED. As already said an LC arrangement is more likely.
I can't follow dilberts explanation of how an LED works either, wikipedia offers a better description for those interested.
One thing I'd be interested to know about these units is how well heat sunk they are, thermal management is a huge problem in solid state lighting and is often overlooked in retrofit products.
I struggle to see how a resistor could be used to damp any noise generated by an LED. As already said an LC arrangement is more likely.
I can't follow dilberts explanation of how an LED works either, wikipedia offers a better description for those interested.
One thing I'd be interested to know about these units is how well heat sunk they are, thermal management is a huge problem in solid state lighting and is often overlooked in retrofit products.
subaqua said:
ludo said:
This makes no sense. For a start the principal advantage of FM is that it is good at rejecting additive noise in the signal (noise in the power supply would be rejected by the power supply circuits in the radio). This kind of noise might affect an AM radio, but not an FM one. Also there is a much better source of RF noise in a car, namely the spark plugs that would drown any possible noise from a few LEDs.
For the less technically gifted (me definitely included)... the part which lotus supply to suppress interference is called an inductor jump harness (by them at least). I have no idea what it is - but what it does is cure interefence on AM radio signals.I have an earlyish 55 reg 111R with LEDS, which did not (originally) have the harnesses fitted. Radio on FM and DAB was fine, but on AM (DAB signal in Dorset is pants) while running with lights on (hence LED tail lights) was ok, just the mildest graze of the middle pedal sent a huge shock of static through the speakers... the first time it happened, I nearly stacked the car.
Upshot is, if you think you might want to use AM radio, make sure you get the harness with your LEDs - if you are never going to use it - there's probably no need.
Edited by subaqua on Tuesday 29th May 11:34
It could well be that the brake light has more circuitry in it than just the LEDs, e.g. a small voltage regulator - which could conceivably kick out a fair bit of noise. If it is an inductor rather than a resitor that would make much more sense.
Its a short connector with what appears to be the harness wrapped around the circuit as you described.
I can't host pics from work... but the connector is shown here:
http://www.bell-colvill.co.uk/LotusShop/Details.as...
I can't host pics from work... but the connector is shown here:
http://www.bell-colvill.co.uk/LotusShop/Details.as...
subaqua said:
Its a short connector with what appears to be the harness wrapped around the circuit as you described.
I can't host pics from work... but the connector is shown here:
http://www.bell-colvill.co.uk/LotusShop/Details.as...
Yep, that is a simple passive inductor, not a resitor, so that is one issue cleared up. This suggests to me that the brake light contains more than just leds with a current limiting resistor as I can't see how an LED that is on constantly could generate any significant amount of interference. I can't host pics from work... but the connector is shown here:
http://www.bell-colvill.co.uk/LotusShop/Details.as...
21TonyK said:
vetteheadracer said:
......don't believe the hype 
But these are stock Lotus pieces, not after market jobbies. Should last more than 2 months!
vetteheadracer said:
21TonyK said:
vetteheadracer said:
......don't believe the hype 
But these are stock Lotus pieces, not after market jobbies. Should last more than 2 months!
21TonyK said:
vetteheadracer said:
21TonyK said:
vetteheadracer said:
......don't believe the hype 
But these are stock Lotus pieces, not after market jobbies. Should last more than 2 months!
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


